H. L. (Henry Louis) Mencken · Public domain edition · 105 cards · 31 chapters
H. L. Mencken’s In Defense of Women argues that women are often more practical and perceptive than men, while men mistake custom and self-interest for female inferiority. The cards cover his claims about criticism, originality, American intolerance, the 1918 edition’s reception, sex literature, reputation, heroism, genius, and intelligence.
1 / 105
Chapter 1 · Question
What does Mencken claim is his principal business as a critic?
WakeCards · wakecards.com · Big ideas. Quick review.
Chapter 1 · Answer
The author argues his principal business is manufacturing platitudes for tomorrow: ideas so novel they are instantly rejected by right-thinking men, yet so sound they eventually force themselves into the traditional wisdom of the race. He admits much of his stock consists of old platitudes rescued from yesterday's shelves and given new labels.
WakeCards · wakecards.com · Big ideas. Quick review.
Arrow keys move between cards. Space or Enter flips.
All questions and answers
Every card in the deck, in reading order. Click a chapter to expand. The reviewer above uses the same content.
Section 14 cards
What does Mencken claim is his principal business as a critic?
The author argues his principal business is manufacturing platitudes for tomorrow: ideas so novel they are instantly rejected by right-thinking men, yet so sound they eventually force themselves into the traditional wisdom of the race. He admits much of his stock consists of old platitudes rescued from yesterday's shelves and given new labels.
Chapter 1
According to Mencken, why do thinkers rarely achieve genuine originality?
The author argues nature and God conspire against originality. The dead hand pushes everyone into intellectual cages, and an inner weakness limits capacity to throw off the prejudices of race and culture. He cites Haeckel's claim that the cell does not act but reacts, suggesting reflection is merely a congeries of cells, so even loftiest flights recycle old schoolroom ideas.
Chapter 1
Why did Mencken expect his American audience to resist novel ideas?
The author argues that in the United States alone among great nations there is a right and wrong way to think about everything, from theology to trivial daily matters. He claims questioning majority faith risks social disaster, that the old English offence of imagining the King's death has been revived and extended, and that democracy, grounded in childish fallacies, must penalize free play of ideas.
Chapter 1
What examples does Mencken give of American intolerance toward dissent?
The author cites a citizen opposing a public clamour—such as an equestrian statue of Susan B. Anthony, leopards for the zoo, or hosting the Structural Iron Workers in Symphony Hall—being denounced as an anarchist and public enemy. He claims hundreds are jailed for revived 'imagining the King's death,' now extended to beliefs like negro equality before the law, speaking enemy languages, or sharing a synthetic gin formula.
Chapter 1
Section 24 cards
What rule did Mencken set for the ideas included in the 1918 edition?
Mencken laid down the rule that no idea should go into the book unless it was already so obvious that it had been embodied in the proverbial philosophy, or folk-wisdom, of some civilized nation, including the Chinese. He kept to this rule throughout, producing what he calls a pastiche of proverbs, though he was often tempted to insert notions that seemed to have escaped the peasants of Europe and Asia.
Chapter 2
How did American reviewers and Southern newspapers react to the 1918 edition?
Mencken says not a single American reviewer noticed his ideational abstinence, and most slated the book as a mass of heresies and contumacies, an attack on revered truths about the woman question. In the South, some newspapers denounced it as German propaganda designed to break down American morale and urged the Department of Justice to prosecute him for criminal anarchy.
Chapter 2
What does Mencken say is the primary problem the literature of sex leaves unsolved?
Mencken argues the literature of sex leaves the primary problem unsolved: what is to be done about the conflict between the celibacy enforced upon millions by civilization and the appetites implanted in all by God. In the main, he says, it counsels yielding to celibacy, which he compares to advising a dog to forget its fleas. He offers no remedy of his own, being suspicious of remedies for life's major ills.
Chapter 2
How does Mencken describe his own national reputation and his attitude toward truth?
Mencken says he is held suspect as a foreigner in the United States and was denounced during the war, while abroad, especially in England, he is tortured for his intolerable Americanism. He claims to be wholly devoid of public spirit or moral purpose and to respect only intellectual honesty. He says if he knew what was true he would probably sweat and strive for it, but so far he has not found it.
Chapter 2
Section 33 cards
Why does Mencken say women secretly regard men as asses?
The author argues women's so-called intuition is really a sharp perception of reality and immunity to emotional enchantment, letting them distinguish appearance from substance. In the family circle the man appears a hero and demigod, but the substance is a poor mountebank. He calls this shrewd perception one of the best proofs of feminine intelligence.
Chapter 3
How does Mencken rebut the proverb that no man is a hero to his valet?
He calls the proverb insincere and untrue, and of masculine manufacture. It is insincere because it masks the egotistic doctrine that a man is potentially a hero to everyone else. It is untrue because a valet, being a fourth-rate man, envies his master and would change places with him, making him the last person to penetrate the master's charlatanry.
Chapter 3
What does Mencken say about genius in women and the mixing of sexes?
The author argues women of genius are commonly distinctly mannish, naming George Sand, Catherine the Great, Elizabeth of England, Rosa Bonheur and Cosima Wagner. He concludes neither sex, without fertilization by the complementary character of the other, reaches the highest human endeavour: the wholly manly man lacks wit to give form to dreams, and the wholly womanly woman is too cynical to dream at all.
Chapter 3
Section 43 cards
What does Mencken claim men mistake for a deficiency of intelligence in women?
The author argues that what men mistake for female stupidity is merely an incapacity for mastering small intellectual tricks, petty knowledges, and cerebral rubber stamps—the chief mental equipment of the average male. He calls these empty talents superficial accomplishments, no more demanding than a chimpanzee learning to catch a penny or scratch a match.
Chapter 4
What did Charles Francis Adams reportedly say about business geniuses?
Mencken cites the late Charles Francis Adams, grandson and great-grandson of American Presidents, who after a long lifetime among the chief business 'geniuses' of the United States reported in old age that he had never heard a single one say anything worth hearing. Mencken calls them vigorous, masculine, successful—but intellectually blank cartridges.
Chapter 4
What did Havelock Ellis find about first rate men in his study of British genius?
Mencken reports that in Havelock Ellis's great study of British genius, an incapacity for petty expertness appeared in almost all first rate men. They are bad at tying cravats, do not understand fashionable card games, are puzzled by book-keeping, and know nothing of party politics—inert in the very fields where average men perform best.
Chapter 4
Section 53 cards
According to the author, in what kinds of work do women typically fail and succeed?
The author argues women usually fail in law and business, which demand hollow phrases, formulae, and roguery, but succeed in sick-nursing, which requires ingenuity, quick comprehension, courage, and skill at penetrating character. He also claims women hold their own in the arts and are the best actors and teachers.
Chapter 5
How does the author explain what men call women's 'intuition'?
The author argues intuition is simply intelligence: keen enough to see hidden truth through false appearances and honest enough to state it plainly. He rejects mystical guessing, divine inspiration, or inherited magic, comparing it to Darwin's, Wagner's, and Columbus's reasoning, and calls women the supreme realists of the race.
Chapter 5
What does the author claim about women and sentimentality?
The author argues women are not sentimental — not prone to let emotion and illusion corrupt their judgment of a situation. He anticipates protest, saying the belief that women are sentimental is itself a favourite sentimentality, and promises to support his contention with obvious facts despite romantic rubbish to the contrary.
Chapter 5
Section 64 cards
According to the author, why does the fact that marriages occur at all prove women are more cool-headed than men?
The author argues that men's interest is to avoid marriage as long as possible, while women's interest is to make a favourable marriage as soon as possible. Since the average man is duly married and the average woman gets a husband, the great majority of women prevail in this conflict, demonstrating their substantial superiority to the great majority of men.
Chapter 6
What two explanations does the author give for why a man marries?
The author argues a man marries either because he has been bowled over in a combat of wits (relative stupidity) or because he resigns himself to marriage as the safest form of liaison (relative cowardice). He says the two are almost identical in symptoms and effects, and that the man's inherent sentimentality is the chief weapon in his opponent's hand.
Chapter 6
According to the author, when do women acknowledge falling in love, and why?
The author argues women never acknowledge falling in love until the man has formally avowed the delusion and cut off his retreat; to do otherwise would bring mockery and contumely from other women. With them, falling in love appears as an afterthought or contagion, inspired by the man's avowed love. Only once he is committed may she unbend into forced sentiment.
Chapter 6
What does the author claim 'falling in love' means for a man?
The author argues it is a procedure whereby a man accounts for his marriage, after feminine initiative and generalship have made it inevitable, by enshrouding it in a purple maze of romance. He sets up the doctrine that a self-possessed woman engaged deliberately in her life's most important adventure is a naive, tender, moony creature enchanted by passion that stole upon her unawares.
Chapter 6
Section 74 cards
Why does Mencken say women distrust handsome men in courtship?
The author argues women view the handsome fellow with suspicion because his native male vanity becomes intolerable and forms an unnatural armour, making him resistant to ordinary approaches. Reflective women therefore direct matrimonial enterprises toward less pulchritudinous men, who are easier to bring down and hold down. Women of poise regard falling for an Apollo as flighty or bad taste, reserving such weakness for shop girls and senile widows.
Chapter 7
How does Mencken refute the claim that women are anesthetic to beauty?
The author calls the notion absurd, arguing women commonly have a keener aesthetic sense than men: beauty matters more to them, they think about it more, and they crave it in their surroundings. He contrasts this with the average English or American man's bovine pride in anaesthesia to the arts. Women resist beauty in men, he argues, because such beauty is chiefly imaginary, not because they cannot perceive it.
Chapter 7
What does Mencken claim women's uniforms revealed about female form?
The author argues that when women in belligerent countries adopted uniforms during the late war, their deficiency in design was revealed: below neck and waist two masses refuse to fit a balanced composition, suggesting a drunken dollar-mark. He says ordinary clothing conceals this with draperies of uncertain outline, but uniform is like stripping her, and her alleged beauty vanishes.
Chapter 7
Why does Mencken say men fail to distinguish real from artificial beauty?
The author argues men lack critical sense and emotional suggestibility overwhelms them: face powder, dyed hair, false hips, and pretty frocks satisfy them as readily as genuine features. He claims men estimate women by superficial aspects, never analyzing impressions, so many never really see their wives until years of marriage. Even aesthetically trained men, given the right woman and setting, are deceived like a yokel.
Chapter 7
Section 84 cards
According to Mencken, why do men defend their choice of a woman so fiercely?
The author argues that once a man has succumbed to a woman's charms, his vanity reinforces the delusion: he defends his choice as a point of honor. To call his wife or stenographer unbeautiful insults his taste so deeply that even an enemy avoids it—he would be less offended by being told his wife is an idiot.
Chapter 8
What does Mencken claim women value in men, in contrast to what men value in women?
The author argues that women commonly value not mere showiness, physical or spiritual, but the compound of small capacities making up masculine efficiency and passing for intelligence. This intelligence guarantees security, position, and livelihood, so women respect and seek it in husbands. Men, by contrast, idealize a pretty wife and often esteem coquetry and disdain for intelligence as charms.
Chapter 8
What biological evidence does Mencken cite against women having innate superior acumen?
The author claims experiments and vivisections show no anatomical or physiological advantage: women have smaller brains, no prompter nervous responses or muscular coordination, and the same blemishes, parasites, senses, and diseases as men. Hydrocyanic acid and wine affect a sagacious woman just as they affect any man, so he locates women's acumen in physical weakness, not constitution.
Chapter 8
Why does Mencken say feminine weakness increased under civilization, and what result followed?
The author argues women were already weaker at history's dawn, and civilization worsened it: childbirth became more exhausting and child-rearing more onerous as culture grew complex. This disability and need for protection inflamed male vanity, making men esteem women for dependence rather than self-sufficiency. The result, he says, is women's chief physical character today: fragility.
Chapter 8
Section 94 cards
According to the chapter, why did women develop intellectual dexterity?
The author argues that women's physical frailty led them to seek compensation in the intellectual field, using their resources to the utmost there. This constant maximum use enlarged those resources, and natural selection increased them further, so every woman inherits an extra-masculine mental dexterity as a function of her femaleness, plus admission to the traditional esoteric philosophy of woman as a whole.
Chapter 9
Why does the author say women have no sense of honour?
The author argues honour is predicated on a feeling of absolute security, and in the conflict between man and woman culminating in marriage, the woman's security is not in being but something she strives to attain. In such a struggle, he says, honour can have no place, just as an animal fighting for existence uses all means. He adds that men seldom display honour when something of first value is at hazard.
Chapter 9
What does the author mean by calling women 'dishonorable'?
The author argues that being dishonorable means being relatively uncivilized, and he considers this one of woman's chief charms. He says no genuine woman cares for law when it blocks her private interest; she is essentially an outlaw, a rebel, what H. G. Wells calls a nomad. He calls civilization a mere device for regimenting men, symbolized by the goose-step, and says its value is overestimated.
Chapter 9
Why does the author say women's emotional control shows they are less civilized?
The author argues that the capacity to control and conceal emotions is a characteristic of savages, not civilized men, and its loss is a penalty paid for civilization. He describes the true savage as reserved, dignified and courteous, while civilized man yields to feelings. He further argues civilization grows maudlin and hysterical, especially under democracy, and that modern wars are begun by panicking mobs rather than judged by superior men.
Chapter 9
Section 104 cards
What does Mencken claim about women's stance on war once it begins?
The author argues that women are nearly always against war in modern times because its justifications are usually dishonest or childishly sentimental. But once war begins, they commonly favor conducting it outrance, aligning with the theory of great captains. He claims no woman protested the blockade that killed German children, and that only men maintained the doctrine of non-combatant immunity.
Chapter 10
What does Mencken say causes the masculine belief that women are passionless?
The author argues the belief stems from women's talent for concealing emotion, aided by men's inexact observation. He says there is no reason to believe the normal woman is passionless. Men's vanity, especially in Northern countries, values the virginal type, so sexual selection makes that type more common—but it has not superseded the normal type described by medieval theologians.
Chapter 10
What does Mencken claim actually motivates women who denounce men?
The author argues the man-hating woman is largely imaginary. Women who spend time denouncing men are not genuine man-haters but women who tried to snare men and failed. He says most inflammatory suffragettes of the sex-hygiene and birth-control species fit this, and that birth-control advocacy comes from women facing no risk of unwilling motherhood.
Chapter 10
According to Mencken, what delights a man about a woman who has yielded to him?
The author argues a man chiefly delights in the sharp contrast between a woman's reserve before other men and her complaisance before himself. The greater the contrast, the greater his satisfaction—until suspicion arises. If she diminishes that contrast publicly, by smiling at an actor or holding the rector's hand, he begins looking for clandestine notes and doubting his children.
Chapter 10
Section 113 cards
What does Mencken claim is the common view of women and marriage, and what is the 'truth'?
The author notes the general acceptance of the notion that women are reluctant to marry and must be persuaded by eloquence, pertinacity, or intimidation. He argues the truth is the opposite: in a materialistic society, marriage offers the best career the average woman can reasonably aspire to, and for many the only actual livelihood. She exchanges sexual charm for a share of one man's earnings, converting her handicap into advantage.
Chapter 11
What does Mencken say is the most valuable benefit a woman gains from marriage?
The author argues economic security is the most valuable benefit, though it is usually relative rather than absolute: a husband may die underinsured, desert, become an invalid or insane, or cross the line into prison. Women may be deceived or guess wrong about a clerk's prospects. Still, he contends women marry realistically, weigh the economic situation, and seldom take avoidable chances, unlike men who may marry for looks alone.
Chapter 11
According to Mencken, how do women regard a woman who loses her virginity outside marriage?
The author argues women show little respect for virginity per se. They condemn the woman who loses hers outside marriage not because something intrinsically valuable is lost, but because she made a bad bargain that diminishes men's sentimental respect for virtue and thus harms the sex's general advantage. He calls this a guild resentment rather than a moral one, and claims women are not actively moral or noticeably modest.
Chapter 11
Section 124 cards
Why does the author say women are less expert than men in the workplace?
The author argues the disadvantage is partly congenital: women's intellectual enterprise makes it hard to become the efficient machines men are. Partly it is because marriage always looms, promising swift relief, so women feel no implacable pressure to master the sordid arts they revolt against. Time is short and incentive feeble before they marry and abandon business.
Chapter 12
When does a woman buckle down in earnest to her craft, per the chapter?
The author argues it is not until a woman has definitely put away the hope of marriage, or admitted she may have to do so soon or late, that she buckles down in earnest to her craft and makes a genuine effort to develop competence. He adds that no sane employer would pick a young marriageable woman for a post needing laborious training.
Chapter 12
What does Eliza Burt Gamble argue about female animals and male ornamentation?
The author quotes Gamble arguing that male birds' and fishes' beautiful coloring and appendages serve only to secure females' favors, and that the female made the male beautiful so that she might endure his caresses. She also claims males acquired no discriminating characters except from passion: pugnacity and perseverance. The author calls this the Don Juan idea in fresh bib and tucker.
Chapter 12
How does the author turn Gamble's argument against itself?
The author argues that if spectacular decoration is bait to overcome the other sex's reluctance, then today it is men who primp, parade, and wear vestments serving no useful purpose but securing favors. Carried to its last implication, her argument holds that women are all Donna Juanitas and that without their millinery and cosmetics men could not endure their caresses.
Chapter 12
Section 132 cards
According to the author, why do most women not marry their first choice?
The author argues that not one woman in a hundred marries her first choice among marriageable men, because that first choice is almost invariably beyond her talents for fortuitous or intrinsic reasons. He illustrates with a shop-girl whose ideals—fictional heroes, film actors, a clergyman, a partner, managers—are successively out of reach or taken by more attractive women, until, fearing spinsterhood, she marries the ultimate numskull.
Chapter 13
How does the author explain American chivalry versus French boldness in courtship?
The author argues that under Protestant Christianity the initiative lies with the woman, who raises her amorous eye as high as it will roll; in America, few class barriers mean every presentable man is measured for his wedding coat. On the Continent, especially Latin countries, class barriers make a woman's overture an invitation to disaster, so third parties or the man must act—making Frenchmen enterprising and offensive, and Americans chivalrous. The author calls American chivalry really a sort of coquetry.
Chapter 13
Section 144 cards
Why does Mencken say wives hold their husbands in contempt?
The author argues women feel a natural intellectual superiority over men, and marriage adds a concrete comparison plus resentment that such a comparison was needed. The typical husband, he says, is a second-rater loved by only one woman and only as a second or nth choice; the bachelor remains the unattainable, hence admirable, first choice.
Chapter 14
How does Mencken explain the supposed superiority of bachelors?
The author argues a bachelor's ability to avoid marriage proves his freedom from ordinary male sentimentalism, bringing him closer to women's clear-headedness. He cites Herbert Spencer, harassed by women including George Eliot until he made clear he would resist marriage, after which his last decades were peaceful and productive.
Chapter 14
What does Mencken claim about heredity and the celibacy of great men?
The author argues intellectual superiority is inheritable as easily as bodily strength, citing Galton, Pearson and other English anthropometricians. He contends that celibacy of men like Spinoza, Kant, Schopenhauer, Spencer and Nietzsche deprives the race of superior offspring, and that English and German philosophy declined after their deaths for lack of sons.
Chapter 14
What is the dot, and what does Mencken say it accomplishes?
The dot is a money payment or dowry, borrowed by Christians from the Jews, designed as a bribe to overcome men's disinclination to marry. The author argues it gives women a wider choice of husbands, may bring a superior man within reach, and among practical peoples like the Jews and French promotes intellectual suppleness in the race.
Chapter 14
Section 154 cards
What alternative marriage scheme does Mencken propose as a hypothesis?
The author proposes prohibiting sentimental marriages by law and substituting matchmaking by the common hangman. He presents it not as practical politics but as a hypothesis to clarify the problem. He argues it would purge marriage of romantic fol-de-rol and counter the process that selects fit men out of marriage, throwing the burden of paternity on inferior men.
Chapter 15
Why does Mencken say women would oppose the hangman scheme?
The author argues women would oppose substituting chance or arbitrary fiat for the existing struggle because every woman is convinced, and no doubt rightly, that her own judgment is superior to that of either the common hangman or the gods, and that her own enterprise is more favorable to her opportunities.
Chapter 15
Why does Mencken say men would oppose the hangman scheme?
The author argues men would oppose it because it would restrict their liberty, though he says this liberty is largely imaginary—at bottom only the privilege of being bamboozled by the first woman who essays the business. Still, men cherish the notion that unconditioned volition and a touch of the daring and devilish enter into marriage.
Chapter 15
How does Mencken say first-class men can transmit qualities without marriage?
The author says it is a rhetorical exaggeration that all first-class men escape marriage or that their qualities go wholly untransmitted. He notes the biological fact that offspring can be achieved without Church and State approval—not the irregularity that stigmatizes children as illegitimate, but a refined form that safeguards social dignity while protecting them from inheritance from their legal fathers.
Chapter 15
Section 164 cards
According to the chapter, why do civilized men favor monogamy?
The author argues monogamy is not favored for ethical motives, which he calls deductions from experience abandoned when experience turns against them. Rather, experience is overwhelming on its side: civilized men favor it because it works. It works because it is the most effective antidote to the alarms and terrors of passion—monogamy kills passion, the most dangerous surviving enemy to civilization, which is based on order, decorum, restraint, and regimentation.
Chapter 16
What does the author propose for handling a young man of twenty's passion?
He argues the present plan of scare-crows and prohibitions is supererogation and imbecility, since the young man already knows passion is dangerous and passion cannot be killed by arguing against it. Instead, passion should be given rein under unfavourable, dispiriting conditions to reduce it to an absurdity. He suggests forbidding polygamy before marriage but permitting monogamy—easier to enforce, satisfying curiosity, and producing a disillusioned, passion-free ideal citizen.
Chapter 16
What does the author claim about when first-rate men marry, and why?
The author argues first-rate men usually marry relatively late, postponing it longer than average men; early marriage suggests intolerable external pressure (as with Shakespeare) or mental sensitiveness near insanity (as with Shelley). He attributes this to declining mental agility with age, while profundity may improve. Since agility matters most in the duel of sex, the aging man faces progressively younger women, whose youth can tip over his tottering defences.
Chapter 16
How does the author criticize Havelock Ellis's inference about genius and old fathers?
Ellis observed that most men of unusual capacities are sons of relatively old fathers but ascribed it to a mysterious quality in a declining man begetting better offspring. The author calls this a palpable absurdity, counter to facts established by animal breeders, and notes it tacitly assumes talent is an acquired character that can be transmitted. He argues talent is congenital, present in early life, citing James Mill, young when John Stuart Mill was born.
Chapter 16
Section 174 cards
According to Mencken, why do superior men tend to marry late?
The author argues that as a man ages, marriage's disabilities diminish and its advantages grow: at thirty he fears monogamy's inhibitions, but at sixty he is beyond amorous adventure and needs ease and security. Facing physical decay, he chooses between a wife and a nurse, usually picking the wife as less expensive and exacting. Mencken says men's aversion to marriage rests on social and economic self-sufficiency and fades when that sufficiency disappears.
Chapter 17
Why does Mencken claim first-rate men often marry inferior wives?
The author argues that first-rate men postpone marriage until their faculties are crippled by senility, leaving them open to women with meretricious attractions, such as empty flappers, scheming widows, and trained nurses skilled in professional sympathy. Women of genuine merit are no longer interested in him. Mencken adds that such unions help explain the low calibre of many first-rate men's sons, since mediocrity is dominant and extraordinary ability recessive.
Chapter 17
How does Mencken explain women of merit marrying second-rate men?
The author argues the first-rate woman is a realist: in a world dominated by second-rate men, she marries a second-rate man at the top of his class to share the rewards society gives such men. He also cites the charm of the unlike, or heliogabalisme, and a maternal, pitying superiority, since there can be no mystery between intellectual equals. Such husbands, he notes, are inferior but rarely paupers or bad providers.
Chapter 17
What does Mencken say monogamous marriage does to the mystery of love?
The author argues that monogamous marriage forces too persistent and unmitigated an intimacy, with contact at too many points and too steadily, until all mystery is gone and the pair stand in an unsexed, brother-and-sister position. He says Shaw's 'maximum of temptation' contains the seeds of its own decay: a husband moves from kissing his wife to scheming to avoid it, a proceeding as romantic as having his boots blacked.
Chapter 17
Section 181 cards
What does Mrs. Cox propose to keep marriage from becoming dull?
Mrs. Cox proposes interrupting marriage's course by separating the parties now and then, so neither becomes too familiar. She argues curiosity will revive, each personality can expand alone, and reunions will carry the surprise and adventure of the honeymoon. The author says the scheme has merit and has been tried with success, but notes two obstacles: its costliness and the scandal it provokes.
Chapter 18
Section 203 cards
According to the author, how did women secure the suffrage extension?
The author argues that women won the suffrage not by an attack en masse but by a mere foray, and that the majority of women were not eager for it and regard it as of small value. He claims they can get what they want without voting and are out of sympathy with the professional suffragists' reforms.
Chapter 20
What does the author predict enfranchised women will do to democracy?
The author argues that once women are at ease with the ballot and rid of the suffragist leaders, they will attack the sentimentalities corrupting politics and initiate measures against democracy, which he calls the worst evil of the present-day world. He predicts they will restrict suffrage to a small intelligent minority rather than extend it.
Chapter 20
What evidence does the author give that women resist new fallacies longer than men?
The author argues women take twice as long as men to convert to a new fallacy and even then hesitate with criticism. He cites Colorado women voting 21 years before prohibition passed via male voters, with their own majority against it, and California women rejecting prohibition in 1914 after enfranchisement in 1911.
Chapter 20
Section 214 cards
What does Mencken predict will happen to the ex-suffragettes' political influence?
The author argues that the ex-suffragettes' current prominence is due only to male politicians mistakenly treating them as spokeswomen for all women. Sooner or later, he predicts, the mass of sensible women will turn on and depose them, reducing them to a tolerated minority sect like Swedenborgians or Christian Scientists. He says this pattern already occurred in American states that extended suffrage before the national amendment.
Chapter 21
Why does Mencken think women voters will resist political fear-mongering?
The author argues that women are harder to fool than men because their 'shell of logic' resists emotional penetration. He claims male voters are cowards and asses who repeatedly elect mountebanks to combat imaginary perils, while women are not easily set off by such alarms. He cites patent-medicine testimony, noting twenty male witnesses for every female one, and says even Lydia Pinkham's Compound is mostly bought by men.
Chapter 21
What does Mencken claim motivates reform-minded suffragists' sexual reform advocacy?
The author argues that nine-tenths of reform-monging suffragists advocate measures like the single standard, medical certificates for bridegrooms, and birth control, and that their motive is 'mere rage and jealousy.' He claims the woman who is not pursued declares pursuit offensive to her sex and wants to make it a felony, while genuinely attractive women enjoy masculine admiration and are cynical about harassment complaints.
Chapter 21
What does Mencken believe is the real remedy for the 'gaudy crimes' suffragist alarmists describe?
The author argues that men pursue women and women lure them on, and that if women stopped luring, the game of love would end because most men take no notice of women spontaneously. He claims nine in ten men would be happy without women once accustomed to quiet. His satirical 'remedy' is to shave pretty girls' heads, pluck their eyebrows, pull their teeth, dress them in khaki, and forbid wriggling, scents, and lip-sticks—concluding reform mistakes the fish for the fly.
Chapter 21
Section 223 cards
What did Mencken claim about US presidents chosen by male voters before suffrage extension?
The author argues that male voters typically chose presidents not for competence but for a talent for idiocy, reflecting a male weakness for what is rhetorical, sentimental, feeble, and untrue. He names Wilson, Taft, Roosevelt, and Harding as examples of such 'phrase-merchants' and 'platitudinarians,' and asks readers to compare their ideas with those of an average midwife.
Chapter 22
What does Mencken say the suffragette fundamentally is?
The author argues the suffragette is a woman who has stupidly carried her envy of certain superficial male privileges to the point of obsession, blinding her to their valueless and often imaginary character. He claims she centers this frenzy on the alleged privilege of promiscuity in amour, denouncing the double standard of morality in hysterical terms.
Chapter 22
Why does Mencken say the average man is pure in act despite temptation?
The author argues the average man lacks the courage, lacks the money, and is fundamentally moral with a conscience. He claims it takes more sinful initiative, ingenuity, intrepidity, and concealable money than most men possess to carry off an affair. He adds that a wife who knows her husband's income accurately has a sure means of holding him to his oaths.
Chapter 22
Section 234 cards
What three factors does Mencken give for the delusion that the average man is highly amorous?
The author argues the delusion arises from three factors: the idiotic vanity of men, who boast through open lying or sinister hints; the notions of vice crusaders, nonconformist divines, and Y.M.C.A. secretaries about what they would do if they had courage; and the same notions held by certain suffragettes. Together these create a generalization that causes women needless uneasiness and inflates men's conceit.
Chapter 23
According to Mencken, what do most men in public haunts of sin actually do?
The author argues most men in public haunts of sin are not there for overt ribaldry but to tremble agreeably on the edge of the abyss. They resemble fairgoers at smutty shows and readers of sex magazines, conjuring carnality while lacking courage. For one clerk who succumbs, five hundred yield to lack of means, sex-hygienist warnings, and their own consciences.
Chapter 23
What does Mencken call the 'secret scandal of Christendom' regarding married men?
The author argues the secret scandal of Christendom, at least in Protestant regions, is that most men are faithful to their wives. He notes you would travel far to find a married man who admits it, but insists the facts are the facts. This claim supports his broader argument that male promiscuity is largely a delusion.
Chapter 23
How does Mencken explain the vice crusader's mistaken reasoning about other men?
The author argues the vice crusader reasons fallaciously from his own secret aspirations, assuming unconsecrated men share his longing to debauch but lack his other weaknesses, such as timidity, lack of resourcefulness, and conscience. Mencken says they do share these weaknesses, so the crusader's picture of widespread sin is mistaken.
Chapter 23
Section 243 cards
How does the author explain women's apparent tolerance of physical pain?
The author argues women actually have less endurance than men; massive injuries shock them more and kill them faster. But with acute pain unaccompanied by profounder phenomena, they bear it with greater show of resignation. A man sees pain as an invasion of his liberty and self-esteem, while a woman senses the dramatic effect her suffering makes on sympathetic spectators.
Chapter 24
What does the author say about women's complaints about their husbands?
The author argues women take unhealthy pleasure in suffering and like to picture themselves as slaughtered saints. A woman with a husband not open to question will invent mythical offences to make him bearable, and if invention fails she is miserable. Among women, the most esteemed gossip has the longest repertoire of complaints; a placidly contented wife is looked on as a numskull.
Chapter 24
How does the author link civilization, repression, and women's mental symptoms?
The author argues that being a woman under Christian civilization means a life heavy with repression and dissimulation, which produces effects indistinguishable from disease. He cites Adler and Poul Bjerre arguing womanliness under Christianity is itself a disease. Suppressed revolt against man-made inhibitions yields symptoms ranging from the suffragette to the neurotic woman with bogus martyrdom.
Chapter 24
Section 251 cards
What does Mencken identify as the two hardest things women must bear?
The author argues women face (a) masculine disinclination to admit their intellectual superiority, equality, or even normal human equipment for thought, and (b) the doctrine that women are a special ineffable species of vertebrate lacking natural instincts and appetites—transcendental, almost gaseous mammals without salient mammalian characters. He calls both positions stupid and imbecilic.
Chapter 25
Section 264 cards
Why does the author say women are reluctant to enter the clergy?
The author argues women's cynical view of religious emotionalism and "ecclesiastical balderdash" makes them reluctant to become clergy. He claims women are too intelligent to be effective ecclesiastics, since their sense of reality opposes the "sacerdotal masquerade" and their humor resists pulpit oratory. He notes women neither protest exclusion from the pulpit nor eagerly enter sects that admit them.
Chapter 26
What motives does the author claim actually drive women into religious life?
The author argues women entering religious life are almost never moved by mere pious inflammation. In Catholic countries, he says, girls are driven into convents by economic considerations or disasters of amour more often than hope of heaven, and many female saints tried marriage first. In Protestant lands, secular impulses are almost always visible—such as a girl wanting to marry a heroic missionary, which she duly does.
Chapter 26
What does the author say is the real purpose of church societies and sewing circles?
The author argues the average missionary society or church sewing circle is not primarily religious. Its actual purpose, he says, resembles that of clubs and secret orders for less resourceful men: refreshment, self-expression, personal display, political manipulation, boasting, and discreet intrigue if the pastor is interesting. He claims never to have met a woman who cared authentically for the actual heathen.
Chapter 26
Why does the author say women are drawn to Catholicism over evangelical Protestantism?
The author argues religion offers most people their only bait of beauty—music, dim lights, architecture, eloquence, mystery—and that women are more responsive to beauty than men, whom he calls aesthetically insensitive. He says men invented sects like the Mennonites, Dunkards, Wesleyans and Scotch Presbyterians with their antipathy to ritual, so the normal woman moves toward Catholicism and evangelical sects struggle to hold her.
Chapter 26
Section 274 cards
According to the author, why do women litigants almost always win their cases?
The author argues women litigants almost always win not because jurymen fall in love with them, as is commonly assumed, but because they are clear-headed, resourceful, implacable and without qualms. He claims it is an axiom of the bar that women invariably lie on the stand, and that a barrister's whole effort goes to keeping a female client within bounds so the male jury's suspicions are not aroused.
Chapter 27
What does the author say women's gentleness depends on?
The author argues women's gentleness, like the so-called honour of men, is visible only in situations that offer them no menace. Once a woman faces an antagonist genuinely dangerous to her own security or to those under her protection, such as a child or husband, she displays a bellicosity that stops at nothing, however outrageous. He contrasts this with rare male extremists who tell the truth even against their cause.
Chapter 27
What advantage does the author say women hold in business and in the duel of sex?
The author argues women's advantage in both arenas lies in their freedom from sentimentality. In business they address themselves wholly to their own profit and give no thought to the hopes and amour propre of antagonists. In the duel of sex they fence not to make points but to disable and disarm. He claims a man feels maudlin sympathy for a woman he has thrown off, but women take delight in such agonies and boast of them.
Chapter 27
What change does the author say the industrial system brought to women's economic dependence?
The author argues the rise of the industrial system, though harsh on the race generally, brought women unmistakable benefits. Their economic dependence, while still strong enough to make marriage attractive, is so far broken down that large classes of women are almost free agents, independent of men's favour. They needn't marry if they don't want to, since they can earn their bread by their own labour, unlike grandmothers who faced ignominy and possible starvation.
Chapter 27
Section 284 cards
According to the chapter, why is the marriage rate falling?
The chapter states that the declining marriage rate and even more rapidly declining birth rates show women's growing economic security changing their habits of life and mind. The author argues that male statisticians wrongly ascribe the fall to growing male disinclination; in fact the disinclination is on the female side, as women approach marriage with greater fastidiousness and are harder to please.
Chapter 28
What does the author claim about the effect of losing chastity on a woman's marriage prospects?
The author argues that the common theory—that loss of virginity impairs marriage chances—is unsupported by facts. He contends that, all else equal, a woman who sacrifices chastity stands a better chance of a creditable marriage, especially among lower economic classes, because she gains contact with higher-class men and acquires their refinements; such marriages are more numerous than they appear.
Chapter 28
Why does the author say prostitution may become respectable?
The author argues prostitution may become more respectable, as it was in ancient Greece, if it ever becomes quite unnecessary—since whatever is unnecessary is always respectable, like religion or fashionable clothing. He claims the prostitute is disesteemed only because she is assumed to have been driven into the trade by dire necessity, and that she commonly likes her work and is free to leave it.
Chapter 28
How does the chapter characterize women who are economically independent but not averse to marriage?
The chapter describes a growing class of women who, while not genuinely averse to marriage, reject the theory that it is necessary or invariably desirable. Some are vociferous propagandists; many more quietly carry out their ideas. With economic independence assured by inheritance or their own efforts, chiefly in arts and professions, they do as they please, and their superiority to convention makes them attractive to the better sort of men.
Chapter 28
Section 294 cards
According to Mencken, how did the average prostitute in his city end her career?
Mencken reports that a local inquiry found the average prostitute ended her career "not in the morgue but at the altar of God." About eighty per cent married, often to husbands beyond their reach had they stayed virtuous, and the unmarried sometimes practiced ten to twenty years before retiring on competences. He offers this as evidence against the common superstition of a five-year career ending in the gutter.
Chapter 29
Why does Mencken say educated women misjudge prostitutes' feelings about their clients?
The author argues the educated woman imagines shrinking from gross clients and assumes the prostitute suffers acutely. He counters that such men, however repulsive to her, are measurably superior to men of the prostitute's own class, like her father and brothers, so contact with them can seem romantic rather than disgusting. He cites a woman delighted to attract a police lieutenant.
Chapter 29
Why does Mencken think marriage will not be abolished?
The author argues that for women to compete equally with men in the labour market they would need a practical, mechanical expertness that requires sacrificing intelligence — he calls it spiritual suicide. Since they likely will not go that far, a shade of their superiority and relative inefficiency remains, keeping marriage attractive to most and preventing its overthrow.
Chapter 29
What does Mencken identify as a symptom of women's unsettled transition between old and new life schemes?
The author argues women vacillate between economic independence, still full of conditions, and revolt against old conventions, producing unrest and extravagant revolt. One symptom he names is intellectual striving aimed not at genuine mental riches but at men's rubber stamps — party politics, social reform, and women's-club wisdom he calls ignorant and untrue, most visible in the leisured United States.
Chapter 29
Section 304 cards
Why does Mencken say women lack skill at housekeeping?
The author argues a woman's disinclination to acquire the expertness behind good housekeeping stems from her active intelligence, since concentrating on stupid, meticulous enterprises is difficult for her. He adds that women generally lack conscientiousness and the dog-like fidelity to duty he calls a shining mark of men, so they work under protest.
Chapter 30
How does sentimentality let women avoid culinary criticism, per the author?
The author argues men's sentimentality is largely responsible: once a woman catches a man she need not master cooking, since he must eat whatever she sets before him. His lack of intelligence lets her shut off criticism by appealing to his emotions, and he finally attaches positive value to her indolence, reading it as fineness of soul.
Chapter 30
What does the author predict economic autonomy and suffrage will bring women?
The author argues that as women gain economic autonomy and compete with men, husbands will demand a fair quid pro quo and scrutinize their doings more soberly. He predicts the suffrage will plant dragons' teeth that gnaw the women themselves, since men will stop coddling them as romantic invalids and treat them as free competitors in a harsh world.
Chapter 30
What does the author foresee after a predicted shortage of husbands?
The author predicts wars will cause a shortage of husbands, making survivors harder to snare, with superior men pursued by battalions of women and driven into sharp bargaining. He suggests the state may interfere to encourage monogamy, perhaps by improving the monogamous husband's position, and proposes laws letting women resign dower, maintenance and immunity from discipline to make their own terms.
Chapter 30
Section 314 cards
According to the author, what is the real trouble with marriages that include a third party?
The author argues the trouble is not the perjury or any fundamental offence to the wife; such arrangements often increase the husband's devotion through comparison. Rather, the trouble is that very few men can manage them intelligently. The average Protestant married man, if he succumbs, chooses a meretricious, flamboyant woman bent on fleecing him, unlike the Frenchman who consults his wife.
Chapter 31
How does the author contrast French and Teutonic men in handling extramarital affairs?
The author argues the Frenchman's harsh realism beats Teutonic sentimentality: a Frenchman would no more take a mistress without consulting his wife than stand for office without consulting her, so he is seldom victimized. For one Frenchman ruined by women there are at least a hundred Englishmen and Americans, though a hundred times as many Frenchmen engage in such recreation. Zola's supervised amours are cited as typical.
Chapter 31
Why does the author say women will always remain provocative to men?
The author argues women may emancipate themselves, borrow masculine tricks, and lose their desire for the vegetable security of marriage, but they will never cease to be women and so remain provocative. Their chief charm lies in being dangerous—threatening masculine liberty and autonomy—and men fear them yet are fascinated. He cites Nietzsche calling them the recreation of the warrior, not the poltroon.
Chapter 31
What is the author's own notion of perfect peace and contentment?
The author rejects passion as too exciting and alarming for so indolent a man, and is too egoistic to want mothering. Instead he imagines a winter afternoon after a busy day: cocktails, a fire, a divan, and beside him a good-looking, well-dressed woman with a soft low voice who talks of books, music, men, and other women—no politics, business, religion, or metaphysics—as he drifts in and out of sleep.
Chapter 31
Source and licence
Text used: Project Gutenberg eBook #1270 (Public domain in the United States). Generated from the full text; cards paraphrase the source.
Version: Public domain edition. Retrieved 2026-11-19. Cards reviewed 2026-11-19.
These cards paraphrase the text for study. They are not a substitute for reading the book, and they do not reproduce long passages.
Turn your own notes into cards
Upload a PDF, Word, or text file and get question-and-answer cards for closed-notes practice. Five cards are free, no signup.