Book Cards

The Advancement of Learning Flashcards

Francis Bacon argues that learning should be directed to the benefit of mankind rather than to ornament or private gain. This deck covers his 1605 treatise to King James, including his criticisms of past philosophy, the three discredits of learning, and his proposed division of the work.

1 / 251

Chapter 1 · Question

Why did young Bacon dislike Aristotle's philosophy, according to Dr. Rawley?

WakeCards · wakecards.com · Big ideas. Quick review.

Arrow keys move between cards. Space or Enter flips.

All questions and answers

Every card in the deck, in reading order. Click a chapter to expand. The reviewer above uses the same content.

Section 14 cards
  1. Why did young Bacon dislike Aristotle's philosophy, according to Dr. Rawley?

    Rawley reports that at about sixteen Bacon first fell into dislike of Aristotle's philosophy, not for the author's worthlessness—he ascribed all high attributes to Aristotle—but for the unfruitfulness of the way, calling it strong only for disputatious and contentions, and barren of works for the benefit of human life. The author of the introduction notes Bacon held this mind to his dying day.

    Chapter 1

  2. What was the original 1605 title-page of this book?

    The original title-page read: 'THE TVVOO Bookes of Francis Bacon. Of the proficience and aduancement of Learning, divine and humane. To the King. At London. Printed for Henrie Tomes, and are to be sould at his shop at Graies Inne Gate in Holborne. 1605.' The introduction describes it as the book in which Bacon prepared the way for his New Organon.

    Chapter 1

  3. What did Bacon write at about twenty-one, and what did he call it?

    About the time he was admitted to the outer bar in June 1582, at age twenty-one, Bacon wrote a sketch of his conception of a New Organon that should lead man to more fruitful knowledge, in a little Latin tract he called 'Temporis Partus Maximus' ('The Greatest Birth of Time'). The introduction presents this as an early seed of his later philosophical program.

    Chapter 1

  4. How did Bacon's early parliamentary career and Essex patronage unfold before 1605?

    Bacon entered the Commons in 1584 for Melcombe Regis, later sat for Taunton, Liverpool, Middlesex, and Ipswich, and attached himself to the Earl of Essex. Essex sought the Attorney-Generalship for him, but the Queen gave it to Sir Edward Coke and the Solicitor-Generalship to Serjeant Fleming; Essex consoled Bacon with Twickenham Park, which Bacon later sold for £1,800.

    Chapter 1

Section 24 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what is the true end of knowledge, as opposed to its common misuses?

    Bacon says the discredits of learning arise from mistaking or misplacing the furthest end of knowledge. Some seek it as a couch for a restless spirit, a terrace for a wandering mind, a tower for a proud mind, a fort for contention, or a shop for profit. The true end, he argues, is a rich storehouse for the glory of the Creator and the relief of man's estate.

    Chapter 2

  2. How does Bacon describe the Second Book on the Advancement of Learning?

    Bacon describes the Second Book as a general and faithful perambulation of learning, inquiring which parts lie fresh and waste, not improved and converted by man's industry. The purpose is that such a plot, made and recorded to memory, may minister light to any public designation and excite voluntary endeavours. It functions as an intellectual map or ground-plan of all subjects of study.

    Chapter 2

  3. What does Bacon claim about King James's learning compared with past monarchs?

    Bacon asserts that since Christ's time no king or temporal monarch has been so learned in all literature and erudition, divine and human. He invites comparison with Roman emperors, including Caesar the Dictator and Marcus Antoninus, and with the lines of France, Spain, England, and Scotland. He calls a king who truly drinks of the fountains of learning almost a miracle.

    Chapter 2

  4. What triplicity does Bacon ascribe to King James, following the ancient Hermes?

    Bacon says there is met in the King a rare conjunction of divine and sacred literature with profane and human, so that he stands invested with the triplicity venerated in the ancient Hermes: the power and fortune of a king, the knowledge and illumination of a priest, and the learning and universality of a philosopher. Bacon says this deserves a solid, immortal monument.

    Chapter 2

Section 33 cards
  1. What three sources does Bacon say the discredits of learning arise from?

    Bacon says the disgraces of learning come from ignorance disguised in three ways: the zeal and jealousy of divines, the severity and arrogancy of politics, and the errors and imperfections of learned men themselves. He frames this as clearing the way so the true testimonies of learning's dignity can be heard without the interruption of tacit objections.

    Chapter 3

  2. What does Bacon say experience shows about learned men and learned times?

    Bacon reports the claim that experience demonstrates learned men have been arch-heretics, learned times have been inclined to atheism, and the contemplation of second causes derogates from dependence upon God, the first cause. He lists these as objections raised by divines, to be cleared away before the dignity of learning can be heard.

    Chapter 3

  3. What two-part structure does Bacon propose for his treatise to the King?

    Bacon says the treatise has two parts: the first concerns the excellency of learning and knowledge, plus the merit and true glory of augmenting and propagating it; the second sets out the particular acts and works undertaken for the advancement of learning, and the defects and undervalues he finds in them. He aims to excite the King's own cogitations rather than propound framed particulars.

    Chapter 3

Section 42 cards
  1. What is the 'true corrective' that keeps knowledge from swelling, and what verse supports it?

    The corrective is charity. Bacon cites the Apostle: "Knowledge bloweth up, but charity buildeth up," and also the passage about speaking with tongues of men and angels without charity being as a tinkling cymbal. Knowledge severed from charity and not referred to the good of mankind has a sounding rather than substantial virtue.

    Chapter 4

  2. What three limitations does Bacon say bound human knowledge?

    First, that we not place our felicity in knowledge so as to forget our mortality. Second, that we apply knowledge to give ourselves repose and contentment, not distaste or repining. Third, that we not presume by contemplating Nature to attain the mysteries of God. These bounds still allow knowledge to comprehend universal nature.

    Chapter 4

Section 54 cards
  1. What political charges against learning does Bacon list before rebutting them?

    Bacon lists charges that learning softens minds and unfits men for arms; makes them too curious and irresolute from varied reading, or too peremptory from strict axioms, or overweening from great examples; diverts them from action to leisure; and relaxes discipline, since men become readier to argue than to obey and execute.

    Chapter 5

  2. Which examples does Bacon cite of men excelling in both learning and arms?

    Bacon cites Alexander the Great, Aristotle's student in philosophy, and Julius Caesar, Cicero's rival in eloquence. For scholars who became great generals he names Epaminondas the Theban, first to abate Sparta's power, and Xenophon the Athenian, first to make way for overthrowing Persia's monarchy. He argues this concurrence appears even more in ages than in persons.

    Chapter 5

  3. How does Bacon answer the claim that learning unfits men for government?

    Bacon compares empiric statesmen to empiric physicians and lawyers who know only practice, not causes or books, and are surprised by unfamiliar cases. He says it is almost without instance that any government was disastrous in the hands of learned governors, and cites minority governments under Seneca, Misitheus, and others as flourishing.

    Chapter 5

  4. What does Bacon say about learned popes versus men bred in affairs of state?

    Bacon argues popes like Pius Quintus and Sextus Quintus, once dismissed as pedantical friars, did greater things and proceeded on truer principles of state than those bred in courts. He concedes learned men may lack ragioni di stato, present convenience, but says they are perfect in plain grounds of religion, justice, honour, and moral virtue.

    Chapter 5

Section 64 cards
  1. How does Bacon answer the charge that learning makes men irresolute?

    The author argues learning supplies stronger remedies than the infirmities it supposedly causes: if it makes men perplexed, it also teaches them when and on what grounds to resolve, and how to hold things in suspense without prejudice. He adds that examples, such as Guicciardini's account of Clement VII's errors, more forcibly convey these medicines into men's minds.

    Chapter 6

  2. Why does Bacon say learned men are the most indefatigable in business?

    The author argues that other men love business for profit, honour, reputation, or pride, so their industry exists in the eyes of others or for their own designs. Only learned men love business as an action according to nature, agreeable to mental health as exercise is to bodily health, taking pleasure in the action itself rather than the purchase.

    Chapter 6

  3. How does Bacon rebut the claim that learning undermines reverence for laws?

    He calls it a depravation and calumny without shadow of truth. To prefer blind custom of obedience over duty taught and understood, he says, is to claim a blind man treads surer by a guide than a seeing man by a light. The author argues learning makes minds gentle, generous, manageable, and pliant to government, while ignorance makes them churlish and mutinous; barbarous, unlearned times have been most subject to tumults.

    Chapter 6

  4. How does Bacon explain Cato the Censor's later desire to learn Greek?

    The author argues Cato was punished in the same kind wherein he offended: past threescore years old, he was seized with an extreme desire to go to school again and learn Greek to peruse Greek authors. This, Bacon says, shows Cato's earlier censure of Grecian learning was affected gravity rather than his inward opinion.

    Chapter 6

Section 74 cards
  1. According to Bacon, from what three sources does the discredit of learning by learned men arise?

    Bacon says the discredit that grows to learning from learned men themselves comes either from their fortune, from their manners, or from the nature of their studies. He notes the first is not in their power and the second is accidental, so only the third is proper to be handled; yet because he deals with popular estimation rather than true measure, he speaks somewhat of the two former as well.

    Chapter 7

  2. How does Bacon answer the charge that teaching youth is a mean employment?

    Bacon argues the charge is unjust if judged by reason rather than popular opinion. Men are more careful what they put into a new vessel than a seasoned one, and what mould they lay about a young plant than an established one, so the weakest times of things need the best helps. He adds that the Hebrew rabbins held youth the worthier age, since visions are nearer apparitions of God than dreams.

    Chapter 7

  3. What single fault does Bacon allow may be inherent in learned men as learned?

    Bacon says he can find no disgrace to learning from the manners of learned men inherent to them as learned, except one fault: because the times they read of are commonly better than the times they live in, and the duties taught better than those practised, they sometimes contend too far to bring things to perfection and reduce corruption of manners to honesty of precepts or examples of too great height. He cites Demosthenes, Cicero, Cato II., and Seneca.

    Chapter 7

  4. What caveats does Bacon cite against reformers who press perfection too far?

    Bacon cites Solon, who when asked whether he gave his citizens the best laws answered, 'Yea, of such as they would receive'; and Plato, who refused office, saying a man's country should be used as his parents are, with humble persuasions, not contestations. Cicero notes Cato II. 'speaks as in Plato's republic, not in the dregs of Romulus,' and excuses philosophers for setting the mark slightly beyond nature's wish.

    Chapter 7

Section 84 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what effect does learning have on men's sense of duty to country or masters?

    Bacon argues learning gives men a true sense of the frailty of their persons, the casualty of their fortunes, and the dignity of their soul and vocation. This makes it impossible for them to see their own greatness as a worthy end, so they desire to give account to God and their masters with the words "Ecce tibi lucrefeci" rather than "Ecce mihi lucrefeci."

    Chapter 8

  2. What two causes does Bacon give for learned men failing to apply themselves to particular persons?

    First, the largeness of their mind can hardly confine itself to exact observation of one person's nature and customs. Second, and more important, it is a rejection upon choice and judgment: the honest bounds of observing another extend only to understanding him enough to avoid offense, give faithful counsel, or guard oneself—not to speculating in order to work, wind, or govern him.

    Chapter 8

  3. How does Bacon defend learned men who err in small points of behavior?

    Bacon says judging them in greater matters by small failings deceives men. He cites Themistocles, who said he could not fiddle but could make a small town a great state—arrogant applied to himself, but just applied to the question. He also cites Plato comparing Socrates to apothecary gallipots: apes and owls outside, precious liquors within.

    Chapter 8

  4. Which behaviors of professed learned men does Bacon refuse to excuse?

    Bacon will not allow base courses: trencher philosophers in great men's houses, little better than solemn parasites, like Lucian's philosopher made to carry a lady's dog; gross flattery that turns Hecuba into Helena and Faustina into Lucretia, most diminishing the price of learning; and modern dedication of books to patrons, since worthy books should have no patrons but truth and reason.

    Chapter 8

Section 94 cards
  1. What three 'distempers' or vanities of learning does Bacon identify?

    Bacon names three vanities in studies: fantastical learning (vain imaginations), contentious learning (vain altercations), and delicate learning (vain affectations). He defines things as vain when they are either false or frivolous, having no truth or no use, and persons as vain when credulous or curious. He begins his treatment with the last, delicate learning.

    Chapter 9

  2. What four causes does Bacon say brought in the excessive study of eloquence?

    Bacon lists four concurring causes: admiration of ancient authors (awakened by Luther's appeal to antiquity), hate of the schoolmen with their coined terms, exact study of original languages, and the efficacy of preaching needed to win the common people. Together these produced an affectionate study of eloquence and copy of speech, which grew speedily to excess.

    Chapter 9

  3. What is Bacon's first distemper of learning, and what emblem illustrates it?

    The first distemper is when men study words and not matter. Bacon says this discredits learning even with vulgar capacities, since such works resemble the large flourish of an initial letter that is still only a letter. He offers Pygmalion's frenzy as the emblem: words are but images of matter, so to fall in love with them without the life of reason and invention is to fall in love with a picture.

    Chapter 9

  4. How does Bacon defend learned men's 'morigeration' or stooping to men in fortune?

    Bacon does not condemn it. He cites Diogenes' answer that philosophers follow rich men because they know what they need, Aristippus' quip that Dionysius had his ears in his feet, and the man who yielded to Hadrian commanding thirty legions. Such applications may have outward baseness, but rightly judged they are submissions to the occasion, not to the person.

    Chapter 9

Section 104 cards
  1. What does Bacon say is the drawback of adorning philosophy with eloquent style?

    The author argues that plausible elocution is a hindrance to deep inquiry into truth because it is "too early satisfactory to the mind of man," quenching the desire for further search before reaching a just conclusion. Yet he says it should not be hastily condemned, since such writing is useful in civil occasions like conference, counsel, persuasion, and discourse.

    Chapter 10

  2. What two marks does Bacon, citing St. Paul, give for suspected and falsified science?

    Bacon cites St. Paul's warning against "profane novelties of terms" and "oppositions of falsely named science," drawing two badges of falsified knowledge: the novelty and strangeness of terms, and the strictness of positions, which necessarily induces oppositions and thus questions and altercations. He says this reproof applies not only to divinity but extends to all knowledge.

    Chapter 10

  3. Why does Bacon criticize the schoolmen's learning as degenerate?

    Bacon says the schoolmen had sharp wits, abundant leisure, and little variety of reading, their wits shut up in a few authors (chiefly Aristotle) as their bodies were shut in monasteries. With little history of nature or time and infinite agitation of wit, they spun laborious webs of learning—cobwebs admirable for fineness of thread but of no substance or profit.

    Chapter 10

  4. What method of the schoolmen does Bacon object to, and what image does he use for the strength of sciences?

    Bacon objects to framing objections to every position and answering with solutions that are mostly distinctions rather than confutations. He says the strength of all sciences is like the old man's faggot, in the bond: the harmony of a science, each part supporting the other, is the true and brief confutation of smaller objections. Take out axioms one by one and you can break them at pleasure.

    Chapter 10

Section 114 cards
  1. What two kinds of 'facility of credit' does Bacon identify, based on subject matter?

    Bacon divides easy belief into two kinds according to subject: belief of history (or, as lawyers say, matter of fact), and belief of matter of art and opinion. He illustrates the first with ecclesiastical history, which too readily registered reports of miracles by martyrs, hermits, monks, relics, shrines, chapels and images—later judged old wives' fables and impostures of the clergy.

    Chapter 11

  2. How does Bacon contrast Aristotle's handling of natural history with Pliny and others?

    Bacon says Pliny, Cardanus, Albertus and various Arabians wrote natural history full of fabulous matter, much of it untried or notoriously untrue, damaging the credit of natural philosophy. Aristotle, by contrast, kept his diligent history of living creatures only sparingly mixed with feigned matter, and placed all prodigious narrations he thought worth recording into one separate book.

    Chapter 11

  3. What are the three sciences Bacon says ally with imagination rather than reason, and what is his verdict on them?

    Bacon names astrology, natural magic and alchemy as sciences with better confederacy with man's imagination than his reason. Their professed ends are noble—astrology claims to reveal correspondence between superior and inferior globes, natural magic to reduce philosophy to works, alchemy to separate unlike parts of bodies—but their theories and practices are full of error and vanity, concealed by enigmatical writings and appeals to auricular traditions.

    Chapter 11

  4. Why does Bacon argue that overmuch credit given to authors keeps sciences from advancing?

    Bacon argues that treating authors as dictators whose words must stand, rather than consuls who merely advise, is the principal cause keeping sciences at a standstill. In mechanical arts the first deviser comes shortest and time perfects; in sciences the first author goes furthest and time corrupts, because many wits spend themselves on one man's wit. Disciples owe masters only temporary belief, not perpetual captivity.

    Chapter 11

Section 124 cards
  1. What does Bacon compare time to when refuting the distrust of new discoveries?

    Bacon compares time to a river or stream that carries down what is light and blown up, while sinking and drowning what is weighty and solid. He argues that popular and superficial ideas survive while substantial and profound ones are lost, so a new search may recover what was wrongly rejected.

    Chapter 12

  2. Why does Bacon say reducing knowledge into exact methods halts its growth?

    Bacon argues that knowledge in aphorisms and observations is still growing, like young men who seldom grow taller once their frame is perfectly shaped. Once knowledge is comprehended in exact methods, it may be polished and adapted for use, but it increases no more in bulk and substance.

    Chapter 12

  3. According to Bacon, what happens if a man begins with certainties in contemplation?

    Bacon states that if a man begins with certainties, he shall end in doubts; but if he is content to begin with doubts, he shall end in certainties. He compares these two paths to the ways of action: one smooth at first but impassable at the end, the other rough at the entrance but fair and even afterward.

    Chapter 12

  4. What does Bacon call the greatest error concerning knowledge?

    Bacon says the greatest error is mistaking or misplacing the final end of knowledge. Men pursue learning for curiosity, delight, reputation, victory in argument, or lucre, rather than to benefit and use men. He argues knowledge should be a rich storehouse for the glory of the Creator and the relief of man's estate.

    Chapter 12

Section 134 cards
  1. What image does Bacon use for the proper end of knowledge?

    Bacon rejects knowledge as a courtesan for pleasure and vanity, or as a bond-woman serving a master's gain. Instead, knowledge should be as a spouse, for generation, fruit, and comfort. He urges that from both natural and moral philosophy we reject vain and empty speculations and preserve and augment what is solid and fruitful, since heaven and earth both contribute to man's benefit.

    Chapter 13

  2. How does Bacon distinguish works of power from works of wisdom in creation?

    Bacon argues creation shows a double emanation from God: one to power, one to wisdom. The confused mass of heaven and earth was made in a moment, but its order and disposition took six days. Of the former it is not said 'Let there be heaven and earth' but that God made them, carrying the style of a manufacture; the latter carries the style of a law, decree, or counsel.

    Chapter 13

  3. What knowledge does Bacon say caused the Fall?

    Bacon argues the knowledge that induced the Fall was not natural knowledge of creatures but moral knowledge of good and evil. The supposition was that God's commandments were not the originals of good and evil but had other beginnings, which man aspired to know in order to defect totally from God and depend wholly on himself. Man's first acts in Paradise were viewing creatures and imposing names.

    Chapter 13

  4. How does Bacon read the ceremonial law of Moses?

    Bacon says the ceremonial law has divine uses—prefiguring Christ, marking out God's people, exercising obedience—but the learned Rabbins also found natural or moral senses in many ceremonies. In the leprosy law, one noted that putrefaction is more contagious before maturity than after; another drew the moral point that those half good and half evil corrupt manners more than those abandoned to vice.

    Chapter 13

Section 144 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what natural philosophy does the book of Job contain?

    Bacon claims Job is "pregnant and swelling with natural philosophy," citing verses on cosmography and the earth's roundness, the pendulous earth, the north pole, and heaven's convexity; astronomy on the fixed stars, the Pleiades and Arcturus, and the unseen southern pole; and matter of generation and of minerals, including veins of silver and gold, iron from earth, and stone melted into brass.

    Chapter 14

  2. What did Solomon request and receive from God, according to Bacon?

    Bacon says Solomon's petition for wisdom and learning, and God's assent, preferred it before all other terrene and temporal felicity. By that grant Solomon wrote parables and aphorisms on divine and moral philosophy and compiled a natural history of all verdure, from the cedar to the moss on the wall, and of all things that breathe or move.

    Chapter 14

  3. How does Bacon describe the two services philosophy and learning perform for religion?

    Bacon concludes that, besides ornament, learning serves faith in two ways: it induces exaltation of God's glory, since resting only on the exterior of God's works injures His majesty, like judging a jeweller by his street display; and it is a preservative against unbelief and error, since Christ names two books to study, Scripture revealing God's will and the creatures expressing His power, the latter a key to the former.

    Chapter 14

  4. How does Bacon rank inventors of new arts against founders of states in heathen honour?

    Bacon says heathen antiquity honoured founders and uniters of states, lawgivers, tyrant-extirpers, and fathers of the people only as worthies or demigods, like Hercules, Theseus, Minos, and Romulus; but inventors and authors of new arts and commodities were consecrated among the gods, like Ceres, Bacchus, Mercury, and Apollo, because their benefit is permanent and universal rather than confined to one age or nation.

    Chapter 14

Section 154 cards
  1. What does Bacon's Orpheus theatre allegory say about learning and society?

    Bacon reads the myth of Orpheus' theatre, where beasts forgot their predatory and quarrelsome appetites to listen to the harp, as a picture of human nature: people are full of savage desires for profit, lust, and revenge. So long as they heed precepts, laws, religion, and persuasive books and sermons, peace is maintained; if those instruments fall silent or are drowned by sedition, all dissolves into anarchy and confusion.

    Chapter 15

  2. What does Bacon claim about times under learned princes and governors?

    Bacon argues that under learned princes and governors there have always been the best times. Even if kings have imperfections in passions and customs, learning gives them notions of religion, policy, and morality that restrain them from ruinous errors, whispering in their ears when counsellors are silent. Learned counsellors, he adds, proceed on safer principles than those of mere experience, keeping dangers far off rather than trusting wit to dodge them.

    Chapter 15

  3. How does Bacon describe Trajan's relationship to learning?

    Bacon says Trajan was not learned personally, but deserves a place among the most learned princes because he was a great admirer and benefactor of learning: a founder of famous libraries, a perpetual advancer of learned men to office, and a familiar converser with learned professors. Bacon also cites the legend that Gregory the Great prayed for Trajan's soul and obtained its release, with a caveat against repeating such petitions.

    Chapter 15

  4. How does Bacon compare Hadrian and Trajan as governors?

    Bacon calls Hadrian the most curious and universal inquirer, noting it was counted an error that he wished to comprehend all things rather than reserve himself for the worthiest. In civil government Bacon says Hadrian did not match Trajan's glory of arms or perfection of justice, but exceeded him in deserving the subject's welfare: Trajan's buildings served glory and triumph, while Hadrian's peaceful reign was spent surveying the empire, restoring decayed cities and forts, cutting rivers, building bridges, and granting new ordinances.

    Chapter 15

Section 164 cards
  1. What three particulars show Alexander's high estimation of learning?

    Bacon cites three: Alexander envied Achilles for having Homer as the trumpet of his praises; he judged Homer's works worthy to be placed in Darius's precious cabinet; and he wrote to Aristotle complaining that publishing the secrets of philosophy was wrong, saying he esteemed excelling in learning above power and empire.

    Chapter 16

  2. How does Bacon characterize Queen Elizabeth's learning and reading habits?

    Bacon says Elizabeth's learning was singular for her sex and rare even among male princes, in language, science, ancient and modern, divinity and humanity. To the last year of her life she appointed set hours for reading, scarcely any young university student more daily or duly. Bacon argues her 45-year reign showed learning joined with felicity in the people.

    Chapter 16

  3. How does Bacon use Alexander's remark on Diogenes to illustrate moral philosophy?

    Seeing Diogenes content with little, Alexander said that were he not Alexander he would wish to be Diogenes, raising the question whether enjoying outward things or contemning them brings greater happiness. Bacon notes Seneca inverts it: there was more that Diogenes would refuse than Alexander could give or enjoy.

    Chapter 16

  4. What does Bacon claim about learning's effect on military virtue, and what evidence does he give?

    Bacon argues learning has no less power in enabling martial virtue than civil, citing Alexander the Great and Caesar the Dictator. Alexander was taught by Aristotle, who dedicated books to him, and was accompanied in camp by Callisthenes and other learned men. Bacon also notes Alexander's speeches were full of science and its use.

    Chapter 16

Section 174 cards
  1. How does Bacon illustrate Alexander's use of a metaphor against Antipater?

    When Antipater's friend praised him for keeping the ancient Macedonian habit of black rather than adopting Persian purple, Alexander replied, "True, but Antipater is all purple within." Bacon offers this as an excellent use of metaphor or translation, exposing the governor's inner tyranny despite his outward moderation.

    Chapter 17

  2. What distinction did Alexander make between Hephaestion and Craterus?

    Alexander said one loved Alexander and the other loved the king. Bacon treats this as a significant distinction in policy between princes' best servants: some love their master's person out of affection, others love the crown out of duty.

    Chapter 17

  3. What did Alexander answer when asked what he reserved for himself after giving large gifts?

    He answered, "Hope." Bacon argues this was a correct accounting, since hope must be the portion of all who resolve upon great enterprises. He compares it to Caesar's portion when he first went into Gaul with his estate ruined by largesses, and to Henry Duke of Guise, called the greatest usurer in France for turning his estate into obligations.

    Chapter 17

  4. How did Caesar's one word Quirites end the army mutiny?

    Roman generals addressed soldiers as Milites, but magistrates addressed the people as Quirites. When mutinous soldiers demanded discharge, Caesar began, "Ego Quirites," addressing them as already discharged. Surprised and confused, they stopped him and begged to be called Milites again, abandoning their demands.

    Chapter 17

Section 184 cards
  1. How does Bacon analyze Caesar's reply 'Non Rex sum, sed Caesar'?

    Bacon says the speech's life can scarce be expressed: it was a non-serious refusal of the name, it signified infinite confidence and magnanimity as if Caesar presumed his own title greater, and chiefly it allured toward his purpose, as if the state strove with him only for a name that even mean families bore, since Rex was a Roman surname as King is with us.

    Chapter 18

  2. What did Caesar say and do to Metellus in the treasury?

    After war was declared and Caesar possessed Rome, he entered the inner treasury to take the money; Metellus, tribune, forbade him. Caesar threatened to lay him dead in the place, then immediately added, 'Young man, it is harder for me to speak it than to do it.' Bacon calls it a speech compounded of the greatest terror and greatest clemency from a man's mouth.

    Chapter 18

  3. What did Xenophon say to Falinus, and how did Falinus respond?

    When the king demanded the Greeks surrender their arms, Xenophon said they had only two things left, their arms and their virtue, asking how they could use virtue if they yielded their arms. Falinus, smiling, said Xenophon was likely an Athenian studying philosophy, but was much abused if he thought his virtue could withstand the king's power. Bacon notes the scorn, then the wonder that followed.

    Chapter 18

  4. What does Bacon claim genuine learning does to the mind's morals?

    Bacon cites the verse that faithfully learning the liberal arts softens manners and does not let them be savage, stressing the accent on fideliter, since superficial learning works the contrary. Learning removes levity and insolency by suggesting doubts and balancing reasons, cures vain admiration by showing nothing new under the sun, and mitigates fear of death, disposing the mind to growth and reformation.

    Chapter 18

Section 194 cards
  1. According to Bacon, how does the commandment of knowledge compare to command over men's wills?

    The author argues knowledge's commandment is higher than command over the will, because it rules reason, belief, and understanding—the highest part of the mind—and gives law to the will itself. No earthly power sets up a throne in men's thoughts, imaginations, opinions, and beliefs except knowledge and learning.

    Chapter 19

  2. What does Bacon say about satiety in the pleasures of knowledge versus other pleasures?

    The author argues all other pleasures bring satiety and lose their verdure once used, showing they were deceits of pleasure and that novelty pleased rather than quality—hence voluptuous men turn friars and ambitious princes turn melancholy. Of knowledge there is no satiety; satisfaction and appetite are perpetually interchangeable, so it appears good in itself.

    Chapter 19

  3. Why does Bacon claim the monuments of learning are more durable than monuments of power?

    The author argues Homer's verses have lasted 2,500 years or more without losing a syllable, while palaces, temples, castles, and cities have decayed. True pictures of Cyrus, Alexander, and Caesar cannot survive because originals cannot last and copies lose life and truth, but images of men's wits remain in books, exempt from time's wrong and capable of perpetual renovation.

    Chapter 19

  4. What does Bacon say about learning's power to bestow fortune on particular persons?

    The author argues learning's beneficence is not confined to states and commonwealths but also gives fortune to particular persons. It was well noted long ago that Homer has given more men their livings than Sylla, Caesar, or Augustus did with their largesses, donatives, and land distributions to legions; it is hard to say whether arms or learning have advanced greater numbers.

    Chapter 19

Section 204 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what three things make works 'over common' for advancing learning?

    Bacon lays down that all works are advanced by amplitude of reward, soundness of direction, and conjunction of labours. The first multiplies endeavour, the second prevents error, and the third supplies human frailty. He argues direction is the principal of these, citing the proverb that a lame man on the path outruns a runner off it, and Solomon on sharpening iron.

    Chapter 20

  2. What three objects do works of merit toward learning concern?

    Bacon says such works are conversant about three objects: the places of learning, the books of learning, and the persons of the learned. He compares knowledge to water that scatters and perishes unless collected into receptacles, so universities, colleges, schools, books, traditions, and conferences preserve it. Each object then divides into specific works, such as buildings, libraries, and rewards for readers and writers.

    Chapter 20

  3. What four works concern the seats and places of learning?

    Bacon lists four: foundations and buildings, endowments with revenues, endowments with franchises and privileges, and institutions and ordinances for government. All of them, he says, tend to quietness and privateness of life and the discharge of cares and troubles. He likens these to the stations Virgil prescribes for hiving bees, sheltered from the winds.

    Chapter 20

  4. What error does Bacon identify in colleges dedicated only to professions?

    Bacon finds it strange that Europe's colleges are all dedicated to professions with none free for arts and sciences at large. Using the fable of the stomach, he argues philosophy and universality are not idle but supply all professions. He claims this dedication has hindered the progression of learning and prejudiced states, leaving princes a solitude of able men for affairs of estate.

    Chapter 20

Section 214 cards
  1. What defect does Bacon identify in public lectures?

    Bacon argues the salaries or rewards assigned to public lectures, whether in arts or professions, are too small and mean. Since lecturers are meant to generate and propagate sciences, they must be the ablest men, and their endowment must be sufficient to content them to devote their whole labor and age to that function, comparable to what a profession would yield.

    Chapter 21

  2. Why does Bacon invoke David's military law for lecturers?

    Bacon argues that if sciences are to flourish, those who stay with the carriage must share equally with those in action. Lecturers are the guardians of the stores and provisions of sciences from which active men are furnished, so they ought to receive equal entertainment. Otherwise, weak or ill-maintained fathers in sciences produce starving offspring.

    Chapter 21

  3. What does Bacon say is needed for deep study of natural philosophy and physic?

    Bacon argues books are not the only instruments for deep, fruitful, operative study of many sciences, especially natural philosophy and physic. He notes some provision exists, like spheres and maps for astronomy, or gardens and anatomies for physic, but these cover few things. In general there will hardly be main proficiency in disclosing nature unless allowance is made for expenses about experiments.

    Chapter 21

  4. What two university defects does Bacon cite as examples?

    Bacon says scholars come too soon and unripe to logic and rhetoric, arts fitter for graduates than children, since minds empty of matter turn these grave arts into childish sophistry. He also finds exercises divorce invention from memory: speeches are either wholly premeditated or wholly extemporal, whereas life mixes both, so exercises do not fit practice.

    Chapter 21

Section 224 cards
  1. What three parts of human understanding does Bacon map learning onto?

    Bacon says the parts of human learning refer to three parts of man's understanding, the seat of learning: history to his memory, poesy to his imagination, and philosophy to his reason. He adds that divine learning receives the same distribution, since the spirit of man is the same though revelation and sense differ, so theology consists of Church history, parables (divine poesy), and holy doctrine or precept.

    Chapter 22

  2. Which kind of history does Bacon allow as extant, and which does he note as deficient?

    Bacon divides history into natural, civil, ecclesiastical, and literary. He allows the first three as extant but notes the fourth, literary history, as deficient. No one, he says, has set himself to describe the general state of learning from age to age, as many have done for Nature and for civil and ecclesiastical states; without it the history of the world seems to him like the statue of Polyphemus with his eye out.

    Chapter 22

  3. What three sorts of natural history does Bacon identify, and their status?

    Bacon says history of Nature is of three sorts: of Nature in course, of Nature erring or varying, and of Nature altered or wrought — that is, history of creatures, history of marvels, and history of arts. The first he holds extant and in good perfection; the latter two he notes as deficient, finding no substantial, severe collection of Nature's irregulars with due rejection of fables and popular errors.

    Chapter 22

  4. Why does Bacon say the opinion of plenty causes want?

    Bacon argues that the opinion of plenty is among the causes of want, and that the great quantity of books shows rather superfluity than lack. This surcharge is not to be remedied by making no more books, but by making more good books, which, like the serpent of Moses, might devour the serpents of the enchanters. He also urges public designation of writers for parts of knowledge not yet sufficiently laboured.

    Chapter 22

Section 234 cards
  1. Why does Bacon value a history of marvels, beyond satisfying curious wits?

    Bacon gives two weighty reasons: it corrects the partiality of axioms and opinions, which are commonly framed only on familiar examples; and the wonders of Nature provide the nearest passage toward the wonders of art, since by following Nature in her wanderings one may later lead her to the same place again. He insists such narrations be sorted apart from merely natural ones.

    Chapter 23

  2. How does Bacon classify superstitious narrations such as sorceries, witchcrafts, and dreams?

    Where there is assurance and clear evidence of the fact, Bacon would not exclude them entirely, since it is not yet known how far effects attributed to superstition participate of natural causes. Though the practice is to be condemned, speculation on them may disclose Nature. He holds such narrations should be sorted by themselves, not mingled with sincerely natural ones.

    Chapter 23

  3. What does Bacon argue about mechanical history and 'vulgar' experiments?

    Bacon argues the use of mechanical history is the most radical and fundamental toward an operative natural philosophy benefiting man's life. He criticizes collections that reject familiar and vulgar experiments out of arrogancy, derided in Plato's Hippias. Small things often discover great better than great discover small, and nature appears more fully in the trials and vexations of art.

    Chapter 23

  4. How does Bacon divide civil history, and what does he say of epitomes?

    Bacon compares civil history to pictures: memorials are history unfinished, perfect histories are complete, and antiquities are history defaced, remnants saved from the shipwreck of time. Memorials are commentaries (naked events without motives or counsels) or registers (public acts without continuous narration). He assigns no deficience to these imperfect kinds, but would banish epitomes as corruptions that corrode sound histories.

    Chapter 23

Section 244 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what are the three kinds of just and perfect history?

    Bacon divides just and perfect history into three kinds according to what it represents: chronicles represent a time, lives represent a person, and narrations or relations represent an action. He ranks chronicles as the most complete and esteemed, but says lives excel in profit and use, while narrations excel in verity and sincerity.

    Chapter 24

  2. Why does Bacon say narrations of actions are more purely and exactly true than histories of times?

    Bacon argues narrations of single actions, such as the Peloponnesian war, the expedition of Cyrus Minor, or the conspiracy of Catiline, can be more purely and exactly true because the writer may choose an argument comprehensible within his notice and instructions. By contrast, one who writes the story of a long time meets many blanks he must fill from his own wit and conjecture.

    Chapter 24

  3. What deficiency does Bacon identify in modern histories, and what remedy does he propose?

    Bacon says some modern histories are worthy but most are beneath mediocrity. He criticizes the unworthiness of England's history in its main continuance and the partiality and obliquity of Scotland's in the latest and largest author he has seen. He proposes joining Great Britain in one history for past times, as it is now joined in monarchy, or at least covering the period from the uniting of the Roses to the uniting of the kingdoms.

    Chapter 24

  4. How does Bacon explain the rarity of writings of lives, and what poet's invention does he cite?

    Bacon finds it strange that his times so little esteem the virtues of the times, so that writings of lives are infrequent. He says many worthy personages deserve better than dispersed report or barren eulogies. He cites a late poet's invention: at the end of each man's life thread a medal bore his name, and Time carried the medals to the river Lethe, where birds briefly caught them; only a few swans carried names to a consecrated temple.

    Chapter 24

Section 253 cards
  1. What does Bacon say about the praise of the dead and the phrase bona fama?

    Bacon cites Solomon that the memory of the just flourishes with praises while the name of the wicked rots. He endorses the received styles felicis, piæ, and bonæ memoriæ, and, borrowing Cicero from Demosthenes, calls good fame the proper possession of the dead. The author notes this possession lies much waste in his times, which he counts a deficience.

    Chapter 25

  2. How does Tacitus's division of annals and journals differ, and why does Bacon value it?

    Tacitus assigns matters of estate to annals and acts of a meaner nature to journals, as when he says illustrious matters go to annals and such things to the daily acts of the city. Bacon calls this a contemplative heraldry and warns that mixing triumphs, ceremonies, or novelties with matters of state debases a history's authority. Journals were also kept for persons, especially princes and memorable enterprises.

    Chapter 25

  3. What is cosmography composed of, and why does Bacon praise his own age for it?

    Cosmography mixes natural history of regions, civil history of peoples' habitations and manners, and mathematics of climates and heavenly configurations. Bacon says this part has most profited lately, claiming the world's great building never had through-lights till the age of us and our fathers. He credits circumnavigation of the globe, done only in later times, and adds the motto imitabile cælum.

    Chapter 25

Section 264 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what does the history of Providence contain?

    Bacon says it contains the correspondence between God's revealed will and His secret will. This correspondence is usually obscure and not legible to natural man, nor often to those who behold it from the tabernacle. Yet at times God writes it in such capital letters that even mere sensual persons hastening past His judgments may read it.

    Chapter 26

  2. Why does Bacon rank letters from wise men so highly?

    Bacon judges letters from wise men the best of all words of man, because they are more natural than orations and public speeches, and more advised than conferences or present speeches. He adds that letters of affairs from those who manage them or are privy to them are the best instructions for history, and to a diligent reader the best histories in themselves.

    Chapter 26

  3. What does Bacon say poesy feigns, and why?

    Bacon argues poesy feigns acts and events greater and more heroical, because true history lacks the magnitude that satisfies the mind. It feigns more just retribution, because true history's outcomes are not agreeable to the merits of virtue and vice. It adds more rareness and unexpected variations, because true history is more ordinary. Thus poesy serves magnanimity, morality, and delectation.

    Chapter 26

  4. What are Bacon's three divisions of poesy, and what is allusive poesy?

    Bacon divides poesy into narrative, representative, and allusive. Narrative imitates history with excesses, commonly choosing wars and love. Representative is a visible history, an image of actions as if present. Allusive, or parabolical, is a narration applied only to express some special purpose or conceit, as in Aesop's fables, the sentences of the seven, and hieroglyphics.

    Chapter 26

Section 274 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what do libels and slanders represent after open rebels are suppressed?

    Bacon expounds that once princes and monarchs have suppressed actual and open rebels, the malignity of the people—which he calls the mother of rebellion—brings forth libels and slanders and taxations of states. These he describes as being of the same kind as rebellion but more feminine.

    Chapter 27

  2. How does Bacon interpret the fable of Pallas calling Briareus to aid Jupiter?

    Bacon expounds that monarchies need not fear any curbing of their absoluteness by mighty subjects, as long as by wisdom they keep the hearts of the people, who will be sure to come in on their side. Pallas calling Briareus with his hundred hands illustrates this point about popular support.

    Chapter 27

  3. How does Bacon say Machiavelli interpreted the fable of Achilles raised by Chiron?

    Bacon says Machiavelli expounded it ingeniously but corruptly: that the education and discipline of princes should teach them to play the lion in violence and the fox in guile, as well as the man in virtue and justice. Bacon reports this interpretation without endorsing it.

    Chapter 27

  4. What does Bacon doubt about the relation between fables and their moral expositions?

    Bacon says he rather thinks the fable was first and the exposition devised, than that the moral came first and the fable was framed upon it. He cites Chrysippus's ancient vanity of fastening Stoic assertions onto the fictions of the ancient poets, and says he interposes no opinion on whether all poetic fables are figure rather than pleasure.

    Chapter 27

Section 284 cards
  1. What are the bounds of natural theology, according to Bacon?

    Bacon says natural theology is knowledge of God gained by contemplating His creatures—divine in object, natural in light. Its bounds are that it suffices to convince atheism but not to inform religion. He argues no miracle was ever wrought to convert an atheist, since the light of nature could lead him to confess a God, while miracles were wrought to convert idolaters and the superstitious.

    Chapter 28

  2. Why does Bacon warn against mixing religion and philosophy?

    The author argues that commixing religion and philosophy produces an heretical religion and an imaginary, fabulous philosophy. He cites the fable of the golden chain: men and gods could not draw Jupiter down, but Jupiter could draw them up. So we should not submit God's mysteries to reason, but raise reason to divine truth. He notes excess here, not deficiency.

    Chapter 28

  3. What inquiry into angels and spirits does Bacon say is permitted?

    Bacon says the appendix on angels and spirits is neither inscrutable nor interdicted. Scripture forbids only two things: adoration of them, and fantastical opinion—extolling them beyond the degree of a creature, or claiming knowledge of them beyond one's grounds. Sober, grounded inquiry from Scripture or the gradations of nature is not restrained. Contemplating evil spirits' nature and illusions is lawful, as is studying poisons.

    Chapter 28

  4. How does Bacon divide natural philosophy, and what does he mean by 'natural magic'?

    Bacon divides natural philosophy into the inquisition of causes and the production of effects—speculative and operative, natural science and natural prudence—likened to miners and smiths, the mine and the furnace. He asks to revive the abused name 'natural magic' for the operative part, meaning natural wisdom or prudence purged of vanity and superstition. He calls for both parts to be handled separately.

    Chapter 28

Section 294 cards
  1. How does Bacon distinguish physic from metaphysic by the causes they study?

    Bacon assigns physic the material and efficient causes, and metaphysic the formal and final causes. Physic's causes are variable or respective, as fire hardens clay but melts wax. Metaphysic handles fixed and constant causes. He notes physic also examines natures like whiteness, but only as to material and efficient causes, which he calls the vehicle of form, not the form itself.

    Chapter 29

  2. What does Bacon say about the possibility of discovering essential forms?

    Bacon rejects the inveterate opinion that man cannot find essential forms. He argues the invention of forms is the worthiest part of knowledge, saying those who see only sea and conclude there is no land are ill discoverers. He faults Plato for abstracting forms from matter and turning the doctrine toward theology, and urges inquiry into simple natures like sense, motion, and colour.

    Chapter 29

  3. Why does Bacon say the forms of substances like lion or gold are not to be inquired?

    Because such substances, multiplied by compounding and transplanting, are so perplexed that their forms cannot usefully be sought. Bacon compares this to seeking the forms of whole words, which are infinite by composition, rather than the simple letters. Instead, metaphysic should inquire the forms of simple natures and qualities, like an alphabet, of which all creatures' essences consist.

    Chapter 29

  4. How does Bacon separate prima philosophia, natural theology, and metaphysic?

    Bacon makes summary or first philosophy a parent to all knowledge, holding common axioms indifferent to several sciences and handling adventive characters of essences as they have efficacy in nature, not logically. Natural theology, formerly confused with metaphysic, he bounds by itself. What remains for metaphysic is inquiry into formal and final causes, the abstracted and fixed, as distinct from physic's transitory, inherent matter.

    Chapter 29

Section 304 cards
  1. In Bacon's pyramid of natural philosophy, what are the three stages from base to apex?

    Bacon describes knowledges as pyramids: natural history is the basis of natural philosophy, physic (physics) is the stage next the basis, and metaphysic is the stage next the vertical point. He adds that whether man's inquiry can reach the very vertical point—the summary law of nature—is unknown. These three he calls the true stages of knowledge.

    Chapter 30

  2. Why does Bacon say final causes are misplaced rather than omitted?

    Bacon argues final causes are true and worthy of inquiry, but belong in metaphysic, not mixed into physical inquiries. When handled alongside physics, they intercept the severe inquiry of real causes and let men rest on specious, satisfactory explanations, arresting further discovery. He notes Plato, Aristotle, and Galen all fell into this, though he insists final and physical causes are compatible, not repugnant.

    Chapter 30

  3. According to Bacon, why is metaphysic the worthiest knowledge?

    Bacon argues metaphysic is worthiest because it is charged with least multiplicity: it considers the simple forms or differences of things, which are few in number, and whose degrees and co-ordinations produce all the variety we see. He also says it enfranchises man's power to the greatest liberty of works, since whoever knows a form knows the utmost possibility of superinducing that nature upon any matter.

    Chapter 30

  4. Why does Bacon place mathematics under metaphysic rather than as a principal part of natural philosophy?

    Bacon says mathematics treats determined or proportionable quantity, which appears to be one of the essential forms of things and is the most abstracted and separable from matter—hence most proper to metaphysic. He notes Democritus ascribed figure to the first seeds and Pythagoras made numbers the principles of things. He adds the placement matters little, since his partitions aim only to let one part cast light on another.

    Chapter 30

Section 314 cards
  1. How does Bacon divide mathematics, and what does each part handle?

    Bacon divides mathematics into pure and mixed. Pure mathematics handles determinate quantity severed from axioms of natural philosophy, and consists of geometry (quantity continued) and arithmetic (quantity dissevered). Mixed mathematics takes some axioms or parts of natural philosophy as its subject and considers determined quantity as auxiliary and incident to them, including perspective, music, astronomy, cosmography, architecture, and engineery.

    Chapter 31

  2. What deficiency does Bacon report in the mathematics?

    Bacon reports no deficiency in mathematics except that men do not sufficiently understand the excellent use of pure mathematics in remedying defects of the wit and intellectual faculties: it sharpens a dull wit, fixes a wandering one, and abstracts one too inherent in the sense. He compares this collateral use to tennis, a game of no use in itself but great use for making a quick eye and ready body.

    Chapter 31

  3. What three parts does Bacon divide operative natural philosophy into, and what do they correspond to?

    Bacon divides natural prudence, or the operative part of natural philosophy, into three parts—experimental, philosophical, and magical—which correspond and are analogous to the three speculative parts: natural history, physic, and metaphysic. Operations arise by casual incidence, by purposed experiment (varying or extending it, or transferring and compounding experiments), and by knowledge of physical causes kept with one eye on use.

    Chapter 31

  4. How does Bacon distinguish true natural magic from the magic found in books?

    Bacon calls true natural magic the great liberty and latitude of operation depending on knowledge of forms, and reports it deficient because metaphysic is deficient. The magic in books, with credulous conceits about sympathies, antipathies, and hidden proprieties, differs from true knowledge as the story of King Arthur differs from Caesar's Commentaries. He likens it to Ixion embracing a cloud, begetting centaurs and chimeras.

    Chapter 31

Section 324 cards
  1. What two excellent uses does Bacon give for registering doubts?

    Bacon states two uses: first, it saves philosophy from errors and falsehoods by reserving uncertain matters in doubt rather than collecting them into assertion, so error does not draw error; second, doubts act as suckers or sponges to draw out knowledge, since matters that would otherwise pass unnoticed are attended to when a doubt prompts inquiry.

    Chapter 32

  2. What inconvenience does Bacon say accompanies the registering of doubts?

    Bacon warns that once a doubt is received, men labor rather to keep it a doubt still than to solve it, bending their wits accordingly. He cites lawyers and scholars as familiar examples, noting that an admitted doubt becomes authorized as a doubt ever after. He commends calendars of doubts only with the caution that resolved doubts be omitted and discarded.

    Chapter 32

  3. Why does Bacon advise collecting ancient philosophies whole rather than by titles?

    Bacon argues it is the harmony of a philosophy in itself that gives it light and credence, whereas if it is singled and broken it seems more foreign and dissonant. He criticizes Plutarch's method of packing philosophies by titles, comparing it to reading Nero's or Claudius's actions in Suetonius, gathered into bundles rather than in order of time, which makes them seem more monstrous.

    Chapter 32

  4. How does Bacon illustrate that experience in childhood accepts every philosophy?

    Bacon cites Aristotle's saying that children at first call every woman mother, but later distinguish according to truth. So experience, if it be in childhood, will call every philosophy mother, but when it comes to ripeness it will discern the true mother. He uses this to argue that several theories can satisfy ordinary experience, while finding real truth requires another manner of severity and attention.

    Chapter 32

Section 334 cards
  1. What two arts does Bacon say spring from the discovery of body by mind?

    Bacon says the branch of discovery has begotten two arts of prediction: physiognomy, which discloses the disposition of the mind by the lineaments of the body (honored with the inquiry of Aristotle), and the exposition of natural dreams, which discloses the state of the body by the imaginations of the mind (honored with Hippocrates). He says both, once purged of superstition, have solid ground in nature and profitable use in life.

    Chapter 33

  2. What deficiency does Bacon note in Aristotle's treatment of physiognomy?

    Bacon notes that Aristotle ingeniously and diligently handled the factures of the body but not its gestures, which he says are no less comprehensible by art and of greater use. Lineaments disclose the mind's general disposition and inclination, but motions of the countenance and parts further disclose the present humour and state of the mind and will. Bacon quotes the king: as the tongue speaks to the ear, so gesture speaks to the eye.

    Chapter 33

  3. How does Bacon answer the objection that the mind's dependence on the body threatens its immortality?

    Bacon says anyone of weak judgment who thinks the mind's suffering from the body questions immortality or derogates from the soul's sovereignty may be taught by easy instances: the infant in the mother's womb is compatible with the mother yet separable, and the most absolute monarch is sometimes led by his servants without subjection. He argues dependence on the body does not entail the soul's subjection or mortality.

    Chapter 33

  4. What caution does Bacon give about imagination's power to help the body?

    Bacon says it is an inquiry of great depth and worth how far imagination alters the body of the imaginant. Although it has manifest power to hurt, it does not follow that it has the same degree of power to help, no more than one can conclude that because pestilent airs can suddenly kill a healthy man, there must be sovereign airs able to suddenly cure a sick one. He calls the inquiry difficult and profound.

    Chapter 33

Section 344 cards
  1. Why does Bacon say medicine is more conjectural than other arts?

    Bacon argues medicine is conjectural because the human body is so variable, making the art uncertain and leaving room for imposture. Other arts are judged by acts or masterpieces—the lawyer by his pleading, the pilot by his course—but the physician is judged by the event, since no one can tell whether recovery or death is art or accident.

    Chapter 34

  2. What deficiency does Bacon find in the anatomical inquiry of his time?

    Bacon says anatomists inquire of the parts, their substances, figures, and collocations, but not the diversities of parts, the secrecies of passages, the seats of humours, nor the footsteps and impressions of diseases. He attributes this to the first inquiry being satisfied by one or few anatomies, while the latter requires comparative observation of many.

    Chapter 34

  3. What remedy does Bacon propose for the mind's incomprehension of nature?

    Bacon argues the problem is not the mind's insufficiency but its remote standing from the object. As sense is exact at hand but mistaken afar off, so is understanding. The remedy is not to quicken or strengthen the organ but to go nearer to the object—so physicians should learn and use the true approaches and avenues of nature.

    Chapter 34

  4. How does Bacon defend the nobility of medicine?

    Bacon says medicine's nobility is shadowed by the poets making Æsculapius son of the sun, the fountain of life, with medicine as second stream. He says it is infinitely more honoured by Christ's example, who made the body the object of His miracles as the soul was of His doctrine, doing no miracle about honour or money except the tribute to Cæsar.

    Chapter 34

Section 354 cards
  1. What deficiency does Bacon identify in physicians' inquiry into disease cures?

    Bacon notes that physicians abandon cures for many diseases, deeming some incurable by nature and others past the period of cure. He argues this pronounces an incurable verdict that enacts a law of neglect and exempts ignorance from discredit, comparing their edicts to the proscriptions of Sylla and the Triumvirs, which killed fewer men than these ignorant decrees.

    Chapter 35

  2. What does Bacon consider the physician's office beyond restoring health?

    Bacon argues the physician's office includes mitigating pain and dolors, not only when mitigation aids recovery but also to make a fair and easy passage at death. He cites Augustus Caesar's wish for Euthanasia and the gentle death of Antoninus Pius, and criticizes physicians who scruple to stay with patients after the disease is deplored.

    Chapter 35

  3. Why does Bacon say empirics and old women sometimes cure better than learned physicians?

    Bacon attributes this to physicians' magistralities: they add, remove, and change quid pro qua in receipts at pleasure, tying themselves to few fixed receipts except treacle, mithridatum, and diascordium. Empirics and old women are more religious in holding their medicines. He urges setting down experimental medicines for particular diseases from practice, books, and empirics' traditions.

    Chapter 35

  4. What deficiency does Bacon find in the preparation of medicines?

    Bacon finds it strange that no one has sought to imitate by art natural baths and medicinable fountains, which are confessed to receive virtues from minerals such as sulphur, vitriol, or steel. If nature could be reduced to compositions of art, the variety of such medicines would increase and their temper would be more commanded.

    Chapter 35

Section 364 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what two parts make up knowledge concerning the mind?

    Bacon divides knowledge of the mind into two parts: one inquiring into the substance or nature of the soul or mind, and the other into its faculties or functions. The first covers questions of the soul's origin, whether native or adventive, its exemption from laws of matter, and its immortality. The second concerns the mind's powers, which Bacon later divides into rational and moral philosophy.

    Chapter 36

  2. How does Bacon classify divination, and which sort does he consider superstitious?

    Bacon divides divination into artificial and natural. Artificial predicts by argument from signs and tokens; natural is a presentiment by internal power without a sign. Artificial has two sorts: one coupled with derivation of causes (rational), the other grounded only on coincidence of effect (experimental), which Bacon says is mostly superstitious, citing heathen sacrifice observations, bird flights, bee swarms, and Chaldean astrology.

    Chapter 36

  3. What is fascination, and why does Bacon judge ceremonial magic unlawful?

    Fascination is the power and act of imagination intensive upon bodies other than the imaginant's own. Bacon notes Paracelsus's school exalted imagination nearly to miracle-working faith, while others suppose spirit-to-spirit transmissions without the senses. Even granting imagination has power and ceremonies fortify it, Bacon holds such ceremonies unlawful because they oppose God's edict that man eat bread by the sweat of his face, offering noble effects through easy, slothful observances.

    Chapter 36

  4. What role does Bacon assign to imagination between reason and action?

    Bacon calls imagination an agent or nuncius in both provinces, judicial and ministerial: sense sends to imagination before reason judges, and reason sends to imagination before the decree is acted, since imagination precedes voluntary motion. Its face toward reason bears truth, toward action bears good. Citing Aristotle, Bacon says reason rules imagination as a magistrate rules a free citizen, who may come to rule in turn, as when faith raises imagination above reason.

    Chapter 36

Section 374 cards
  1. What four intellectual arts does Bacon divide according to their ends?

    Bacon divides the arts intellectual into four, according to the ends of man's labour: the art of inquiry or invention (to invent what is sought), the art of examination or judgment (to judge what is invented), the art of custody or memory (to retain what is judged), and the art of elocution or tradition (to deliver over what is retained).

    Chapter 37

  2. Why does Bacon call the art of invention of arts and sciences deficient?

    Bacon reports the invention of arts and sciences as deficient, comparing it to an inventory of a deceased estate that lists no ready money, since this knowledge should purchase all the rest. He argues logic does not pretend to invent sciences but passes it over with a cuique in sua arte credendum, and that inventions are commonly referred to chance rather than to art.

    Chapter 37

  3. What does Bacon criticize about the logicians' form of induction?

    Bacon argues the logicians' induction is utterly vicious and incompetent, because concluding upon an enumeration of particulars without a contradictory instance is no conclusion but a conjecture. He notes one cannot be sure there are no unseen particulars on the contrary side, comparing it to Samuel resting on Jesse's sons brought before him and failing of David, who was in the field.

    Chapter 37

  4. According to Bacon, why are rational knowledges the keys of all other arts?

    Bacon argues that, speaking truly of things as they are in worth, rational knowledges are the keys of all other arts. He cites Aristotle that the hand is the instrument of instruments and the mind the form of forms, so these are the art of arts. They not only direct but confirm and strengthen, as the habit of shooting enables both a nearer shoot and a stronger bow.

    Chapter 37

Section 384 cards
  1. Why does Bacon say syllogism cannot deduce middle propositions in natural philosophy?

    Bacon argues that arguments consist of propositions, propositions of words, and words are only tokens of popular notions. If those notions are collected grossly and variably from particulars, no examination of argument consequences or propositional truth can correct the error, which he says lies in the "first digestion." He concedes syllogism has use in moralities, laws, and divinity.

    Chapter 38

  2. What was the sceptics' chief error, according to Bacon?

    Bacon says the sceptics and academics rightly denied certainty but wrongly charged the deceit upon the senses. In his judgment the senses sufficiently certify and report truth, though not always immediately—by comparison, by instruments, and by reducing subtle things to sensible effects. They should have blamed the weakness of the intellect and the manner of collecting and concluding from sense reports.

    Chapter 38

  3. How does Bacon distinguish experientia literata from interpretatio naturae?

    Bacon says he has digested the invention of sciences into two parts: experientia literata and interpretatio naturae. The former, learned experience, is but a degree and rudiment of the latter, the interpretation of nature. He promises to propound this part fully if God gives him leave, but declines to dwell too long or speak too greatly upon a promise.

    Chapter 38

  4. Why does Bacon say the invention of speech or argument is not properly invention?

    Bacon argues that to invent is to discover what we do not know, not to recover what we already know. The invention of speech only draws forth from knowledge the mind already possesses what is pertinent to the purpose at hand. So it is really remembrance or suggestion with application, which is why the schools place it after judgment, as subsequent rather than precedent.

    Chapter 38

Section 393 cards
  1. How does Bacon describe the relationship between invention and judgment in induction versus syllogism?

    Bacon says induction coincides with invention: whether in good or vicious form, the same action of the mind that inventeth judgeth, as in the senses. Proof by syllogism differs because it proceeds by a mean, so inventing the mean is one thing and judging the consequence another—one exciting, the other examining. For exact judgment he refers to interpretation of Nature.

    Chapter 39

  2. What two methods of doctrine does the art of judgment by syllogism have?

    Bacon gives two: the method of direction, which sets down a true form of consequence so errors may be judged by variations from it, handling propositions and their simple words—this is the logic in the Analytics; and the method of caution, introduced for expedite use and assurance, which discovers subtle sophisms and illaqueations with their redargutions, termed elenches.

    Chapter 39

  3. What broader use does Bacon assign to elenches beyond refuting sophisms?

    Bacon argues elenches have wider latitude: inquiry into common adjuncts of essences (majority, identity, possibility, act, parts, privation, and the like) is really an elenche—wise cautions against ambiguity of speech, the great sophism of all sophisms. Likewise, distributing things into categories or predicaments are cautions against confusion in definitions and divisions.

    Chapter 39

Section 404 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what is the mind like, and why does this matter?

    Bacon argues the mind is not a clear, equal glass reflecting things at their true incidence, but rather an enchanted glass full of superstition and imposture unless delivered and reduced. These false appearances infect the understanding generally and inwardly, not merely in particulars, so cautioning against them greatly matters for the true conduct of human judgment.

    Chapter 40

  2. What does Diagoras's reply about Neptune's temple illustrate?

    It illustrates that the mind favors the affirmative or active over the negative or privative: a few hits or presences outweigh many failings or absences. When shown pictures of those who escaped shipwreck and paid vows, Diagoras asked where those who drowned were painted. Bacon calls this instance the root of all superstition.

    Chapter 40

  3. What does Bacon say about mathematicians and celestial motion?

    Bacon argues the human spirit supposes greater equality and uniformity in nature than truly exists. Hence mathematicians cannot satisfy themselves unless they reduce celestial motions to perfect circles, rejecting spiral lines and laboring to be discharged of eccentrics. He also notes they feign an element of fire to keep square with earth, water, and air.

    Chapter 40

  4. Why does Bacon say words entangle the understanding, and what remedy does he propose?

    Bacon argues words are framed according to the conceit and capacities of the vulgar sort and, like a Tartar's bow, shoot back upon the understanding of the wisest, mightily entangling judgment. He proposes imitating mathematicians by setting down definitions of terms at the very beginning of controversies, so others know how we accept and understand them.

    Chapter 40

Section 414 cards
  1. What two intentions does Bacon say the art of memory is built upon?

    Bacon states the art of memory rests on two intentions: prenotion and emblem. Prenotion narrows indefinite seeking by directing us to something congruent with our place of memory. Emblem converts intellectual conceits into sensible images, which strike the memory more strongly. From these, Bacon argues, better axioms and practices may be drawn than those currently in use.

    Chapter 41

  2. Why does Bacon judge the existing art of memory barren rather than dangerous?

    Bacon argues the art, as managed, may reach prodigious feats of ostentation but is barren in use—not burdensome or dangerous to natural memory as some imagine, but not dexterous for serious business and occasions. He compares feats like repeating many names or extempore verses to the tricks of tumblers and funambuloes: matters of strangeness without worthiness.

    Chapter 41

  3. According to Bacon, what are the two sorts of notes of cogitations?

    Bacon divides notes of cogitations into two sorts: those having similitude or congruity with the notion, and those ad placitum, having force only by contract or acceptation. Hieroglyphics and gestures belong to the first sort; gestures are called transitory hieroglyphics. Characters real and words belong to the second. Bacon notes the Chinese and High Levant use characters real expressing things or notions, not letters or words.

    Chapter 41

  4. What does Bacon say grammar's two duties are, and where is its use greatest?

    Bacon says grammar's duty is twofold: popular, for speedily and perfectly attaining languages for speech and understanding authors; and philosophical, examining the power and nature of words as footprints of reason. Its use is small in a mother tongue, more in a foreign tongue, and most in foreign tongues that have ceased to be vulgar and become learned tongues.

    Chapter 41

Section 424 cards
  1. What three virtues does Bacon say make ciphers preferable?

    Bacon states ciphers should be preferred by three virtues: that they be not laborious to write and read, that they be impossible to decipher, and, in some cases, that they be without suspicion. He adds that the highest degree is to write omnia per omnia, possible with a proportion quintuple at most of infolding to infolded writing, with no other restraint.

    Chapter 42

  2. How does Bacon distinguish magistral method from method of probation?

    Bacon divides method into that referred to use and that referred to progression. The first he calls magistral, the second of probation. He says the method of probation seems via deserta et interclusa, because as knowledge is now delivered there is a contract of error between deliverer and receiver: the author wants to be believed, not examined, and the learner wants present satisfaction rather than expectant inquiry.

    Chapter 42

  3. Why does Bacon say aphorisms test whether a writer is superficial or solid?

    Bacon argues aphorisms cut off illustration, examples, connection and order, and descriptions of practice, leaving only observation to fill them. Therefore no one can or will attempt aphorisms unless sound and grounded. By contrast, method lets a man make a great show of an art that, disjointed, would come to little. Aphorisms also invite further inquiry, while methods secure men as if at the furthest.

    Chapter 42

  4. What does Bacon mean by delivering knowledge as roots rather than slips?

    Bacon says knowledge delivered as a thread to be spun on should, if possible, be delivered in the same method in which it was invented. Though no man knows how he came to anticipated knowledge, he may revisit its foundations and transplant it into another mind. He compares this to plants: for use, roots do not matter, but to transplant and grow, roots are surer than slips.

    Chapter 42

Section 434 cards
  1. What does Bacon compare immoderate use of confutation to in delivering sciences?

    Bacon compares it to an army besieging every little fort instead of pursuing the main enterprise; if the field is kept, smaller things follow. He argues confutation should be used sparingly, only to remove strong preoccupations and prejudgments, not to stir up disputatious doubts.

    Chapter 43

  2. Why does Bacon reject a uniform method for all subjects?

    Bacon argues mathematics, the most abstract knowledge, differs greatly from policy, the most immersed, so particular methods of delivery are warranted. He says forcing uniformity reduces learning to empty, barren generalities—husks and shells of sciences with the kernel pressed out—and he allows particular topics for invention as well as particular methods of tradition.

    Chapter 43

  3. How should new knowledge foreign to received opinion be delivered?

    Bacon says it needs a different form than familiar knowledge: those whose conceits lie beyond popular opinions have double labour—to make themselves conceived and to prove and demonstrate—so they must use similitudes and translations. He notes Aristotle, in seeming to tax Democritus, actually commends him, and that in rude times the world was full of parables.

    Chapter 43

  4. What imposture method does Bacon criticize, and what is his counter-image?

    Bacon criticizes a method of imposture that delivers knowledge so men may quickly make a show of learning they lack, citing Raymundus Lullius's art and books of typocosmy—masses of words from all arts so users seem to understand. He compares such collections to a fripper's or broker's shop with ends of everything but nothing of worth.

    Chapter 43

Section 444 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what is the duty and office of rhetoric?

    Bacon states that the duty and office of rhetoric is to apply reason to imagination for the better moving of the will. Reason is disturbed by three means: illaqueation or sophism (logic), imagination or impression (rhetoric), and passion or affection (morality). The end of rhetoric is to fill the imagination to second reason, not to oppress it, for abuses of arts come in obliquely, for caution.

    Chapter 44

  2. Why does Bacon criticize Plato's view of rhetoric as cookery?

    Bacon calls it great injustice in Plato, springing from a just hatred of the rhetoricians of his time, to esteem rhetoric as a voluptuary art resembling cookery. Bacon argues speech is more conversant in adorning good than colouring evil, since no man speaks more honestly than he can do or think. He cites Thucydides on Cleon, who inveighed against eloquence because he held the bad side.

    Chapter 44

  3. Why is eloquence needed to win the imagination against the affections?

    Bacon argues that if the affections were pliant and obedient to reason, naked propositions and proofs would suffice. But because of the continual mutinies of the affections, reason would become captive unless eloquence wins the imagination from the affections' part, forming a confederacy between reason and imagination. The affection beholds merely the present, while reason beholds the future, so the present commonly vanquishes reason until persuasion makes future things appear present.

    Chapter 44

  4. What three defects does Bacon find in Aristotle's collection of rhetorical colours?

    Bacon says Aristotle began collecting the popular signs and colours of good and evil, which are as the sophisms of rhetoric. He finds three defects: first, there are but a few of many; second, the elenches (refutations) are not annexed; and third, Aristotle conceived but a part of their use, for their use is not only in probation but much more in impression. Bacon notes forms equal in signification differ in impression, as sharp and flat piercing differ.

    Chapter 44

Section 454 cards
  1. What error does Bacon attribute to critics correcting authors' texts?

    Bacon warns that rash diligence in correcting authors has done great prejudice: critics often presume that what they do not understand is falsely set down. He illustrates with a priest who changed "Demissus est per sportam" to "per portam" because sporta was a hard word outside his reading. Bacon says such errors, though less ridiculous, are of the same kind, and notes the most corrected copies are commonly the least correct.

    Chapter 45

  2. How does Bacon propose to remedy a child who is bird-witted?

    Bacon argues that every defect in the intellectual faculties seems to have a proper cure in some study. For a child who is bird-witted—lacking the faculty of attention—he prescribes mathematics as the remedy, because in mathematics if the wit wanders away for even a moment, one must begin anew. He adds that faculties also have a sympathy toward certain sciences for speedy profiting.

    Chapter 45

  3. What does Bacon say about ordering exercises, citing Cicero?

    Bacon holds that the ordering of exercises greatly matters for hurt or help. Citing Cicero, he notes that men exercising their faculties, if not well advised, exercise their faults and acquire ill habits as well as good. Therefore great judgment is needed in the continuance and intermission of exercises. He adds that such considerations are of mean appearance but singular efficacy, like the care of young plants.

    Chapter 45

  4. Why does Bacon say he altered the accepted divisions of knowledge?

    Bacon says a double necessity forced him to alter divisions. First, it differs in end and purpose to sort things next in nature versus next in use—like a secretary sorting papers by nature in his study but by use in his particular cabinet. Second, introducing the deficiencies altered the partitions of the rest: the parts of fifteen are not the parts of twenty. He does not disallow divisions he does not use.

    Chapter 45

Section 464 cards
  1. What omission does Bacon identify in existing writings on the will and appetite?

    Bacon argues that writers on the will and appetite supply only fair exemplars and copies of good, virtue, duty, and felicity, describing them as the true objects of man's will, but they pass over or handle slightly how to attain these marks and how to frame and subdue the will to conform to them. Scattered glances about habit, nature, doctrine, persuasion, reward, and punishment do not excuse this absence.

    Chapter 46

  2. What reason does Bacon give for this omission in moral knowledge?

    Bacon supposes the cause is that men have despised to be conversant in ordinary and common matters, whose judicious direction he calls the wisest doctrine, since life consists not in novelties nor subtleties. Instead they compounded sciences chiefly of a resplendent mass of matter chosen to glorify subtle disputation or eloquent discourse, a hidden rock on which many barks of knowledge are cast away.

    Chapter 46

  3. How does Bacon divide moral knowledge into its main parts?

    Bacon states the main and primitive division of moral knowledge is into the exemplar or platform of good, and the regiment or culture of the mind. The first describes the nature of good; the second prescribes rules for how to subdue, apply, and accommodate the will of man to it. He compares the latter to the Georgics of the mind, the husbandry and tillage thereof.

    Chapter 46

  4. What double nature of good does Bacon describe in all things?

    Bacon says there is formed in everything a double nature of good: one as each thing is a total or substantive in itself, the other as it is a part or member of a greater body. The latter is in degree greater and worthier because it tends to conserve a more general form. He illustrates with iron, which forsakes the loadstone when it exceeds a certain quantity and moves to the earth.

    Chapter 46

Section 474 cards
  1. According to Bacon, how does his principle decide the contemplative versus active life debate against Aristotle?

    Bacon argues Aristotle's reasons for the contemplative life are private, concerning a man's own pleasure and dignity, where contemplation indeed has pre-eminence. But Bacon insists that in the theatre of man's life only God and angels may be mere lookers-on; contemplation finished in itself, casting no beams on society, is unknown to divinity. He notes the Church defended monastic life only as not simply contemplative.

    Chapter 47

  2. Which schools does Bacon say place felicity in private repose rather than society?

    Bacon says the Cyrenaics and Epicureans placed felicity in pleasure, making virtue a servant to it; the reformed Epicureans placed it in serenity of mind and freedom from perturbation; and Herillus placed it in extinguishment of the mind's disputes, with no fixed nature of good and evil. Bacon says all these tend to private repose and contentment, not to society.

    Chapter 47

  3. How does Bacon criticize Epictetus's view that felicity lies in what is in our power?

    Bacon says Epictetus's philosophy presupposes felicity must rest in things within our power, to avoid fortune and disturbance. Bacon objects that it is far happier to fail in good and virtuous ends for the public than to obtain all one wishes privately. He cites Consalvo preferring to die one foot forward rather than retreat, and scripture's 'a good conscience is a continual feast.'

    Chapter 47

  4. What distinction does Bacon draw between active and passive good, and which does he rank higher?

    Bacon divides particular good into active and passive, likening them to the Roman promus and condus. He says creatures have two appetites: to preserve themselves and to dilate or multiply themselves, the latter seeming worthier, as heaven acts and earth is acted upon. He ranks active good higher, though it is not identical with the good of society, since it can serve private power and glory.

    Chapter 47

Section 484 cards
  1. How does Bacon divide passive good?

    Bacon subdivides passive good into conservative and effective (perfective). Preserving a thing in its state is the lesser; preserving it with advancement is the greater. He grounds this in a triple appetite impressed on all things: to preserve, to perfect, and to multiply their form. The multiplying he already treated as active good, so there remain conserving and perfecting, the latter being the highest degree of passive good.

    Chapter 48

  2. What question does Bacon say has not been inquired into regarding fruition?

    The good of fruition or contentment lies either in sincerity of enjoyment, produced by equality, or in quickness and vigour, produced by vicissitude. Bacon says which of these is the greater good is a controverted question, but whether man's nature may be capable of both is a question not inquired. He treats the second question as the one that, decided rightly, makes the first superfluous.

    Chapter 48

  3. How does Bacon characterize the philosophers' teachings on death and serenity?

    The author argues most philosophical doctrines are more fearful and cautious than the nature of things requires. By making life a preparation to die, they increase fear of death while claiming to cure it. He also says they seek to make minds too uniform, not breaking them to contrary motions, likely because they led private, unapplied lives. He urges procuring serenity without destroying magnanimity, like a jeweller grinding a flaw without wasting the stone.

    Chapter 48

  4. How does Bacon distinguish duty from virtue and from civil science?

    Duty concerns the good that respects society, while virtue applies to a mind well composed in itself; yet neither is understood without some relation to the other. Bacon says this part may seem to belong to civil and politic science, but it concerns each man's government of himself, not of others, as framing a building's parts differs from joining and erecting them. Duty divides into common duty as a man or member of a state, and special duty in one's profession, vocation, and place.

    Chapter 48

Section 494 cards
  1. What does Bacon identify as deficient in the treatment of frauds and vices of professions?

    Bacon argues that the frauds, cautels, impostures, and vices of every profession have been handled satirically and cynically rather than seriously and wisely. Men have sought by wit to deride and traduce what is good in professions rather than with judgment to discover and sever what is corrupt. He notes this managing of the argument with integrity and truth as deficient, calling it one of the best fortifications for honesty and virtue.

    Chapter 49

  2. Why does Bacon say we are beholden to Machiavelli and similar writers?

    Bacon says we are much beholden to Machiavelli and others who write what men do, not what they ought to do. He argues it is impossible to join serpentine wisdom with columbine innocency unless men know exactly all the conditions of the serpent—its baseness, volubility, envy, sting, and all forms of evil. Without this knowledge, virtue lies open and unfenced, and an honest man cannot reclaim the wicked.

    Chapter 49

  3. How does Bacon answer Jason of Thessalia's maxim about doing small injustice for great good?

    Jason of Thessalia held that some things must be done unjustly so that many may be done justly. Bacon rejects this, offering the reply: you have the author of present justice, but not the sponsor of future justice. Men must pursue things which are just in present and leave the future to Divine Providence. Bacon thus denies that future good justifies present injustice.

    Chapter 49

  4. What role does Bacon assign to moral philosophy in relation to sacred divinity?

    Bacon says the cure of men's minds truly belongs to sacred divinity, but moral philosophy may be preferred to her as a wise servant and humble handmaid. As the Psalm says the handmaid's eyes look perpetually toward the mistress, yet much is left to the handmaid's discretion; so moral philosophy should attend constantly to divinity's doctrines while yielding many sound and profitable directions within due limits.

    Chapter 49

Section 504 cards
  1. What two things does Bacon say are beyond our command in the culture of the mind?

    Bacon states that in the culture and cure of the mind, two things are without our command: points of Nature and points of fortune. Our work is limited and tied to the basis of the one and the conditions of the other. In these matters we can only proceed by application, not alteration, just as the farmer cannot command the earth or weather.

    Chapter 50

  2. What does Bacon identify as the first article of this knowledge of applying to minds?

    The first article is to set down sound and true distributions and descriptions of the several characters and tempers of men's natures and dispositions. This should especially regard differences most radical as fountains of the rest, or most frequent in concurrence. Bacon says handling a few in passing to describe virtues' mediocrities cannot satisfy this intention.

    Chapter 50

  3. What examples of external fortune does Bacon list as shaping the mind?

    Bacon lists sovereignty, nobility, obscure birth, riches, want, magistracy, privateness, prosperity, adversity, constant fortune, variable fortune, and rising per saltum or per gradus. He also includes inherent impressions from sex, age, region, health and sickness, and beauty and deformity. These observations, he argues, were never incorporated into moral philosophy though they essentially appertain to it.

    Chapter 50

  4. What complaint does Bacon make about existing observations of men's natures?

    Bacon complains that such observations wander in words but are not fixed in inquiry: the distinctions are found, but no precepts are concluded upon them. He says history, poesy, and daily experience are goodly fields where these observations grow, yet men make only a few posies to hold in their hands, and no one brings them to the confectionary to make receipts for use of life.

    Chapter 50

Section 514 cards
  1. What does Bacon say the poets and historians contribute to knowledge of the affections?

    The author argues that poets and writers of histories are the best doctors of this knowledge, vividly depicting how affections are kindled, pacified, restrained, disclosed, varied, and fortified, and how they intertwine and conflict. He singles out as especially useful in moral and civil matters the technique of setting one affection against another, as in hunting beast with beast, the foundation of reward and punishment.

    Chapter 51

  2. How does Bacon criticize Aristotle's treatment of the affections?

    Bacon finds it strange that Aristotle wrote volumes of Ethics yet never handled the affections, the principal subject thereof. In the Rhetorics, where affections are considered only collaterally as moved by speech, Aristotle handles them well for the quantity, but where their true place is he pretermits them. Bacon says disputations on pleasure and pain cannot satisfy this inquiry, since pleasure and pain relate to particular affections as light does to colours.

    Chapter 51

  3. What is Bacon's view of Aristotle's claim that custom cannot change what comes by nature?

    Bacon calls it a negligent opinion. He grants the principle holds where Nature is peremptory, but not where Nature admits a latitude. He counters with examples: a strait glove comes on more easily with use, a wand bends otherwise than it grew, voice grows louder and stronger with use, and enduring heat or cold improves with practice. These resemble manners more than Aristotle's stone example.

    Chapter 51

  4. What precepts does Bacon give for ordering the exercises of the mind?

    Bacon advises: avoid too high or too weak a strain at first, lest you discourage, breed sloth, or fail great tasks; practise chiefly at two times, when the mind is best and worst disposed; bear toward the contrary extreme of one's natural inclination, like rowing against the stream; and pursue aims not first in intention but tanquam aliud agendo, since the mind hates necessity and constraint.

    Chapter 51

Section 524 cards
  1. According to Bacon, why are ancient moral books of little effect on honesty of life?

    The author argues they are of little effect because they are not read and revolved by men in their mature and settled years, but are confined almost to boys and beginners. He links this to Aristotle's view that young men are unfit auditors of moral philosophy, being unsettled by the boiling heat of their affections and lacking time and experience.

    Chapter 52

  2. What caution does Bacon give about young men studying matters of policy?

    He says young men are even less fit auditors of policy until thoroughly seasoned in religion and morality, lest their judgments be corrupted into thinking there are no true differences of things except according to utility and fortune. He cites Machiavel's saying that had Caesar been overthrown he would have been more odious than Catiline.

    Chapter 52

  3. What two means does Bacon give for fixing the good hours of the mind and obliterating the evil?

    Fixing the good is practised by vows or constant resolutions, and by observances or exercises, valued not so much in themselves as because they keep the mind in continual obedience. Obliterating the evil is practised by some kind of redemption or expiation of the past, and by an inception or account de novo for the time to come. Bacon calls this part sacred and religious.

    Chapter 52

  4. Why does Bacon prefer setting good ends over acquiring virtue by habit?

    The author argues that electing and propounding good and virtuous ends within one's compass, pursued resolutely, moulds a man into all virtue at once, like nature forming all parts of a creature together, whereas habit is like a carver shaping one part while the rest stays rude stone. He cites Aristotle calling this state divine rather than virtuous.

    Chapter 52

Section 534 cards
  1. How does Bacon compare the good of the mind to the good of the body?

    Bacon notes a conformity between bodily and mental goods. As the body's good divides into health, beauty, strength, and pleasure, so the mind's good aims to make it sound and free from perturbation, beautiful and graced with decency, and strong and agile for all duties of life. He observes these three seldom meet and commonly sever, though two may sometimes combine and rarely all three.

    Chapter 53

  2. What three parts of civil knowledge does Bacon identify, and what actions of society correspond to them?

    Bacon divides civil knowledge into three parts matching society's three summary actions: conversation, negotiation, and government. Man seeks comfort, use, and protection in society, yielding three wisdoms of different natures that often sever: wisdom of behaviour, wisdom of business, and wisdom of state.

    Chapter 53

  3. According to Bacon, what is the true model of behavior in conversation?

    Bacon cites Livy's phrase that one should seem neither arrogant nor obnoxious, the first forgetting others' liberty and the second one's own. He concludes the sum of behavior is to retain one's own dignity without intruding upon the liberty of others. He also warns that over-cultivating outward carriage may pass into affectation, consume time, and steal from meditation.

    Chapter 53

  4. Why does Bacon argue the wisdom of business has been neglected in writing, and what consequence does he predict?

    Bacon argues the wisdom of business has not been collected into writing, to the derogation of learning and its professors. From this springs the opinion that there is no great concurrence between learning and wisdom. He predicts that if books were written on business, learned men with mean experience would far excel men of long experience without learning.

    Chapter 53

Section 544 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what did ancient Roman senators like Coruncanius and Lælius do in the Place?

    Bacon reports, citing Cicero, that senators reputed generally wise—such as Coruncanius, Curius, and Lælius—walked at certain hours in the Place and gave audience to citizens seeking advice on private matters like marrying a daughter, employing a son, a purchase, or an accusation. Bacon argues this shows a wisdom of counsel in private causes, gathered by general observation of like causes.

    Chapter 54

  2. What does Bacon say the book De petitione consulatus by Q. Cicero consists of?

    Bacon calls it the only book of business written by the ancients that he knows. Though it concerned a particular action then on foot, its substance consists of many wise and politic axioms containing not a temporary but a perpetual direction in the case of popular elections. Bacon uses it as evidence that counsel can be reduced to general precepts.

    Chapter 54

  3. What does Bacon draw from the proverb about the poor wise man who saved the small city?

    Bacon reads the proverb as setting forth the corruption of states that esteem virtue or merit no longer than they have use of it: the poor wise man delivered the city by his wisdom, yet no one afterward remembered him. Bacon presents this as a lesson about how commonwealths treat merit once its utility has passed.

    Chapter 54

  4. How does Bacon compare a judge who respects persons with a briber?

    Bacon says a judge would be better to be a briber than a respecter of persons, for a corrupt judge offends not so lightly as a facile one. He cites the proverb that one who knows a face in judgment does not do well and will desert truth for a morsel of bread, ranking favoritism as the graver judicial fault.

    Chapter 54

Section 554 cards
  1. According to Bacon, why should one avoid reproving arrogant and scornful natures?

    Bacon cites the proverb that he who instructs a scorner does himself injury, and he who rebukes the wicked gets himself a stain. Such natures treat reproof as contumely and return it accordingly. The caution is about how we offer reprehension to the arrogant, whose habit is to resent correction and repay it with hostility.

    Chapter 55

  2. What distinction does Bacon draw from 'Da sapienti occasionem'?

    Bacon distinguishes wisdom brought into habit from wisdom that is merely verbal and swimming in conceit. The habitual kind, when an occasion is presented, is quickened and redoubled; the merely verbal kind is amazed and confused by the same occasion. So the proverb separates practiced wisdom from wisdom that exists only in words.

    Chapter 55

  3. Why does Bacon prefer discourse built on examples rather than examples cited for discourse?

    Bacon argues that when the example is the ground, set down in a history at large with all its circumstances, it can control or supply the discourse and serve as a pattern for action. Examples cited for the discourse's sake are given succinctly, without particularity, and carry a servile aspect toward the discourse they support. He calls this a difference of substance, not order.

    Chapter 55

  4. How does Bacon say the maxim 'every man is the maker of his own fortune' should be used?

    Bacon says such positions, taken as spurs to industry rather than stirrups to insolency, for resolution rather than presumption or outward declaration, are sound and good. Declared and professed too much, they are impolitic and unlucky, as with Timotheus, who credited fortune with no part and never prospered afterward. Great politiques ascribed success to felicity, not skill.

    Chapter 55

Section 564 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what is the most summary precept for prevailing in fortune?

    Bacon says the most summary precept for prevailing in fortune is to obtain the "window" Momus demanded: to procure good information of particulars about persons—their natures, desires, ends, customs, helps, weaknesses, friends, factions, and enemies—and also about actions, how they are conducted, favored, and opposed. He calls such particulars the minor propositions of every active syllogism.

    Chapter 56

  2. What does Bacon say about trusting words versus countenances and deeds?

    Bacon advises slowness of belief and distrust, giving more trust to countenances and deeds than to words, and among words preferring sudden, surprised speech over set, purposed speech. He rejects the saying "Fronti nulla fides" as applying only to general outward behavior, not to subtle motions of countenance, which he calls the gate of the mind.

    Chapter 56

  3. Why does Bacon warn that deeds cannot be trusted without considering their magnitude and nature?

    Bacon warns that fraud builds credit for itself in small things to deceive with greater profit later, and that small favors merely lull men asleep as to caution and industry—Demosthenes' "food of sloth." He also cites Mutianus, who under pretense of strengthening Antonius Primus gave offices to his friends and thereby desolated him and won away his dependents.

    Chapter 56

  4. From whom are men's weaknesses, virtues, customs, and opinions best learned, according to Bacon?

    Bacon says weaknesses and faults are best known from enemies, virtues and abilities from friends, customs and times from servants, and conceits and opinions from familiar friends with whom men discourse most. General fame is light and the opinions of superiors or equals are deceitful, since men wear more masks before them; truer report emanates from those within the household.

    Chapter 56

Section 574 cards
  1. What three things make up the most compendious way of inquiry?

    Bacon names three: first, gaining acquaintance with those who look most into the world, including a private, well-informed friend for each kind of business; second, keeping a good mediocrity between liberty of speech and secrecy, using liberty in most things and secrecy where it matters; third, reducing oneself to a watchful and serene habit of observing as well as acting in every conference and action.

    Chapter 57

  2. What caution does Bacon attach to obtaining good information?

    Bacon warns that above all things men must take good hold of themselves, so that much knowing does not draw on much meddling. He calls light and rash intermeddling in many matters the most unfortunate thing. The variety of knowledge should serve only to make a better and freer choice of actions that concern us, conducted with less error and more dexterity.

    Chapter 57

  3. How does Bacon advise judging one's nature against the times?

    Bacon says to consider how the constitution of one's nature sorts with the general state of the times. If agreeable and fit, give oneself more scope and liberty; if differing and dissonant, be more close, retired, and reserved throughout life. He cites Tiberius, never seen at a play and absent from the senate twelve years, versus Augustus, who lived ever in men's eyes, as Tacitus observes.

    Chapter 57

  4. What error does Bacon identify in guiding oneself by examples?

    Bacon warns against thinking one can do as others do when natures and carriages differ greatly. He says Pompey fell into this error, often saying 'Sylla potuit, ego non potero?' Cicero notes Pompey was much abused, since his nature and proceedings were the unlikest in the world to Sylla's: the one fierce, violent, and pressing the fact; the other solemn, full of majesty and circumstance, and therefore less effectual.

    Chapter 57

Section 584 cards
  1. What three methods does Bacon give for covering defects?

    Bacon names caution, colour, and confidence. Caution means discreetly avoiding tasks one is unfit for, while bold spirits thrust themselves in and expose their wants. Colour means framing a plausible excuse so faults seem to proceed from a better cause, or pretending the virtue that shadows the want. Confidence, the last but surest remedy, means seeming to despise what one cannot attain.

    Chapter 58

  2. How does Bacon illustrate 'confidence' using the example of poets?

    Bacon describes a confidence that faces out defects: seeming to think oneself best where one is failing, and least confident where one is best. He compares this to poets who, when a line is criticized, say it cost them more labour than any other, then pretend to doubt some other line they know is the best in the piece.

    Chapter 58

  3. According to Bacon, why is a pliant mind obedient to occasion so important?

    Bacon argues nothing hinders fortunes more than staying as one was when occasions turn, quoting 'Idem manebat, neque idem decebat.' He cites Livy on Cato's versatile ingenium, and notes grave solemn wits who cannot make departures have more dignity than felicity. He lists causes of restiveness: nature, conceit from past success, want of judgment, and reluctance to lose past labours.

    Chapter 58

  4. What does Bacon conclude about continual dissimulation as a political method?

    Bacon contrasts men like Sylla, Caesar, and Augustus, who professed their desires openly and prospered, with Pompey, who pursued the same ends darkly through secret engines and failed because men understood him not. Bacon concludes, following Tacitus, that the continual habit of dissimulation is but a weak and sluggish cunning, not greatly politic.

    Chapter 58

Section 594 cards
  1. According to Bacon, what is the first pursuit in marshalling men's pursuits toward fortune?

    Bacon holds that the amendment of one's own mind comes first, because removing the impediments of the mind clears the passages of fortune sooner than obtaining fortune removes the impediments of the mind. He places wealth and means second, reputation third, and honour last, arguing honour is more easily won by the other three than they can be purchased by honour.

    Chapter 59

  2. What error does Bacon identify in men who judge things by the labour spent on them?

    Bacon says some men measure things by the labour, difficulty, or assiduity spent about them, thinking that if they are ever moving they must advance. He cites Caesar's contemptuous description of Cato the second as laborious and indefatigable to no great purpose: Hæc omnia magno studio agebat. Bacon concludes men wrongly think the greatest means best, when it should be the fittest.

    Chapter 59

  3. What does Bacon mean by imitating nature, which does nothing in vain?

    Bacon advises interlacing business and not bending the mind too much on what one principally intends. In every action a man should have one thing under another: if he cannot get what he seeks in the best degree, then in a second or third; if no part, turn its use to something else; if nothing for the present, make it a seed for the future; if no substance, win good opinion by it.

    Chapter 59

  4. What does Bacon's fable of the two frogs illustrate about engagement?

    Bacon advises not to engage oneself peremptorily in anything, even what seems not liable to accident, but always to keep a window to fly out at or a way to retire. In the fable, when their plash dried, one frog proposed a pit because the water was unlikely to dry there; the other replied that if it did dry, they could not get out again.

    Chapter 59

Section 604 cards
  1. What deficiency does Bacon note in writings about law?

    Bacon argues that all writers on law have written either as philosophers or as lawyers, never as statesmen. Philosophers make imaginary laws for imaginary commonwealths, like stars giving little light because they are so high; lawyers write what is received law in their states, not what ought to be law. The wisdom of a law-maker differs from that of a lawyer.

    Chapter 60

  2. What does Bacon say about the secrecy of government versus governors' disclosure?

    Bacon holds that government itself is secret and retired, either because hard to know or unfit to utter, like God's government of the world and the soul's government of the body. Contrariwise, governors toward the governed should make all things manifest as far as human frailty permits, so that the people's natures, factions, and discontents lie clear before princes and senates.

    Chapter 60

  3. How does Bacon compare the pursuit of fortune by evil arts versus the fair way?

    Bacon says evil principles—such as Machiavelli's appearance-of-virtue, rule by fear, or deceiving men with oaths—may make the pressing of a man's fortune more hasty and compendious. Yet he concludes that in life as in ways, the shortest way is commonly the foulest, and the fairer way is not much about, meaning not much longer.

    Chapter 60

  4. What two foundations does Bacon contrast regarding the pursuit of fortune?

    Bacon contrasts the human foundation, which has somewhat of the sands, illustrated by Brutus's complaint that Virtus is an empty name, with the divine foundation upon the rock. He joins divinity and philosophy in the precept Primum quærite: seek first the kingdom of God, or the goods of the mind, and the rest will either be added or not harm.

    Chapter 60

Section 614 cards
  1. Why does Bacon say England's laws excel the civil law?

    Bacon says he could note both the dignity and some defect of England's laws, but that they must excel the civil law in fitness for government, because the civil law was nonhos quæsitum munus in usus—not made for the countries it governs. He then stops, declining to mix matter of action with matter of general learning.

    Chapter 61

  2. What image does Bacon use for his own work at the pause?

    Judging his own work as far as a man can, Bacon likens it to the noise musicians make while tuning their instruments—unpleasant to hear, yet the cause the music is sweeter afterward. He was content to tune the instruments of the Muses so that others with better hands might play.

    Chapter 61

  3. What reasons does Bacon give for expecting a third period of learning to surpass Greece and Rome?

    Bacon cites the vivacity of this age's wits, help from ancient writers, printing, navigation disclosing experiments and natural history, leisure, present peace, exhaustion of religious controversy, the king's learning, and time's property of ever disclosing more truth. He argues this third period will far surpass the Greek and Roman, if men know their own strength and weakness.

    Chapter 61

  4. How does Bacon distinguish the two senses of the light of nature regarding morality?

    Bacon says the light of nature means either what springs from reason, sense, induction, and argument, or what is imprinted on man's spirit by inward instinct according to the law of conscience, a sparkle of his first estate. In the latter sense only is man participant of some light touching the moral law—sufficient to check vice but not to inform duty.

    Chapter 61

Section 624 cards
  1. How does Bacon distinguish the two uses of reason in religion?

    Bacon distinguishes reason used in conceiving and apprehending revealed mysteries, which works only by illustration and not argument, from reason used in inferring and deriving doctrine, which does consist of probation and argument. The first accommodates God's mysteries to human capacity; the second is permitted only as secondary and respective, not original and absolute, once the articles of religion are exempted from reason's examination.

    Chapter 62

  2. What comparison does Bacon draw between religion, games like chess, and human laws?

    Bacon argues that in religion, as in chess and human laws, there are posita and placita that are positive and not examinable by reason. The first laws of a game are merely ad placitum, yet directing play to win is rational; likewise legal maxims are placita juris upon authority, while what is just relatively according to them affords disputation. So too divinity rests on the placets of God.

    Chapter 62

  3. What deficiency does Bacon note regarding reason in spiritual things?

    Bacon notes it has not been sufficiently inquired and handled what the true limits and use of reason in spiritual things are, a kind of divine dialectic. Because this is undone, men search into what is not revealed under pretext of conceiving what is revealed, and examine what is positive under pretext of drawing out inferences. He compares these errors to Nicodemus and to the scandalised disciples.

    Chapter 62

  4. How does Bacon distinguish fundamental from non-fundamental points of doctrine?

    Bacon advises that fundamental points and points of further perfection be distinguished with piety and wisdom. Using Moses, he says an Egyptian point of doctrine must be slain by the sword of the Spirit, but an Israelite point, though wrong, prompts "why strive you?" Christ's rule: on fundamentals, he who is not with us is against us; on non-fundamentals, he who is not against us is with us.

    Chapter 62

Section 634 cards
  1. Why does Bacon say summary abridgments ultimately expand rather than shrink knowledge?

    Bacon argues that contraction makes a summary obscure; obscurity then requires exposition, and exposition grows into large commentaries or commonplaces vaster than the original writings. He cites the schoolmen's volumes exceeding the fathers' writings, and modern civil-law doctors exceeding the ancient jurisconsults compiled in the digest. Thus sums and commentaries make sciences more immense in quantity and more base in substance.

    Chapter 63

  2. What is Bacon's verdict on reducing knowledge into exact methods for strength?

    Bacon says exact methods show strength because parts seem to support each other, but this is more satisfactory than substantial—like buildings held by architecture and compaction, more subject to ruin than those strong in their several parts though less compacted. He adds that the more you recede from your grounds, the weaker you conclude, and in divinity the more you recede from Scripture by inferences, the weaker your positions.

    Chapter 63

  3. Why does Bacon hold that completeness or perfection should not be sought in divinity?

    Bacon argues that whoever reduces a knowledge into an art makes it round and uniform, but in divinity many things must be left abrupt, concluded with "O altitudo sapientiæ et scientiæ Dei!" and "Ex parte scimus." To have the form of a total where there is only matter for a part requires supplies by supposition and presumption. He concludes sums and methods belong in institutions or introductions, but handling the main body of knowledge by them is prejudicial in all sciences and dangerous in divinity.

    Chapter 63

  4. Why does Bacon reject seeking natural philosophy in Scripture, as the school of Paracelsus did?

    Bacon says there is no enmity between God's Word and His works; those who seek all natural philosophy in Scripture do not honour it but embase it. Seeking heaven and earth in the Word is seeking temporary things among eternal—like seeking the living among the dead. Scripture's scope is not to express matters of nature except in passage, for application to man's capacity and to moral or divine matters; citing a basilisk or unicorn as illustration does not affirm it as fact.

    Chapter 63

Section 644 cards
  1. Which form of divinity writing does Bacon judge most rich and precious?

    The author argues that the most rich and precious form of writing in divinity is positive divinity collected upon particular texts of Scripture in brief observations — not dilated into commonplaces, not chasing controversies, not reduced into method of art. He notes this abounds in sermons, which vanish, but is defective in books, which remain.

    Chapter 64

  2. Into what four main branches does Bacon say divinity divides?

    Bacon states that from the two kinds of matter — belief and truth of opinion, and service and adoration — issue four main branches of divinity: faith, manners, liturgy, and government. Faith contains doctrine of God's nature, attributes, and works; manners concerns the law disclosing sin; liturgy covers reciprocal acts between God and man; government covers the Church's patrimony, franchises, offices, and laws.

    Chapter 64

  3. How does Bacon distinguish heresy, idolatry, and witchcraft?

    Bacon defines three declinations from religion besides privative atheism: heresy, when we serve the true God with a false worship; idolatry, when we worship false gods supposing them true; and witchcraft, when we adore false gods knowing them to be wicked and false. He credits the monarch's observation that witchcraft is the height of idolatry, and cites Samuel to say all are of one nature once there is receding from the Word of God.

    Chapter 64

  4. What does Bacon say about the heathen religion's lack of a soul?

    Bacon argues the heathen religion was not only a worship of idols but the whole religion was an idol in itself, for it had no soul — no certainty of belief or confession. He reasons the chief doctors of their church were the poets, and their gods were not jealous gods but glad to be admitted into part, nor did they respect purity of heart so long as external honour and rites were paid.

    Chapter 64

Source and licence

Text used: Project Gutenberg eBook #5500 (Public domain in the United States). Generated from the full text; cards paraphrase the source.

Version: Public domain edition. Retrieved 2026-11-19. Cards reviewed 2026-11-19.

These cards paraphrase the text for study. They are not a substitute for reading the book, and they do not reproduce long passages.

Turn your own notes into cards

Upload a PDF, Word, or text file and get question-and-answer cards for closed-notes practice. Five cards are free, no signup.

Try 5 free cards