Book Cards

Geological Observations on South America Flashcards

Charles Darwin's Geological Observations on South America argues that South American rock formations, fossils, and Andean uplift record gradual geological change. This deck covers the book's publication history, its editorial apparatus, and Darwin's specific conclusions on fossils, salt deposits, granitic rocks, and metamorphic foliation.

1 / 387

Chapter 1 · Question

How long did Darwin take to write this South American geology book, and when was it published?

WakeCards · wakecards.com · Big ideas. Quick review.

Arrow keys move between cards. Space or Enter flips.

All questions and answers

Every card in the deck, in reading order. Click a chapter to expand. The reviewer above uses the same content.

Section 14 cards
  1. How long did Darwin take to write this South American geology book, and when was it published?

    Darwin's diary records the writing was accomplished within ten months, between July 1844 and April 1845. The book was not actually issued until late the following year, with the preface dated September 1846. The Critical Introduction notes this was a shorter writing period than either of the other volumes in the Beagle geology trilogy.

    Chapter 1

  2. According to the Critical Introduction, how much total time did Darwin's geological books consume?

    Darwin states in his Autobiography that the geological books 'consumed four and a half years' steady work.' This came out of the ten years that elapsed between the return of the Beagle and the completion of his geological books. The Introduction adds that most of the remainder of that time was, sadly, 'lost through illness.'

    Chapter 1

  3. What does the Editorial Note say about the value and price of these reprinted books?

    The Editorial Note says the books will never lose value for the originality of their observations, and many parts are admirably adapted for giving insight into problems of the earth's surface structure and changes, forming a charming introduction to physical geology and physiography. It notes the books themselves could not be obtained for many times the price of the present volume.

    Chapter 1

  4. What does the Editorial Note say the three introductions by Professor Judd provide?

    The Editorial Note states that the three introductions, which the editor's friend Professor Judd kindly furnished, give critical and historical information which makes this edition of special value. The note presents this as a feature distinguishing the present edition, alongside its convenient and cheap form, for both the general reader and the student of geology.

    Chapter 1

Section 24 cards
  1. What did Darwin tell Lyell about his South America volume?

    Darwin wrote to Lyell that the volume would be about 240 pages, "dreadfully dull, yet much condensed," and predicted Lyell would find the collection of facts on land elevation and terrace formation "pretty good." The text's author endorses "much condensed" but disputes "dull," noting Darwin spent three and a half years in South America doing continuous scientific work.

    Chapter 2

  2. According to the text, how did Darwin's geological work lead to conclusions about the fossil record?

    Darwin was struck by how rapidly evidence of earth movements is obliterated, especially rain-water percolating through deposits and dissolving shells and calcareous organisms. This led him to generalize that a palaeontological record can only be preserved during periods of long-continued slow subsidence, and then to the wider conclusion that the geological record is a series of isolated fragments.

    Chapter 2

  3. Why did Darwin argue that salt deposits lack marine shells?

    In his third chapter Darwin presented facts from the plains and valleys of Chile on saliferous deposits—salt, gypsum, and nitrate of soda. He insisted on the absence of marine shells in beds associated with such deposits, arguing that if the strata formed in shallow waters and were then exposed by upheaval to subaerial action, all shells and other calcareous organisms would be removed by solution.

    Chapter 2

  4. What did Darwin's discovery of a true Equus in the Pampean formation confirm?

    Darwin's account of the Pampean formation included mammalian remains such as Mastodon, Toxodon, Scelidotherium, Macrauchenia, Megatherium, Megalonyx, Mylodon, and Glyptodon. His discovery of a true Equus confirmed the fact already established in North America that horse species had existed and become extinct in the New World before the Spaniards introduced them in the sixteenth century.

    Chapter 2

Section 34 cards
  1. What did Darwin conclude about the tropical character of older tertiary productions in temperate Europe?

    Darwin argued that the causes which gave the older tertiary productions of the quite temperate zones of Europe a tropical character were of a local character and did not affect the whole globe. This opposed the prevalent view that a higher temperature prevailed universally during early geological periods. The author credits extensive travel with freeing Darwin from such prevailing prejudices.

    Chapter 3

  2. What did Darwin conclude about classifying geological periods across widely distant regions?

    Studying older formations in the Cordilleras of Northern and Central Chili, Darwin recognized an admixture of forms distinctive in Europe of the Cretaceous and Jurassic periods. He concluded that the classification of geological periods, though fairly expressing facts where the science was first studied, cannot be applied to widely distant regions. He generalized that each great period had a geographical distribution of life comparable to the existing fauna and flora.

    Chapter 3

  3. What did Darwin show about the mineral composition of granitic and lava rocks?

    Darwin's Andes studies convinced him of close relations between granitic or Plutonic rocks and undoubted lavas. With Professor Miller he compared their minerals and showed they are identical in all essential respects, and that a complete gradation exists between highly crystalline granitic rock-masses and lavas containing glassy matter between crystals. This contradicted the then-common creed that highly crystalline rocks are of great geological antiquity.

    Chapter 3

  4. What did Darwin conclude about the origin of foliation in metamorphic schists?

    Darwin insisted the distinct folia of quartz, feldspar, mica and other minerals in metamorphic schists could not have been separately deposited as sediment, opposing the view then generally prevalent. He concluded that foliation, like cleavage, is not an original but a superinduced structure, resulting from re-crystallisation of the rock's materials under the controlling influence of great pressure.

    Chapter 3

Section 44 cards
  1. What did Darwin conclude about the foliated structure of igneous rocks?

    Darwin argued that when igneous rocks undergo great differential movements during consolidation, they acquire a foliated structure closely analogous to that of crystalline schists. He inferred such rocks must have been in a plastic state, like cooling lava. Judd notes Darwin lacked later experiments by Tresca and Daubree showing solid masses become plastic under enormous pressure.

    Chapter 4

  2. Who opposed Darwin and Sharpe on foliation, and what did they claim?

    Sir Roderick Murchison and Dr. A. Geikie read a paper in 1861 to the Geological Society arguing that Scottish observations disproved Darwin's conclusion that foliation is a secondary structure independent of original stratification. They insisted foliation coincided with stratification. Daniel Sharpe had earlier defended Darwin's views in papers on the Scottish Highlands and the Alps.

    Chapter 4

  3. How did the Geological Survey's later work affect the Darwin-Murchison dispute?

    When officers of the Geological Survey began detailed study of the Scottish Highlands, they formally retracted the views Murchison and Geikie had put forward. They abandoned the idea that foliation was determined by original stratification and admitted it resulted from profound movements. Judd adds that Reusch in Norway and Lehmann in Saxony supported the same conclusions.

    Chapter 4

  4. What evidence of recent elevation did Darwin find near the Rio Plata?

    Near Maldonado, Darwin found a six-foot bed of muddy clay with shells of species still living in the Plata, including Azara labiata and Solen Caribaeus embedded vertically as it lived, only two feet above a lake. At Monte Video, living Mytilus beds lay raised some feet above the Plata, and at thirteen to sixteen feet M. Isabelle collected eight species.

    Chapter 4

Section 54 cards
  1. What do the shell-beds near the Rio de la Plata contain, and how far from the river do they lie?

    The shell-beds contain species that are all, perhaps with the exception of one Buccinum, recent and living on the South American coast, including Buccinanops globulosum, Olivancillaria auricularia, Venus flexuosa, Mactra Isabellei and Ostrea pulchella. They extend from one league to six leagues from the Plata and must lie many feet above its level.

    Chapter 5

  2. How does Darwin explain the parallel ranges of sand-dunes and the argillaceous flats between them?

    The author argues that tides on shoal, protected coasts tend to throw up a bar parallel to the shore at some distance from it; the bar grows, provides a base for sand-dunes, and the shallow space within silts up with mud. Repetition of this process, without any elevation, would form a level plain crossed by parallel sand-hillocks; during slow elevation the hillocks would rest on a gently inclined surface.

    Chapter 5

  3. What did Darwin find at Punta Alta within Bahia Blanca, and what was the height of the shells?

    Punta Alta is a small piece of tableland about twenty feet above high-water mark, formed of cemented gravel and red earthy mud abounding with shells and bones of extinct mammifers. The twenty shells, with a Balanus and two corals, are all recent species still living in neighbouring seas; five are identical with upraised shells near Buenos Ayres. He observed no shells higher than twenty feet there.

    Chapter 5

  4. How does Darwin account for pumice pebbles found 120 feet above sea level at Monte Hermoso?

    The author argues the pumice was originally brought down from the Cordillera by rivers crossing the continent, as the Negro anciently brought and still brings down pumice and the Chupat brings scoriae. Once delivered at a river mouth, the pebbles would travel along coasts and be cast up during elevation at different heights. Since no shells were seen above twenty feet, the age of these pebbles remains uncertain.

    Chapter 5

Section 63 cards
  1. What did d'Orbigny find at San Blas, and what uplift did it imply?

    At San Blas (40 degrees 40' S.), d'Orbigny found fourteen species of existing shells, six identical with those from Bahia Blanca, embedded in their natural positions. Judging from the depth zone these shells inhabit, they must have been uplifted thirty-two feet. He also found remains of an ancient beach fifteen to twenty feet above this bed.

    Chapter 6

  2. What shells did Darwin find at San Josef, and at what height?

    At San Josef, above gravel capping an old tertiary formation, Darwin found an irregular bed and hillock of sand several feet thick, abounding with Patella deaurita, Mytilus Magellanicus (retaining much colour), Fusus Magellanicus and a large Balanus, all still living on this coast. He estimated this bed at eighty to one hundred feet above sea level.

    Chapter 6

  3. What shells lay on the Port Desire plains, and in what condition?

    On the gravel-capped 245-255 and 330 feet plains, up to three or four miles inland, Darwin found Mytilus Magellanicus, M. edulis, Patella deaurita and another worn Patella. The shells looked very old: mussel blue much faded, Patellas with only traces of colour and scaling surfaces. They lay scattered on gravel, most abundant at heads of small valleys, often containing sand.

    Chapter 6

Section 73 cards
  1. What did Darwin find embedded in a hollow of the ninety-foot plain near Port Desire?

    In a hollow of the lowest plain, filled with sandy and reddish earthy matter, Darwin reports the skeleton of Macrauchenia Patachonica was embedded. The same earthy mass, on its surface and upper parts, contained numerous shells of Mytilus Magellanicus, M. edulis, Patella deaurita, and fragments of other species. The plain forms a promontory seven or eight miles long and three or four wide.

    Chapter 7

  2. How did the 355-foot plain at the Santa Cruz mouth rise toward the escarpment?

    Darwin states the 355-foot plain appears level to the eye, but crossing S.S.W. toward an escarpment about six miles away, it rose first insensibly and then sensibly in the last half-mile, reaching 463 feet — a rise of 108 feet in six miles. He looked for beach ridges, since local tides reach forty feet at syzygy, but saw none.

    Chapter 7

  3. What does Darwin conclude about the Santa Cruz valley's past, and on what evidence?

    The author argues that within the recent period the Santa Cruz formed a sea-strait intersecting the continent, leaving South America an archipelago of islands 360 miles north to south. He cites the bay-like diverging escarpments, sand-dunes on the head plain, a gap in the Cordillera, ancient shells of existing species in two places, and the fossil-bearing 355-463-foot plain sweeping from the Atlantic far up the valley.

    Chapter 7

Section 84 cards
  1. What heights above the river did Darwin measure for the Santa Cruz valley terraces?

    At a point midway between the Cordillera and the Atlantic, plain A north was 1,122 feet above the river; sixteen miles lower down B north was 869 feet; near A north, C north was 639 feet; D north was never measured; and the lowest terrace E north stood about twenty feet above the river in many places.

    Chapter 8

  2. How does Darwin explain the terraces rising in elevation up the valley?

    Darwin suspects the gradual inclination of the plains up the valley was chiefly caused by elevation of the continent in mass being greater nearer the Cordillera. The summit-plain rises from 840 feet on the coast to 1,416 feet at 100 miles inland and 3,200 to 3,300 feet near the Cordillera; D north rose 185 feet over twenty-four miles.

    Chapter 8

  3. What did Darwin conclude about the origin of the three upper Santa Cruz terraces?

    Darwin thinks there can be no doubt the three upper terraces were modelled by the sea, when the valley was occupied by a strait, in the same manner as the step-formed, shell-strewed plains along the Patagonian coast. He doubted terrace D was river-formed because its pebbles were whitewashed and cemented, unlike river-thrown pebbles.

    Chapter 8

  4. How does Darwin account for terrace E standing about twenty feet above the river?

    Darwin's first impression was to doubt terrace E was river-formed, but he notes horizontal upheaval increases a stream's total descent, boosting its corroding and deepening power first near the coast and then up the valley. So an alluvial plain formed nearly level with a stream can later be cut through and left standing above the water.

    Chapter 8

Section 94 cards
  1. What evidence does Darwin give for recent uplift extending far south of his shell finds?

    Darwin notes that the boulder formation continues at nearly the same height for 150 miles south of 53°20', his southernmost landing where he found upraised shells. He also cites Captain Sulivan's observation of a similar formation on Byron Sound in Tierra del Fuego, a fact he says he mentions especially because his earlier paper had declared the formation absent from the eastern island.

    Chapter 9

  2. How does Darwin define 'recent' in the context of the upraised shells?

    Darwin uses 'recent' to mean only the period within which the now living mollusca came into existence. He explicitly notes that this does not imply all associated remains are modern: at Bahia Blanca and P. S. Julian, the mammiferous quadrupeds that coexisted with these shells belong to extinct species, as he explains further in the Fourth Chapter.

    Chapter 9

  3. Why does Darwin doubt that upraised shells near the Plata indicate the full width of uplift?

    Darwin argues that near La Plata the distance from Maldonado to the Cordillera is 760 miles, and a N.N.E.–S.S.W. range of tertiary volcanic rocks at the head of the Plata estuary may mark an axis of elevation distinct from the Andes. Earthquakes have been felt in the Cordova chain but only gentle oscillations at Mendoza, so the Pampas may have risen along several distinct axes.

    Chapter 9

  4. What does Darwin conclude about the uniformity of the elevatory process?

    Darwin infers a remarkable degree of equability in the elevatory process from the similar heights of gravel-capped plains at distant points. He first measured the plains only to record where shells occurred, then was struck by the uniformity of his measurements compared with Survey measurements, and tabulated all representing summit-edges of plains. The 330 to 355 feet plain extends over 500 geographical miles north to south.

    Chapter 9

Section 103 cards
  1. What evidence leads Darwin to conclude the plains' modeling action was singularly uniform?

    Darwin reports repeated measurements of plain edges at consistent heights—about 245 to 255 feet from Port Desire to north of St. George's Bay, and similar coincidences at 560 to 580 and 80 to 100 feet over long distances. He notes he used all measurements representing plain edges, not a selected series, so he thinks the coincidences could scarcely be accidental, concluding the action modeling the plains was singularly uniform.

    Chapter 10

  2. How does Darwin explain the formation of the stepped, gravel-capped terraces?

    Darwin argues the sea is the active power: it cuts cliffs into soft strata, and the sea bed shoals gradually with a gravel bottom. If the coast were suddenly elevated one or two hundred feet, an inland escarpment would form with a gravel-capped sloping plain at its foot. Repetition of this elevatory and denuding process would produce a series of terraces rising one above another, like those in Patagonia.

    Chapter 10

  3. How does Darwin counter d'Orbigny's argument that upraised shells prove sudden elevation?

    Darwin argues that in protected bays where mud-banks accumulate or winds heap sand-dunes, shell beds could be preserved in living positions even at a constant level, and the smallest elevation would aid preservation. He does not exclude small earthquake-related starts, citing the 1835 uplift of a rocky flat at Santa Maria leaving attached mussel-shells. He cites parallel sand-dune lines at several levels as requiring long time, concluding the last 100 feet of elevation was exceedingly slow.

    Chapter 10

Section 114 cards
  1. How does Darwin explain the inclined, gravel-capped plains of Patagonia?

    The author argues that a slow, nearly equable rise of the coast, fast enough to prevent the waves from removing each part as it emerges, would make every portion of the sea bed successively form a beach-line. On this view the whole surface has been a beach, so no single beach-line need be marked, and an inclined surface thickly capped with well-rounded pebbles would be left.

    Chapter 11

  2. What does Darwin conclude about elevation along this coast within the period of existing shells?

    He concludes that at least 1,180 miles of coast has been elevated to 100 feet in La Plata and 400 feet in Southern Patagonia within the period of existing shells, but not of existing mammifers. In La Plata the elevation was very slow; in Patagonia it may have been by starts but probably slow and quiet, with long intervening periods of comparative rest during which the sea corroded the land.

    Chapter 11

  3. How many periods of denudation does Darwin count, and to what height was the land similarly modelled?

    Darwin states there have been at least eight periods of denudation, and that the land up to a height of from 950 to 1,200 feet has been similarly modelled and affected. He also says the periods of denudation and elevation were contemporaneous and equable over great spaces of coast, as shown by the equable heights of the plains.

    Chapter 11

  4. What does Darwin find remarkable about faults in the exposed strata?

    Considering the great upward movements along this long line of coast and the proximity of its southern half to the volcanic axis of the Cordillera, the author argues it is highly remarkable that in the many fine sections exposed in the Pampean, Patagonian tertiary, and Boulder formations, he nowhere observed the smallest fault or abrupt curvature in the strata.

    Chapter 11

Section 124 cards
  1. How does Darwin argue the Santa Cruz gravel pebbles were transported?

    Darwin argues the pebbles were not carried by rivers, since Patagonian streams are few and small and the Santa Cruz River has little transporting power—compact basalt pebbles were found only ten miles below their source. He concludes the pebbles came from the westward, probably chiefly from the Cordillera, and that ice-agency did not transport them, given the absence of angular fragments and the contrast with the boulder formation.

    Chapter 12

  2. Why does Darwin doubt the Santa Cruz mouth pebbles came from the nearby Cordillera?

    Darwin notes that high in the valley the gravel contains pebbles of crystalline feldspathic rocks, clay-slate, quartzose schists, pale porphyries, and basalt, with few or none of the reddish or gallstone-yellow porphyries common near the coast. Since the coast pebbles are mainly those porphyries, he concludes they were probably derived chiefly from farther north, except possibly the clay-slate, which may have come from the south.

    Chapter 12

  3. What is remarkable about the distribution of the gallstone-yellow siliceous porphyry pebbles?

    Darwin states the porphyry is not found in situ in Fuegia, the Falkland Islands, or the Patagonian coast, yet its pebbles occur over 840 miles north to south and at the Falklands, 300 miles east of Patagonia. He suggests their occurrence in Fuegia and the Falklands may perhaps be due to the same ice-agency that transported the boulders there.

    Chapter 12

  4. What evidence does Darwin give that Patagonian gravel was not ice-transported?

    Darwin argues the gravel of Central and Northern Patagonia was not transported by ice-agency because there are no angular fragments in the gravel, and because the shingle formation contrasts completely in many respects with the neighbouring boulder formation. He notes ice-agency seems to have played a considerable part farther south and in the northern hemisphere, but not here.

    Chapter 12

Section 134 cards
  1. What evidence does Darwin give that the sea can sift and distribute pebbles on its bottom?

    Darwin cites the gradual, uniform decrease in pebble size with increasing depth and distance offshore, which he says irresistibly shows the sea sifts and distributes loose bottom matter. He adds Martin White's report that the British Channel bed is disturbed during gales at sixty-three and sixty-seven fathoms, and that groundswells discolour the sea around the West Indian Islands.

    Chapter 13

  2. What difficulty about pebbles on the sea bottom does Darwin raise, and how does he resolve it?

    Experiments on running water suggest sea currents cannot move even moderate stones, and Darwin repeatedly found bottom pebbles encrusted with delicate, unbroken living corallines, implying they are rarely violently disturbed. He adopts Playfair's view: sea undulations tend to lift pebbles, so small forces can nudge them along, letting weak currents or undertow move them without harming the corallines.

    Chapter 13

  3. How do beach waves distribute shingle, according to Palmer as cited by Darwin?

    Darwin cites Mr. Palmer's memoir showing that vast masses of shingle travel with surprising quickness along lines of coast, according to the direction in which waves break on the beach, which is determined by the prevailing winds. Darwin says this agency could explain the wide distribution of the gallstone-yellow porphyry and differences between pebbles at the Santa Cruz mouth and valley head.

    Chapter 13

  4. What conclusion does Darwin reach about the origin of the Patagonian shingle-bed?

    Darwin declines to assign shares to the several complicated agencies, but from his chapter's considerations and the frequent gravel capping on tertiary deposits worldwide, he cannot doubt that widely dispersing gravel is an ordinary contingent of sea action. He concludes there is no occasion to call in debacles, and notes the formation's vast area, thickness, superficial position, recent origin, and similar pebbles deserve geological attention.

    Chapter 13

Section 144 cards
  1. What difficulty did Darwin face when viewing sea-worn cliffs of Patagonia and volcanic islands?

    He could not understand how horizontal tertiary strata and gently inclined lava streams, which must once have extended far seaward, could have been removed by the sea at a considerable depth beneath its surface. The St. Helena section illustrates this problem, since the basaltic streams appear to have once extended under what is now deep water.

    Chapter 14

  2. What does Captain Austin's survey show about the sea bottom around St. Helena?

    The bottom is uneven and rocky only within five or six fathoms of the beach. Beyond that, to about one hundred fathoms, it is smooth, gently inclined, and formed of mud and sand; past one hundred fathoms it plunges into unfathomable depths, as commonly occurs where sediment accumulates.

    Chapter 14

  3. How does Darwin explain the removal of hard basaltic rock beneath the sea at St. Helena?

    He argues that if St. Helena had slowly subsided over a long period, the difficulty would vanish. Waves would act on cliffs with fresh vigour, the rocky ledge near the beach would sink to depths where sand and mud settle on it, and renewed subsidence would repeat the process, smoothly burying each new rocky shoal.

    Chapter 14

  4. What general conclusion does Darwin suspect about cliff-bounded islands and Patagonia's shores?

    The author argues that in all such cases the land with the adjoining sea bed has in truth subsided. He suggests geologists will come to regard land retaining the same level through a whole geological period as improbable as the atmosphere staying absolutely calm for an entire season.

    Chapter 14

Section 154 cards
  1. What did Darwin find in the 350-foot shell bed near Catiman, Chiloe?

    On the south side of the Lacuy peninsula, Darwin found an immense bed of Venus costellata and oyster shells on the summit-edge of tableland 350 feet above sea level, packed in and covered by black peaty mould two or three feet thick, with a forest growing on it. The fine ridges on the Venus shells were perfectly preserved, though blackened. A few feet below, he found a horn of the little Cervus humilis, which still inhabits Chiloe.

    Chapter 15

  2. What did the three terraces near Castro indicate to Darwin?

    Near Castro, on each side of the Gamboa creek, Darwin saw three distinct terraces: the lowest about 150 feet and the highest about 500 feet, with the country rising irregularly behind. Obscure traces of the same terraces appeared elsewhere along the coast. Darwin states there can be no doubt that their three escarpments record pauses in the elevation of the island.

    Chapter 15

  3. How much did St. Mary island and Concepcion rise in the 1835 earthquake, and what happened after?

    Darwin recalls Fitzroy's account: the southern end of St. Mary island was uplifted eight feet, the central part nine, and the northern end ten, more than surrounding districts. Mussels, patellae, and chitons still adhering to rocks were raised above high-water mark, and a rocky flat formerly always submerged was left dry, exhaling an offensive smell from putrefying shells. Both St. Mary and Concepcion (uplifted only four or five feet) subsided within some weeks, losing part of their first elevation.

    Chapter 15

  4. What shells did Kent collect on the hill of Sentinella, and what did their condition show?

    From the hill of Sentinella behind Talcahuano, at 160 feet, Kent collected numerous shells packed close beneath the surface in black earth: two species of Mytilus, two of Crepidula, Concholepas, Fissurella, Venus, Mactra, Turbo, Monoceros, and Balanus psittacus. They were bleached, and within some Balani other Balani were growing, showing they had long lain dead in the sea. Darwin compared them with living bay species and found them identical.

    Chapter 15

Section 164 cards
  1. What evidence convinced Darwin that shells at 1,300 feet were raised by natural causes?

    Darwin cites the shells' uniform appearance of extreme antiquity, their distance from the coast or inaccessibility from the beach, the absence of fresh water for men, the shells not lying in heaps, and the close similarity of the embedding soil to soil lower down shown to be largely marine debris. He notes he had earlier stated proofs of elevation were unsatisfactory above 230 feet.

    Chapter 16

  2. How did Darwin interpret the earth packed inside high-elevation shells?

    Microscopic examination showed the mould from a Concholepas at about 100 feet was largely composed of minute fragments of Echini spines, mouth-bones and shells, plus tiny Patellae and Mytili. It smelled like garden-mould mixed with guano. Darwin argues this shows soils naturally considered purely terrestrial may owe their origin chiefly to the sea.

    Chapter 16

  3. Why did the native fisherman's ridicule matter to Darwin's argument?

    On a 557-foot hill Darwin found many very young, small shells under a quarter inch across, of Concholepas, Trochus, Patellae, Crepidulae and Mytilus. The fisherman ridiculed the idea such tiny shells were brought up for food, and some species could not have adhered to larger shells when alive. This supported natural, not human, transport.

    Chapter 16

  4. What did Darwin observe at Valparaiso about the level and extent of raised shells?

    A beach of broken shells about fourteen or fifteen feet above high-water mark appears in many places, with coast-rocks corroded in a band at that level. South of the bay, headlands between 60 and 230 feet are coated with thick masses of comminuted shells, mostly Concholepas. Shells remain numerous up to 1,000 feet and occur rarely at 1,300 feet.

    Chapter 16

Section 174 cards
  1. What evidence supports the idea that upraised shells were left on successive beach-lines?

    Darwin argues the shells are all littoral or sub-littoral species, found at various heights up to 1,300 feet, in vast numbers and generally comminuted. Combined with their position on hill summits and edges, he concludes they were left on successive beach-lines during gradual elevation of the land.

    Chapter 17

  2. How does Darwin explain whole, perfectly preserved shells on an exposed coast?

    He offers two explanations: shells thrown by gales onto flat rock ledges just above high-water mark, never touched by waves again as land rises; or rocky reefs covered with marine animals uplifted in one blow during earthquakes like those of 1822, 1835, and 1837. He considers the earthquake explanation most probable for the Mytilus and Mesodesma beds.

    Chapter 17

  3. What historical evidence at Valparaiso shows the land has risen?

    A sea-wall built around 1680 was still washed by waves in 1817-1819, but by 1834 houses stood seaward of it. A measured difference of eleven feet six inches between the wall's lowest visible part and the present beach-line shows rise. The church of S. Augustin, built 1614, stands nineteen feet six inches above the highest beach-line.

    Chapter 17

  4. What did Darwin observe about upraised shells between Valparaiso and Quintero?

    For seventy-five miles north of Valparaiso he found innumerable masses of upraised shells. At Quintero, immense accumulations of Mesodesma donaciforme were worked for lime, chiefly about fifteen feet above high-water, though Mr. Miers reports shells up to 500 feet and three leagues inland. Near Plazilla and Catapilco, at 200-300 feet, comminuted shells packed in layers were truly immense.

    Chapter 17

Section 184 cards
  1. What does Darwin say the losa rock consists of in parts, and how did it form?

    Darwin describes the losa as remarkable because parts are entirely formed of empty, pellucid capsules or cells of calcareous matter the size of small seeds. A series of specimens showed these capsules once contained minute rounded fragments of shells, since gradually dissolved by water percolating through the mass. The rock is divided into strata dipping about ten degrees seaward and is used for building.

    Chapter 18

  2. How do the embedded shells' proportions differ from the present beach, and what explanations does Darwin offer?

    Darwin was struck that the embedded shells, though all recent species still living nearby, differ in proportional numbers from those on the present beach: he found only one Concholepas and the Pecten was very rare, though both are now commonest. He declines to determine how far this depends on the deposit's age versus the difference between present sandy beaches and the calcareous bottom where the embedded shells must have lived.

    Chapter 18

  3. What evidence does Darwin give for recent slow elevation at Coquimbo?

    Darwin cites Mr. Caldcleugh's researches indicating a rise within the last century and a half, probably slow since no sudden change was observed during occasional earthquakes. The Pelicans rocks, a fleur d'eau in 1710 according to Feuillee, now stand said twelve feet above low-water mark, though spring-tides rise only five feet; another rock now nine feet above high-water was five or six feet out of water in Frezier's and Feuillee's time.

    Chapter 18

  4. Why does Darwin say absence of sea-shells on the surface is weak evidence against recent elevation?

    On the syenitic ridge bounding Herradura Bay, Darwin found Concholepas and Turritella cingulata fragments at 242 feet, and could not have told they weren't brought by man without one small mass cemented in friable calcareous tuff. He carefully searched many apparently favourable spots at lesser heights and found not even the smallest fragment. He argues this is one of many instances showing absence of surface shells, though often inexplicable, is an argument of very little weight against other evidence of recent elevation.

    Chapter 18

Section 193 cards
  1. What did Darwin conclude formed the six terraces at Coquimbo?

    Darwin argues the six terraces were formed by the action of the sea, with their five escarpments marking periods of comparative rest in the elevatory movement, during which the sea wore into the land. He bases this on shells strewn over terraces A, B, C and the upper plain F, all being littoral and sub-littoral species.

    Chapter 19

  2. Where within the valley did Darwin fail to find shells, and why does it matter?

    Within the valley, at only a mile and a half to three or four miles from the sea, Darwin could not find even a fragment of a shell, though marine remains were copiously strewed at the mouth on the lower terraces and south of town on the upper one. He says this fact well deserves notice, yet still treats the terraces as undoubtedly marine in origin.

    Chapter 19

  3. Why did Darwin favor a slow rather than sudden elevatory movement?

    Darwin argues the movement was probably slow, citing the littoral and sub-littoral shells on the three lower terraces and upper one, the gravel-capped terraces at Conchalee, analogical facts at Valparaiso, and evidence of a slow rise lately or still in progress. He allows the elevation between rest periods may have been sudden, averaging no more than seventy-two feet each time.

    Chapter 19

Section 202 cards
  1. Why does Darwin say the diagonal inclination of terraces differs between terraces?

    The author argues each terrace is an accumulation of successive beach-lines around bays whose forms and sizes differed at each level. In a narrow creek the beach slopes toward the middle; in an open bay or slight coastal concavity it slopes toward the mouth, almost seaward. As a bay changes shape and size, the inclination of its successive beaches changes too.

    Chapter 20

  2. Why is no single terrace horizontal across its whole breadth up the valley?

    Each separate beach-line must have been horizontal, but the only visible lines are the summit and basal edges of escarpments. How much terrace survives at the head versus the mouth depends on how slowly elevation resumed, how much river detritus arrived, and how protected the altered bay forms were. So terraces differ in transverse and longitudinal inclination.

    Chapter 20

Section 214 cards
  1. What evidence suggests uplift was greater inland than near the coast?

    Darwin cites Mr. Place's report that during Chile's 1822 earthquake the upheaval one mile inland was nearly double (five to seven feet) what it was on the Pacific. He also notes Bravais's finding that Scandinavian sea-beaches slope from the interior toward the coast and are not parallel, showing the coast-interior difference varied over time.

    Chapter 21

  2. How many terraces did Darwin observe in the valley of Guasco?

    Following the valley thirty-seven miles from the coast to Ballenar, Darwin found five grand terraces at corresponding heights on both sides, more conspicuous than Coquimbo's three best-developed ones. At Freyrina, twelve miles up, he counted six terraces beside the valley floor; the sixth is the summit-plain, expanding inland into a great basin.

    Chapter 21

  3. What did Darwin find on the plains near Copiapo?

    At the valley mouth, a plain estimated by Meyen at fifty to seventy feet has an upper part chiefly of gravel abounding with recent shells, mainly Concholepas, Venus Dombeyi, and Calyptraea trochiformis. Inland, on a plain Darwin estimated near three hundred feet, the upper stratum was broken shells and sand cemented by white calcareous matter, with Mulinia Byronensis and Pecten purpuratus most numerous.

    Chapter 21

  4. What does Darwin suggest about the gravel plain A north of the Guasco valley?

    In Figure 12, the summit-plain of gravel A on the northern side has two escarpments, one facing the valley and one facing a great basin-like plain B stretching several leagues north. Darwin argues this narrow plain evidently once formed a spit or promontory of gravel projecting into and dividing two great bays, later worn on both sides into steep cliffs.

    Chapter 21

Section 224 cards
  1. What did d'Orbigny conclude from shells still attached to porphyry at 300 feet near Cobija?

    D'Orbigny argued the elevation must have been great and sudden, since shells of Concholepas, Chiton, Calyptraea, Fissurella, and Patella—known to live close to the beach—were still attached where they had lived at 300 feet. Darwin disagrees, judging such sudden uplift improbable, even impossible, from his dredging experience, and calls gradual movement far more probable.

    Chapter 22

  2. How does Darwin explain the uplift indicated by the San Lorenzo shell bed?

    Darwin attributes it to gradual movement with small starts, like the earthquakes of 1822 and 1835, which lifted whole beds of attached shells above the reach of waves. The San Lorenzo bed, over two feet thick and traced a mile, lies up to eighty-five feet above high-water mark and contains eighteen recent species, some encrusted inside by Balani and Serpulae.

    Chapter 22

  3. What did Blake observe about the shells near Iquique that supported gradual uplift?

    Blake described a compact uniform bed inland toward the mountains where scarcely a trace of original shells is discernible; approaching the shore the forms become gradually more distinct until living shells appear on the coast. Darwin cites this progressive decay as showing how slowly and gradually the coast was uplifted, and says it is confirmed at Lima.

    Chapter 22

  4. What evidence at the Morro of Arica did Lieutenant Freyer report?

    Freyer stated the Morro of Arica is about four hundred feet high, worn into obscure terraces, with Balani and Milleporae adhering to bare rock. Between twenty and thirty feet the shells and corals were quite fresh, at fifty feet much abraded, and traces of organic remains occurred at greater heights—evidence Darwin aligns with gradual elevation.

    Chapter 22

Section 234 cards
  1. What human-made objects did Darwin find embedded with shells at San Lorenzo?

    Darwin dug into a level spot on San Lorenzo and found, indisputably embedded with the shells, a piece of woven rushes, a piece of nearly decayed cotton string, and heads of Indian corn, along with corallines, ovule-cases of Mollusca, seaweed roots, and birds' bones. He compared the rush, string, and corn with objects from ancient Peruvian burial-grounds and found them indistinguishable, noting the Peruvians used string only of cotton.

    Chapter 23

  2. Why did Darwin conclude the San Lorenzo shells accumulated on a true beach, not an earthquake-wave?

    Darwin argued the small quantity of sand or gravel, absence of large stones, width and thickness of the bed, and the time needed to cut a ledge into the sandstone all show the remains were not thrown up by an earthquake-wave. Instead these facts, with the many dead shells and floating objects marine and terrestrial, natural and human, make it almost certain they accumulated on a true beach since upraised eighty-five feet.

    Chapter 23

  3. What did Darwin find beneath the loam at the 120-foot cliff near Callao?

    At one of the highest parts of the cliff, about 120 feet above the sea, Darwin found two right-angled sections of the floor of a shed or building. Each face showed two rows of large round stones packed on an artificial layer of sand two inches thick, laid on the natural clay-beds, and covered by three feet of loam with broken sea-shells and pottery. He concluded the plain was inhabited before the loam was deposited.

    Chapter 23

  4. How did Darwin explain the loam with broken shells and pottery on the Callao plain?

    Darwin noted the plain's smoothness, the bulk of deposited matter, and obscure stratification suggest the loam was deposited underwater, while broken sea-shells, varied pebbles, and the artificial stone floor almost prove it came from a rush of water from the sea over the land. He argued that when the land stood eighty-five feet lower, such an event could have occurred, perhaps converting the plain into a temporary lake as happened in the earthquakes of 1713 and 1746.

    Chapter 23

Section 244 cards
  1. What does Darwin conclude about the cause of the corroded shells on San Lorenzo?

    The author argues that salt from sea-spray, packed with shells and occasionally moistened by Peruvian dew, partially decomposes the carbonate of lime. He notes a difficulty: the expected products would be carbonate of soda and muriate of lime, but only the latter is present, so he conjectures the carbonate of soda becomes a sulphate by unexplained means.

    Chapter 24

  2. What does Darwin say about the white powder on the second and third ledges?

    On the second ledge at 170 feet, a white powder up to two inches thick lies on salt-cemented sandstone fragments under about four inches of earth. It resembles the decayed shelly mass and he infers it was originally a bed of shells. Mr. Reeks found the same constituents as the lower-ledge powder, but with only very little carbonate of lime.

    Chapter 24

  3. What unexpected conclusion does Darwin draw about dry versus humid climates and shell preservation?

    The author argues that a dry climate, by leaving sea-spray salt undissolved, is much less favourable to preserving upraised shells than a humid climate. He supports this with San Lorenzo and Iquique, where shells packed with salt and occasionally moistened decay and lose their structure, and calls the conclusion very unexpected.

    Chapter 24

  4. What evidence does Darwin cite for elevation exceeding eighty-five feet at San Lorenzo?

    Darwin states San Lorenzo has been upraised eighty-five feet since the Peruvians inhabited the country. He argues that whatever recent subsidence occurred, the elevation must have exceeded eighty-five feet by that amount. He also cites Ulloa's sea-action marks five leagues north of Callao and Cruikshank's sea-cliffs with rounded blocks at 700 feet near Lima.

    Chapter 24

Section 254 cards
  1. Over what distance along the Pacific coast do upraised marine remains occur, per Darwin?

    Darwin states upraised marine remains occur at intervals, and in some parts almost continuously, from latitude 45 degrees 35' to 12 degrees S. along the Pacific shores—a north-south distance of 2,075 geographical miles. He notes Byron's observations extend the elevation sixty miles further south, and the similarity of country near Lima suggests it probably extended many leagues further north.

    Chapter 25

  2. What elevations of upraised shells does Darwin report at Chiloe, Concepcion, Valparaiso, Coquimbo, and Lima?

    Judging from upraised shells alone, Darwin estimates elevation at Chiloe of 350 feet, at Concepcion certainly 625 feet (by estimation 1,000), at Valparaiso 1,300 feet, at Coquimbo 252 feet, and at Lima 85 feet, where shells were decaying, probably hastened by salt. North of Coquimbo he believes shells have not been found above 300 feet.

    Chapter 25

  3. Why does Darwin think the elevation at Coquimbo was much less than at Valparaiso?

    Darwin believes recent elevation at Coquimbo was much less than Valparaiso's 1,300 feet, based on finding no shells above 252 feet and on a small change in proportional numbers of species between living and upraised shells. He argues such inequality only 200 miles apart is not improbable, given differences in earthquake shocks along the coast and the fact that single areas like Concepcion have been uplifted unequally during one earthquake.

    Chapter 25

  4. What evidence shows the elevation of the land is generally intermittent rather than continuous?

    Darwin cites successive terraces and escarpments at defined heights—three at Chiloe within about 500 feet, five at Coquimbo within 364 feet, six at Guasco, and three at Lima within about 250 feet—showing the upward movement was interrupted by periods of comparative rest and denudation. He concludes, with evidence from other parts of the world, that elevation of the land is generally an intermittent action, and the long-removed matter suggests the rests were very long.

    Chapter 25

Section 264 cards
  1. What evidence led Darwin to conclude the western coast's elevation was slow and gradual?

    Darwin argues the movement was slow and gradual, aided probably by small occasional starts. His evidence: the analogy of movements now in progress, and vast numbers of shells now living exclusively on or close to the beach, strewn over the land up to considerable heights. At Coquimbo, five escarpments within 364 feet show that even if elevations were sudden, they cannot have been very great.

    Chapter 26

  2. Why does Darwin use the term 'comparative rest' rather than absolute rest for the elevation?

    The rest is comparative both with what preceded and followed it, and with the sea's power of corrosion at each spot and level. At Chiloe a vegetated fringe lies between the present beach and low cliffs the waves lately reached, so land is gaining. Near Lima, cliffs show the sea gaining on land, with evidence of recent subsidence. Only narrow rock ledges or narrow detritus mounds prove long absolute stationariness.

    Chapter 26

  3. What does Darwin say about the horizontality of terraces formed of gravel or sand?

    He notes that in terraces of gravel or sand, even if the elevation was strictly horizontal, no single level beach-line may be traceable, and neither the terraces themselves nor the summit or basal edges of their escarpments may be horizontal. Only where the sea slowly corroded a narrow ledge into solid rock, or heaped a narrow detritus mound, can long absolute stationariness be confidently asserted.

    Chapter 26

  4. Over what distances does Darwin report upraised recent organic remains on the two coasts?

    On the Atlantic, shells occur at intervals from Eastern Tierra del Fuego for 1,180 miles northward; on the Pacific, for 2,075 miles. For 775 miles they occur in the same latitudes on both sides. He suggests the Pacific shores were continuously and recently upraised from Lima for 2,480 nautical miles southward, equal to the distance from the Red Sea to the North Cape of Scandinavia.

    Chapter 26

Section 274 cards
  1. How does Darwin explain the drainage of the Rancagua basin flowing to three separate openings?

    Darwin argues the eye-level plain was finely modelled so drainage goes to three mountain breaches without conspicuous watersheds: water first flows north through the land-strait, then southwest to the northern western breach, then to the southern breach, with no marked ridge crossed. He compares this to Captain Herbert's account of similar drainage in Himalayan plains.

    Chapter 27

  2. Why does Darwin reject the lake-burst and debacle theories for the basin-plains?

    Darwin rejects the inhabitants' sudden lake-drainage idea because multiple separate breaches sit at nearly the same level, which he says precludes it. He also calls the great-debacle view of Meyen and Gay improbable in the highest degree, citing well-rounded pebbles, stratification with sand layers, overlying calcareous tuff, and worn hummocks.

    Chapter 27

  3. What evidence leads Darwin to conclude the basin-plains were formed by the sea during slow emergence?

    Darwin argues the mountains were breached, islet-like rocks worn, and stratified detritus deposited by the sea as land slowly emerged. He cites the plains' continuous union with the Rio Rapel plain showing sea-action marks, similarity to coast plains with upraised marine remains, and resemblance to Tierra del Fuego fiords, where tidal sawing kept breaches open.

    Chapter 27

  4. How does Darwin answer the objection that no marine remains are found in these high inland plains?

    Darwin says the absence cannot be properly adduced against a marine origin: shells are not found in Patagonia's great shingle beds though copiously strewn on their surfaces, showing such deposits are eminently unfavourable for embedding remains. As for surface shells, the previous chapter showed exposed remains decay and disappear over time.

    Chapter 27

Section 284 cards
  1. What evidence led Darwin to conclude the eastern Cordillera escarpments were formed by the sea?

    Darwin observed an eighty-foot escarpment of perfectly round pebbles running north-south near Mendoza, with a second similar gravel escarpment behind it. Because these escarpments become broken and obliterated north of Mendoza and never enclosed a lake-like area, he concludes they were formed by the sea when it reached the foot of the Cordillera, like similar escarpments on the coasts of Chile and Patagonia.

    Chapter 28

  2. How do the gravel terraces of the Cordilleran valleys differ from ordinary detritus?

    The terrace gravel consists of perfectly rounded, generally stratified pebbles with parting seams of sand, sometimes coated with aluminous or calcareous crust. The detritus has more angular fragments, unequal rounding, associated earth, no stratification, and irregular upper surfaces. Darwin could point out the separation line to within an inch or two, the stratified shingle containing only a small proportion of the adjoining colored rock fragments, and those well rounded.

    Chapter 28

  3. What did Darwin conclude about the porphyry hillocks at the mouth of the Portillo valley?

    At the valley mouth, about 3,500 feet above sea level, small isolated hillocks of several porphyry varieties project. Smooth, often white-washed pebbles of these same porphyries, excluding all others, extend a circumscribed distance around them, amid the vast stream of stones from the main Cordillera. Darwin argues only the quiet, long-continued action of the sea on these hillocks could have rounded and white-washed the fragments and made them radiate from such insignificant centers.

    Chapter 28

  4. What exception did Darwin note to the rule that abundant terrace boulders indicate the same rock higher upstream?

    Darwin observed that where blocks of a rock became numerous on or in a terrace, that rock soon appeared in situ higher up. The exception is the Cachapual valley, where M. Gay found numerous large white granite blocks not occurring nearby; Gay states the granite lies at least twenty leagues away, though Darwin suspects it will be found closer. Darwin also saw rounded blocks of white granite and andesitic syenite near the baths of Cauquenes, above the terrace.

    Chapter 28

Section 294 cards
  1. Why does Darwin reject ordinary river action for the valley gravel fringes?

    The author argues rivers could not have deposited the shingle along every valley and branch as the land now stands, because the same rivers are now removing much of the deposit and are everywhere tending to cut deep, narrow gorges in the hard underlying rocks. He calls the river-deposition idea preposterous.

    Chapter 29

  2. What features show the valley gravel was not mountain detritus or a debacle?

    Darwin cites the gravel's distinct stratification, smooth upper surface, well-rounded and sometimes encrusted pebbles (unlike loose mountain debris), and terraces keeping uniform inclination around the most abrupt bends. These contrast completely with detritus piles on valley sides and in front of ravines, ruling out both fallen detritus and debacles.

    Chapter 29

  3. How does Darwin explain the gravel terraces using sea action and uplift?

    He supposes the sea once occupied the valleys, as it now does in southern parts where creeks penetrate the range, and that the mountains rose slowly. Each valley bottom stood at the head of a sea creek; torrents delivered rock fragments, tides rolled and encrusted them, rudely stratified them, and levelled the surface by blending successive beach lines.

    Chapter 29

  4. Why would periods of rest during uplift leave little trace in the gravel terraces?

    Waves at the heads of deep creeks have little erosive power. So if the sea stayed at one level, the upper creek simply filled with gravel and sand to water level, and later rivers laid a talus over it. After the creeks became valleys, the main difference at long-rest points is a gentler inclination and river-worn rather than sea-worn detritus on the surface.

    Chapter 29

Section 304 cards
  1. How does Darwin explain the formation of terrace-like fringes at the Cordillera's foot?

    The author argues these terrace-like fringes, continuously joined to the basin-shaped plains at the foot of the Cordillera, were formed by the arrestment of river-borne detritus at successive levels. He compares this to what now occurs at the heads of the many deep, winding fiords on the southern coasts. He calls this one of the most important conclusions of his South American geological observations.

    Chapter 30

  2. What does Darwin conclude about the uplift of the Cordillera mountain-chain?

    The author argues that one of the grandest and most symmetrical mountain-chains in the world, with its several parallel lines, was uplifted together in mass between seven and nine thousand feet, gradually, in the same manner as the eastern and western coasts within the recent period. He allows slight differences in elevation, but infers no great abrupt faults since the sea occupied these valleys, since the gravel terraces remain continuous.

    Chapter 30

  3. What one difficulty does Darwin admit for his view, and how does he address it?

    The far-transported blocks high on the sides of the valley of the Cachapual. He declines to fully explain them, but suggests the Cauquenes ridge was raised long after neighboring ranges, greatly altering the country; and that events like Molina's 1762 earthquake slip, which dammed the Lontue for ten days before bursting and inundating the country, may have moved great rock fragments.

    Chapter 30

  4. Why does Darwin reject classifying the Cachapual boulders with European erratic boulders?

    He notes the blocks he saw are not gigantic, are not angular, and were not transported fairly across low spaces or wide valleys. So he is unwilling to class them with boulders in both hemispheres that Geological Transactions volume 6 page 415 says were transported by ice. He hopes M. Gay's long-continued Chilean labours will throw more light on the subject.

    Chapter 30

Section 314 cards
  1. What did Darwin conclude about the relative power of sea water versus rain and rivers on land?

    The author argues that sea water is far the most efficient agent on land, and that its chief tendency is to widen valleys, while torrents and rivers tend to deepen them and remove the debris of the sea's destruction. Because waves have more power where the space is open and exposed, they widen valley mouths more than upper parts, which he says explains why most valleys expand at their mouths.

    Chapter 31

  2. How did earthquake waves move large rock and brick masses on the South American coast?

    Darwin reports that after the 1835 Concepcion earthquake he saw large sandstone slabs, one six feet long, three broad and two thick, thrown high on the beach, torn from considerable depth judging by adhering marine animals. At Callao, the recoil-wave of the 1746 earthquake carried brickwork masses three to four feet square seaward. He cites these to explain granite boulders embedded in fine tertiary sediment.

    Chapter 31

  3. What did Darwin conclude about the origin of the superficial saline beds near Iquique?

    Though the beds stand about three thousand feet above sea level, Darwin concludes the salt was left by evaporation of sea-water, extending d'Orbigny's conclusion to Iquique. He abandoned his earlier alluvial idea after finding the salt-cemented sand consists of thin layers of differently tinted sand alternating with very fine parallel salt layers, not irregular cementation. D'Orbigny cited recent sea-shells on and rounded blocks beneath the beds.

    Chapter 31

  4. What evidence showed the anhydrite veins in the gypseous concretions formed by segregation, not infiltration?

    Each small embedded fragment of foreign rock is edged by a narrow border of pure white anhydrite, which would not happen if the veins formed by later infiltration. Some cracked included fragments are penetrated by anhydrite, with portions evidently mechanically displaced. Darwin compares this to calcareous matter deposited by rain water at St. Helena, which also separated small rock fragments from larger masses.

    Chapter 31

Section 324 cards
  1. How did Darwin explain the origin of the nitrate of soda bed?

    The author argues the compact, gently inclined bed following the plain's sinuous margin for miles was deposited from a sheet of water. He cites embedded shell fragments, abundant iodic salts, a higher-level saliferous crust probably of marine origin, and the plain's resemblance to those of Chile and Uspallata as evidence that this water was at least originally connected with the sea.

    Chapter 32

  2. What did Parchappe's analyses reveal about the saline incrustations near Bahia Blanca?

    Specimens from the extreme head of the low plain near the River Manuello consisted of 93 per cent sulphate of soda and 7 per cent common salt, while specimens taken close to the coast contained only 63 per cent sulphate and 37 per cent muriate of soda. Darwin suggests this, plus the plain's recent submergence, hints common salt may change into sulphate by some unknown process.

    Chapter 32

  3. What did Hayes's analysis of an average nitrate of soda specimen show?

    Hayes found 64.98 per cent nitrate of soda, 3.00 per cent sulphate of soda, 28.69 per cent chloride of soda, 0.63 per cent iodic salts, and 2.60 per cent shells and marl, totaling 99.90. Darwin notes purity varies, with Blake reporting nitrate content from 20 to 75 per cent, and nodules of common salt often present.

    Chapter 32

  4. Where and under what conditions do saline incrustations most often occur in South America?

    Darwin reports they occur most frequently on low damp surfaces of mud where the climate is rather dry, and these low surfaces have in almost every case been raised above sea level within the recent period. He notes they are most abundant near Bahia Blanca, where square miles of mud-flats whiten after dry weather, and the thickest crust does not exceed a quarter of an inch.

    Chapter 32

Section 334 cards
  1. Where do salinas occur on the eastern side of the continent?

    Darwin reports salinas in the argillaceo-calcareous deposit of the Pampas, in the sandstone of the Rio Negro where they are very numerous, in the pumiceous and other beds of the Patagonian tertiary formation, and in small primary districts within that formation. Port S. Julian, at latitude 49 to 50 degrees, is the most southerly point where they are known to occur.

    Chapter 33

  2. What did Mr. Reeks's analysis of Rio Negro salina salt show?

    Reeks found the salt composed entirely of chloride of sodium, except 0.26 of sulphate of lime and 0.22 of earthy matter, with no traces of iodic salts. Salt from the Pampean formation's salina Chiquitos is equally pure. Darwin notes this purity, or absence of other saline bodies found in all sea-water, as the only assignable cause for its inferiority in preserving meat.

    Chapter 33

  3. What did Darwin conclude about the origin of the salina salt?

    Darwin says the analysis seems opposed to d'Orbigny's view that the salt comes from evaporation of sea-water and drainage from sea-salt-impregnated strata. He notes a reported brine spring on the north side of the Rio Negro salina, suggesting at least that case may be subterranean. He argues fresh water near salinas is opposed to salt being washed from surrounding strata, but not to its being sea-water residue left as land was elevated.

    Chapter 33

  4. What crystals did Darwin find in the mud of the Rio Negro salina?

    Darwin found crystals of sulphate of soda lying crossways on the muddy bottom, and embedded in the mud numerous crystals of sulphate of lime from one to three inches long; d'Orbigny reports some acicular and over nine inches. Locals call the selenite crystals 'padre del sal' and the sulphate of soda 'madre del sal,' saying the sulphate of soda dissolves annually and crystallises before common salt.

    Chapter 33

Section 344 cards
  1. What does Dr. Carpenter conclude about the microscopic structure of the Pampas tosca-rock?

    Dr. Carpenter found most specimens amorphous with traces of incipient crystalline metamorphosis; others contained minute rounded amorphous concretions cemented by often-crystalline material. He detected traces of shells, corals, Polythalamia, and rarely spongoid bodies. He noted that chemical precipitation yields carbonate of lime in an opaque amorphous state, but Darwin says it would be hazardous to conjecture whether the Pampas material formed that way.

    Chapter 34

  2. What evidence shows the Pampean mud was deposited within the period of an existing estuary shell?

    Near Buenos Ayres, Sir W. Parish reported numerous shells of Azara labiata (and probably Venus sinuosa) embedded in a stratified earthy mass with small marly concretions, said to be precisely like the great Pampean deposit, on the highest parts of the plain about forty feet above the Plata. Darwin concludes the Pampas mud continued to be deposited to within the period of this existing estuary shell.

    Chapter 34

  3. What did Darwin observe at the Salado River cliffs regarding fossils and gypsum?

    The cliffs on the Salado consist of pale Pampean mud including and passing into great masses of tosca-rock. There a skeleton of the Megatherium and bones of other extinct quadrupeds were found. Large quantities of crystallised gypsum occur in these cliffs, and Mr. Lumb assured Darwin it also occurs in Pampean mud on the River Chuelo, seven leagues from Buenos Ayres. Darwin mentions this because d'Orbigny stressed the supposed absence of gypsum.

    Chapter 34

  4. What does Darwin say about the presence of shells in the Pampean formation overall?

    Darwin states that although the formation is of immense extent, he knows of no other instance of the presence of shells in it besides those near Buenos Ayres. There, recent marine and estuary shells occur on the surface as far as three or four leagues from the Plata, and shells embedded in marly rock at A. del Tristan closely resemble the Azara labiata.

    Chapter 34

Section 354 cards
  1. How does Darwin explain the tosca-rock hills standing higher around the Sierras?

    The author argues the greater height of the Pampean formation around these primary hills should not be attributed chiefly to more energetic uplift, but to the argillaceo-calcareous mud having collected around them when they existed as islets or submarine rocks, at a greater height than the adjoining open sea bottom; the cliffs were later worn during elevation of the whole country in mass.

    Chapter 35

  2. What surprised Darwin about the calcareous plain at the foot of Sierra Ventana?

    Although the marly beds come up nearly horizontally to the mountain foot and interfold between parallel ranges, Darwin was greatly surprised to find not a single pebble on the boundless calcareous plain only half a mile from the lofty, jagged, battered mountains. Quartz-pebbles of considerable size had, however, been transported forty to fifty miles to the shores of Bahia Blanca.

    Chapter 35

  3. What does Darwin suspect about the ridge twenty miles south of Bahia Blanca?

    The ridge runs W. by N. and E. by S., formed of small, separate, flat-topped, steep-sided hills rising 100 to 200 feet above the Pampean plain. Its uppermost stratum is pale, highly calcareous, compact tosca-rock resting on reddish Pampean mud. Since the strata show no disturbance and the direction matches the metamorphic lines of the area, Darwin suspects the Pampean sediment accumulated on and over a ridge of hard rocks, rather than around submarine flanks.

    Chapter 35

  4. What strata did Darwin find in the Monte Hermoso section at Bahia Blanca?

    The section is about one hundred feet high with four apparently horizontal strata thickening slightly to the N.W.: an uppermost bed of obliquely laminated soft sandstone with quartz pebbles, a hard dark sandstone only six inches thick, then pale Pampean mud, and finally darker Pampean mud with horizontal layers and lines of pinkish tosca-rock concretions. Ehrenberg found three Polygastrica and six Phytolitharia in the two lower beds.

    Chapter 35

Section 364 cards
  1. What do the shells in the two gravel beds at Punta Alta indicate about the coast?

    M. d'Orbigny named twenty species of Mollusca from the two gravel beds, and Darwin notes that all these shells now live on this coast, most in the same bay. The proportional numbers of kinds matched those then cast up on the beach, with Voluta, Crepidula, Venus and Trochus most abundant. Four or five species also match upraised shells near Buenos Ayres.

    Chapter 36

  2. How does Darwin explain the numerous rodent remains at Monte Hermoso?

    Darwin doubts the beds formed in an open sea 800 to 1,000 feet deep, since that would require drifting nearly perfect carcasses hundreds of miles. He argues the area was slowly rising during the Pampean period, forming land of Pampean sediment round the Ventana and other ranges where quadrupeds lived, and a stream drifted their bodies into the adjoining sea.

    Chapter 36

  3. What are the four beds in the Punta Alta section, from bottom to top?

    Bed A is stratified gravel or conglomerate with pinkish marl layers, holding many gigantic mammifer bones and shells. Bed B is red tough clayey mud resembling Pampean mud, with a Dasypoid dermal armour. Bed C is stratified gravel with more shells and a Megatherium head. Bed D is an unconformable mantle of stratified sandy earth with pebbles and shells.

    Chapter 36

  4. What condition and appearance do the Punta Alta shells show?

    Darwin describes all the specimens as having a very ancient and bleached appearance, and they do not emit an animal odour when heated. Some are changed throughout into a white, soft, fibrous substance; others have the space between the external walls either hollow or filled with crystalline carbonate of lime. He suspects a fresher-looking Bulinus was collected by mistake.

    Chapter 36

Section 374 cards
  1. Which extinct mammals did Professor Owen describe from the two gravel beds?

    Owen described remains including Megatherium Cuvierii, Megalonyx Jeffersonii, Mylodon Darwinii, a giant edentate, an almost entire Scelidotherium leptocephalum skeleton, Toxodon fragments, a tooth of Equus curvidens, and a pachyderm tooth allied to Palaeotherium, probably Macrauchenia Patagonica. Darwin also found bony armour of a large Dasypoid quadruped with foot bones attached.

    Chapter 37

  2. What does Darwin conclude from bones retaining their minutest prominences?

    Darwin concludes that bones preserving all their finest prominences, even in the coarsest conglomerate, were probably protected by skin, flesh, or ligaments when buried. For the Scelidotherium he states it is quite certain the whole skeleton was held together by its ligaments when deposited in the gravel. He notes some bones were instead broken, abraded, and rolled before embedding.

    Chapter 37

  3. What did Ehrenberg find in the fine matter near the mammalian remains?

    Ehrenberg found two Polygastrica, decidedly marine forms, and six Phytolitharia, one probably marine and the rest fresh-water or terrestrial. Only one of the eight is shared with Monte Hermoso, but five are shared with Pampean mud on the Parana banks. Darwin finds the fresh-water infusoria remarkable given the arid country, and suggests they were washed out of the Pampean formation and redeposited.

    Chapter 37

  4. How does the fauna of these gravel beds contrast with Monte Hermoso?

    Darwin calls the preponderance of edentate quadrupeds remarkable, and notes the absence of rodents as a contrast with the beds of Monte Hermoso. He also records that most bones are soft and friable and, like the shells, emit no animal odour when burnt, and that barnacles, Serpulae, and corallines are attached to many bones.

    Chapter 37

Section 384 cards
  1. What does Darwin conclude about d'Orbigny's suggestion that the mammiferous remains were washed out and redeposited?

    The author rejects d'Orbigny's supposition entirely. He argues the bones' delicate prominences and surfaces are too perfect to have been re-embedded, that the Scelidotherium skeleton was indisputably deposited whole, and that the fragile tessellated armour of the Dasypoid quadruped could not have survived transport without being dashed into atoms. He concludes these quadrupeds were embedded fresh in the strata where found.

    Chapter 38

  2. What does Darwin conclude about the relative age of the Punta Alta deposits compared with Monte Hermoso?

    The author concludes the coarse sub-littoral deposits of Punta Alta are of subsequent origin to the Pampean mud of Monte Hermoso. His grounds are the rolled fragment of black bone at Punta Alta, resembling those from Monte Hermoso, and the fact that the plain of Punta Alta is lower than that of Monte Hermoso. He adds that Monte Hermoso is probably later than the high tosca-plain near Sierra Ventana.

    Chapter 38

  3. What did Darwin observe in the cliffs at San Nicolas that bears on the Pampean formation's origin?

    In the cliffs on the Parana at San Nicolas, the Pampean mud contains little tosca. Darwin recorded in his notebook 'horizontal lines of variation both in tint and compactness,' quoting it because d'Orbigny had insisted on the general absence of stratification as proof of the deposit's diluvial origin. d'Orbigny had found there remains of two rodents and the jaw of a Canis.

    Chapter 38

  4. What did Darwin find at Gorodona regarding the Mastodon Andium skeletons and the base of the Pampean deposit?

    At Gorodona, in the estancia, two gigantic skeletons of Mastodon Andium were embedded six feet above the river. Their bones were scattered a few feet apart, but many still held proper relative positions; they were much decayed and soft as cheese, one great molar tooth crumbling in Darwin's hand. He notes this shows the Pampean deposit contains mammiferous remains close to its base.

    Chapter 38

Section 394 cards
  1. What did Ehrenberg conclude about the origin of the deposit from the mastodon tooth at Gorodona?

    Professor Ehrenberg found seven Polygastrica and thirteen Phytolitharia in red mud from a mastodon tooth. Most were fresh-water forms; only two Coscinodiscus species and a Spongolithis showed direct marine influence. He therefore concluded the deposit was of brackish-water origin. Nine of the thirteen Phytolitharia also occur in the Bahia Blanca deposits, which other Polygastrica indicate were brackish.

    Chapter 39

  2. What two formations make up the cliff section at St. Fe Bajada?

    The lower half consists of tertiary strata with marine shells; the upper half, about thirty feet thick, is Pampean mud, pale below and brighter red above, with arenaceous tosca layers and small concretions. The lowest bed is obliquely laminated blackish indurated mud with vegetable remains. Darwin notes his section differs from d'Orbigny's, perhaps because the beds vary over short distances.

    Chapter 39

  3. Which fossils identified the St. Fe Bajada beds as belonging to the Patagonian formation?

    M. d'Orbigny named eight shells from these beds, including Ostrea Patagonica, Ostrea Alvarezii, Pecten Paranensis, Pecten Darwinianus, Venus Munsterii, Arca Bonplandiana, and Cardium Platense. All species are extinct. The six first were found by d'Orbigny and Darwin in formations of the Rio Negro, S. Josef, and other parts of Patagonia, so the beds belong to the great Patagonian formation.

    Chapter 39

  4. What did Darwin conclude about the white hard tosca bed just above the marine limestone?

    He first considered this thin concretionary bed as marking a passage between the inferior deposits and the Pampean formation. He later became convinced he was deceived on this point, so it should be regarded as either the uppermost bed of the inferior deposits or the lowest of the Pampean formation, not as transitional between them.

    Chapter 39

Section 404 cards
  1. What does Darwin say about the Pampean deposit in Banda Oriental compared with the Pampas?

    The author notes that in Banda Oriental the Pampean formation might readily be mistaken for an alluvial deposit. Compared with the Pampas, it is often more sandy, contains small fragments of quartz, has much smaller concretions, and lacks extensive masses of tosca-rock. Near Maldonado it is more arenaceous and holds small concretions of marl and ferruginous sandstone.

    Chapter 40

  2. What did Darwin find in the cliffs at P. Gorda regarding the Pampean deposit?

    In the vertical cliff at P. Gorda, the upper bed is crystalline cellular limestone with shells like those at St. Fe Bajada. Beneath it lies white sand, then pale clay with Ostrea Patagonica, and near river level a bed of red mud like the Pampean deposit with large white compact tosca-rock concretions. Darwin corrects his earlier inaccurate statement about the order.

    Chapter 40

  3. What did the bones found in the Sarandis valley contain, and why were they notable?

    The bones included a head of Toxodon Platensis, a Mylodon head, and dermal armour differing from Glyptodon clavipes. They were notable for their extraordinarily fresh appearance: held over a spirit lamp they gave a strong odour and burned with a small flame. Mr. Reeks found about 7 percent animal matter and 8 percent water.

    Chapter 40

  4. Why does Darwin think the later Pampean-like deposit in western Banda Oriental postdates the tertiary hills?

    Darwin argues the deposit is of quite subsequent origin because the sea had already worn the tertiary strata into cliff-bounded hills before it was laid down. He admits he never obtained a section of it close to the foot of the higher hills, but says he has not the least doubt about the ordering.

    Chapter 40

Section 414 cards
  1. What did Darwin conclude about the red sandstone and crystalline white limestone near Calera de los Huerfanos?

    Although the two beds differ greatly, Darwin believed they were equivalents: the crystalline white limestone is the uppermost bed and often passes into calcareous sandstone interstratified with pure sand, while the red sandstone also passes into soft white sandstone and is likewise uppermost. He extended this equivalence to the calcareous tuff, tosca-like stone, and semi-crystalline limestone of the flat-topped hills near S. Juan.

    Chapter 41

  2. What evidence led Darwin to infer volcanic action during the tertiary period in this region?

    Darwin was struck by the resemblance of the agates, chalcedonic and jaspery rocks, some limestones, and bright red sandstones to deposits formed near volcanic action. He cites M. Isabelle's description of similar beds on the Itaquy and Ibicuy containing fragments of red decomposed true scoriae hardened by zeolite and black retinite, and notes Bonpland's amygdaloidal rocks near S. Anna as possibly of the same epoch.

    Chapter 41

  3. What did Darwin find in the earthy mass at Port S. Julian, and why did he think the skeleton was buried intact?

    He found a large part of the skeleton of Macrauchenia Patachonica, a gigantic pachyderm allied, per Professor Owen, to Palaeotherium but with affinities to Ruminants, especially American Camelidae. Several vertebrae in a chain and nearly all bones of one limb, down to the smallest foot bones, lay in proper relative positions, so the skeleton was certainly still united by flesh or ligaments when enveloped in mud.

    Chapter 41

  4. Why did Darwin consider the S. Julian earthy mass only accidentally similar to the Pampean formation?

    The mass resembles Pampean sections such as P. Alta and Barrancas de S. Gregorio, filling furrows in the underlying gravel with concretions and mammiferous remains. But Darwin suspected the resemblance was only accidental, believing mud now accumulating in deep narrow gullies at the head of the harbour would, after elevation, present a very similar appearance. The true Pampean formation's southernmost part on the Colorado lies 560 miles north.

    Chapter 41

Section 424 cards
  1. How does Darwin date the Macrauchenia relative to the raised shells?

    Darwin argues the Macrauchenia was entombed in a fresh state and lived after the gravel on the 90-feet plain was spread out. Since that plain formed after the 250-feet and 350-to-400-feet plains were elevated with recent shells on them, the skeleton must postdate those upraised shells, eight species of which are still living on the coast.

    Chapter 42

  2. Why does Darwin reject d'Orbigny's debacle theory for the Pampean formation?

    Darwin argues a debacle cannot explain horizontal zones of colour, upper and lower parts differing in colour and constitution, or marly concretions arranged in horizontal lines rather than irregularly. He also asks where so vast a mass of fine calcareous mud could have accumulated, and notes the same agency supposedly carried only mud in the Pampas but only gravel in Patagonia.

    Chapter 42

  3. What is the extent of the Pampean formation according to the chapter?

    Darwin passed continuously over it from the Colorado to St. Fe Bajada, 500 geographical miles, and d'Orbigny traced it 250 miles further north. Darwin examined it over 300 miles east-west near the Plata, and d'Orbigny believes it extends 100 miles further inland. Darwin says its area is probably at least equal to France, perhaps two or three times as great.

    Chapter 42

  4. How does Lyell's conclusion on North American extinct mammifers relate to the Santa Cruz boulders?

    Lyell concluded the North American extinct mammifers lived after erratic boulders were transported by floating ice in temperate latitudes. Darwin notes that 50 miles south of the Macrauchenia, iceberg-carried boulders lie at 1,400 feet on the Santa Cruz plain, and several step-formed plains must be crossed to reach it, so the 90-feet plain formed long after the ice action.

    Chapter 42

Section 434 cards
  1. What theory of the Pampean formation's origin does Darwin say he cannot doubt?

    The author argues the Pampean formation slowly accumulated at the mouth of the former estuary of the Plata and in the adjoining sea. He bases this on reasons against rival theories and on geography: Azara labiata shells show brackish-water deposition near Buenos Ayres, marine shells occur southward, and Ehrenberg's microscopic organisms from mud near a Mastodon tooth indicate brackish-water origin for the lowest beds.

    Chapter 43

  2. Why does Darwin reject the theory that rivers deposited the Pampean formation on marshy plains?

    The author argues the deposit's appearance and composition, its sloping up and around the primary ranges, the underlying marine beds, estuary and sea-shells on the surface, and the overlying sandstone at M. Hermoso all oppose this view. He also disbelieves that any extinct mammifer skeleton was found upright, as if mired—undercutting the marshy-plain scenario.

    Chapter 43

  3. What evidence leads Darwin to place the Pampean formation in the Recent Period?

    The author argues the still-living Azara labiata is embedded in tosca-rock near Buenos Ayres, and at Punta Alta extinct mammifers coexisted with twenty species of Mollusca, a barnacle and two corals still living on that coast. He notes the bones were embedded fresh—articulated skeletons and fragile dermal armour—so the animals coexisted with the shells, making the formation Recent.

    Chapter 43

  4. At what depths does Darwin say mammiferous remains occur in the Pampean formation?

    The author states the remains occur at all depths from top to bottom of the deposit, and that nowhere in the Pampas is there much appearance of superficial denudation. Examples: a Glyptodon five feet below the surface at the Matanzas, remains averaging eighteen feet near Luxan, a skeleton at sixty feet in Buenos Ayres, and two Mastodon skeletons only five or six feet above the deposit's base on the Parana.

    Chapter 43

Section 444 cards
  1. What did Darwin initially think about the junction at St. Fe Bajada, and how did d'Orbigny respond?

    Darwin thought the concretionary marl layer marked a passage between the marine and estuary formations. M. d'Orbigny disputed this, and Darwin admits his view was erroneous, though partly excusable because of the conformability and abundant calcareous matter in both. Darwin notes it would be a great anomaly for a true passage to exist between a deposit with existing mollusca and one where all mollusca appear extinct.

    Chapter 44

  2. Why does Darwin think the same estuary mud could be deposited in the same area over an immense time span?

    Darwin initially found it improbable that mud of the same nature was deposited on nearly the same spot from perhaps the Eocene to the Pampean period. But he argues that a great expanse of water was surrounded by the same rocky framework now bounding the Pampean plains—Sierra Ventana to the south, the Cordillera to the west, Corrientes to the north, and Brazil to the north-east—making repeated deposition credible.

    Chapter 44

  3. What does Darwin infer about the elevation of the southern Pampas from plains, cliffs, and sand-dunes?

    Darwin infers the elevation was slow and interrupted by several periods of rest, based on plains, cliffs, and lines of sand-dunes with shells and pumice-pebbles standing at different heights. He also believes Pampean mud continued to be deposited after parts of the formation had been elevated, as mud would still accumulate in the estuary of the Plata if its mud-banks were uplifted into plains.

    Chapter 44

  4. Why does Darwin think many skeletons at Monte Hermoso imply surrounding land was already uplifted?

    Darwin finds it improbable that so many skeletons and bones accumulated at one spot where M. Hermoso now stands, at a depth of eight hundred to one thousand feet and far from any land except small rocky islets. He reasons the high tosca-plain around the Ventana and adjoining Sierras must already have been uplifted into land supporting mammiferous animals.

    Chapter 44

Section 454 cards
  1. Where does Darwin suggest the Pampas animals may have lived, given their wide fossil range?

    Darwin notes that some Pampas species also occur in the highlands of Brazil and that Mastodon Andium is embedded high in the Cordillera. Since no higher land exists, he infers the mastodon lived on plains and valleys of that range. For the Pampas individuals, he looks to nearer dry land such as Corrientes, and to land formed from already-elevated Pampean deposits near Bahia Blanca.

    Chapter 45

  2. What does Darwin argue about the relationship between extinction and rarity?

    Darwin argues we should not feel more surprise at a species becoming extinct than at one being rare, since rarity is viewed as an ordinary event needing no extraordinary agency. He admits we cannot explain the precise cause of extinction, but insists the astonishment is misplaced. He refers readers to his earlier Journal for the fuller argument.

    Chapter 45

  3. What does Darwin conclude about change in organic forms and lapse of time?

    Darwin concludes we must be cautious in judging a formation's antiquity from even great differences between extinct and living species in one class. He goes further, urging caution in accepting the general proposition that change in organic forms and lapse of time are necessarily correlatives. He supports this with extinct mammals coexisting with molluscs still living in the adjoining sea.

    Chapter 45

  4. What evidence does Darwin give that large pachyderms could endure severe climates?

    Darwin cites the Siberian mammoth and rhinoceros as showing how severe a climate the larger pachydermata could endure, addressing the difficulty of Mastodon Andium reaching near-perpetual-snow regions. He also notes the guanaco ranges from hot Peruvian deserts to lofty Cordillera pinnacles and damp Tierra del Fuego, and the puma spans equator to Magellan, with footsteps seen near perpetual snow in Chile.

    Chapter 45

Section 464 cards
  1. What fossil mammals did Darwin report from the Rio Luxan area?

    Darwin notes two Megatherium skeletons found at the Rio Luxan, and that Dr. F. X. Muniz collected numerous remains from an average depth of eighteen feet within eight leagues of Luxan, which Muniz believed represented no fewer than nine distinct species of mammifers. Darwin also mentions large bones at Areco, which inhabitants believed the river water had changed from small bones.

    Chapter 46

  2. What did d'Orbigny find in the Rio Negro cliff beds, and in what order?

    At the base of the southern cliffs, d'Orbigny found a bed with two extinct fresh-water shells, a Unio and Chilina. This bed rested on one containing bones of an extinct rodent, Megamys Patagoniensis, which in turn rested on a bed with extinct marine shells. Darwin uses this succession to discuss the formation's age and origin.

    Chapter 46

  3. How does Darwin explain the Rio Negro sandstone's distinct composition?

    Darwin says the formation, though contemporaneous with the rest of Patagonia, differs in mineralogical composition, connected only by one thin white layer. He attributes the difference to sediment brought down in ancient times by the Rio Negro, which also explains the presence of fresh-water shells and bones of land animals. He judges it contemporaneous with the formation under the Pampean deposit in Entre Rios and Banda Oriental, based on identity of four shells.

    Chapter 46

  4. What did Darwin observe in the cliffs at San Josef?

    Darwin's examination at San Josef was very short. The cliffs are about a hundred feet high; the lower third consists of yellowish-brown, soft, slightly calcareous, muddy sandstone, parts of which emit a fetid smell when struck. In this bed the great Ostrea Patagonica, often marked with dendritic manganese and small coral-lines, were extraordinarily numerous.

    Chapter 46

Section 474 cards
  1. Which fossil species occur at St. Fe in Entre Rios and in the Rio Negro sandstone?

    The first four species listed—Ostrea Patagonica, Ostrea Alvarezii, Pecten Paranensis, and Pecten Darwinianus—occur at St. Fe in Entre Rios, while the two first of these, the two Ostrea species, occur in the sandstone of the Rio Negro. Above this fossiliferous mass lies a fine-grained pale brown mudstone with numerous laminae of selenite.

    Chapter 47

  2. What did Ehrenberg conclude about the white pumiceous mudstone, and what did Darwin conclude independently?

    Ehrenberg found the mudstone consists of minute triturated cellular glassy pumice fragments with broken crystals, and identified organic structures affected by volcanic heat, including Polygastrica and Phytolitharia of marine, chiefly oceanic, origin. Darwin, examining specimens under a common microscope and comparing them with specimens undoubtedly volcanic, came to the same conclusion: the deposit is of volcanic origin.

    Chapter 47

  3. What do the strata at Port S. Julian reveal about the age of the white mudstone?

    At Port S. Julian the white pumiceous mudstone forms sea-cliffs up to between one and two hundred feet, with laminae of transparent gypsum, and inland builds truncated hills representing a former continuous plain 950 feet high. Thin earthy layers containing Ostrea Patagonica, Pecten Paranensis, and Turritella ambulacrum are interstratified at various heights, showing the whole mass belongs to the same epoch.

    Chapter 47

  4. How does Darwin describe the physical properties of the pumiceous mudstone at Port Desire?

    Darwin describes it as generally white, yellowish, or feebly green-tinted; almost friable under the finger or as hard as chalk; easily fusible, of little specific gravity, not harsh to the touch, adhering to the tongue, and exhaling a strong aluminous odour when breathed on. It sometimes contains a little calcareous matter and traces of gypsum, and to the naked eye shows no organic forms.

    Chapter 47

Section 484 cards
  1. What is the height and composition of the cliffs at the mouth of the Santa Cruz river?

    The gravel-capped cliffs at the mouth of the river are 355 feet high. The lower fifty or sixty feet consist of a more or less hardened, darkish, muddy or argillaceous sandstone containing many shells, some silicified and some converted into yellow calcareous spar. The upper part is generally divided into three great strata resembling pumiceous mudstone, though more arenaceous and of greater specific gravity.

    Chapter 48

  2. Which common Patagonian shell is notably absent at Santa Cruz, and what does Darwin find remarkable about this?

    Darwin states it is remarkable that the Pecten Paranensis, so common in all other parts of the coast, is here absent. The shells present instead include Ostrea Patagonica, Pecten centralis, Venus meridionalis, Crassatella Lyellii, and numerous others listed by G.B. Sowerby, with the great oyster abundant in layers and the Trigonocelia and Turritella also very numerous.

    Chapter 48

  3. What unusual salts and veins does Darwin describe in the upper cliff strata at Santa Cruz?

    The upper strata are interlaced with numerous thin veins partially or quite filled with transverse fibres of gypsum; these fibres were too short to reach across the vein and have curved or bent extremities. In the same veins, in separate veins, and in little nests, there is much powdery sulphate of magnesia in an uncompressed form, as ascertained by Mr. Reeks; Darwin believes this salt had not previously been found in veins.

    Chapter 48

  4. What does the section at one hundred miles from the coast show, and what does Darwin conclude about the whole width of Patagonia?

    Figure 18 shows a surface plain with erratic boulders at 1,146 feet above the sea, then gravel and boulders 212 feet thick, basaltic lava 322 feet thick, and sedimentary layers totaling 592 feet. The coloured layers rest on a soft pebbly sandstone. Darwin concludes the valley of the S. Cruz gives a fair idea of the constitution of the whole width of Patagonia.

    Chapter 48

Section 494 cards
  1. Where does the basaltic lava formation of the S. Cruz begin and how far does it extend?

    It is first met with sixty-seven miles from the mouth of the river, then extends uninterruptedly, generally but not exclusively on the northern side of the valley, close up to the Cordillera. The aggregate streams flowed about one hundred geographical miles from the Cordillera, a distance Darwin calls unparalleled in any case yet known.

    Chapter 49

  2. What evidence leads Darwin to conclude the basalt is contemporaneous with the upper tertiary beds?

    Darwin never saw the actual junction, but at the lowest point down the valley where the streams thin into irregular projections, the gaps between them are filled to the level of the denuded gravel-capped plains with white-zoned sedimentary beds. This proves the sediment kept being deposited after the streams flowed, so the basalt is contemporaneous with the upper parts of the great tertiary formation.

    Chapter 49

  3. What thickness and inclination measurements does Darwin report for the basaltic mass?

    Where first met the lava is 130 feet thick, increasing to 322 feet thirty-five miles up the valley. Over the first fourteen and a half miles the upper surface slopes toward the Atlantic at only 0 degrees 7 minutes 20 seconds; over the whole thirty-five miles, 0 degrees 10 minutes 53 seconds. The sedimentary beds beneath now incline only 0 degrees 7 minutes 52 seconds.

    Chapter 49

  4. What does Darwin say about the Port Gallegos gravel-capped plain and its fossils?

    Captain Sulivan informed Darwin of a gravel-capped plain two to three hundred feet high, ninety miles south of S. Cruz, formed of numerous strata including pale fine-grained beds and darker grit-like layers with decomposed volcanic fragments and gravel. It abounds with mammiferous remains including Pachydermata, Edentata, and Rodentia. Professor Ehrenberg found the microscopic organisms wholly different from S. Cruz, being fresh and brackish-water forms, so its age is unknown.

    Chapter 49

Section 503 cards
  1. What evidence leads Darwin to assign the uppermost plains of Tierra del Fuego to the Patagonian tertiary?

    Darwin judges from the height, general appearance, and white colour of patches on the hillsides that the uppermost plain on the north and west of the Strait of Magellan, and along eastern Tierra del Fuego as far south as near Port St. Polycarp, probably belongs to the great Patagonian tertiary formation. He calls this a probable identification, not certain, and notes these table-ranges are fringed by low plains of the boulder formation.

    Chapter 50

  2. How does Darwin argue the lower fossiliferous mass at Patagonian localities belongs to nearly the same epoch?

    Of seven shells from St. Fe, four were found by d'Orbigny at Rio Negro and by Darwin at San Josef; three of six from San Josef match Port Desire and S. Julian, which together have fifteen species with three shared; Santa Cruz has seventeen species with five shared with those two places. Given the latitudes involved and only thirty-six species collected, Darwin conceives this proportion sufficient to show the mass belongs nearly, not absolutely, to the same epoch.

    Chapter 50

  3. What does Darwin conclude about the origin and extent of the white pumiceous mudstone?

    Darwin considers it originally volcanic, formed either by long-continued attrition of vast pumice quantities or by long-continued eruption of fine ash clouds, judging from microscopic structure and analogy with volcanic districts. It is certainly continuous from Coy Inlet to Port Desire (230 miles), probably to Rio Chupat, Nuevo Gulf, and San Josef (570 miles), eight to nine hundred feet thick at S. Julian, and belongs to the same general epoch as the underlying fossiliferous mass.

    Chapter 50

Section 513 cards
  1. What shells did Darwin collect from the strata he examined on Huafo island?

    On Huafo, about eight hundred feet high and possibly with a nucleus of metamorphic rocks, Darwin examined fine-grained muddy sandstones with lignite fragments and calcareous sandstone concretions. He collected eight extinct shells, including Bulla cosmophila, Pleurotoma subaequalis, Fusus cleryanus, Triton leucostomoides, Turritella Chilensis (in great numbers), a Venus and Cytheraea probably distinct but imperfect, and Dentalium majus.

    Chapter 51

  2. What does Darwin suggest about why marine remains were confined to calcareous sandstone concretions in Chiloe?

    In Chiloe, Darwin found marine remains only in concretions of hard calcareous sandstone, and notes he observed elsewhere that organic remains were exclusively confined to such concretions. He asks whether shells lived only at those points, or whether it is more probable their remains were preserved only where concretions formed. The shells were in a bad state, including Tellinides oblonga, Natica striolata, Natica pumila, and Cytheraea sulculosa.

    Chapter 51

  3. How does Darwin explain the junction of the white tufaceous mass with the underlying beds at Point Tenuy?

    At Point Tenuy, Darwin describes stratified brown tuffs and greenish mudstone (AA) abruptly cut off against a white, largely unstratified tufaceous mass. He proposes a current of water cut a deep, steep submarine channel and filled it with tufaceous and brecciolated matter, which spread over surrounding beds and became stratified in distant, less troubled parts. He admits he cannot explain three beds prolonged beyond the junction.

    Chapter 51

Section 524 cards
  1. What relation did Darwin observe between fissures/veins and concretionary zones in the tuff?

    In a horizontal tuff surface about four feet by two and a half, Darwin observed that fissures partially filled with oxide of iron and agate determined, or were determined by, the shape of whole concretions or only their central parts. The fissures also determined the curvatures of the long undulating concretionary zones, showing how intimately concretionary action and vein formation are related.

    Chapter 52

  2. What structures did Darwin find in the peninsula of Lacuy, and why did the case interest him?

    Over a width of four miles, strata were upheaved by three distinct and some indistinct north-south lines of elevation. One is a regular anticline about two hundred feet high with strata dipping 15 degrees from a central valley of elevation; a second narrow ridge sixty feet high is uniclinal, dipping westward. Darwin says this interested him as the first case in South America of formations perhaps of tertiary origin broken by lines of elevation.

    Chapter 52

  3. What do the beds near Lirguen contain, and what is said about the imperfect coals there?

    The lower sandstones are generally ferruginous but vary and even pass into an argillaceous nature; they contain hard concretions, fragments of lignite, silicified wood, and pebbles, and alternate with numerous often very thin layers of imperfect coal of little specific gravity. The main bed is three feet thick, and only this one bed's coal has a glossy fracture. These imperfect coals ignite spontaneously when placed in a heap.

    Chapter 52

  4. What did Darwin learn about Mocha without landing, and what shells were identified?

    Darwin did not land on Mocha (latitude 38 degrees 20 minutes); Mr. Stokes brought him specimens of grey, fine-grained, slightly calcareous sandstone precisely like that of Huafo, containing lignite and numerous Turritellae. The island is flat-topped, 1,240 feet high, and appears like an outlier of the mainland sedimentary beds. Shells collected included Turritella Chilensis, an imperfect Fusus, and fragments of Venus.

    Chapter 52

Section 533 cards
  1. Why does Darwin link the Tome concretions to the Lirguen and Quiriquina beds?

    Darwin argues the fossiliferous concretions at Tome belong to the same formation as the Lirguen beds, based on identity in mineralogical nature of the rocks and Captain Belcher's description of the coast. The Lirguen beds match the Quiriquina strata, and three shells from Tome are identical with Quiriquina species.

    Chapter 53

  2. What did Forbes conclude about Baculites vagina and its significance?

    Professor E. Forbes considered the tolerably preserved Baculites vagina certainly identical with a species he named from Pondicherry, India, where it is associated with decidedly Cretaceous species approaching Lower Greensand or Neocomian forms. Darwin calls this identity, given the vast distance between Chile and India, truly surprising.

    Chapter 53

  3. What did Darwin collect at Navidad, and what did he note about the species?

    At Navidad, 160 miles north of Concepcion, Darwin collected thirty-one species in a short time despite suffering from illness. All were extinct, and several genera do not now range nearly so far south. Pectunculus and Oliva were most numerous, followed by Turritella and Fusus.

    Chapter 53

Section 544 cards
  1. What fossils did Darwin find in the calcareous concretions of bed F at Herradura Bay?

    Bed F is a soft whitish sandstone with ferruginous veins, granite pebbles, and hard calcareous sandstone concretions. These concretions contain many large silicified bones, apparently of cetaceous animals, a shark's tooth closely resembling Carcharias megalodon, and numerous shells. The most conspicuous shells are the gigantic oyster and Perna, alongside species such as Bulla ambigua, Cardium auca, and Panopaea Coquimbensis.

    Chapter 54

  2. Why did Darwin reject a gradual transition between beds E and D?

    The upper layers of the ferruginous sandy mass E are conformably covered by and impregnated with the calcareous matter of bed D (losa), which once suggested a gradual passage. But all species in bed D are recent, while the most characteristic shells of E's uppermost layers are the extinct Perna, Pecten, and Monoceros. Darwin therefore agrees with d'Orbigny that only a mineralogical passage exists, with no gradual transition in organic remains.

    Chapter 54

  3. How many of the twenty-four shells from the lower beds are extinct, and which are exceptions?

    Of the twenty-four shells enumerated from the two lower beds (fourteen listed by Darwin plus ten described by d'Orbigny), all are extinct except, according to Mr. Sowerby, Artemis ponderosa, Mytilus Chiloensis, and probably the great Balanus. Sowerby could find no distinguishing character between the fossil Artemis ponderosa and the recent species, nor between the fossil Mytilus Chiloensis and the recent one, though the latter's imperfect condition limited comparison.

    Chapter 54

  4. What did Darwin conclude about the age and origin of the Pacific coast tertiary formations?

    Darwin argues the coast-formations from Central Chiloe to Concepcion, some 400 miles apart, are the same age, based on land form and height, identical mineralogical composition, lignite and silicified wood fragments, and imperfect coal layers. He suspects Mocha, Huafo, and Ypun belong to the same period. He also concludes the deposits accumulated in troughs by submarine ridges, or around isolated rocky centres, so outlying masses need not have been continuously united with the mainland.

    Chapter 54

Section 554 cards
  1. Why does Darwin suspect the Concepcion formation is Secondary rather than Tertiary?

    Darwin cites the Baculite (apparently identical to the Cretaceous Pondicherry species), the presence of an Ammonite, and the Nautilus's resemblance to two upper greensand species as strong evidence that Concepcion is Secondary. He sets Concepcion and Eastern Chiloe aside as one group, yet notes the Cardium auca occurs both there and in the undoubtedly tertiary strata of Coquimbo.

    Chapter 55

  2. What structural evidence shows the strata between the Cordillera and the Pacific were broken up?

    Although the strata are generally horizontal, Darwin reports they were upheaved in Chiloe along north-south anticlinal and uniclinal lines; near P. Rumena by eight or nine symmetrical east-west uniclinal lines; and near Concepcion by less regular single lines running N.E.-S.W. and N.W.-S.E. He argues this shows the strata were fractured in the same variously directed manner as the older plutonic and metamorphic rocks.

    Chapter 55

  3. How does the distribution of fossil wood relate to living forests, in Darwin's view?

    The sandstone between Concepcion and Southern Chiloe is everywhere lignitiferous with much silicified wood, whereas Northern Chile has no lignite beds and yields silicified bones instead. Darwin notes living forests run from Cape Horn to near Concepcion and vanish in Central and Northern Chile. He concedes the coincidence may be accidental but inclines to think the lignitiferous climate varied along the coast somewhat as it now does.

    Chapter 55

  4. What does Darwin conclude about the age of the fifty-nine fossil species from Navidad and other localities?

    Of the fifty-nine species (excluding twenty from Concepcion and Chiloe), only an Artemis, Mytilus and Balanus from Coquimbo are, per Mr. Sowerby but not M. d'Orbigny, identical with living shells. Few approach living species closely; some genera are extinct or absent from the west coast, and twelve of thirty-two genera ranged very differently. Darwin concludes the deposits are tertiary and probably verge on the commencement of the tertiary era, perhaps contemporaneous with northern Eocene formations.

    Chapter 55

Section 564 cards
  1. Why does Darwin think the Chilean and Patagonian fossil formations are nearly the same age?

    Darwin argues the formations belong to nearly the same epoch based on their generic resemblance and the small number of species approaching living forms on either coast; he notes M. D'Orbigny holds this opinion. He adds that even a single shared fossil shell would not be required, since Cuming and Hinds found only one living species in common across nearly two thousand compared from opposite sides of South America.

    Chapter 56

  2. What evidence makes Darwin cautious about inferring a warmer Tertiary climate at Navidad?

    Darwin notes warm-water genera like Cassis, Pyrula, Pleurotoma, Terebra and Sigaretus no longer range as far south as their fossils did, suggesting warmth. But he warns caution: Cardium, Bulla and Fusus, not characteristic of hot climates, also ranged farther south formerly, and Voluta is now confined to colder southern latitudes. Compared with similar latitudes in the Mediterranean or Australia, there is no evidence Navidad's sea was hotter than its latitude predicts.

    Chapter 56

  3. What does Darwin conclude about the cause of tropical-looking older Tertiary fossils in temperate Europe?

    Darwin argues the conclusion that southern seas were not hotter than their latitude would predict is highly important. Following Mr. Lyell's views, he believes the causes giving older Tertiary productions of temperate Europe a tropical character were local and did not affect the entire globe. He contrasts this with a later period when Europe and North and South America were nearly contemporaneously subjected to ice-action.

    Chapter 56

  4. Why is the absence of extensive modern shell deposits along South America remarkable to Darwin?

    Darwin finds it remarkable given Forbes's finding that molluscs chiefly abound within 100 fathoms, the many thousands of miles of coast upraised recently, the diversity of shores, and favourable conditions for sediment. Coquimbo's calcareous beds, twenty to thirty feet thick but of trifling breadth, are the marked exception. He expects upraised shells to be destroyed by alluvial action and dissolution, so a whole conchological series may vanish without memorials.

    Chapter 56

Section 574 cards
  1. Why does Darwin think recent conchiferous deposits are absent on South American coasts?

    The author argues that formations surviving to a distant epoch must be wide and thick, since every sedimentary formation measures an equal amount of wear of pre-existing rocks. Shells live mostly within 100 fathoms, so on stationary or rising coasts conchiferous strata stay thin and unconsolidated, and the rising land plus wave erosion on lofty cliffs destroys them.

    Chapter 57

  2. What happens to conchiferous strata when the sea bed stays at a stationary level?

    Darwin argues such strata can accumulate only to the thickness of the depth at which the shells can live. They reach considerable width only on gently inclined coasts, and without superincumbent pressure the sediment is seldom much consolidated. Such formations have a poor chance, once upraised, of long resisting denudation.

    Chapter 57

  3. Why does slow subsidence favor preserving conchiferous deposits?

    During slow subsidence, sediment keeps accumulating, so strata can reach any thickness while each layer forms in shallow water and abounds with shells that cannot live at great depths. Pressure from each fresh bed helps consolidate the lower ones, and on steep coasts the formation tends to widen as water encroaches on the land.

    Chapter 57

  4. Why is a slowly rising sea bed unfavorable for lasting shell deposits?

    Darwin argues that with slow rising, total thickness is less, and each part must successively pass through the ordeal of the beach before being consolidated or covered by superincumbent matter. Waves on the beach tend to wear down and disperse whatever is exposed. Since South America's shores show slow rising and sea-cut cliffs, the absence of extensive recent deposits is unsurprising.

    Chapter 57

Section 584 cards
  1. What evidence at Navidad suggests the tertiary beds were deposited during subsidence?

    At Navidad the strata are about 800 feet thick, with abundant fossil shells both at sea level and up the cliffs. Professor E. Forbes judged from their generic character that the shells lived in water between one and ten fathoms deep. Therefore the sea bottom must have subsided at least 700 feet to allow the overlying matter to be deposited.

    Chapter 58

  2. What three conditions does the author argue are needed to accumulate durable fossiliferous deposits?

    The author argues three conditions must concur: first, a long-continued supply of sediment; second, an extensive shallow area; and third, that this area slowly subside to a great depth, so a widely extended thick mass of overlying strata can accumulate. He notes it is probable these conditions rarely coincide in the world at present.

    Chapter 58

  3. Why does the author doubt a perfect sequence of fossil shells between two formations at one spot?

    The author argues such a sequence would require a subsiding movement at the same spot over an enormous period, from one geological era to another, with sediment accumulating at the proper rate so depth never became too great for molluscous animals. He concludes it is scarcely possible to have a perfect sequence of fossil shells at the same spot.

    Chapter 58

  4. Why does the author think certain periods favored preservation of contemporaneous formations at distant points?

    The author argues the earth's crust tends to sink and rise contemporaneously over vast spaces within the same quarter of the globe. Since South America shows the seafloor sinking off Chile and Patagonia at nearly the same tertiary period, distant points share the conditions needed for thick, hard fossiliferous masses that resist denudation and last into the distant future.

    Chapter 58

Section 594 cards
  1. How does Darwin define cleavage, foliation, and stratification in metamorphic rocks?

    Darwin defines cleavage as planes of division making an otherwise homogeneous rock fissile. Foliation refers to layers or plates of different mineralogical nature composing most metamorphic schists, which may also include homogeneous fissile layers. Stratification means alternate, parallel, large masses of different composition that are themselves often foliated or fissile, such as alternating mica-slate, gneiss, glossy clay-slate, and marble.

    Chapter 59

  2. What did Darwin conclude about the angular hornblende masses embedded in Bahia gneiss?

    Darwin could not doubt that most or all of the angular, sometimes bent masses of hornblende rock in the gneiss were derived from the breaking up of dikes. He saw the first stage in a dike laterally disjointed with unbroken gneiss between the ends. Some separated masses corresponded exactly in size and shape, evidently once united. The gneiss folia bent gently round the fragments, showing the gneiss was softened and modified afterward.

    Chapter 59

  3. What strike direction did Darwin find for gneiss folia across Brazil and northern South America?

    Darwin reports that near Bahia the best-defined folia extended most frequently N.E. by N. (East 50 degrees N.) and S.W. by S., nearly matching the coastline north of the bay. Gardner found E. 45 degrees N. in Ceara, Schomburgk E. 57 degrees N. in Guyana, and Humboldt described gneiss-granite in Venezuela and Colombia striking E. 50 degrees N. Darwin concludes these observations tend to show folia over this whole region extend within almost a point of the compass of the same direction.

    Chapter 59

  4. Why did Darwin think the conical gneiss-granite peaks of Rio did not rule out an intrusive origin?

    Darwin observed that the gneiss-granite mountains are remarkably abruptly conical, apparently because the rock tends to exfoliate in thick, conically concentric layers. These peaks resemble phonolite and other injected rocks on volcanic islands. He notes that the grain or foliation is no difficulty for the idea that the gneiss-granite was an intrusive rather than a metamorphic formation.

    Chapter 59

Section 604 cards
  1. What did Darwin observe about the gneiss fragment in Botofogo Bay, and what explanation did he offer?

    Darwin observed a fragment seven yards long and two wide, with angular edges, made of a distinct gneiss variety with dark mica layers and garnets, surrounded by ordinary gneiss-granite. Both were dislocated by a granitic vein. The folia strike the same N.N.E.-S.S.W. line, but in the fragment they are vertical while the surrounding rock dips slightly S.S.E. He calls it a unique case and declines to explain its origin.

    Chapter 60

  2. How deep is the rock decomposition near Rio, and what evidence suggests it happened before valley excavation?

    Near Rio, every mineral except quartz has been softened, in places to a depth little less than one hundred feet, with minerals retaining their folia positions and fractured quartz veins traceable into the softened mass. Darwin judged the decomposition did not conform to present surface undulations, and that the gneiss was softened before the sea excavated the broad flat-bottomed valleys. He suspected it occurred under the sea.

    Chapter 60

  3. What does Darwin say about the porphyritic gneiss now exposed to air, and what did he note at the water's edge?

    Darwin states the porphyritic gneiss where now exposed to the air seems to withstand decomposition remarkably well, showing no tendency to produce the argillaceous masses described. He was also struck that where a bare surface sloped into a quiet bay, there were no marks of erosion at water level, and the parts above and below preserved a uniform curve.

    Chapter 60

  4. In the Maldonado region, how do cleavage, foliation, stratification, and hill ranges relate in direction?

    Darwin reports that throughout the district north and west of Maldonado, the cleavage of clay-slate and marble, the foliation of gneiss and quartz, the stratification or alternating masses of these rocks, and the range of the hills all coincide in direction. Although the country is only hilly, the planes of division are almost everywhere highly inclined or vertical. He also notes mica is remarkably rare there.

    Chapter 60

Section 614 cards
  1. What rock types alternate with gneiss near Monte Video, and what causes the transitions?

    Near Monte Video, gneiss alternates with and passes insensibly into beds of dark-green hornblendic slate, from a few yards to nearly a mile thick, which often pass into chloritic schist. The author attributes these passages chiefly to changes in the mica and its replacement by other minerals, and connects the passage into hornblendic or chloritic slate with segregation of quartz veins.

    Chapter 61

  2. What does Darwin conclude about the greenstone near the summit of The Mount?

    The Mount consists of hornblendic slate with nearly vertical east-west cleavage. Near the summit the slate becomes more coarsely crystallised and less plainly laminated, passing into a heavy, sonorous greenstone with slaty conchoidal fracture; the laminae on the north and south sides dip inwards, as if the upper part had expanded or bulged outwards. Darwin considers this greenstone to be metamorphosed hornblende-slate.

    Chapter 61

  3. What directions do foliation, cleavage, and stratification take west of the Sierra de las Animas?

    Westward of the S. de las Animas, as far as even the Uruguay, the foliation, cleavage, and stratification all range about E. by S. and W. by N., nearly coincident with the direction of the northern shore of the Plata. Lines of hills are excluded, since there are no defined ones there. Near Las Minas, where the two great systems intersect, these planes run in various directions.

    Chapter 61

  4. What rocks make up the Sierra Ventana, and how do its layers strike and dip?

    The Sierra Ventana, rising 3,340 feet, consists up to its summit of quartz, generally pure and white but sometimes reddish, divided into thick laminae or strata; in one part there is a little glossy clay-slate with tortuous cleavage. The thick quartz layers strike W. 30 degrees N., dipping southerly at 45 degrees and upwards. The principal mountain line ranges about W. 45 degrees N., but only W. 25 degrees N. at its S.E. termination.

    Chapter 61

Section 624 cards
  1. What did Darwin conclude about the origin of the claystone porphyry at Port Desire?

    Darwin states that although casual inspection would suggest the whole series is plutonic or volcanic, this is far from the case: much of the porphyry is certainly of metamorphic origin. He traced earthy tufaceous beds passing gradually into indurated, porphyritic rocks with feldspar crystals, and argued the crystals formed through metamorphic aggregation of alternating tuff layers.

    Chapter 62

  2. How did Darwin explain the parallel orientation of large feldspar crystals in the metamorphosed tuff?

    Darwin describes short, parallel, often curved layers of granulo-crystalline feldspathic matter passing into wedge- or almond-shaped masses and finally into true feldspar crystals. He could not doubt these crystals originated in metamorphosis and aggregation of alternating tuff layers, so their parallel position must be attributed not to chemical laws but to the original planes of deposition.

    Chapter 62

  3. What are the pseudo-dikes near Port Desire, and why did Darwin think they were not injected from below?

    Darwin found three vertical dikes closely resembling volcanic dikes. The first was whitish indurated tufaceous matter like the beds it cuts; the second was purplish-brown with rounded quartz grains, feldspar, mica, and porphyry fragments, showing mechanical sedimentary origin. It thinned out upwards and did not cut the uppermost strata, suggesting material was washed or drawn into a fissure rather than injected.

    Chapter 62

  4. What did Darwin conclude about the fragments in the breccia-like rock with pinkish feldspathic borders?

    Darwin describes a rock that would pass for a stratified porphyritic breccia, but all included angular fragments consist of a pinkish crystalline feldspathic border surrounding a dark translucent siliceous centre, sometimes with quartz grains. This uniformity shows the fragments are not of mechanical but of concretionary origin, perhaps from self-breaking up and aggregation of indurated tuff layers.

    Chapter 62

Section 634 cards
  1. What rock types and fossils characterize the Falkland Islands' ridges and lower country?

    The mountain-ridges consist of quartz, while the lower country is clay-slate and sandstone, the latter containing Palaeozoic fossils described by Messrs. Morris and Sharpe. Some fossils resemble Silurian and others Devonian forms. The parallel quartz ridges run west-east in the eastern group, becoming W.N.W.-E.S.E. and more northerly further west. Cleavage-planes of the clay-slate are highly inclined, generally above 50 degrees and often vertical, striking almost invariably with the quartz ranges.

    Chapter 63

  2. What fossils did Darwin find in Tierra del Fuego, and where?

    Organic remains were found only on the shore a few miles north of Port Famine and on the summit of Mount Tarn (2,600 feet high). They include Ancyloceras simplex, Fusus, Natica and Pentacrimus at Mount Tarn, and Lucina excentrica, Venus, Turbinolia (?) and Hamites elatior at Port Famine. The Hamites elatior specimens were later lost after Darwin's return to England.

    Chapter 63

  3. To what geological age did d'Orbigny and Forbes assign the Tierra del Fuego clay-slate?

    M. d'Orbigny believed, from the general character of the fossils and from the Ancyloceras being identical (as far as its imperfect condition allowed) with A. simplex of Europe, that the formation belongs to an early stage of the Cretaceous system. Professor E. Forbes, judging only from Darwin's specimens, concurred in the probability of this conclusion. Darwin notes the great clay-slate formation being Cretaceous is a very interesting fact.

    Chapter 63

  4. What evidence convinced Darwin that the parallel feldspathic masses at Ponsonby Sound were injected dikes?

    On the east side of Ponsonby Sound, at least one hundred pale sonorous feldspathic dikes occurred within a mile, nearly equalling the intermediate slate in bulk, with excessively fine and perfectly parallel junctions to the almost vertical clay-slate laminae. Darwin was unable to persuade himself these masses had been injected until he found one dike that abruptly thinned to half its thickness and had a jagged wall with slate fragments embedded in it.

    Chapter 63

Section 644 cards
  1. How do the folia of the metamorphic schists differ from the clay-slate cleavage laminae?

    Darwin notes that the folia of the metamorphic schists strike parallel to the clay-slate cleavage-planes, which have a very uniform direction over this part of the country. However, the folia are undulatory and tortuous, while the cleavage-laminae of the slate are straight. These schists compose the chief mountain-chain of Southern Tierra del Fuego, with Mounts Sarmiento and Darwin rising to 6,800 and 6,900 feet.

    Chapter 64

  2. What does Darwin suggest determines whether gneiss or feldspathic porphyry forms from metamorphosed clay-slate?

    The author argues that where clay-slate has been metamorphosed at great depths beneath the surface, gneiss, mica-slate, and allied rocks have been formed; but where the action took place nearer the surface, feldspathic porphyries, greenstones, etc., resulted, often accompanied by submarine volcanic eruptions. He presents this as a temptation to believe rather than a settled conclusion.

    Chapter 64

  3. What did Darwin observe about the tints and texture of clay-slate cleavage laminae cutting through stratification?

    Darwin was struck that fine laminae of clay-slate, where cutting straight through bands of stratification and therefore indisputably true cleavage-planes, differed slightly in greyish and greenish tints, in compactness, and in some laminae having a more jaspery appearance. He had not seen this recorded and considered it important, since it shows the same cause producing fissile structure also slightly altered the rock's mineralogical character in those planes.

    Chapter 64

  4. What strike direction and extent did Darwin find for cleavage and foliation in this region?

    Darwin found the clay-slate cleavage and metamorphic schist foliation extending with an average W.N.W. and E.S.E. strike over an area about forty miles north to south and ninety miles east to west. On Navarin Island the laminae ranged with extreme regularity in this direction, seldom varying more than one point of the compass, with dips between 45 and 90 degrees, generally S.S.W. but sometimes N.N.E. or vertical.

    Chapter 64

Section 654 cards
  1. What is the average strike of foliation and cleavage along the 200-mile Chonos coast?

    Darwin reports an average strike of N. 19 degrees W. and S. 19 degrees E. over the 200 miles from Cape Tres Montes to the Northern Chonos Islands. At Low's Harbour folia ranged within eight degrees of this line, and Lieutenant Stokes found the strike invariably northerly over 100 miles south of it.

    Chapter 65

  2. How does the Chonos Archipelago differ from Brazil, La Plata, the Falklands and Tierra del Fuego?

    In those other regions there is generally an obvious relation between the axis of elevation, the coastline, and the strike of cleavage or foliation. In the Chonos Archipelago, Darwin states, neither the minor coastline details, nor the Cordillera, nor subordinate transverse mountain-axes accord with the strike of foliation and cleavage. The island seaward faces and apparently the Cordillera run N. 11 degrees E., while foliation averages N. 19 degrees W.

    Chapter 65

  3. What is the predominant rock between Cape Tres Montes and the Northern Chonos Islands?

    The predominant rock is mica-slate with thick quartz folia, frequently alternating with and passing into a chloritic or black, glossy, often striated, slightly anthracitic schist that soils paper, whitens under great heat, and then fuses. Thin feldspar layers sometimes form crystallised kernels. Darwin concludes all rocks on this coast belong to one series, varying insensibly from altered feldspathic clay-slate into true mica-schist.

    Chapter 65

  4. What does Darwin conclude about the dip direction along the northern half of this coast?

    Throughout the northern half of this line of coast the dip prevails in one direction, to the west, rather than sometimes west and sometimes east. Darwin calls this, judging from what he has seen elsewhere, an unusual circumstance. At Low's Harbour the dip was always west, generally about forty degrees, and Stokes found only one exception to westerly dip over 100 miles.

    Chapter 65

Section 664 cards
  1. What anomalous strike and dip did Darwin find in the mica-slate at Tres Montes?

    At the northern point of Tres Montes, a granite chain runs E.S.E. (E. 28° S.). The mica-slate folia there dip nearly due north at small angles, from 5° to 20°, sometimes up to 30°, both at the foot, on the northern flank, and across the summit. Darwin notes this departs from the prevalent strike elsewhere in the Archipelago, where a dip directly away from the ridge might have been expected.

    Chapter 66

  2. What hypothesis did Darwin propose for the Tres Montes foliation, and how did Hopkins test it?

    Darwin suggested the already inclined laminae were obliquely tilted later by the granitic axis. Hopkins calculated that laminae dipping 40° to W. 19° S., tilted 45° along an E. 28° S. axis, would dip 28° 31' to N. 30° 33' W. Darwin still found this hard to reconcile with the actual folia, especially the near-horizontal ones at the base.

    Chapter 66

  3. What did Darwin conclude about the cause of the anomalous foliation at Tres Montes?

    Although Hopkins noted that irregularities and lateral thrusts in great lines of elevation could explain deviations from his calculations, Darwin remained unconvinced. Considering that the granitic veins show the axis was injected after the mica-slate formed, and that folia strike uniformly elsewhere in the Archipelago, the author argues the anomalous position is somehow directly and mechanically related to the intrusion of the W.N.W.–E.S.E. granite chain.

    Chapter 66

  4. How were dikes at Low's Harbour oriented, and what did Darwin infer from embedded mica-slate fragments?

    At Low's Harbour, great parallel dikes, one ninety yards and another sixty yards wide, followed the foliation of the mica-schist and thus inclined westward at 45°. They consist of porphyritic traps, some with rounded quartz grains. In the ninety-yard dike, isolated mica-slate fragments lay with foliation exactly parallel to the surrounding rock, so Darwin inferred they were once wedge-shaped depending portions of a continuous crust over the dike, later denuded.

    Chapter 66

Section 674 cards
  1. Over what distance do folia strike similarly from Tres Montes to northern Chiloe?

    Darwin reports that from the southern part of Tres Montes to the northern end of Chiloe, a distance of 300 miles, closely allied rocks have folia striking on average in the same direction, between N. 11 degrees and 22 degrees W. In Chiloe the folia dipped E.N.E. or more commonly W.S.W. at an average of 22 degrees, though one spot reached 60 degrees.

    Chapter 67

  2. How does Darwin explain the bent laminae tops at Concepcion, and what alternative does he cite?

    Darwin suggests the bent tops of clay-slate laminae under soil at Concepcion may be due to frequent earthquakes, which jerk superficial detritus or push it downslope during strong vibrations. He notes Mr. R.A.C. Austen attributed a similar Devonshire phenomenon to frosts but doubted frosts penetrate deep enough, and Darwin saw an analogous, larger-scale effect in North Wales caused by stranding icebergs.

    Chapter 67

  3. What does Darwin conclude about the eight parallel dikes at Quiriquina Island?

    At the northern end of Quiriquina Island, at least eight rudely parallel dikes occur within a quarter mile, varying in composition from feldspathic porphyries to greenstones. Though close and parallel, Darwin thinks they were formed at different periods. They cut the metamorphic schists in a N.W.-S.E. line, matching the later tilting of overlying strata and the fissures of the February 1835 earthquake.

    Chapter 67

  4. What rock types constitute the Pacific shores from Concepcion to Copiapo?

    Northward of Concepcion as far as Copiapo, the Pacific shores consist, apart from some small tertiary basins, of gneiss, mica-schist, altered clay-slate, granite, greenstone and syenite. Darwin therefore states that the coast from Tres Montes to Copiapo, a distance of 1,200 miles, and he believes for a much greater space, is almost similarly constituted.

    Chapter 67

Section 684 cards
  1. What does Darwin conclude about the power producing slate cleavage?

    From the Tierra del Fuego clay-slate, where cleavage-laminae cut straight through stratification, and from parallel differences in colour, texture and hardness, the author concludes that the same power which impressed the fissile structure or cleavage on the slate has tended to modify its mineralogical character in parallel planes.

    Chapter 68

  2. How does the strike of foliation compare with cleavage over large areas?

    Both preserve remarkably uniform strike over wide areas. Humboldt found gneiss, granite, mica and clay-slate striking N.E.-S.W. for 300 miles in Venezuela; Chonos and Chiloe foliation held near N.19°W. for 300 miles. Dip angle and direction, however, vary and may alternate sides or be vertical.

    Chapter 68

  3. Where does foliation fail to parallel mountain ranges and coastlines?

    In Eastern Banda Oriental, parts of Brazil and elsewhere, foliation runs parallel to mountain-ranges and adjoining coast-lines. Among the Chonos Islands this coincidence fails; Darwin suspects a granitic axis burst through and tilted already-inclined mica-schist folia. He notes cleavage's strike may also sometimes fail to match main stratification.

    Chapter 68

  4. How do cleavage and foliation behave where the two rock types meet?

    Where fissile and foliated rocks alternate, Darwin says cleavage and foliation are parallel in all cases he saw. Where one district is fissile and an adjoining one foliated, the planes are generally parallel too: Chonos feldspathic slates match northern mica-schists, and eastern Tierra del Fuego clay-slate cleaves in the same line as western gneiss and mica-slate.

    Chapter 68

Section 694 cards
  1. What do Sedgwick, Lyell, and most authors believe about the folia of metamorphic schists?

    They believe the constituent parts of each layer were separately deposited as sediment and then metamorphosed. Darwin says he finds this view untenable in the majority of cases, citing clay-slate passing gradually into gneiss as evidence that folia of distinct minerals can originate through metamorphosis of a homogeneous fissile rock.

    Chapter 69

  2. How does Darwin relate foliation and cleavage?

    Darwin concludes that in most cases foliation and cleavage are parts of the same process. Cleavage involves only an incipient separation of constituent minerals, while foliation is a much more complete separation and crystallisation. He supports this with the analogy between foliation and cleavage in strike, dip, and uniformity over wide areas.

    Chapter 69

  3. What exception does Darwin make for thick masses in the metamorphic series?

    Darwin says his view that so-called beds are complex folia cannot extend to thick masses of totally different composition from adjoining schists, far extended, as with quartz and marble; these must generally be true strata. Such strata usually strike parallel to the folia but generally dip at a different angle.

    Chapter 69

  4. What evidence does Darwin cite that foliation can arise without prior structural arrangement?

    Darwin infers this from injected, once-liquified rocks of volcanic and plutonic origin that sometimes have a 'grain' and sometimes distinct folia of different compositions. He cites gigantic mountain-like masses of red granite in the Cordillera of Chile, injected while liquified, which nevertheless display a decidedly laminar structure in parts.

    Chapter 69

Section 704 cards
  1. What does Darwin conclude about the orientation of cleavage and foliation planes relative to landforms?

    Darwin states that cleavage and foliation planes generally strike parallel to the principal axes of elevation and to the outline of the land. He reasons, following Mr. Hopkins, that the strike of axes of elevation is determined by the form of the area undergoing changes of level, and the resulting direction of lines of tension and fissure.

    Chapter 70

  2. What does Darwin suspect causes the planes of cleavage and foliation?

    The author suspects the planes of cleavage and foliation are intimately connected with planes of different tension to which the area was long subjected after the main fissures or axes of upheavement formed, but before the mass finally consolidated and all molecular movement ceased. He holds this despite Mr. Fox's experiments on electrical currents and the puzzling variation in cleavage-laminae inclination.

    Chapter 70

  3. What rock forms the prevailing basal strata of the Cordillera, and what fragments does it contain?

    The prevailing rock is a purplish or greenish porphyritic claystone conglomerate. Embedded fragments range from particles to blocks six or eight inches across, rarely more, and are angular, rounded, or mixed—so Darwin says 'breccia' should strictly be appended. Fragments are mostly claystone porphyry varieties; quartz pebbles appeared only at Jajuel, and mica was nowhere observed.

    Chapter 70

  4. What does Darwin describe at the Campana of Quillota?

    The Campana, fifteen miles from the Pacific and 6,400 feet high, has a summit nucleus of fine greenstone with epidote and octahedral magnetic iron ore, uncovered for 800 feet. Its flanks are porphyritic claystone conglomerate with porphyries and amygdaloids, alternating with pale feldspathic slaty rock whose cleavage-laminae dip inward at a high angle; syenites and quartzose rocks lie at the base.

    Chapter 70

Section 714 cards
  1. How does Darwin explain the rounding and angularity of fragments in the porphyritic conglomerate?

    The author argues the fragments came from craters that erupted the interstratified porphyries as submarine lavas. After a great explosion, water in the heated, scarcely quiescent crater stayed agitated long enough to triturate and round loose fragments; these were shot forth at the next eruption with few or many angular fragments, depending on the explosion's strength.

    Chapter 71

  2. Why does Darwin reject an igneous origin for the feldspathic slaty rock?

    He notes it is distinctly laminated, sometimes porphyritic, and includes parallel layers of epidote. At Jajuel he found an included layer of hard, blackish, siliceous, infusible clay-slate that no one could consider igneous, and he had seen in Tierra del Fuego how readily true clay-slate becomes feldspathic and porphyritic. Its gentle passage into aqueous porphyritic conglomerate also counted.

    Chapter 71

  3. What did Darwin suspect about the amygdaloidal balls in the Jajuel porphyry?

    He suspected some were of concretionary origin rather than deposited in pre-existing air-vesicles. In those specimens, pea-shaped masses marked with minute pits consist of green earth mixed with stony matter like the porphyry's basis, including imperfect feldspar crystals, and are themselves amygdaloidal with minute green-earth spheres, making the porphyry doubly amygdaloidal. He cautions that metamorphic action may have altered them.

    Chapter 71

  4. What did Darwin estimate about the thickness and extent of the porphyry-conglomerate formation?

    He estimated its thickness within the Cordillera at six to seven thousand feet in several places. It extends many hundred miles, forming the western flank of the Chilean Cordillera, and even at Iquique in Peru, 850 miles north of his southernmost Chilean point, the coast-escarpment rising two to three thousand feet is thus composed. He attributes its thickness, narrowness, and linear extent to ancient submarine orifices arranged in a band.

    Chapter 71

Section 732 cards
  1. What does Darwin report about the gypseous formation in the Yeso basin?

    At about 7,000 feet above sea level, the gypseous formation is very thick, mostly snow-white compact gypsum with saccharine fracture, including nests and thin layers of blackish carbonate of lime and concretions of hard anhydrite. Hillocks of pure white gypsum have cracked surfaces like newly baked bread. Darwin argues the mineralogical characters suggest some metamorphic action, and the strata appeared highly inclined, bending up to vertical conformably with the underlying porphyritic conglomerate.

    Chapter 73

  2. What does Darwin infer about the trappean masses within the gypseous beds and the later fault at [G]?

    Darwin believes the irregular, well-defined feldspathic masses in the gypseous strata were injected from the nearby andesite mass while still fluid, and that because the gypseous strata were soft they did not acquire ordinary dike forms. After this injection, a great dislocation occurred: the shattered gypseous strata overlie a hillock of vertical impure limestone and black calcareous shale, which belong to the upper gypseous series and must have been thrown down by a vast fault.

    Chapter 73

Section 744 cards
  1. What structural feature does Darwin identify in the Yeso valley-basin strata?

    Darwin describes a great hill of stratified porphyritic conglomerate dipping 45 degrees west, then a few hundred yards farther a gypsum bed three to four hundred feet thick dipping eastward at a very high angle. He concludes this indicates a fault and anticlinal axis, since the dips on the two sides are opposed.

    Chapter 74

  2. What fossils did M. d'Orbigny identify in the black calcareous shales of the Pequenes ridge?

    The fossils were few and imperfect: an indeterminable Ammonite near A. recticostatus, a Gryphaea near G. Couloni, an indeterminable Natica, Cyprina rostrata, Rostellaria angulosa (?), and Terebratula (?). Some ammonite fragments were as thick as a man's arm, and the Gryphaea was the most abundant shell. D'Orbigny assigned them to the Neocomian stage of the Cretaceous system.

    Chapter 74

  3. How do d'Orbigny and Von Buch differ in dating the fossils, and what does Darwin note about the beds' superposition?

    D'Orbigny placed the fossils in the Neocomian (Cretaceous); Von Buch, using Meyen's collection, called the formation intermediate between Jura limestone and chalk, analogous to uppermost Jurassic beds. Darwin notes the relative superposition of the black shales and red sandstones is hard to determine, since gypseous beds are lens-shaped and thin out; he thinks the black shales probably form the uppermost part.

    Chapter 74

  4. What does Darwin find remarkable about dikes near the Pequenes range, and how do the eastern-slope strata behave?

    Darwin remarks it is remarkable that, given how violently the central ranges were dislocated and how numerous dikes are in the exterior Cordillera, he did not notice a single dike there. Descending the eastern slope, strata dipping east at about 40 degrees become nearly vertical; red sandstone and underlying black shales stand vertical in juxtaposition, and beyond a synclinal valley the corresponding beds dip west at 45 degrees, increasing to 60.

    Chapter 74

Section 754 cards
  1. What did Darwin infer about the original cover of the fossils on the Peuquenes western slope?

    Darwin states the fossils found low on the western slope must originally have been covered by a great thickness of black shaly rock, plus now-denuded thick overlying masses of red sandstone. He regretted not estimating the thickness in hundreds or thousands of feet, calling it a highly interesting point indicative of great subsidence, with analogous evidence expected elsewhere in the Cordillera during the same period.

    Chapter 75

  2. What do the Portillo conglomerate pebbles reveal about their sources?

    The conglomerate's pebbles include purplish sandstones, porphyries, brownish limestone, and black calcareous shale like that in situ in the Peuquenes, some containing the same fossil shells; also quartz, micaceous schist, and rounded crystals of reddish orthitic feldspar. Darwin affirms the feldspar did not come from the western ranges but may have come with quartz and schists from the eastern Portillo line; the fossiliferous slate and purple sandstone pebbles came from the Peuquenes or western ranges.

    Chapter 75

  3. Why does the conglomerate present a deceptive appearance when viewed from the eastern side of the valley?

    Both the gypseous strata and the conglomerate dip westward, the conglomerate at first only 20 degrees, increasing to about 45 degrees further on. Looking from the eastern side of the valley toward the Peuquenes range, this makes it appear as if the newer conglomerate beds dipped directly under the much older gypseous beds. Darwin notes the conglomerate is of great thickness, estimated at least 1,500 to 2,000 feet.

    Chapter 75

  4. How does Darwin explain the relationship between the red granite and the mica-schist of the Portillo range?

    Darwin describes the junction of dark mica-slate and coarse red granite as clearly visible from a vast distance; the granite sent many small veins into the mica-slate and included angular fragments of it. He thinks it more probable, given the schist's perfect metamorphic character and well-pronounced foliation, that it belongs to an anterior epoch connected with the white granites. He notes the granite had once been almost wholly encased by mica-schist, with caps and patches of schist remaining on the peaks.

    Chapter 75

Section 763 cards
  1. Why did Darwin conclude the lava-streams had been upheaved and tilted?

    The inclination of the streams from Los Arenales to the mouth of the valley is so great that Darwin concluded they must have been upheaved and tilted from the mountains after flowing. He notes he was then ignorant of Elie de Beaumont's researches on the extremely small slope over which lava can flow while retaining compact structure and considerable thickness, but he can now entertain not the smallest doubt of this conclusion.

    Chapter 76

  2. What evidence dates the white tuff relative to the basaltic lava-streams?

    The tuff at the mouth of the valley is a compact white deposit of broken pumice, volcanic crystals, mica scales, and lava fragments, much denuded. Darwin argues its deposition postdates the denudation of the basaltic lava-streams, as attested by their encircling cliffs standing at a higher level. He asks whether the ancient sea, not the present arid climate, provided the power to denude this soft deposit.

    Chapter 76

  3. What did Darwin conclude about the age and injection of the red granite in the Portillo chain?

    Darwin concluded the main part of the red granite was injected in a liquified state after accumulation of both the laminated sandstone and the conglomerate, having thrown them off at an angle of forty-five degrees. The conglomerate accumulated after deposition, elevation, and long denudation of the fossiliferous Peuquenes strata, which belong to the early Cretaceous. He therefore places the granite late in a geological sense.

    Chapter 76

Section 774 cards
  1. What do the inclined lava-streams at the Portillo's eastern foot indicate about the range?

    The author argues the lava-streams are interesting because their inclination, taken together with their thickness and compactness, shows that after the great range had assumed its present general outline, it continued to rise as an axis of elevation. The plains from the Cordillera base to the Atlantic show the continent was upraised in mass to 3,500 feet, and probably much more.

    Chapter 77

  2. What evidence does Darwin give that the Cordillera underwent subsidence, not only elevation?

    The author argues subsidence occurred: the sea bottom sank several thousand feet during deposition of strata in the Cordillera, and buried upright trees show another subsidence of many thousand feet during formation of the Uspallata chain. In the valley of Tenuyan, conglomerate 1,500 to 2,000 feet thick offers presumptive evidence, since large pebbles are transported only in shallow water.

    Chapter 77

  3. How does the structure of the Cumbre's western side compare with the Peuquenes section?

    The author states that in composition and stratification the western side of the divortium aquarum is far more simple than the corresponding part of the Peuquenes section. The stratification, where clearly distinguishable, is inclined westward toward the Pacific, seldom above 25 degrees except near the Cumbre. Only at one spot near the Cumbre did he see strata apparently of the gypseous formation conformably capping stratified porphyries.

    Chapter 77

  4. What elevatory axes does Darwin identify in the gypseous strata near the Cumbre's eastern slope?

    The author describes the gypseous strata as upheaved and crushed within a narrow space by a great uniclinal, an anticlinal, and one lesser uniclinal line of elevation. Between these three lines and the Cumbre, in the sandstones, conglomerates, and porphyritic formation, there have been at least two or three other great elevatory axes. The strata dip westward generally 30 degrees, sometimes 45, broken by vertical faults.

    Chapter 77

Section 784 cards
  1. What total thickness did Darwin estimate for the Puente del Inca section?

    Darwin estimated about six thousand feet total: roughly 3,000 feet of beds beneath the gypsum, at least 2,000 feet from the lowest to the uppermost gypsum bed, plus the porphyritic conglomerate and altered clay-slate below. He inspected about 4,000 feet of strata directly, could distinguish 1,000 feet more, and added about 1,000 feet of inferior strata seen lower in the valley.

    Chapter 78

  2. Which beds in the section does Darwin identify as submarine lavas?

    Darwin identifies beds 11, 15, 13, and 19 as submarine lavas. Bed 11 is a lilac-grey porphyritic rock with feldspar, black mica and ferruginous spots; bed 15 a hard yellowish-white feldspathic rock with hexagonal mica plates; bed 13 a singular amygdaloidal rock with lime carbonate balls; bed 19 a greenish-black crystalline stone with epidote veins.

    Chapter 78

  3. What evidence suggests the Puente del Inca strata accumulated on a shallow, uneven bottom?

    The author argues this from the lens-shape of the strata: not only the gypsum but the alternating sandstones and conglomerates thin out and replace each other, with a 300-foot sandstone bed between two gypsum beds disappearing within about a mile. He also cites the mineralogical diversity, abundant calcareous matter, coarse conglomerates, and rounded quartz pebbles, suggesting nearby land of porphyry and quartz-rock.

    Chapter 78

  4. Why does the porphyritic claystone conglomerate fall short of its usual thickness here?

    Darwin suggests this may be partly because metamorphic action was much less energetic here than usual, though the lower beds were still affected somewhat. He argues that had metamorphism been as strong as elsewhere in Chile, many sandstone and conglomerate beds with rounded porphyry masses would have become porphyritic conglomerate, alternating and blending with the submarine lavas.

    Chapter 78

Section 794 cards
  1. What fossils did d'Orbigny identify near Puente del Inca, and what age did they suggest?

    M. d'Orbigny identified a Gryphaea near G. Couloni and an Arca perhaps A. Gabrielis, both of Neocomian formation. Von Buch, examining Mr. Pentland's collection, found a Trigonia resembling T. costata, a Pholadomya like one from Alencon, and Isocardia excentrica from the Jura. Professor E. Forbes also held a strong impression the specimens indicated the Cretaceous period, probably an early epoch.

    Chapter 79

  2. Why did Darwin conclude the sea floor subsided after the fossil limestone was deposited?

    The shells in the limestone must have been covered by at least 4,000 feet of strata. Forbes's researches showed the sea below about 600 feet is exceedingly barren of organic beings, and he thought these mollusca lived no deeper than twenty fathoms (120 feet). Darwin therefore argued the sea bottom must have subsided some thousand feet to allow the overlying submarine strata to accumulate.

    Chapter 79

  3. What did Darwin observe about the brick-red porphyry near the Jaula?

    The brick-red porphyry consists of a red feldspathic base with large red feldspar crystals, angular quartz grains, and bits of soft green mineral resembling soapstone. Its feldspar differs from the albite-like variety common in other rocks. It appears to have burst through the other porphyries, sending out red dikes, though in a few places it was intersected by white dikes. Darwin thought it belonged to the same injection axis as the Portillo granite.

    Chapter 79

  4. How did Darwin describe the intrusive porphyries between the Jaula and the plain of Uspallata?

    Darwin called the number and bulk of intrusive masses of differently coloured porphyries truly extraordinary, injected one into another and intersected by dikes. He saw a white porphyry mountain sending two huge dikes branching downwards into blackish porphyry, and a white porphyry hill burst through dark strata, itself injected by purple brecciated porphyry, both crossed by a green dike and upheaved by a granitic dome.

    Chapter 79

Section 804 cards
  1. What is the Plain of Uspallata composed of, and how thick is it?

    The plain is composed to a thickness of some hundred feet of loosely aggregated, stratified shingle, which continues with a gently sloping surface up the valleys in the mountains on both sides. It is ten or fifteen miles wide, said to extend 180 miles northward, and its surface lies nearly six thousand feet above the sea.

    Chapter 80

  2. What unusual feature does section Z of the Plain of Uspallata show?

    Section Z shows alternating layers of almost loose red and white sand with lines of pebbles and beds of gravel inclined at 45 degrees, and in some spots even higher. These beds are dislocated by small faults and capped by a thick mass of horizontally stratified gravel of subaqueous origin. Darwin felt sure the inclination was not produced by currents.

    Chapter 80

  3. How do the Uspallata porphyries differ from the porphyritic conglomerate of Chile?

    The porphyries here rest unconformably on the altered feldspathic clay-slate, whereas the Chilean porphyritic conglomerate alternates with and rests conformably on it. Darwin therefore argues they probably do not belong to the same age. The porphyries, except one blackish stratum and one indurated white tufaceous bed, also differ from the beds in the Villa Vicencio Pass line.

    Chapter 80

  4. What structure does the summit of the Uspallata Range form, and what lies lower on the eastern slope?

    Neglecting small irregularities, the summit forms a broad anticlinal axis, with strata on the western slope dipping about 25 degrees west and on the upper eastern slope about 25 degrees east. Lower down near Los Hornillos there is a well-marked synclinal axis, beyond which strata incline 20 to 30 degrees inwards or westward. Denudation hides this synclinal axis in the outline.

    Chapter 80

Section 814 cards
  1. What is the most probable conclusion Darwin reaches about the clay-slate and the white conglomerate?

    The author argues that after the clay-slate was dislocated and tilted, but while still under the sea, a fresh and more recent deposition of clay-slate occurred, on which the white conglomerate was conformably deposited, with here and there a thin intercalated bed of clay-slate. On this view the conglomerates, tuffs and lavas are really unconformable to the main part of the clay-slate.

    Chapter 81

  2. What evidence convinced Darwin the clay-slate was consolidated and dislocated before the overlying beds were deposited?

    He found in the clay-slate one great, vertical, dike-like fissure filled with an indurated whitish tuff quite similar to some of the upper beds. This shows the clay-slate must have been consolidated and dislocated before those beds were deposited. He also saw the white conglomerate and overlying beds inclined 25 to 30 degrees west while the clay-slate and grauwacke at the mountain's base dipped 70 to 80 degrees.

    Chapter 81

  3. How does Darwin describe the junction between the sixth volcanic stratum and the underlying semi-porcellanic strata?

    Viewed from a distance the line of junction was distinct, but examined closely it was impossible to point out within a foot where the lava ended and the sedimentary mass began. At the junction the rock was in most places hard, bright green, and abounded with irregular amygdaloidal masses of ferruginous and pure calcareous spar, and of agate.

    Chapter 81

  4. What does Darwin say about the thin pitchstone layer and its origin?

    The tenth layer is a conformable layer less than two feet thick of pitchstone, generally brecciated and traversed by veins of agate and of carbonate of lime. Parts are composed of apparently concretionary fragments of a more perfect variety arranged in horizontal lines in a less perfectly characterised variety. Darwin states he has much difficulty in believing that this thin layer flowed as lava.

    Chapter 81

Section 824 cards
  1. What did Darwin find high on the western flank at about 7,000 feet, and how were they positioned?

    Darwin counted the stumps of fifty-two trees in an escarpment of green gritstone and mudstone. They projected two to five feet above ground and stood at right angles to strata inclined about 25 degrees west. Eleven were silicified and well preserved; forty were casts of coarsely crystallised carbonate of lime, one of dark argillaceous limestone.

    Chapter 82

  2. What did Mr. R. Brown determine about the silicified wood from the tree stumps?

    Darwin had Mr. R. Brown examine the wood when sliced and polished. Brown said it is coniferous, partaking of the characters of the Araucarian tribe, with some curious points of affinity with the Yew. The bark had been circularly furrowed with irregular lines, as shown by markings in the surrounding mudstone.

    Chapter 82

  3. How do the lava streams on the western flank and crest differ from those on the eastern side?

    The author argues that on the crest and western flank the streams, viewed as a whole, are mostly basaltic, either compact and fine-grained with minute augite and feldspar crystals, or coarse-grained with large coppery-brown augitic crystals. The eastern-side streams, which stand lower in the series, are mostly feldspathic.

    Chapter 82

  4. What did Darwin conclude about the thin bed resembling imperfect pitchstone?

    The bed was evidently of sedimentary origin but closely approached imperfect pitchstone, including extremely thin layers of perfect pitchstone and nodules and irregular fragments of the same rock arranged in horizontal lines. Darwin conceived that this bed, only a few feet thick, must have assumed its present state through metamorphic and concretionary action.

    Chapter 82

Section 832 cards
  1. Why did Darwin reject a lake origin for the tree-bearing strata?

    The author argues a lake origin is highly improbable: a very deep lake was needed to receive the matter below the trees, then drained for their growth, then re-formed and made profoundly deep to receive several thousand feet of later sediment — all before the Uspallata range formed, on the margin of the Pampas. He concludes submarine accumulation is infinitely more probable.

    Chapter 83

  2. How does Darwin explain the order of feldspathic versus basaltic lavas in the range?

    The author argues the submarine lavas are mostly feldspathic low in the series and mostly basaltic on the summit and western flank. He compares this to recent volcanic districts, where heavier basaltic lavas sink to a lower level in the crust and are erupted later over the lighter, upper trachytic lavas. He also notes the lava strata thickened westward, suggesting eruptions lay toward the Cordillera or buried under the Uspallata plain.

    Chapter 83

Section 843 cards
  1. How do the strata of the Uspallata range differ from those of the Cumbre range?

    The Uspallata range lacks the Cordillera's porphyritic conglomerate, gypseous strata, magnesian and other limestones, red sandstones, and siliceous beds with quartz pebbles. Instead it has indurated tuffs with veins and concretionary arrangement, grit and mud stones, semi-porcellanic rocks, and basaltic lava absent from the Cordillera. The Cordillera's feldspathic lavas contain mica, which the Uspallata lavas lack.

    Chapter 84

  2. Why does Darwin reject the two ranges' strata being contemporaneous?

    The chains are only ten to fifteen miles apart, and the Uspallata lavas came from the west, between the ranges. If deposited together without a dividing ridge, the Cordillera's gypseous and sedimentary masses should have spread east, and the Uspallata tuffs and basalts west. Darwin concludes the strata of one chain were deposited, and the chain uplifted, before the other formed.

    Chapter 84

  3. What two distinct periods of subsidence does Darwin infer, and what supports the second?

    The first accompanied deposition of the Neocomian strata in the Cordillera, where the sea bed subsided many thousand feet. Later, an adjoining area received strata, was upheaved into land with coniferous trees, then subsided several thousand feet for overlying submarine strata before being broken up and elevated. The coarse conglomerate at Tenuyan, with pebbles from the gypseous or Neocomian strata, supports a distinct later subsidence.

    Chapter 84

Section 854 cards
  1. What does Mr. R. Brown say about the silicified wood in the siliceo-calcareous slate?

    According to Mr. R. Brown, judging from several specimens, all the huge embedded logs of silicified wood found in the black and brown siliceo-calcareous slate are coniferous. These strata alternate with the porcellanic layers, claystones, and green porcelain-jasper of the upper half of the gypseous formation.

    Chapter 85

  2. What did Darwin find at Panuncillo that made the ridge worth noticing?

    Darwin reports a short N.N.W. and S.S.E. ridge with a nucleus of greenstone and slate-coloured porphyry containing glassy feldspar. It is notable for its almost vertical strata, chiefly a granular mixture of white carbonate of lime, protoxide of iron, and yellowish garnets (identified by Professor Miller), each grain nearly a perfect crystal.

    Chapter 85

  3. What is the structure of the Cuesta de Los Hornos range, and what exception does Darwin note?

    Darwin describes the range as a second uniclinal axis of elevation: the stratified porphyritic conglomerate on its north-eastern flank and some summits is inclined N.E., while the main pile dips about 20 degrees to N.E. by N. He notes one exception—a narrow fringe of upper gypseous strata brushed up and inclined south-eastward at the south-eastern foot.

    Chapter 85

  4. Why did Darwin hesitate to call the red and green stratified rocks at Arqueros submarine lavas?

    Darwin says he might have mistaken several of these stratified rocks for submarine lavas, like those at the Puente del Inca, had he not examined, a few leagues eastward, a fine series of analogous but less metamorphosed sedimentary beds of the gypseous formation, probably derived from a volcanic source.

    Chapter 85

Section 864 cards
  1. What minerals and compounds make up the silver veins near the mines described?

    The veins consist of native silver, muriate of silver, an amalgam of silver, cobalt, antimony, and arsenic, generally embedded in sulphate of barytes. They run irregularly N.W. and S.E., generally at right angles to the many dikes. Darwin cites Domeyko's account in the Comptes Rendus, tome 14, page 560. Mr. Lambert assured him native copper without a trace of silver occurs in the same vein as native silver without copper.

    Chapter 86

  2. How does vein productivity differ between Aristeas and S. Rosa?

    At Aristeas, the silver veins are said to be unproductive once they pass into the green strata. At S. Rosa, only two or three miles distant, the reverse happens. When Darwin visited, miners were working through a red stratum hoping the vein would become productive in the underlying green sedimentary mass. Darwin also had a specimen of green rock, taken a yard from any vein, containing disseminated native and muriate of silver.

    Chapter 86

  3. What fossils occur in the brown argillaceous limestone above the porphyritic conglomerate?

    The limestone, some hundred feet thick and in parts crystalline, is in parts almost composed of Hippurites Chilensis, d'Orbigny. It also contains an impression of a Pecten and a coral, and great numbers of a large Gryphaea, very like and, according to Professor E. Forbes, probably identical with G. Orientalis, Forbes MS., a cretaceous species probably from upper greensand at Verdachellum, Southern India.

    Chapter 86

  4. What does Darwin conclude about the difference between the Arqueros and Coquimbo beds?

    Darwin argues the only difference lies in the Arqueros beds having been more metamorphosed, in conformity with their more dislocated and injected condition. Consequently the calcareous matter, oxide of iron, and green colouring matter were segregated under a more crystalline form. He notes both places share easily fusible rocks of the same bright green and red colours, containing calcareous matter, often finely brecciated, passing into each other and alternating.

    Chapter 86

Section 874 cards
  1. What did Darwin name the formation whose fossils mix oolitic and cretaceous types?

    Darwin calls it the cretaceo-oolitic formation. He argues the Hippurites, Gryphaea, Ostrea, Pecten, Turritella, Nautilus, two Terebratulae and a Spirifer all belong to one formation, which appears to form a passage between the oolitic and cretaceous systems of Europe. He admits the term is unusual but adopts it for convenience.

    Chapter 87

  2. Why did d'Orbigny conclude there were two distinct formations in this area?

    D'Orbigny judged the Pecten, Ostrea, Turritella and Hippurite to indicate the cretaceous period, while the two Terebratulae and the Spirifer pointed to the oolitic series. Not having examined the country himself, he concluded two formations existed. Darwin counters that he extracted the Spirifer and T. aenigma from the same bed as the Pecten and Ostrea.

    Chapter 87

  3. What happens to the strata as they approach the andesite and porphyry mountain on the north side of the R. Claro?

    The strata are much dislocated by faults and dikes and incline northward toward the mountain, into which they appear almost blended. Their inclination increases up to 70 degrees as they near it, and the upper rocks become highly metamorphosed. The section's lowest visible bed is a purplish hard sandstone, overlain by white siliceous sandstone and fossiliferous limestone.

    Chapter 87

  4. What do Forbes and d'Orbigny disagree about regarding Terebratula aenigma and T. ignaciana?

    D'Orbigny links T. aenigma to T. concinna from the Forest Marble and T. ignaciana to T. ornithocephala from the Lias, both oolitic. Forbes finds many T. aenigma specimens almost indistinguishable from the oolitic British T. tetraedra, and T. ignaciana hard to separate from mountain limestone T. hastata and some Marlstone Terebratulae, noting internal structure is needed to decide identity.

    Chapter 87

Section 883 cards
  1. What does Darwin believe the globular and pear-shaped balls in Bed 3 of the Copiapo section are?

    The balls are very tough, slate-coloured porphyry with imperfect feldspar crystals, ranging from apple to man's-head size. Darwin states they do not resemble pebbles and believes they are subaqueous volcanic bombs, differing from subaerial bombs only in not being vesicular.

    Chapter 88

  2. In the Copiapo valley section, how do the strata of the gypseous formation [B] change in dip?

    The strata begin horizontal or gently inclined westward, then become highly inclined in various directions and contorted by underlying intrusive rocks, and lastly take a regular eastward dip, forming a tolerably well pronounced north-south line of hills. The formation consists of thin alternating strata of calcareous slate-rock, pseudo-honestones, and jaspery layers with gypsum.

    Chapter 88

  3. What does the Copiapo section show about the porphyritic conglomerate compared with Central Chile?

    The porphyritic conglomerate east of the unstratified porphyry hills [C] is far less metamorphosed than in most parts of Central Chile. It consists of beds of true purple claystone porphyry repeatedly alternating with thick beds of purplish-red conglomerate containing well-rounded, large pebbles of various porphyries, not blended together.

    Chapter 88

Section 894 cards
  1. Why does Darwin say any mineral-based division of this formation is arbitrary?

    Darwin states that in a formation so highly variable in mineralogical nature, any division not founded on fossil remains must be extremely arbitrary. He nonetheless treats beds below the last conglomerate as porphyritic conglomerate and those above as the gypseous formation, marked [E] in the section.

    Chapter 89

  2. How does the section near Potrero Seco change within a few miles?

    Darwin reports that at a distance of only two to three miles, the green mudstones and white indurated tuffs are largely replaced by red sandstone and black calcareous shaly rocks alternating together. Bed 11's white tuff there contains little or no gypsum, while across the valley it is thicker and abounds with gypsum layers.

    Chapter 89

  3. What is the structure of the fourth axis of elevation in the Copiapo valley?

    The fourth axis is formed by a mountain chain [F] whose central masses near La Punta consist of andesite with green hornblende and coppery mica, with outer porphyries injected by andesite hummocks. Darwin describes it as mainly uniclinal toward the S.E., like the third axis, and only locally anticlinal.

    Chapter 89

  4. What does Darwin find remarkable about the conglomerate near Las Amolanas?

    Above the porphyritic conglomerate's uppermost porphyries lies a coarse arenaceous conglomerate, white below and pink above, mostly porphyry pebbles but with some red sandstone and jasper. Darwin notes an oblique or current lamination he did not elsewhere observe, and in the underlying purplish conglomerate a single granite pebble, the first such instance in the sections described.

    Chapter 89

Section 904 cards
  1. What name does Darwin provisionally use for the formation containing these mixed fossils?

    Darwin states that the fossils all belong to one formation, but because some species have an ancient, oolitic aspect while the Pecten, Turritella, Astarte, and Hippurites are cretaceous in character, he is driven back to the provisional name "cretaceo-oolitic." From geological evidence he believes it equivalent to the Neocomian beds of the Cordillera of Central Chile.

    Chapter 90

  2. Why does Darwin conclude the sea bottom subsided during the shells' existence?

    The fossil shells lie in limestone now covered by 5,000 to 6,000 feet of strata, yet Forbes thinks they lived at only 30 to 40 fathoms (180 to 240 feet). Since some of the same shells occur high up as well as low down in the series, Darwin concludes the sea bottom subsided while the shells lived, allowing the overlying submarine strata to accumulate.

    Chapter 90

  3. What evidence shows the whole thick pile at Las Amolanas is one age?

    Near the junction of the upper black calcareous slate-rock and the upper red sandstone, Darwin found Gryphaea Darwinii and Turritella Andii, the latter an eminently characteristic species. Because these same shells also occur in the lower beds, he argues the entire vast pile of strata, estimated at least 8,000 feet thick, belongs to the same age.

    Chapter 90

  4. What do the silicified tree trunks in the red conglomerate reveal?

    The coarse red conglomerate, two to three thousand feet thick, contains thousands of huge embedded silicified tree trunks, one eight feet long and another eighteen feet in circumference. Darwin marvels that every vessel in so thick a mass of wood was converted into silex, and notes that all the specimens he brought home present a coniferous structure according to Mr. R. Brown.

    Chapter 90

Section 914 cards
  1. What did Darwin conclude about the land source of the gypseous conglomerate pebbles?

    Darwin concludes that land, probably islands, existed nearby during formation of the conglomerates, where innumerable pebbles were rounded and then dispersed. He argues this land was mainly porphyries with some mica-slate (source of the quartz), red sandstone, and jaspery rocks. He also reasons the coniferous forests grew on this land, since it is improbable so many thousand logs drifted from any great distance.

    Chapter 91

  2. How do the gypseous conglomerates differ from the porphyritic-conglomerate formation?

    In the gypseous conglomerates, both upper and lower beds, the pebbles are all well rounded and include various porphyries plus red sandstone, jaspery stone, one mica-slate pebble, and quartz particles. In the porphyritic-conglomerate formation, angular and rounded fragments are mingled together and are almost exclusively porphyries, which Darwin says were probably ejected from craters deep under the sea.

    Chapter 91

  3. What fossils occur at the base of the gypseous formation in the Copiapo section, and what does their position imply?

    The lowest bed is yellowish siliceous sandstone, like that of Amolanas, with gypsum veins and layers of black calcareous non-fissile slate-rock containing Turritella Andii, Pecten Dufreynoyi, Terebratula aenigma var., and some Gryphites. The sandstone varies from twenty to eighty feet thick because of inequalities in the underlying purple claystone porphyry, so the fossils lie at the very base and were probably once covered by strata about seven thousand feet thick.

    Chapter 91

  4. What does Darwin say about the length and continuity of the axes of elevation near Copiapo?

    Although Darwin describes seven or eight axes of elevation between Copiapo and the western flank of the main Cordillera, running nearly north and south, he cautions it must not be supposed they all run continuously for great distances. As in Central Chile, most lines of elevation, except the first, third, and fifth, are very short. He adds that stratification is everywhere disturbed and intricate, with numerous faults and dikes, and the district is more or less metalliferous.

    Chapter 91

Section 924 cards
  1. What fossils did Darwin find in the limestone beds at Maricongo?

    At the foot of the first main ridge of the Cordillera, in the ravine of Maricongo, at an estimated elevation of about ten thousand feet, Darwin found beds of white sandstone and limestone containing Pecten Dufreynoyi, Terebratula aenigma, and some Gryphites. He estimated the elevation from the extreme coldness and the appearance of the vegetation.

    Chapter 92

  2. Why did Darwin conclude the tufaceous deposit was deposited beneath the sea?

    Darwin argues the horizontal tufaceous beds cap summits at an exactly corresponding level while leaving higher points bare. Volcanic ash hardened by rain, he reasons, would have covered all neighbouring summits equally. A lake at that height without a barrier is out of the question, so the matter must have been deposited beneath the sea before the valleys were excavated.

    Chapter 92

  3. What does the tufaceous deposit imply about the elevation of the Copiapo district?

    Darwin argues the deposit confirms the conclusion drawn from the stratified shingle fringes, namely that the great range has been elevated in mass to between eight and nine thousand feet. Judging from the tufaceous deposit, he concludes the horizontal elevation in the Copiapo district has been about ten thousand feet.

    Chapter 92

  4. How does Darwin describe the second case of disturbed stratification in the Despoblado?

    In two low ridges uniting at the head of a wedge-shaped valley, the strata dip 45 degrees east in both. Following the left ridge up the valley, the dip steepens to vertical, then falls over, until at the valley head the beds are reversed at 45 degrees. The beds were thus turned through 135 degrees, forming an anticlinal axis with the left-hand strata upside down.

    Chapter 92

Section 934 cards
  1. Why does Darwin think porphyritic lava streams are rarely traceable to their sources?

    Darwin argues the original eruption points tend to become points of later injection and disturbance, since crust that yielded once yields again even if magma no longer reaches the surface. Intrusive masses form the Cordillera's axis-lines, and valleys were hollowed along these lines, so denudation leaves the masses isolated and hard to trace.

    Chapter 93

  2. What did Darwin observe in the Despoblado about two porphyry strata?

    In the Valley of the Despoblado, Darwin saw two great strata of purple claystone porphyry, long closely united, become separated by fragmentary matter and then thin out, the lower more rapidly than the upper. There alone he traced a thick purplish porphyry stratum conformably overlying breccia-conglomerates and claystone lavas until it blended into unstratified porphyries.

    Chapter 93

  3. What fossils and rock types did Darwin find at Iquique?

    At Iquique the coast is a 2,000-3,000-foot escarpment of porphyritic conglomerate, chiefly reddish and purple porphyries with some breccia-conglomerate, topped by laminated purplish-grey limestone with purple sandstone. The limestone yielded Lucina Americana, Terebratula inca, and Terebratula aenigma, leading Darwin to assign these beds to the cretaceo-oolitic formation.

    Chapter 93

  4. What evidence led Darwin to link South American Cordillera strata to one epoch?

    Darwin cites Terebratula aenigma at Coquimbo and Copiapo, Iquique beds resembling Copiapo's, an Ammonites and Astarte from Cerro Pasco possibly Neocomian, and a grand fossiliferous deposit in Colombia of early Cretaceous age. Bearing in mind Tierra del Fuego fossils, he sees evidence much of the Cordillera's stratified deposits belongs to about the same epoch.

    Chapter 93

Section 944 cards
  1. In central Chile, what general direction did Darwin find the principal metalliferous veins running?

    In nine mining districts Darwin visited in central Chile, the principal veins ran from between north and north-west to south and south-east. He notes exceptions: courses were irregular in the Copiapo valley, and at Tambillos he saw a large copper vein running east and west. He also observed that gneiss and mica-slate foliation tends to run slightly west of north, like the veins.

    Chapter 94

  2. How does Darwin relate the depth of a vein to the minerals found in it?

    Darwin reports that in some cases, as at Panuncillo south-east of Coquimbo, the upper part of a vein contains oxides while the lower part contains sulphurets of copper; he notes Mr. Taylor observed the same in Cuba. For gold, it is believed the upper part of the vein is often most productive, which Darwin links to gold's abundance in Chile's stratified detritus, derived from degradation of upper rock portions.

    Chapter 94

  3. Where does silver chiefly occur in Chile, and what exceptions does Darwin note?

    Silver, as chloride, sulphuret, amalgam, or native, with lead and other metals, occurs chiefly in the upper great gypseous or cretaceo-oolitic formation, which Darwin calls probably the richest mass in Chile, citing Arqueros, Copiapo, and Iquique. Exceptions include silver in porphyritic conglomerate at Paral, argentiferous lead in Uspallata clay-slate, and an old silver mine in syenite at the Bell of Quillota.

    Chapter 94

  4. What is a veta real, and why are cruceros considered valuable?

    According to information from Mr. Nixon of Yaquil and others, the most permanently productive Chilean veins are those of various minerals that include parallel strings rich in metals; such a vein is called a veta real. More commonly mines are worked where thin veins intersect a poor veta real, and it is unanimously believed that at these intersections, or cruceros, the quantity of metal is much greater.

    Chapter 94

Section 954 cards
  1. What does Darwin say metallic veins in Chile are connected with?

    The author argues that metallic veins are connected with the presence of intrusive rocks and with the degree of metamorphic action undergone by different districts of Chile. Such metamorphosed areas are generally accompanied by numerous dikes and injected masses of andesite and various porphyries, and he traced metalliferous veins from intrusive masses into the encasing strata.

    Chapter 95

  2. How do the richly metalliferous Chilean strata compare with unaltered submarine beds of Pacific islands?

    Darwin calls the richness of these strata highly remarkable, since they consist of submarine lavas and debris of erupted rocks, or tuffs and mudstones probably due to volcanic exhalations. By contrast, the erupted beds of often submarine origin composing islands in the Pacific, Indian, and Atlantic Oceans are not metamorphosed, and there metals are entirely absent, their nature even unknown to the aborigines.

    Chapter 95

  3. What fossils occur in the gypseous formation, and how does Darwin interpret their age?

    Palaeontologists who examined the fossil shells of the Cordillera of Central Chile placed them in the earlier stages of the cretaceous system, while Northern Chile shows a singular mixture of cretaceous and oolitic forms. From the geological relations of the two districts, Darwin thinks they all belong to nearly the same epoch, which he provisionally called cretaceo-oolitic.

    Chapter 95

  4. What evidence leads Darwin to conclude the sea bottom subsided during the cretaceo-oolitic period?

    Fossil shells are covered by great thicknesses of strata: in the Peuquenes ridge, at the Puente del Inca by at least five thousand feet, at Coquimbo about six thousand, and at Copiapo five or six thousand and probably seven thousand feet. Darwin argues this shows subsidence allowed accumulation of superincumbent submarine strata, confirmed by coarse conglomerates at many levels whose well-rounded pebbles could not have been transported in very deep water.

    Chapter 95

Section 964 cards
  1. What do the silicified fir-tree trunks at Los Hornos and Coquimbo indicate about this period?

    Darwin states that the extraordinarily numerous silicified trunks of fir-trees at Los Hornos, and perhaps at Coquimbo and two distant points in the Copiapo valley, indicate that land existed at this period in the neighbourhood. This land, or islands, was in the northern Copiapo district almost exclusively composed of granite pebbles, and in the south mainly of claystone porphyries with mica-schist and sandstone.

    Chapter 96

  2. What evidence shows the gypseous formation's lower beds were locally upheaved during its accumulation?

    Darwin argues that pebbles in the gypseous formation derived from its own basal series and from the underlying porphyritic conglomerate show those rocks were already partially upheaved and exposed to wear. Near the Puente del Inca and at Coquimbo, masses of mica-schist or similar rock must have supplied the many small opaque-quartz pebbles. He infers the upper beds may therefore lie unconformably on the lower.

    Chapter 96

  3. What does Darwin infer about the Cordillera's upheaval in mass versus angular dislocation?

    From stratified gravel-fringes sloping up the Cordillera valleys, connected to shell-bearing coastal plains, Darwin infers without hesitation that the range was upheaved in mass by slow movement at least 8,000 feet; in the Despoblado Valley the horizontal elevation was about 10,000 feet. He argues, before reading Hopkins, that angular dislocations were quite subordinate to this great upward movement in mass.

    Chapter 96

  4. How does Darwin describe the andesitic rocks and their role in the Cordillera?

    Darwin says the andesitic rocks were in most cases the last injected, probably form a continuous dome under the range, stand in intimate relationship with modern lavas, and seem the immediate agent in metamorphosing the porphyritic conglomerate and often the gypseous strata. He notes the close similarity of andesitic granites and porphyries throughout Chile, Tierra del Fuego, and Peru, and feldspar cleaving like albite.

    Chapter 96

Section 974 cards
  1. What evidence suggests portions of the porphyritic conglomerate and gypseous formations were successively upheaved?

    Darwin argues that pebbles worn from the porphyritic conglomerate appear in the upper parts of that same formation and often in the gypseous formation, while pebbles from the basal parts of the gypseous formation occur in its upper strata. These included pebbles make it almost certain that portions, possibly ridges, of the two formations were successively upheaved rather than all at once.

    Chapter 97

  2. Why did Darwin think the Portillo range was raised long after the Peuquenes range?

    The author argues a preexisting granitic line in the Portillo range was upraised long after the parallel Peuquenes range. He notes it was not raised by a single blow, as shown by highly inclined basaltic streams in the valley on its eastern flank. He also explains that the river draining the valley between the ranges passes through the higher Portillo line because of slow, subsequent elevation.

    Chapter 97

  3. What did Darwin infer from the small breaches in exterior mountain-ranges near Cauquenes?

    Near the baths of Cauquenes, Darwin was struck by the small size of breaches cut through the exterior mountain-ranges compared with the same valleys higher up inside the Cordillera. He found this scarcely explicable except on the idea that the exterior lines were subsequently upthrown and therefore exposed to less denudation. He also inferred most greater dislocations occurred during the earlier parts of the great elevation in mass.

    Chapter 97

  4. Why did Darwin doubt that high volcanic activity and subsidence were strictly contemporaneous?

    Darwin was convinced by his study of coral formations that these two actions generally do not go on synchronously. He argues that in volcanic districts subsidence ceases as soon as the orifices burst into renewed action and only recommences when they become dormant again. He therefore throws some doubt on the strict contemporaneousness of high volcanic activity and movements of subsidence.

    Chapter 97

Section 984 cards
  1. What does Darwin infer from the shells in Patagonia and Chile's old tertiary formations?

    The nature and grouping of shells in the old tertiary formations of Patagonia and Chile show that the continent then stood only a few fathoms below its present level, and afterwards subsided over a wide area by seven or eight hundred feet. The manner of its later re-elevation to the actual level was described in the First and Second Chapters.

    Chapter 98

  2. How does Darwin describe the pattern of elevation on South America's western side?

    The author argues elevation on the western side has not been equable. At Valparaiso it reached 1,300 feet within the period upraised shells have remained undecayed on the surface, while at Coquimbo, 200 miles north, it was only 252 feet in the same period. At Coquimbo, within 364 feet, elevation was interrupted by five periods of comparative rest.

    Chapter 98

  3. What evidence shows the entire breadth of the continent has been uplifted?

    For a space of 775 miles, upraised recent shells are found on the two opposite sides of the continent. In the southern half of this space, Darwin says it may be safely inferred from the slope of the land up to the Cordillera, and from shells found in central Tierra del Fuego and high up the River Santa Cruz, that the entire breadth of the continent has been uplifted.

    Chapter 98

  4. What does Darwin conclude about the Cordillera's volcanic history and its relation to elevation?

    The author argues the Cordillera has probably been, with some quiescent periods, a source of volcanic matter from before the cretaceo-oolitic formation to the present day. He considers the intimate relation between recent eruptions and slow elevation of the continent in mass highly important, since no explanation of one phenomenon is satisfactory unless applicable to the other.

    Chapter 98

Section 994 cards
  1. How does Darwin describe the formation of the Cordillera, contrary to some geologists?

    The author argues the Cordillera's parallel ridges were slowly and successively upthrown at widely different periods, and the range subsided and was re-elevated multiple times, including during old tertiary formations. He contrasts this complicated, slow history with the view of geologists who believe the mountain-chain was formed in late times by a single blow.

    Chapter 99

  2. What evidence does Darwin cite against single periods of extreme violence in the Cordillera?

    The author argues the excessively disturbed strata do not indicate single violent periods. Instead, they present insuperable difficulties unless one admits that masses of once-liquified rocks of the axes were repeatedly injected with intervals long enough for successive cooling and consolidation. He cites his Geological Transactions paper (volume 5, page 626) for this argument.

    Chapter 99

  3. What does Darwin say about the translations of Ehrenberg's passage on the Pampean formation?

    The note states that translations in France and England implying Professor Ehrenberg believes the Pampean formation was deposited by a sea-debacle rushing over the land are incorrect. Darwin states this on the authority of a letter to him. He quotes the original German passage, which describes the deposits as unchanged brackish freshwater formations.

    Chapter 99

  4. What analogies does Darwin use to support the slowness of the Cordillera's changes?

    The author points to analogies from changes now in progress in the earth's crust: the manner in which volcanic matter is erupted, and the manner in which land is historically known to have risen and sunk. He also cites the vast amount of denudation every part of the Cordillera has obviously suffered, concluding the changes were neither too slowly effected nor too complicated.

    Chapter 99

Section 1003 cards
  1. According to the index, what effects does Darwin attribute to earthquakes on surface rocks and cleavage?

    The index records earthquake effects at S. Maria and elevation during an earthquake at Lemus, plus the 1822 Valparaiso earthquake. It lists effects of earthquakes in shattering surface, fissures made by them, and their probable effects on cleavage. Earthquake-waves are credited with power to throw up shells, effects near Lima, and power in transporting boulders.

    Chapter 100

  2. What does the index say about the age and character of the Pampean formation?

    The index lists the Pampean formation with its area, an estuary origin, and D'Orbigny's views on its age and on the absence of gypsum within it. Professor Ehrenberg is credited with infusoria in the Pampean formation, and D'Orbigny with fossil remains from Bahia Blanca and the banks of the Parana.

    Chapter 100

  3. Which authors does the index credit with observations on elevated or upraised shells along South America?

    D'Orbigny is credited with upraised shells at Monte Video, elevated shells at St. Pedro, near B. Ayres, near Cobija, and near Arica, plus sudden elevation of La Plata and S. Blas. Freyer is credited with elevated shells of Arica, and Gay with elevated shells generally. The index also lists Ensenada's elevated shells and Herradura Bay's elevated shells.

    Chapter 100

Section 1014 cards
  1. What does Darwin report about the preservation of colors in upraised shells?

    The index credits Mr. Lyell with observations on upraised shells retaining their colours, listed among the elevated-shell topics of the South American coast. The chapter's index also records upraised shells that are too small for human food, shells transported far inland for food, and the gradual decay of upraised shells, indicating Darwin weighed how long such shells persist after elevation.

    Chapter 101

  2. What does the index say about the origin of salt formations and salt lakes?

    The index lists Murchison on the origin of salt formations, the origin of strata of salt, and salt lakes including those of Rio Negro and S. Julian. It also notes the purity of salt in salt lakes, deliquescent salt as necessary for preserving meat, and ancient salt formations at Iquique and S. Lorenzo, plus superficial deposits of salts and saline incrustations on the Rio Parana.

    Chapter 101

  3. How does the index characterize the transporting power of rivers and the sea?

    The index lists the small power of rivers in transporting pebbles and their small power in forming valleys, alongside the sea's power in forming valleys. It also cites Murchison and Playfair on waves transporting gravel, Palmer on transportation of gravel, and Malcolmson on trees carried out to sea, showing Darwin weighed fluvial, marine, and other means of moving material.

    Chapter 101

  4. What fossil mammals and other vertebrate remains does the index record in South America?

    The index lists fossil Mammalia at Bahia Blanca, near St. Fe, Banda Oriental, St. Julian, and Port Gallegos, plus the range of Megalonyx, Megatherium, Mastodon Andium, and Macrauchenia Patachonica. It notes remains washed down by floods, the number and range of remains in the Pampas, fossil rodents, and Professor Owen on fossil mammiferous remains, with human skeletons in Brazil and remains near Lima.

    Chapter 101

Section 1024 cards
  1. What does Darwin's index say about the distribution of the silver mines listed?

    The index names silver mines at Arqueros, Chanuncillo, and Iquique, and then lists 'distribution of' as a separate entry. It gives no detail in this chapter beyond these place names and the topic of distribution, so any account of how the mines are spread must come from the body of the work, not from this index text.

    Chapter 102

  2. According to the index, what did Mr. Smith of Jordan Hill observe about upraised shells?

    The index credits Mr. Smith of Jordan Hill with observations on upraised shells retaining their colours, on Madeira, on elevated seaweed, and on inclined gravel beds. These entries point to his work on evidence of elevation, but the index supplies only the topics, not the details of his findings or arguments.

    Chapter 102

  3. What does the index list regarding subsidence and the accumulation of deposits?

    The index lists subsidence during formation of sea-cliffs, near Lima, probably during the Pampean formation, and as necessary for the accumulation of permanent deposits. It also records subsidence during tertiary formations of Chile and Patagonia, and probably during Neocomian formations of the Portillo and Cumbre passes, plus great subsidence at Copiapo and during formation of the Cordillera.

    Chapter 102

  4. What does the index record about terraces in Patagonia and at Coquimbo?

    The index lists terraces of the valley of S. Cruz, terraces of equable heights throughout Patagonia and their formation, terraces of Chiloe, Conchalee, Coquimbo, Guasco, and S. Lorenzo, plus gravel terraces within the Cordillera. It notes specifically that the terraces at Coquimbo are not horizontal, a detail bearing on how they formed.

    Chapter 102

Source and licence

Text used: Project Gutenberg eBook #3620 (Public domain in the United States). Generated from the full text; cards paraphrase the source.

Version: Public domain edition. Retrieved 2026-11-20. Cards reviewed 2026-11-20.

These cards paraphrase the text for study. They are not a substitute for reading the book, and they do not reproduce long passages.

Turn your own notes into cards

Upload a PDF, Word, or text file and get question-and-answer cards for closed-notes practice. Five cards are free, no signup.

Try 5 free cards