Book Cards

The Antiquity of Man Flashcards

Charles Lyell’s The Antiquity of Man argues that human existence predates the conventionally accepted biblical chronology, using geological evidence to place humans alongside extinct animals. This deck covers the book’s central arguments, key fossil and cave discoveries, glacial-period interpretations, and Lyell’s cautious stance on transmutation and the “Missing Link.”

1 / 442

Chapter 1 · Question

What does the introduction say Uniformitarianism means?

WakeCards · wakecards.com · Big ideas. Quick review.

Arrow keys move between cards. Space or Enter flips.

All questions and answers

Every card in the deck, in reading order. Click a chapter to expand. The reviewer above uses the same content.

Section 14 cards
  1. What does the introduction say Uniformitarianism means?

    The introduction sums up Uniformitarianism as "THE PRESENT IS THE KEY TO THE PAST": past processes were the same in general character as those now observed, though probably differing in degree. It contrasts this with the Catastrophic school, which attributed past changes to sudden violent convulsions that destroyed all living beings, followed by fresh creation. The introduction adds that Uniformitarianism does not mean things have always been the same, only similar.

    Chapter 1

  2. How does the introduction describe Lyell's method and response to error?

    The introduction says the keynote of Lyell's work was observation: he was no cabinet geologist but studied phenomena at first hand, travelling widely with ample leisure and means, patiently collecting material and building on foundations laid by Hutton and Playfair. When later research showed his inferences wrong, he never hesitated to say so, unlike some contemporaries. The introduction calls this the only true path to scientific progress.

    Chapter 1

  3. Why did Lyell work backward from recent formations, and what drawback does the introduction note?

    Lyell began with the most recent formations and worked from the known to the unknown. The introduction says modern readers see this as his work's greatest drawback, since it makes studying events in their actual sequence difficult. But given the state of geology before his time, the course was almost inevitable: later rocks were fairly well known through William Smith and others, while lower strata had many gaps and no definite base.

    Chapter 1

  4. What does the introduction conclude about early human remains and the "Missing Link"?

    The introduction says the Neanderthal skull is of a low type but more human than ape-like, and the same applies still more strongly to the Engis skull, the man of Spy, the Sussex skull and other early human remains; only Pithecanthropus of Java shows perhaps more affinity to the apes. It also notes that attempts to prove pre-glacial human existence have not met general acceptance, since in no case is the evidence beyond doubt.

    Chapter 1

Section 24 cards
  1. How did Lyell and most geologists of his day explain Britain during the glacial period?

    Lyell, in common with most geologists of his day, assumed that during the glacial period the British Isles were submerged under the sea to a depth of many hundreds of feet, at least in the region north of a line drawn from London to Bristol. Later authors instead proposed a vast Greenland-type ice-sheet descending from the mountains of Scotland and Scandinavia.

    Chapter 2

  2. What did Penck and Bruckner establish about Alpine glaciation?

    The researches of Penck and Bruckner in the Alps established four glaciations separated by mild interglacial periods. The chapter notes that not all of these can be clearly traced in Britain. This work supports the recognition that the glaciation of Europe was not one continuous process but several episodes separated by warm interglacial periods.

    Chapter 2

  3. To which peoples did the chapter note Palaeolithic man shows affinities?

    The chapter states that one very important point is the recognition of the affinities of certain types of Palaeolithic man to the Eskimo, the Australians, and the Bushmen of South Africa. The chapter presents this as a result of recent research and declines to review the whole subject, referring readers to works cited in the notes.

    Chapter 2

  4. How does the editor R.H. Rastall judge Lyell's Antiquity of Man despite its errors?

    Rastall argues that piling up criticism on points of detail would be easy but thankless. He says most readers will feel astonishment and admiration at Lyell's insight and breadth of view, given the thorny subject and scanty material. He calls the book eminently successful and one of the classics of prehistoric archaeology.

    Chapter 2

Section 34 cards
  1. Where was the fossil human skeleton found that Lyell discusses in Chapter 5?

    Lyell reports a human skeleton found in a cave near Dusseldorf, in the Neanderthal. He describes its geological position and probable age, and notes its abnormal and ape-like characters. He compares this skull and the Engis skull from near Liege with extreme varieties of the native Australian race, drawing on Professor Huxley's descriptions and conclusions.

    Chapter 3

  2. What did Boucher de Perthes discover at Abbeville, and what did the Brixham Cave exploration add?

    M. Boucher de Perthes discovered flint implements in drift containing extinct mammalia in the valleys near Abbeville; similar implements were found at St. Acheul near Amiens. Systematic exploration of the Brixham Cave later revealed flint knives together with bones of extinct mammalia, and the superposition of deposits in the cave was recorded. English and French geologists then visited Abbeville and Amiens.

    Chapter 3

  3. What did Lyell conclude about the earliest known date of man relative to existing fauna and flora?

    In Chapter 12 Lyell argues that the earliest known date of man is long subsequent to the existing fauna and flora. He reaches this after examining the Norfolk and Suffolk Tertiary deposits preceding the Glacial Period, the gradual refrigeration shown by successive marine shell groups, and the great oscillations of level implied by the Norfolk cliff strata.

    Chapter 3

  4. What did Lyell argue about the bearing of the Neanderthal skull's peculiar characters on transmutation?

    Chapter 5 lists among its topics the bearing of the peculiar characters of the Neanderthal skull on the hypothesis of transmutation. Lyell presents Professor Huxley's description and conclusions comparing the Neanderthal and Engis skulls with extreme varieties of the native Australian race, and discusses the range of capacity in human and simian brains, including a skull from Borreby in Denmark.

    Chapter 3

Section 44 cards
  1. What successive ages does Lyell recapitulate as evidence of man's antiquity?

    Lyell recapitulates the Ages of Stone and Bronze, drawing on Danish peat and kitchen-middens and Swiss lake-dwellings. He notes local changes in vegetation, in wild and domesticated animals, and in physical geography that were coeval with the Bronze Age and the later Stone Period, and he offers estimates of positive dates for some later Stone Period deposits.

    Chapter 4

  2. How does Lyell divide the Age of Stone, and what migration does he infer?

    Lyell distinguishes an ancient division of the Age of Stone, represented at St. Acheul and Aurignac, from the later Stone Period. He argues that in that ancient period man migrated from the Continent to England in post-Glacial times, and he stresses the slow rate of progress characteristic of barbarous ages.

    Chapter 4

  3. What doctrine about early mankind does Lyell examine, and whose opinions does he compare?

    Lyell considers the doctrine of the superior intelligence and endowments of the original stock of mankind. He compares the opinions of the Greeks and Romans with those of the modern progressionist, finding a coincidence between them. The chapter thus weighs the idea of original human superiority against progressionist views.

    Chapter 4

  4. What does Lyell say about defining species and race, and about Lamarck?

    Lyell notes the difficulty of defining the terms 'species' and 'race,' and credits Lamarck with introducing the element of time into the definition of a species. He sets out Lamarck's theory of variation and progression and asks how far objections to it are answered, while also weighing modern arguments for progression in the animal and vegetable world.

    Chapter 4

Section 54 cards
  1. What did the 1858 Brixham cave investigation change about cave evidence?

    The systematic investigation of the Brixham cave near Torquay in Devonshire in 1858 renewed public curiosity and prepared the way for general admission that scepticism about cave evidence for the antiquity of Man had been pushed to an extreme. Before this, extreme reluctance to accept such evidence was natural, since caves had successive tenants, served as places of domicile and sepulture, and could be flooded, mingling remains from more than one era in a single deposit.

    Chapter 5

  2. How did Lyell define the Eocene, Miocene, and Pliocene terms?

    Lyell proposed the names in 1833, classing Tertiary strata by the proportion of fossil testacea identical with living species. Eocene, from Greek eos (dawn) and kainos (recent), marked the dawn of the present testaceous fauna. Miocene (meion, less) expressed a minor proportion of Recent species; Pliocene (pleion, more) a comparative plurality. He notes the terms were invented purely on conchological data and are still used by him in that sense.

    Chapter 5

  3. What percentages of living species did Deshayes find in the Tertiary groups?

    After comparing 3000 fossil species with 5000 living ones, Deshayes found about 3 1/2 per cent identical with Recent in the lower Tertiary strata; about 17 per cent in the middle Tertiary (the faluns of the Loire and Gironde); and from 35 to 50, sometimes as much as 90 to 95 per cent, in the upper Tertiary, especially the most modern beds. Lyell reports these results as independent confirmation of his own views.

    Chapter 5

  4. Why did Lyell visit England, France, and Belgium and study glacial formations?

    Lyell says that to qualify himself for appreciating and discussing the new cases bearing on human antiquity, he visited many parts of England, France, and Belgium over three years and corresponded with English and foreign geologists involved in the research. He also describes the glacial formations of Europe and North America to consider their chronological relation to the human epoch and why they often interpose an abrupt barrier to tracing Man's existence farther back.

    Chapter 5

Section 64 cards
  1. How does Lyell define the Recent and Pleistocene groups?

    Lyell places in the Recent those deposits in which not only all the shells but all the fossil mammalia are of living species. In the Pleistocene, the shells are Recent but a portion, often considerable, of the accompanying fossil quadrupeds belongs to extinct species. He admits the line between Newer Pliocene and Pleistocene, or Pleistocene and Recent, may be scarcely possible to draw, and expects such difficulties to increase as gaps in the geological record are filled.

    Chapter 6

  2. What three ages did Danish and Swedish antiquaries establish, and from what are they named?

    Nilsson, Steenstrup, Forchhammer, Thomsen, Worsaae and others established a chronological succession of periods called the ages of stone, of bronze, and of iron, named from the materials that each in turn served for fabricating implements. The implements were studied from peat, coastal sand-dunes, and shell-mounds. The stone age coincided with the Scotch fir vegetation and partly the oak epoch; bronze largely with the oak; iron corresponded more nearly with the beech.

    Chapter 6

  3. What evidence links the Scotch fir in Danish peat to human presence?

    The Scotch fir is not now, nor has been in historical times, native to the Danish Islands, and has not thriven when introduced. Yet it was evidently indigenous in the human period, for Steenstrup took a flint instrument out of the peat from below a buried trunk of one of these pines. The fir was later supplanted by the sessile oak, and still higher the pedunculated oak occurs with alder, birch, and hazel; the beech has now almost superseded the oak.

    Chapter 6

  4. Why does Morlot say bronze-working implies great skill, and what does the pottery show?

    Morlot observes that introducing bronze tools to a people ignorant of metals implies great advance, since bronze is an alloy of about nine parts copper to one of tin. Tin is scarce and never occurs native; detecting it in ore, disengaging it, blending it with copper, and casting the mixture to harden by slow cooling bespeaks sagacity and skilful manipulation. Pottery associated with bronze weapons is more ornamental than any of the stone age; moulds and bronze tags have been found, and the variety of objects indicates long duration.

    Chapter 6

Section 74 cards
  1. What did Lyell suggest about an age of copper between stone and bronze in Europe?

    Lyell notes it has been suggested that an age of copper always intervened between stone and bronze, but if so the interval seems short in Europe, apparently because the aboriginal inhabitants were invaded and conquered by an eastern people already familiar with bronze weapons. Copper hatchets, however, have been found in the Danish peat.

    Chapter 7

  2. Why does Lyell say iron-working marks a greater advance than bronze?

    Lyell argues iron never occurs native except in meteorites, so recognizing its ores and separating the metal from its matrix demands considerable observation and invention. Fusing the ore requires intense heat, obtainable only with artificial appliances such as pipes inflated by human breath, bellows, or similar machinery.

    Chapter 7

  3. What are Danish kitchen-middens and what do they contain?

    The Danish shell-mounds, or Kjokkenmodding, are coastal mounds of cast-away oyster, cockle, and other shells mixed with bones of quadrupeds, birds, and fish eaten by rude hunters and fishers. Scattered through them are flint knives, hatchets, and implements of stone, horn, wood, and bone, with coarse pottery, charcoal, and cinders, but never bronze or iron implements.

    Chapter 7

  4. What evidence do the embedded shells give for the antiquity of the kitchen-middens?

    The shells are all living species, but the eatable oyster attains full size, though Ostrea edulis cannot now live in the brackish Baltic except near its entrance. The cockle, mussel, and periwinkle are of ordinary ocean dimensions, whereas the same species now in the Baltic are stunted to a third of their natural size. Lyell infers the ocean then had freer access to the Baltic.

    Chapter 7

Section 84 cards
  1. What evidence suggests the Danish mound-builders were not cannibals?

    The author states the ancient people were not cannibals because no human bones were mingled with the spoils of the chase in the mounds. Skulls were obtained separately from peat and from stone-period tumuli believed contemporaneous with the mounds, but these were not found mixed with food remains.

    Chapter 8

  2. How do skull shapes differ between the stone, bronze, and iron periods in Denmark?

    Stone-period skulls from peat and tumuli are small, round, with a prominent ridge over the orbits, suggesting a short race with round heads and overhanging eyebrows, resembling modern Laplanders. Bronze-age and iron-period skulls from Danish peat are elongated and larger. The author notes few well-authenticated bronze-period crania exist, probably because that era burned its dead and collected the bones in urns.

    Chapter 8

  3. What sequence of forest trees does the chapter use to argue for the antiquity of Danish peat?

    The author argues that in Roman times the Danish Isles were covered with beech forests, as now, with little change in eighteen centuries. In the preceding bronze period there were no beech trees, or few stragglers, and oak covered the country. In the stone age the Scotch fir prevailed, with human inhabitants already present. Steenstrup and other authorities estimate the peat's formation required at least 4000 years, possibly four times as much.

    Chapter 8

  4. What did the 1853-54 dredging at Meilen on Lake Zurich reveal?

    During the dry winter of 1853-54, when lakes and rivers sank lower than previously known, inhabitants of Meilen dredged mud to raise land and found wooden piles deeply driven into the lake bed, along with hammers, axes, celts, and other stone-period instruments. Exceptions were an armlet of thin brass wire and a small bronze hatchet. Rude hand-fashioned pottery and masses of charred wood were also abundant.

    Chapter 8

Section 94 cards
  1. What did the profuse flint chippings at Moosseedorf imply about that site?

    At Moosseedorf, near Berne, implements of stone, horn, and bone were found but none of metal. Although the flint must have come from a distance, probably the south of France, the chippings were so profuse that they imply a manufactory of implements existed on the spot. Hatchets and wedges of jade and amber, supposedly imported from the Baltic, were also observed there.

    Chapter 9

  2. How did diet differ between the earliest stone age and later periods at Swiss lake settlements?

    Comparison of bones from different sites shows that at early stone-age settlements such as Wangen and Moosseedorf, when hunting habits predominated over pastoral ones, venison (stag and roe) was eaten more than domestic cattle and sheep. This was reversed in the later stone period and the bronze age. The tame pig, absent from some oldest stations, later replaced the wild boar as common food.

    Chapter 9

  3. How do the animal remains from Swiss lake-dwellings compare with Danish kitchen-middens?

    Professor Rutimeyer's treatise lists twenty-four wild mammalia, eighteen birds, three reptiles, and nine freshwater fish, totaling fifty-four species, all but one (the wild bull, Bos primigenius) still living in Europe. The bones bear the same relation to primitive Swiss inhabitants as kitchen-midden contents do to ancient Baltic fishing and hunting tribes. Most served for food, and marrow bones were split open as in Denmark.

    Chapter 9

  4. What change in fauna occurred between the first stone age and the bronze age?

    The fox was very common in the first era but nearly disappears in the bronze age, during which a large hunting-dog, supposed imported from abroad, becomes the chief representative of the canine genus. The reindeer is missing from the Swiss lake-settlements, as from the Danish kitchen-middens, though it once ranged over France with the mammoth as far south as the Pyrenees.

    Chapter 9

Section 104 cards
  1. What evidence suggests Swiss lake-dwellers avoided eating hare?

    Only a single fragment of hare bone (Lepus timidus) has been found at Moosseedorf. The near-total absence of this quadruped is supposed to imply the lake-dwellers were prevented from eating it by the same superstition that prevailed among the Laplanders and that Julius Caesar found in full force among the ancient Britons. Rutimeyer notes the contrast: they fed largely on fox yet abstained from hare.

    Chapter 10

  2. How did domesticated cattle differ from wild Bos primigenius?

    In a tame state the bones of Bos primigenius were somewhat less massive and heavy, and the horns somewhat smaller, than in wild individuals, though in domesticated form it still rivalled the largest living cattle, such as those of Friesland. Rutimeyer, agreeing with Cuvier and Bell, considered northern Europe's larger domestic cattle descendants of this wild bull, an opinion Owen disputes.

    Chapter 10

  3. How can osteologists distinguish tame from wild races by skeletons alone?

    Among other characters, they rely on the diminished thickness of the bones and the comparatively smaller ridges that afford attachment to muscles; also the smaller tusks in the boar and smaller whole jaw and skull, and the diminished horns of the bull. These modifications are attributed to a regular supply of food and the absence of any need to exert strength to obtain subsistence or defend against enemies.

    Chapter 10

  4. How did Morlot date the Tiniere delta layers?

    Morlot used three buried vegetable soil layers in the delta's flattened cone, exposed in a railway cutting. The upper layer, about 4 feet down, held Roman tiles and a coin. The second, at 10 feet, held unvarnished pottery and bronze tweezers. The third, at 19 feet, held rude pottery, charcoal, broken bones, and a small round thick skull. Assuming the Roman period means 1600–1800 years, he assigned the bronze age 3000–4000 years and the stone layer 5000–7000 years.

    Chapter 10

Section 114 cards
  1. How did M. Troyon estimate the age of the Chamblon pile-dwellings?

    Troyon used the Roman town of Eburodunum (Yverdun), once on the lake border, now separated from the shore by 2500 feet of newly gained dry land, to gauge how fast sediment filled the lake over fifteen centuries. Assuming the lake retreated at the same rate before Roman times, he concluded the bronze-period pile-works of Chamblon must be at least 3300 years old.

    Chapter 11

  2. What did M. Morlot and M. Gillieron calculate about the Pont de Thiele pile-dwelling?

    Gillieron compared the old convent of St. Jean, founded 750 years ago on the Lake of Bienne margin and now far from shore, to measure land gain over seven and a half centuries. Extrapolating that rate to the morass between convent and the Pont de Thiele dwelling gave 6750 years total. Morlot thought the bottom shape probably uniform, but Lyell notes this was not tested by boring.

    Chapter 11

  3. How were Irish crannoges constructed, and how do they differ from Swiss lake-dwellings?

    According to Mr. Digby Wyatt, one class was built by laying horizontal oak beams on the lake bottom, mortising in oak posts 6 to 8 feet high, and joining them with cross beams into a circular enclosure, as at Lagore, 520 feet in diameter. Mr. Wylie states the crannoge system was well nigh without parallel in Swiss waters, since the Irish dwellings were not built on platforms supported by piles deeply driven into the mud.

    Chapter 11

  4. Why does Lyell caution against using peat depth to date the Drumkellin cabin?

    The Drumkellin log-cabin in Donegal was found beneath 14 feet of peat, but Lyell argues peat depth is no safe age criterion. In the Principles of Geology he showed that in England and Ireland, within historical times, bogs have burst and sent black mud creeping over the country like lava, overwhelming woods and cottages and leaving deposits of bog-earth 15 feet thick.

    Chapter 11

Section 124 cards
  1. Why did the Nile mud borings show almost no lamination or stratification?

    Mr. Horner attributed the lack of successive deposition to the extreme thinness of the annual sediment film, estimated by French engineers at about 5 inches per century. This layer dries quickly, raises dust, and is disturbed by agriculture, worms, insects, and plant roots, which would confound deposits of successive years.

    Chapter 12

  2. What organic remains were found in the Nile mud excavations, and what was absent?

    All organic remains found, including land-shells and bones of quadrupeds, belonged to living species. Bones of ox, hog, dog, dromedary, and ass were common, but no extinct mammalia were found. No marine shells were detected, though borings sometimes reached the Mediterranean level but never went below it.

    Chapter 12

  3. How did Lyell answer the objection that the Nile may have shifted and filled old channels?

    Lyell gave two answers: first, in historical times the Nile has been stationary and has not shifted its position in the valley; second, mud from ancient channels would have been stratified and would not correspond so closely with inundation mud. He notes Captain Newbold saw sand and clay alternations in the plain, but such stratification was scarcely detected in Hekekyan Bey's borings.

    Chapter 12

  4. What evidence did Birch and Wilkinson give against the claim that baked brick predates the Romans in Egypt?

    Mr. Birch told Lyell the notion is erroneous, citing a baked brick from a Theban tomb bearing the name of Thothmes, dated to the 18th dynasty (about 1450 B.C.), and a brick ending "of the temple of Amen Ra," conjecturally of the 19th dynasty (1300 B.C.). Sir Gardner Wilkinson also had mortar from the three great pyramids containing bits of broken pottery and burnt clay or brick.

    Chapter 12

Section 134 cards
  1. What did Linant Bey find in a 72-foot boring near the delta apex?

    Linant Bey found a fragment of red brick in a boring 72 feet deep, 2 or 3 feet below the level of the Mediterranean, in the parallel of the apex of the delta, 200 metres from the river on the Libyan side of the Rosetta branch. Using Rosiere's estimated deposit rate, Lyell notes such a depth would imply burial over 30,000 years ago, but cautions the brick might be far more modern if the river arm had silted up when the delta apex lay farther south.

    Chapter 13

  2. Why do some Egyptologists doubt Horner's Memphis sediment measurements?

    Lyell reports that some experienced Egyptologists consider Horner's experiments at the pedestal of Rameses' fallen statue unsatisfactory because the rate of deposit at that locality is uncertain. Lyell explains the ancient Egyptians enclosed temple areas with embankments to exclude Nile waters, so the relevant date is when the city decayed and embankments were neglected, not when the monument was erected. Herodotus noted such enclosed spots appeared sunk below the raised surrounding ground.

    Chapter 13

  3. What evidence shows the Ohio mound-builders had long-distance trade?

    Lyell states the Ohio mound-builders clearly had commercial intercourse with natives of distant regions. Among buried articles were objects of native copper from Lake Superior, mica from the Alleghenies, sea-shells from the Gulf of Mexico, and obsidian from the Mexican mountains. He also notes pottery, ornamental sculpture, silver and copper articles, and stone weapons, some of hornstone resembling ancient flint implements found near Amiens.

    Chapter 13

  4. How did Lyell and Harrison estimate the mounds' minimum age from trees?

    Lyell cites Dr. Hildreth showing him a tree on a Marietta mound with eight hundred annual rings. General Harrison argued several generations of trees must have lived and died before the mounds supported the same diverse species as the surrounding forest, since cleared Ohio land is first monopolized by one or two species, then succeeded by others, suggesting several thousand years. Lyell calls this the only positive data for a minimum age.

    Chapter 13

Section 144 cards
  1. Why did Lyell abandon his first interpretation of the Philadelphia tufa with the skull?

    Lyell first thought the deposit formed under the sea and was later uplifted, since oysters with serrulae were in the same matrix as a human skull and teeth. After rereading Dr. Meigs's memoir, he concluded the shells were likely brought and heaped up when the bodies were buried, like shells in Indian mounds, and the earthwork later solidified by carbonate of lime infiltration.

    Chapter 14

  2. What minimum age does Lyell assign to the existing Mississippi delta, and on what basis?

    Lyell describes the delta and alluvial plain as sedimentary matter covering 30,000 square miles, in places several hundred feet deep. He says exact computation is impossible because data are incomplete, but a minimum estimate can be approximated by experimentally determining the river's annual water discharge and its mean annual solid load. The lowest estimate gives many tens of thousands of years, probably more than 100,000.

    Chapter 14

  3. How did Agassiz estimate the age of southern Florida's coral reefs?

    Agassiz described Florida's low peninsula as numerous coral reefs growing in succession, extending land southward, a process still active. Assuming land advances one foot per century, reefs built up from 75 feet depth, and each reef adding ten miles to the coast, he calculated 135,000 years to form the southern half of the peninsula. Lyell notes the whole is Post-Tertiary, with fossils of species still living nearby.

    Chapter 14

  4. What human relics did Darwin find in the raised shell bed near Lima, and why were they preserved?

    At 85 feet above sea level on San Lorenzo island near Lima, Darwin found cotton-thread, plaited rush, and the head of a stalk of Indian corn embedded with shells, indicating the sea bed was uplifted 85 feet since the Peruvian race peopled the region. Lyell explains such perishable thread survived because Peru has no rain; in a permeable European raised beach it would likely vanish.

    Chapter 14

Section 153 cards
  1. What did eighteenth-century writers mean by the 'era of existing continents'?

    They supposed a period coinciding with the first appearance of Man, since which the relative level of sea and land had remained stationary, with only slight changes such as delta additions or narrow strips lost to the sea. The author argues modern observations have dispelled this delusion, and geologists are now convinced that land and sea boundaries, heights and depths, and species ranges were never fixed at any past era.

    Chapter 15

  2. What raised beaches occur on Scotland's central coasts and at what heights?

    Lines of raised beaches containing marine shells of the same species as those now living in the neighbouring sea occur on both the east and west coasts of central Scotland. The two most marked littoral deposits lie at about 50 and 25 feet above high-water mark. The 50-foot one is considered more ancient, owing its superior elevation to a continuance of the upheaving movement, and in places rests on glacial boulder clay.

    Chapter 15

  3. What did Buchanan report about canoes found in the Clyde estuary silt at Glasgow?

    Writing in 1855, Buchanan reported that in the preceding eighty years seventeen canoes had been dug out of the estuarine silt, and he had personally inspected many before exhumation. Five lay buried under Glasgow streets, one vertical with prow uppermost and containing marine shells. Twelve were found about 100 yards from the river, averaging about 19 feet deep, some only 4 or 5 feet deep and over 20 feet above sea-level.

    Chapter 15

Section 163 cards
  1. Why did Mr. Geikie suggest the Romans stopped the Antonine Wall at Chapel Hill?

    Geikie suggested that all the low land now between Chapel Hill and the mouth of the Clyde was, sixteen or seventeen centuries ago, washed by tides at high water. The hill's foot lies about 25 or 27 feet above high-water mark, so a 25-foot subsidence could not submerge it. This explains why antiquaries wondered the Romans did not extend the wall farther west.

    Chapter 16

  2. What evidence do the Roman harbours at Inveresk and Cramond give about sea level?

    At Inveresk, high tide would have made the Esk mouth a safe harbour, unlike today's shoaling estuary. At Cramond (Alaterva), Roman quays now sit on dry land, and about 20 feet of upward movement is needed to explain the mud flats stretching nearly two miles. Had these shoals existed eighteen centuries ago, the Romans would not have chosen Cramond as their chief port.

    Chapter 16

  3. What do the fossil whales and bone implements in the Carse of Stirling indicate?

    Whale skeletons found at Airthrie, Dunmore, and Blair Drummond lie 20 to 30 feet above the sea, some with artificially cut deer's-horn implements nearby, one retaining a wooden handle. Together with an iron anchor in the Carse of Falkirk, these finds show the upheaval that laid dry the Leith raised beach extended far westward, probably to the Clyde.

    Chapter 16

Section 174 cards
  1. How did Lyell estimate the age of the coal ornament found near Dundonald?

    Lyell reasoned that if uplift was uniform, 25 feet of rise corresponded to seventeen centuries, so the ornament lying 50 feet above sea level implied 3400 years, placing it around the days of Pharaoh and the supposed exodus. He stressed such estimates are tentative and conjectural, since movement may not have been uniform or always upward, and long stationary periods may have occurred.

    Chapter 17

  2. What did De la Beche report about human remains at Pentuan and Carnon in Cornwall?

    In his 1839 Report on the Geology of Cornwall and Devon, De la Beche described human skulls and works of art buried in an estuary deposit found while mining gravel for tin at Pentuan near St. Austell, with skulls 40 feet deep, and others at Carnon at 53 feet. The overlying strata were marine, containing living sea-shell species, whale bones, and remains of several living mammal species.

    Chapter 17

  3. What did Lyell find near Stockholm indicating human antiquity in raised marine beds?

    Near Stockholm, horizontal beds of sand, loam, and marl at slight elevations contain the brackish-water testacea now living in the Baltic, mingled with works of art implying rude civilization, vessels built before iron was introduced, and an ancient hut. The marine strata containing it had been formed during a prior depression and then upraised, so the upper beds now stand 60 feet above the Baltic.

    Chapter 17

  4. Why did Lyell think the Norwegian raised beaches implied great antiquity?

    Lyell noted the fossil fauna at Uddevalla and Norway consists only of living northern species but represents a more arctic assemblage than now inhabits those latitudes, per Loven, implying a long period for so slight a faunal change. Assuming a high average uplift of 2.5 feet per century, reaching 600 feet would require 24,000 years.

    Chapter 17

Section 184 cards
  1. What did Tournal argue about the Bize cavern fossils?

    Tournal argued the fossils could not be attributed to a "diluvial catastrophe," because they had not been washed in suddenly by a transient flood. Instead, they must have been introduced gradually, together with the enveloping mud and pebbles, at successive periods.

    Chapter 18

  2. What did Desnoyers argue against Tournal and Christol?

    Desnoyers disputed that extinct species such as the rhinoceros, hyaena, and bear had lived in France at the same time as Man. He noted that flint hatchets, arrow-heads, and coarse pottery in caves match those in Gaulish tumuli and dolmens, and that no elephant, rhinoceros, or hyaena bones appear in those monuments.

    Chapter 18

  3. Why did Lyell initially doubt that human and extinct animal bones were coeval?

    Lyell gave weight to Desnoyers and Buckland and visited caves in Germany himself. He reasoned that caverns served at different times as dens of wild beasts and as places of human habitation, worship, sepulture, concealment, or defence, so bones could be swept by floods into one promiscuous heap in the same ossiferous mud or breccia.

    Chapter 18

  4. What did Schmerling conclude about the Liege caverns?

    Schmerling found human bones rolled and scattered, of the same colour and condition as accompanying extinct and extant animal bones. Finding no gnawed bones or coprolites, he inferred the caverns were not dens of wild beasts; their organic and inorganic contents had been swept in by streams from the surface, which also carried in land-shells and occasionally fish, snake, and bird bones.

    Chapter 18

Section 194 cards
  1. How did Lyell explain mostly intact bones mixed with rolled or broken ones in the same breccia?

    Lyell accounted for bones found in very perfect state, or several bones of one skeleton in natural juxtaposition with delicate apophyses uninjured, alongside rolled, broken, or decayed bones, by supposing that portions of carcasses were sometimes floated in during floods while still clothed with their flesh. No entire skeleton was discovered, not even of a smaller mammal, whose bones are usually least injured.

    Chapter 19

  2. What human remains were found in the Engis cavern, and how were they preserved?

    In the Engis cavern, about eight miles south-west of Liege on the left bank of the Meuse, remains of at least three human individuals were disinterred. One skull, of a young person, lay embedded beside a mammoth's tooth; it was entire but so fragile that nearly all fell to pieces during extraction. The adult skull, the only one preserved well enough for anatomical speculation, was buried 5 feet deep in breccia with a rhinoceros tooth, horse and reindeer bones.

    Chapter 19

  3. How did bone distribution differ between the Engis and Engihoul caverns?

    Engis and Engihoul lie on opposite banks of the Meuse, and both held bones of extinct animals mingled with human bones. In Engis there were several human crania and very few other bones; in Engihoul there were numerous bones of the extremities belonging to at least three human individuals and only two small fragments of a cranium. Lyell notes the like capricious distribution in other caverns, especially for the cave-bear.

    Chapter 19

  4. Why did Schmerling attach great importance to the flint implements?

    Schmerling found rude triangular flint flakes dispersed through the cave-mud, though he collected few, being engrossed in osteology. He also found a polished, jointed, needle-shaped bone pierced obliquely at the base in the Chokier cave. He argued the flints could not have been subsequently introduced, being in the same position as the accompanying animal remains, so even without the human bones, cut bones and worked flints would prove Man's existence.

    Chapter 19

Section 204 cards
  1. What did Malaise find in the Engihoul cavern beneath the stalagmite?

    At a depth of 2 feet below the stalagmite crust, Malaise extracted three fragments of a human skull and two perfect lower jaws with teeth. These were associated with bones of bears, large pachyderms, and ruminants, and so closely resembled them in colour and preservation that he concluded Man was contemporary with the extinct animals. He published figures in the Bulletin of the Royal Academy of Belgium, 1860.

    Chapter 20

  2. How does Lyell explain stalagmite formation, following Liebig?

    Liebig suggested that decaying vegetable matter in the soil produces carbonic acid, which rain dissolves and carries into the porous limestone. The water dissolves some limestone; when the excess carbonic acid evaporates inside caverns, the calcareous matter is deposited as stalactite. Lyell adds that while water still flows through caverns, no pure stalagmite layer can form, so such a layer postdates the old drainage system.

    Chapter 20

  3. Why does Lyell think the rate of geological change was once faster in the Meuse basin?

    Lyell concedes that at present rates no lapse of ages would produce the observed revolutions in physical geography. He argues the rate was probably once far more active, noting that the Lower Eifel volcanoes about 60 miles east seem to have erupted in Pleistocene times and may have been connected with repeated risings or sinkings of the land in the Liege district.

    Chapter 20

  4. What two classes of evidence does Lyell cite for the antiquity of human bones in the Liege caverns?

    First, the time required for many carnivorous and herbivorous cave-period species to become scarce and then extinct before the era of the Danish peat and Swiss lake dwellings. Second, the many centuries needed to convert the Liege district from its ancient to its present configuration, since old underground channels once carrying brooks and rivers are now dry and choked.

    Chapter 20

Section 212 cards
  1. What did Schaaffhausen conclude about the Neanderthal individual's body and brain?

    Schaaffhausen found the cranium unusually large and thick, with a narrow, very low forehead and enormously projecting supra-orbital ridges. Limb bone proportions matched a modern European of like stature, but the bones were extraordinarily thick with strongly marked muscle attachments. He concluded the individual had small cerebral development combined with uncommon strength of frame.

    Chapter 21

  2. What did Lyell conclude about the age of the Neanderthal fossil?

    Lyell thought it probable the fossil was about the same age as those Schmerling found in the Liege caverns, but since no other animal remains were found with it, there was no proof it might not be newer. Its position lent no support to supposing it more ancient. He noted the dendritic markings on the bones afford no sure criterion of antiquity.

    Chapter 21

Section 224 cards
  1. What did Schmerling conclude about the Engis skull's development and affinities?

    Schmerling figured the Engis skull and noted it was too imperfect to determine the facial angle, but inferred from the narrow frontal portion that it belonged to an individual of small intellectual development. He speculated on Ethiopian affinities but not confidently, observing that many more specimens would be needed before an anatomist could reach sound conclusions. Geoffroy St. Hilaire and other osteologists denied it resembled a negro's skull.

    Chapter 22

  2. How did the Engis skull cast become more complete than Schmerling's original figure?

    When Lyell saw the original at the Liege museum, he invited Dr. Spring to have a cast made. Spring complied and added several detached fragments Schmerling had obtained from Engis, which fit in exactly, so the cast was more complete than Schmerling's first plate. It shows the position of the auditory foramen on the right side, which Schmerling's figure omitted.

    Chapter 22

  3. What did Huxley's measurements show about the Engis skull's form and forehead?

    Huxley found the Engis skull 7.7 inches long and 5.25 broad, decidedly dolichocephalic, with good height (4 3/4 inches) and a well-arched forehead. The horizontal circumference is about 20 1/2 inches. Superciliary prominences are well but not excessively developed. Busk remarked the narrow forehead could be matched by European skulls, later borne out by measurements.

    Chapter 22

  4. How does Huxley contrast the Neanderthal skull with the Engis skull?

    Huxley says the Neanderthal skull is so extremely different it might belong to a distinct race. It is 8 inches long, 5.75 broad, but only 3.4 inches from the glabello-occipital line to the vertex, with a 23-inch circumference from vast superciliary ridges. The occipital protuberance occupies the extreme posterior end, and the occiput slopes upward and forward. Huxley calls it the most brutal of all known human skulls, resembling apes.

    Chapter 22

Section 234 cards
  1. How does the Neanderthal cranium's capacity compare with human extremes and the gorilla maximum?

    Professor Schaaffhausen measured the Neanderthal cranium at 1033.24 cubic centimetres of water, about 63 English cubic inches. Lyell estimates its minimum capacity at 75 cubic inches, since the whole skull would have held at least 12 more. That sits near the mean of the human extremes (114 largest European, about 55 smallest) and far above the largest gorilla cranium, 34.5 cubic inches.

    Chapter 23

  2. Why does Lyell reject the idea that the Neanderthal skull belonged to an idiot?

    Lyell argues the cranium was certainly not compressed, and that the burden of proof (onus probandi) lies with those proposing the idiot hypothesis. Idiotcy is compatible with varied cranial forms and capacities, but he knows of none resembling the Neanderthal skull. He instead treats it as an extreme degree of a stage of degradation seen naturally in certain races' crania.

    Chapter 23

  3. What did Lyell conclude from comparing Australian skulls with the Engis and Neanderthal crania?

    Seeking to avoid circular reasoning, Lyell examined skulls of Australians, whom he calls a pure and homogeneous race. He found two crania, linked by intermediate gradations, one closely resembling the Engis skull and the other less closely approximating the Neanderthal. This variation led him to argue that cautious reasoners cannot affirm the ancient skulls were necessarily of distinct races.

    Chapter 23

  4. What does Lyell say cranial measurements alone can reveal about race?

    Lyell prints measurements of an English skull listed as typically Caucasian beside the Engis skull, showing both sides of the dispute may be right. He concludes that cranial measurements alone afford no safe indication of race. He also stresses the known independence of cranial variation from hair, colour, and language, and does not claim the ancient skulls belong to the Australian race.

    Chapter 23

Section 244 cards
  1. What modern analogues does Lyell draw for ancient skulls and implements?

    Lyell notes marked resemblances between ancient skulls and modern Australian ones, citing shared habits: the stone axe used by both ancient and modern savages, similar use of kangaroo and emu bones versus deer and urus bones, Australian shell mounds resembling Danish Kjokkenmodding, and pile-dwellings near Torres Straits like ancient Swiss lake works.

    Chapter 24

  2. Why did the Engis and Neanderthal skulls each cause surprise?

    Lyell says the two skulls caused nearly equal surprise for opposite reasons: the Engis skull, though unequivocally ancient, approached the highest or Caucasian type; the Neanderthal skull, having no such decided claims to antiquity, departed widely from the normal standard of humanity. Huxley's observation on Australian skull variation reduced this supposed anomaly.

    Chapter 24

  3. What does Lyell say about expecting lower skull types in older formations?

    Lyell says the expectation of always meeting a lower human skull the older the formation is based on the theory of progressive development and may prove sound. But he stresses that as yet there is no distinct geological evidence that the so-called inferior races always preceded the higher races in chronological order.

    Chapter 24

  4. What does the ape-like Neanderthal skull imply for transmutation theories?

    Lyell argues the Neanderthal deviation from the normal standard is not random but just what transmutationists would anticipate. If very ancient, it shows a less advanced stage of progressive development; if comparatively modern, it illustrates atavism, reversion to a lower ancestral type. He promises to revisit the hypothesis of man's connection to lower animals later.

    Chapter 24

Section 254 cards
  1. What did Boucher de Perthes find at Abbeville, and why did he call the tools 'antediluvian'?

    In ancient alluvium at Abbeville, Boucher de Perthes found flint implements whose antiquity was attested by their geological position. He began collecting them in 1841 and published an account in 1847 in his 'Antiquites Celtiques.' He styled them 'antediluvian' because they came from the lowest beds of ancient alluvial strata bordering the valley of the Somme, which geologists had termed 'diluvium.'

    Chapter 25

  2. Why did the scientific world initially reject Boucher de Perthes' claims about the flint tools?

    The scientific world had no faith that works of art, however rude, had been met with in undisturbed beds of such antiquity. Few geologists visited Abbeville in winter when the sand-pits were open and sections could be verified. Some thought the tools' rude shapes came from accidental fracture in a river's bed; others suspected workmen had fabricated them for sale, or that the gravel had been disturbed and the flints mingled with mammoth bones later.

    Chapter 25

  3. How did Dr. Rigollot confirm Boucher de Perthes' findings near Amiens?

    Rigollot, previously sceptical, visited Abbeville, inspected the collection, and resolved to search the gravel-pits near Amiens himself, about 30 miles away. He found abundant similar flint implements in the same geological position, some nearly level with the Somme and others in deposits on Chalk about 90 feet above the river. Over four years he obtained several hundred specimens, mostly from St. Acheul, and published a memoir with figures and sections.

    Chapter 25

  4. What did Dr. Buckland conclude about human remains in caves, and how did the Brixham cave work change English opinion?

    In 'Reliquiae Diluvianae' (1823), Buckland declared that none of the human bones or stone implements he met in any cavern could be considered as old as the mammoth and other extinct quadrupeds. This view prevailed in England until the careful 1858 Brixham cave exploration near Torquay produced results that brought about a sudden change of opinion, which in turn influenced subsequent French geologists.

    Chapter 25

Section 263 cards
  1. What did Godwin-Austen claim about the Kent's Hole flint implements in his 1842 memoir?

    Godwin-Austen reported finding works of Man in undisturbed loam or clay beneath stalagmite in Kent's Hole, mingled with remains of extinct animals, arguing all were introduced before the stalagmite floor formed. He held this could not be explained by the burial hypothesis used for Buckland's Paviland skeleton, because the flint implements were widely distributed through the loam and lay beneath the stalagmite.

    Chapter 26

  2. What deposits did the Brixham cave excavations reveal, in order from top to bottom?

    The general succession was: first, a layer of stalagmite 1 to 15 inches thick, sometimes containing bones such as a reindeer's horn and a cave-bear humerus; second, ochreous red loam or bone-earth with angular stones and pebbles, 2 to 13 feet thick; third, at the bottom, gravel with many rounded pebbles, almost entirely barren of fossils.

    Chapter 26

  3. What evidence at Brixham showed the flint knives were contemporaneous with extinct animals?

    Besides a cave-bear bone in the overlying stalagmite, excavators found an entire left hind-leg of a cave-bear at the same level in the bone-earth and close to a perfect flint tool in the reindeer gallery. The femur, tibia, fibula, astragalus, and even the patella were in natural juxtaposition, showing the limb was buried in mud with flesh or ligaments, not washed in as a fossil.

    Chapter 26

Section 274 cards
  1. What did Prestwich extract at St. Acheul in 1858, and why did it settle doubts?

    Prestwich extracted a well-shaped flint hatchet from an undisturbed bed of gravel at St. Acheul, buried 17 feet deep and lying on its flat side. No vertical rents appeared in the surrounding matrix or overlying sand and loam, so it could not be argued the tool had gradually worked downward from a younger formation.

    Chapter 27

  2. What three stages does Agassiz say a startling scientific fact passes through?

    The author quotes Agassiz: people first say 'it is not true,' then that 'it is contrary to religion,' and lastly 'that everybody knew it before.' Lyell adds that among geologists the doctrine of Man's co-existence with extinct mammalia had already passed through all three phases.

    Chapter 27

  3. What did Gaudry do at St. Acheul in 1859, and what did he find?

    Gaudry reported to the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris that he never left the workmen for an instant and verified by actual inspection whether hatchets were in situ. He had a deep excavation made and found nine hatchets most distinctly in situ in the diluvium, associated with teeth of Equus fossilis and a species of Bos unlike any now living.

    Chapter 27

  4. What earlier finds did people recall after the English and French debates?

    It was remembered that Mr. Frere had found flint weapons of the same type as those of Amiens in a freshwater formation in Suffolk in 1797, together with elephant remains. Nearly a hundred years earlier, in 1715, another tool of the same kind had been exhumed from the gravel of London with elephant bones.

    Chapter 27

Section 284 cards
  1. What is the stratigraphic relationship between the peat and the gravels 2 and 3 in the Somme valley?

    The peat (Number 1), 10 to 30 feet thick, is newer than the lower and higher level gravels (Numbers 2 and 3) and also postdates the denudation of those gravels, meaning it formed after the valley was excavated through them. Beneath the peat lies a gravel bed, a, 3 to 14 feet thick, resting on undisturbed Chalk, separated from the peat by a thin impervious clay layer.

    Chapter 28

  2. Why does Lyell say the peat belongs to the Recent period?

    Lyell states the peat belongs to the Recent period because all the embedded mammalia and shells are of the same species as those now inhabiting Europe, matching the Danish mosses described earlier. Bones of quadrupeds are numerous, including beaver remains and perfect lower jaws of Ursus arctos, though Boucher de Perthes found only three or four fragments of human skeletons despite abundant stone implements.

    Chapter 28

  3. Why is peat depth near Abbeville an unreliable age test for Roman and Celtic artifacts?

    Lyell notes that in some swamp parts, especially near the river, the peat is so fluid that heavy objects may sink through it under their own gravity, so the depth of Roman works varies and is no sure test of age. However, Boucher de Perthes observed flat Roman pottery dishes lying horizontally, whose shape prevented sinking, and from about fourteen centuries of overlying peat calculated a growth of roughly three centimetres per century.

    Chapter 28

  4. What did Boucher de Perthes calculate about the rate of peat growth, and how does Lyell regard it?

    From Roman pottery buried under about fourteen centuries of peat, Boucher de Perthes calculated the increase at no more than three centimetres per hundred years. Lyell says this rate would demand so many thousands of years for the full 30 feet that we must hesitate to adopt it as a chronometric scale, though multiplying such observations may eventually yield data for estimating the deposit's age.

    Chapter 28

Section 294 cards
  1. What evidence suggests the Somme coast changed level since the peat began growing?

    The author argues that the thickness of peat at Abbeville and the presence of alder and hazel-wood near its base indicate a change of level. If 30 feet of peat were removed, the sea would fill the valley for miles above Abbeville. Yet the peat is supra-marine in origin, since its shells are terrestrial or fluviatile, so it must have grown above sea-level when the land stood higher than now.

    Chapter 29

  2. How do the Somme flint tools differ from Australian stone hatchets?

    The author notes that Australian weapons, like European celts, have edges produced by friction, while the old Somme tools always gained their cutting edge by simple fracture of the flint through many dexterous blows. The oval Australian weapon is also sharpened at one end only, the other left rough and bound into a cleft stick with opossum-hide straps.

    Chapter 29

  3. What tests indicate the Somme flint implements are genuine and ancient?

    Dendrites of mixed iron and manganese oxides on the tools' surfaces are a useful test of antiquity against forged hatchets offered for sale. The most general test is the superficial varnish-like or vitreous gloss, contrasted with the dull aspect of freshly fractured flint. Many tools are also stained according to their enclosing gravel, and some bear a film of carbonate of lime.

    Chapter 29

  4. What does the colouring of the flint tools indicate, according to Mr. Prestwich?

    Mr. Prestwich argues that the accordance between the colouring of the flint tools and the character of the bed they came from indicates not only a real derivation from such strata, but also a sojourn therein of equal duration to that of the naturally broken flints in the same beds. Many hatchets are ochreous-yellow in yellow gravel, others white or brown according to their matrix.

    Chapter 29

Section 304 cards
  1. What did Professor Ramsay say about the flint hatchets of Amiens and Abbeville?

    Professor Ramsay, called by Lyell a most competent judge, said that after more than twenty years of daily handling stones, whether fashioned by nature or art, the flint hatchets of Amiens and Abbeville seemed to him as clearly works of art as any Sheffield whittle. The remark is quoted from the Athenaeum, July 16, 1859.

    Chapter 30

  2. How did Mr. Evans experimentally show that oval flint tools could be shaped without metal hammers?

    Mr. Evans mounted a pebble in a wooden handle to make a stone hammer, then struck off flakes from the edge on both sides of a chalk flint until it acquired precisely the same shape as the oval tool. Lyell cites this experiment to answer the common question of how such uniform shapes were achieved without metallic hammers.

    Chapter 30

  3. What does Lyell say about the number of flint tools found in the Somme valley and how they were discovered?

    Lyell conjectures that the more perfect tools found in the Somme valley since 1842, rejecting knives and suspected forgeries, far exceeded a thousand. He warns that an antiquary or geologist spending a few weeks there would likely detect none, since few lay on the surface; most were exposed only by removing large volumes of sand, clay, and gravel through years of labourer toil.

    Chapter 30

  4. How does Lyell assess Dr. Rigollot's argument that the chalk fossils were used as beads?

    Dr. Rigollot suggested the small round chalk fossils with central cavities were strung as beads, supposing the holes artificial. Lyell notes some are found entire, some have natural holes, and some have large cavities with an artificial look. He says it is impossible to decide whether they served as ornaments, but calls Rigollot's argument, based on finding small groups of perforated specimens together, sound.

    Chapter 30

Section 314 cards
  1. What do the mixed marine and freshwater shells in Bed 3 at Menchecourt indicate?

    The author states that the alternation of fluviatile and marine strata shows the sea sometimes gained upon the river, whether at high tides, when fresh water was less in the dry season, or when the land was slightly depressed. Such accidents could recur at any river mouth, producing the mixed beds seen at Menchecourt.

    Chapter 31

  2. Which shell at Menchecourt no longer lives in Europe, and where does it now occur?

    Cyrena fluminalis, first observed fossil there by Mr. Prestwich, is no longer a European species; it inhabits the Nile and parts of Asia including Cashmere, where it abounds. It is always found in the fluvio-marine bed, in two or three contiguous sand-pits.

    Chapter 31

  3. Why did the marine shells at Menchecourt not come from human food waste?

    The author argues the numbers collected since preclude the idea that the shells were brought inland as eatable shells by the makers of the flint hatchets found at the bottom of the fluvio-marine sands. The shells are littoral species proper to the contiguous French coast, found with freshwater shells and mammal remains.

    Chapter 31

  4. What did M. Lartet observe on some bones from the Somme valley?

    Lartet, after close scrutiny of bones sent to the Paris Museum, noted some bore evident marks of an instrument, agreeing with incisions a rude flint-saw would produce. Among the cut bones were those of Rhinoceros tichorhinus and antlers of Cervus somonensis. He also sought in vain for Ursus spelaeus.

    Chapter 31

Section 324 cards
  1. How does Lyell explain the varied sections of Somme valley alluvium?

    Lyell attributes the endless variety to repeated silting of the main stream and tributaries during different stages of valley excavation, and probably also to changes in land level. Rivers undermine one bank while depositing gravel and sand on the opposite side, and old channels are later cut into and partly refilled, producing the furrowing and filling seen in the tool-bearing sands at Abbeville and Amiens.

    Chapter 32

  2. What did dredging at Bingerloch on the Rhine in 1845 bring up?

    Professor Noeggerath of Bonn reported that when the Rhine bed was deepened by blasting and removing rock at Bingerloch near Bingen about 1845, the dredge brought up several flint hatchets and an extraordinary number of Roman iron weapons. Decomposed iron had cemented much gravel into conglomerate. Lyell notes that a slight shift in the river's course would bury stone and iron tools together under overlying loam.

    Chapter 32

  3. What did borings at Shoeburyness reveal about an old Thames channel?

    Mr. Mylne informed Lyell that boring at Shoeburyness, opposite Sheerness, found an old silted-up Thames bed separated from the present channel by undenuded London Clay. The filled branch is 75 feet thick in fluviatile strata; the modern channel is 60 feet deep with perhaps 10 to 15 feet of sand and gravel below, so a future deviation could create a comparable fluvio-marine deposit.

    Chapter 32

  4. Which Somme valley deposits does Lyell consider older, higher or lower?

    Lyell states the general rule that in the same valley, alluvial formations occupying a more elevated position above the river plain are the oldest. He cites Auvergne and Velay, where fossil quadrupeds occur from 10 to 1000 feet above present rivers, and the fauna departs more from living species at higher terraces, with Tertiary mastodon remains in elevated alluvium near Le Puy.

    Chapter 32

Section 334 cards
  1. What did Prestwich and Lyell find in the gravel at Montiers, and what did it confirm?

    At Montiers, below Amiens, Prestwich and Lyell found flint knives, one flat on one side and the other carefully worked with many fractures from skilful blows. Some came from so low a level that they referred the great gravel bed at Montiers, and the contiguous St. Roch quarries, to the human period. This confirmed Rigollot's earlier report of flint hatchets at St. Roch.

    Chapter 33

  2. What animal remains from St. Roch led Lyell to conclude coexistence with Man?

    From the gravel of St. Roch, many tusks of a hippopotamus were obtained, some recently by Prestwich, and M. Garnier of Amiens procured a fine elephant's molar which Falconer referred to Elephas antiquus. From these Lyell infers that both animals co-existed with Man.

    Chapter 33

  3. What did the Gallo-Roman stone coffins at St. Acheul demonstrate about the terrace?

    Many stone coffins of the Gallo-Roman period were dug from the upper alluvial mass at St. Acheul, with trenches penetrating 8 or 9 feet into the upper part of Number 3. Lyell says they prove that when the Romans were in Gaul the terrace was in the same condition as now, or rather as before so much gravel, sand, clay, and loam was removed for roads, bricks, and pottery.

    Chapter 33

  4. Why did Lyell think ice, not the present Somme, transported the large sandstone blocks?

    Lyell notes great angular blocks of hard sandstone, some 3 or 4 feet and upwards in diameter, in the St. Acheul gravels, derived from Tertiary strata once covering the Chalk. Their size and angularity make it impossible to imagine the present Somme, flowing through flat country with a gentle fall, carrying them for miles without ice co-operating; ice would also let them escape river wear.

    Chapter 33

Section 344 cards
  1. What two causes did Lyell attribute to the contorted strata at St. Acheul?

    Lyell attributed the contortions of sand, marl, and gravel to two causes: first, the pressure of ice running aground on yielding banks of mud and sand; and second, the melting of masses of ice and snow of unequal thickness on which layers of mud and sand had accumulated. He credits the late Mr. Trimmer with first showing how unequal failure of support from melting underlying snow and ice could produce such foldings.

    Chapter 34

  2. Why does Lyell think contorted strata prove ice-action independent of transported blocks?

    Lyell states that contortions and foldings, in which underlying or overlying strata do not participate, are very characteristic of glacial formations. He notes they have no necessary connection with the transportation of large blocks of stone. Therefore, following Mr. Prestwich, such contortions afford independent proof of ice-action in the Pleistocene gravel of the Somme.

    Chapter 34

  3. How does Lyell explain the abundance of flint implements in the St. Acheul gravel?

    Lyell supposes the river froze over annually for months, and primitive people may have lived like American Indians described by Hearne, cutting holes in the ice to fish and draw water. Ice-chisels, hatchets, and spear-heads could slip through these holes, and lost treasures would be swept away by gravel when the ice broke up. Over long winters, thousands of chips and rejected flawed implements would also be thrown in.

    Chapter 34

  4. Why do the fossil shells from the Amiens and Abbeville drift not disprove a colder climate?

    When Lyell showed his collection of common land and freshwater shells from the drift to M. Deshayes in 1859, Deshayes declared them all identical to species now living in the Seine basin. Lyell notes this seems to imply unchanged climate, but all these mollusc species now range as far north as Norway and Finland, so they could have flourished in the Somme valley when the river froze annually in winter.

    Chapter 34

Section 354 cards
  1. Why does Lyell think the absence of human bones in Somme alluvium is instructive?

    Lyell argues the absence of human bones, despite hundreds of flint tools and thousands of mammal bones, shows the value of negative evidence and the extreme imperfection of the geological record. He notes Schmerling found human bones in only three or four of forty-two Belgian caverns rich in osseous remains, and expects human remains will eventually be found in older European valley alluvium.

    Chapter 35

  2. What does Lyell conclude about the relative age of the St. Acheul and St. Roch gravels?

    Assuming the lower-level gravel is newer, Lyell concludes Elephas antiquus and the St. Roch hippopotamus flourished long after the mammoth appeared, since a mammoth tooth was found at St. Acheul in 1860. He also notes flint hatchets and knives occur in alluvial deposits at both high and low levels, so Man was as old an inhabitant of the region as any of the fossil quadrupeds.

    Chapter 35

  3. What does Lyell say about the cause of extinction of large mammals in Europe?

    Lyell argues that while Man hastened the extinction of many large pachyderms and beasts of prey, other causes co-operated. He points to the Cyrena fluminalis, an aquatic mollusc that co-existed with humans and was abundant in the Thames, whose disappearance no naturalist would attribute to human agency. He suggests climatic and other changes affecting this mollusc may have mainly contributed to the mammals' gradual dying out.

    Chapter 35

  4. How does Lyell compare the duration of the peat formation with the interval before it?

    Lyell states the Somme peat likely took thousands of years to grow, yet no marked change occurred in the mammalian fauna since it began. The contrast between the ancient alluvium's fauna and the oldest peat's fauna is almost as great as with the existing fauna, so he infers the interval separating the extinct mammalia from the earliest peat was far longer than the entire growth of the peat.

    Chapter 35

Section 363 cards
  1. What did the Dutch government accomplish at the Lake of Haarlem by 1853, and how?

    The Dutch government drained the roughly 45,000-acre Lake of Haarlem, converting it to dry land by 1853 using powerful steam-driven pumps that raised the water and discharged it into a canal running 20 to 30 miles around the reclaimed land. The new land lay 13 feet below mean ocean level; by 1859 Lyell found part of the old lake bed already arable and settled by an agricultural population of 5000.

    Chapter 36

  2. Why did Staring attribute the scarcity of human bones in Dutch peat, and where did Lyell say this failed to apply?

    Staring attributed the general scarcity of human bones in Dutch peat, despite many preserved works of art, to humic and sulphuric acids in the peat dissolving bones. Lyell allows the theory may be correct but says it does not apply to the Somme valley gravel, where fossil mammal bones are frequent, nor to the uppermost freshwater strata at the bottom of much of the Haarlem Lake, where such acids are not claimed to occur.

    Chapter 36

  3. Why did Lyell argue that even reverent disposal of the dead in the Somme would not guarantee bone preservation?

    Lyell reasoned that a corpse cast into a stream first sinks and must be quickly covered by sediment or it rises again, distended with gases, and may float to the sea. There it can be attacked by bone-digesting marine fish; if enveloped in fluviatile mud, a later flood may tear it out, scatter and roll the bones, and repeat this yearly until all trace vanishes. Only burial in a protected subterranean cavity, such as one with stalactite, offers a better chance.

    Chapter 36

Section 373 cards
  1. What did de Vibraye find in the lowest deposit of the Arcy-sur-Yonne cavern?

    In the lowest formation, a granitic gravel resembling the Paris diluvium gris, de Vibraye found two branches of a human lower jaw with well-preserved teeth, together with bones of Elephas primigenius, Rhinoceros tichorhinus, Ursus spelaeus, Hyaena spelaea, and Cervus tarandus, all identified by M. Lartet. Lyell noted the human and other remains were in the same condition and colour.

    Chapter 37

  2. What fossils did the Abbe Lambert collect from the Oise gravel near Chauny, and what did Lartet identify?

    From the fluviatile Pleistocene alluvium exposed in railway cuttings near Chauny and Noyon, the Abbe E. Lambert collected many fossil bones. M. Lartet recognised Elephas primigenius and E. antiquus, a species of hippopotamus (H. major?), reindeer, horse, and the musk ox (Bubalus moschatus), the last apparently never before seen in the old alluvium of France.

    Chapter 37

  3. What hypothesis did Lyell suggest about the Thames basin faunas in the Pleistocene?

    Lyell suggested the Thames basin shows indications of a meeting of a northern and southern fauna in the Pleistocene. The northern group may have included the mammoth and Rhinoceros tichorhinus, occasionally with reindeer; musk ox skulls were later found at Maidenhead, Bromley, and Bath Easton. He cites Owen's view that the musk ox's cold-adapted constitution implies its companions could also support life in a cold climate.

    Chapter 37

Section 384 cards
  1. Which mammals accompanied the musk ox in the Berlin drift, and which were absent?

    At the Kreuzberg in Berlin, the musk ox skull was found with the mammoth, tichorhine rhinoceros, horse, and ox. Lyell notes he can find no record of a hippopotamus, Elephas antiquus, or Rhinoceros leptorhinus in the drift of northern Germany bordering the Baltic.

    Chapter 38

  2. What fauna and shells distinguish the Gray's Thurrock alluvium in Essex?

    The brick-earth and gravel at Gray's Thurrock, 21 miles below London, contain Elephas antiquus, Rhinoceros leptorhinus, Hippopotamus major, horse, bear, ox, and stag. Shells include the abundant Cyrena fluminalis, Unio littoralis with both valves united, Paludina marginata, and peculiar varieties of Cyclas amnica and Valvata piscinalis.

    Chapter 38

  3. Why does Lyell say fluviatile deposit chronology is so hard to settle?

    Lyell argues that neither organic remains nor superposition reliably orders fluvial deposits, since two river-beds at the same level may differ by thousands of years. At Ilford a channel was cut through Cyrena-bearing sands and refilled with London Clay waste. Channel shifting, reworking of gravel, land movement, and climate change all create complexity.

    Chapter 38

  4. How does Lyell relate the Thames alluvium to the glacial drift?

    Lyell argues the Thames basin and its fluviatile deposits are post-glacial in a modified sense, i.e. later than the drift of the central and northern counties. Northern drift with granite, Palaeozoic rocks, and Chalk wreck caps hills about 200 feet above the Thames, as at Muswell Hill. Following Prestwich, he treats the glacial formation as older.

    Chapter 38

Section 394 cards
  1. What did Mr. Wyatt find at Biddenham gravel pits after months of daily visits?

    Mr. Wyatt, of Bedford, watched the excavation of gravel-pits at Biddenham, two miles west-north-west of Bedford, almost daily for months. He was rewarded with two well-formed implements, one spear-head and one oval, matching the two prevailing French types. Both came from the lowest bed of stratified gravel and sand, 13 feet thick, containing elephant, deer, and ox bones and freshwater shells, resting on Oolitic limestone.

    Chapter 39

  2. What did Lyell conclude after visiting Biddenham in April 1861?

    Invited by Mr. Wyatt, Lyell went to Biddenham within a fortnight of the discovery. There he first saw evidence satisfying him of the chronological relations of three phenomena: the antique tools, the extinct mammalia, and the glacial formation. With Prestwich, Evans, and Wyatt he collected ten species of shells from the stratified drift overlying the lowest gravel, all common fluviatile and land species still living in that part of England.

    Chapter 39

  3. How does Lyell explain the presence of flint tools in Kent cliff deposits?

    Lyell argues such old alluvial deposits now capping Kent cliffs were river-beds of Thames tributaries before the sea encroached and widened its estuary. Tools found at the cliff base between Herne Bay and the Reculvers came from a freshwater gravelly deposit about 50 feet above sea-level. He also cites a freshwater formation at Faversham below sea-level as evidence of subsidence, and suggests the river was once a tributary of the Rhine.

    Chapter 39

  4. What does Lyell say about the Thames basin flint weapons' geological context?

    Lyell notes that more than a dozen flint weapons of the Amiens type had already been found in the Thames basin, but the geological position of none of them had yet been ascertained with the same accuracy as that of many tools dug up in the valley of the Somme. He also mentions finds in the Wey alluvium at Pease Marsh, the Darent valley, and Swalecliff near Whitstable.

    Chapter 39

Section 404 cards
  1. What did the Bedford sections establish that Amiens and Abbeville could not?

    The author states that the Bedford sections teach that the fabricators of the antique flint tools, and the extinct mammalia coeval with them, were all post-glacial. At Biddenham, remains of Elephas antiquus were found in the same gravel, and Mr. Wyatt obtained a flint implement with hippopotamus bones and teeth at Summerhouse hill, east of Bedford, four miles from Biddenham.

    Chapter 40

  2. What did John Frere conclude about the flint tools found at Hoxne?

    In an 1800 paper to the Society of Antiquaries, Frere described flint tools found about 12 feet deep in stratified brick-clay soil at Hoxne, near Diss, Suffolk. He judged them weapons of war made by a people without metals, and argued their antiquity was beyond that of the present world. He thought the site a place of manufacture, not accidental deposit.

    Chapter 40

  3. What did Prestwich find when he visited Hoxne about sixty years after Frere?

    Prestwich visited Hoxne after Evans drew his attention to the weapons and Frere's memoir following his return from Amiens in 1859. He found clay extraction still underway in the same brick-pit. Months before his arrival, two flint instruments had been dug out, one from 7 and one from 10 feet deep, and others were later disinterred from undisturbed gravel in the pit.

    Chapter 40

  4. Why did Lyell think the Hoxne flints indicated a manufactory rather than river transport?

    Lyell examined Hoxne in 1860 with Reverend J. Gunn and Reverend S.W. King, finding Valvata piscinalis abundant in the loamy beds. He observed that the Hoxne flint weapons were more perfect and had sharper cutting edges than those from the Somme valley, seeming neither used by man nor rolled in a river bed. He therefore considered Frere's manufactory opinion probable.

    Chapter 40

Section 414 cards
  1. What did Mr. Dawkins conclude about the Somersetshire cave near Wells?

    Dawkins explored the cavern in 1859 with Mr. Williamson and found bones of Hyaena spelaea in such numbers that he concluded the cavern had long been a hyaena's den. The same bone-earth held Elephas primigenius, Rhinoceros tichorhinus, Ursus spelaeus, and many other extinct and living species, plus worked bone and flint.

    Chapter 41

  2. What was found in Long Hole cave, and why did it matter?

    Colonel Wood discovered in 1861, in an undisturbed deposit at Long Hole, remains of two rhinoceros species, R. tichorhinus and R. hemitoechus, with well-shaped flint knives in the lower part. Lyell states it is clear from their position that Man was coeval with these species, the first well-authenticated case of R. hemitoechus with human implements.

    Chapter 41

  3. How did Falconer sort out the name Rhinoceros leptorhinus?

    Falconer showed that three distinct species had been confounded under R. leptorhinus by Cuvier, Owen, and others: R. megarhinus, the original Cuvier type and the only European Pliocene or Pleistocene species without a nasal septum; R. hemitoechus, with an incomplete septum, accompanying Elephas antiquus in old British caves; and R. etruscus, a slighter form with incomplete septum found in Val d'Arno and the Norfolk Forest bed.

    Chapter 41

  4. What did Falconer and Forbes conclude about the age of the Gower cave deposits?

    Falconer announced in 1860 that the filling of the Gower caves occurred after deposition of the marine boulder clay, making the fauna post-glacial. Edward Forbes had declared in 1846 that the megaceros, mammoth, and other extinct pachyderms and carnivora lived in Britain in post-glacial times. Lyell notes raised beaches and marine-shell sand in the caves as signs of later land-sea change.

    Chapter 41

Section 424 cards
  1. What did Dr. Falconer find in the upper breccia of the Grotto di Maccagnone?

    Dr. Falconer discovered flint knives, bone splinters, bits of charcoal, burnt clay, and other objects indicating human intervention, mingled with entire land shells, horse teeth, hyaena coprolites, and other bones. The whole was agglutinated to one another and to the roof by infiltrated water carrying lime in solution. The perfect condition of the fragile helices convinced Falconer the articles were carried in by tranquil water, not tumultuous action.

    Chapter 42

  2. What evidence of humans was found at San Ciro cave?

    No proofs seem yet to have been found of human existence at San Ciro during the period when the hippopotamus and Elephas antiquus flourished there. The cave's deposit instead yielded marine shells, a breccia with land shells, and bones of two hippopotamus species, Elephas antiquus, Bos, Cervus, Sus, Ursus, Canis, and a large Felis. Human traces appear only at the later Maccagnone cave.

    Chapter 42

  3. What did Count de la Marmora find on Sardinia's southern coast near Cagliari?

    De la Marmora showed that an ancient sea bed containing marine shells of living species and numerous fragments of antique pottery had been elevated 230 to 324 feet above the Mediterranean. Shells included the common mussel, often with both valves united, and a flattened baked-clay ball with a hole through its axis, thought to weight a fishing net. Fragments of Roman pottery occur in the overlying vegetable soil.

    Chapter 42

  4. How does Lyell estimate the age of the Cagliari pottery?

    Lyell assumes an average upheaval rate of 2 1/2 feet per century, so 300 feet gives an antiquity of 12,000 years to the Cagliari pottery, confining the estimate to upheaval above sea level without allowing for the original water depth. He notes this covers only the period of upward movement, and no conjecture can be formed as to its commencement or termination.

    Chapter 42

Section 434 cards
  1. Why does Lyell doubt the extinct hippopotamus lived in cold northern climates?

    Lyell argues that living hippopotami are so aquatic and fluviatile in habit that it is hard to conceive their congeners thriving where rivers froze for months each winter. He also could not learn of any case where hippopotamus bones were found in northern German drift alongside mammoth, tichorhine rhinoceros, musk-ox, reindeer, or lemming remains.

    Chapter 43

  2. What does Sir Andrew Smith report about the living hippopotamus of Southern Africa?

    Smith states that when the Dutch colonised the Cape, the animal abounded in all great rivers as far south as the land extends, but by 1849 they had nearly all vanished near the colony. They show sagacity in quitting districts invaded by settlers with fire-arms, travel speedily over land between pools, and are powerful swimmers in rivers and even the sea.

    Chapter 43

  3. What did the Aurignac grotto contain when first opened in 1852?

    A labourer named Bonnemaison, following a rabbit burrow in the talus, found a human long bone, dug through, and removed a vertical slab of rock. Behind it was an arched vault about 7 or 8 feet high, 10 wide, and 7 deep, almost filled with bones including two entire human skulls. Dr. Amiel determined the remains belonged to seventeen skeletons of both sexes and all ages.

    Chapter 43

  4. Why does Lyell consider the Aurignac find a Pleistocene sepulchral vault?

    Lyell inspected Lartet's fossil bones and works of art from the grotto and saw no grounds to doubt his conclusions. The section shows a vault with seventeen human skeletons, a layer of made ground with human bones, extinct and living animal bones and works of art, and layers of ashes and charcoal with burnt and gnawed bones but no human bones.

    Chapter 43

Section 444 cards
  1. What did Lartet conclude about the origin of the bones and soil inside the grotto?

    Lartet, an experienced investigator of ossiferous caverns in southern France, concluded that all the bones and soil found inside the grotto were artificially introduced. He based this on the absence of stalagmite in the grotto. The substratum remaining after the skeletons were removed was about 2 feet thick and contained about ten detached human bones, including a molar tooth.

    Chapter 44

  2. What did Delesse's nitrogen analysis show, and what caveat did Evans raise?

    Delesse found that a human molar and bones of rhinoceros, bear, and other extinct animals all contained the same proportion of nitrogen, meaning they had lost an equal amount of animal matter. Evans suggested this alone may not be conclusive, since bones in the same matrix may reach a maximum of decomposition and then lose no more, so remains of very different ages could match.

    Chapter 44

  3. How were the animal bones outside the grotto modified, and what did Lartet attribute this to?

    Bones of the herbivora were most numerous; those outside that had contained marrow were invariably split open, many burnt, and the spongy parts were missing, having been gnawed after breaking. Lartet attributed the gnawing to hyaenas, whose bones and coprolites were mixed with the cinders. He supposed these beasts fed on relics of funeral feasts after humans left or between ceremonies.

    Chapter 44

  4. What objects were found inside the grotto, and how did they differ from those outside?

    Inside the grotto were eighteen small, round, flat plates of white cockle shell, pierced through the middle as if for stringing into a bracelet. Also found were a young cave-bear tusk with enamel stripped, carved perhaps as a bird's head and perforated for suspension, and a flint knife evidently never used, unlike the numerous worn specimens outside, suggesting placement as part of funeral ceremonies.

    Chapter 44

Section 454 cards
  1. Why does Lyell think the interior Aurignac bones were buried as a sepulture?

    The interior bones are all entire and uninjured—none broken, gnawed, half-eaten, scraped, or burnt like those among the ashes outside the slab. Many skeleton bones lay in juxtaposition, and one spot held a complete uninjured leg of Ursus spelaeus. Cinders and charcoal are entirely absent inside. Lyell concludes the vault was an ancient place of sepulture, closed so effectively against hyaenas that no teeth marks appear on any bones.

    Chapter 45

  2. What two arguments does Lyell say may be founded on the Aurignac phenomena?

    Lyell notes an argument with an opposite leaning: some say Aurignac implies extinct mammalia survived nearly to our times. First, because the works of art are of modern style; second, because there are no signs of change in the physical geography since the cave was used for sepulture. Lyell presents these as claims made by others, then examines each.

    Chapter 45

  3. How does Lartet counter the claim that Aurignac art is too advanced?

    Lartet holds that the Aurignac bone and stone utensils do not indicate a more advanced state than the Abbeville and Amiens flint implements, and that we cannot assume the Somme toolmakers lacked bone instruments or ornaments. He regards the Aurignac objects as extremely rude compared with later French stone-period work, such as the engraved stag bone at Savigne and the barbed, possibly poisoned arrows, bird-bone needle, and carved bear's head from Massat.

    Chapter 45

  4. How does Lyell answer the objection that the Aurignac landscape shows no physical change?

    Lyell argues it is normal for the earth's surface to change greatly in one place while nearby areas remain unmodified for ages. Rivers may deepen channels, seas undermine cliffs, land rise or sink, or volcanoes erupt, while adjacent forest, heath, or city stays motionless. He notes Auvergne volcanic cones of loose ashes still stand though rivers have cut through basalt and even 50 feet into gneiss, showing incoherent deposits can long survive.

    Chapter 45

Section 464 cards
  1. What does Lyell say the Aurignac cave proves about early humans?

    Lyell argues that if the Aurignac fossils are correctly interpreted, they show a sepulchral vault with human skeletons, relics of funeral feasts at the tomb's portal, food for the departed, and weapons as funeral gifts. He concludes this traces the sacred rites of burial and belief in a future state back to times long before history and tradition, calling the ancient savage "noble" for cherishing hopes of a hereafter.

    Chapter 46

  2. What two fossil finds does Lyell name as leading claims of high human antiquity?

    Lyell identifies two prominent examples: first, the "fossil man of Denise," comprising remains of more than one skeleton found in a volcanic breccia near Le Puy-en-Velay in Central France; second, the fossil human bone of Natchez on the Mississippi, supposedly from a deposit containing Mastodon and Megalonyx. Lyell says he carefully examined both sites and will assess the evidence for their remote date.

    Chapter 46

  3. What did Croizet and Laurillard conclude about the Le Puy fossil?

    At the 1856 Scientific Congress at Le Puy, the late Abbe Croizet, an experienced collector of fossil bones in Central France's volcanic regions, and the late M. Laurillard, who assisted Cuvier in modelling fossil bones, declared the specimen in the Le Puy museum no counterfeit. They believed the human bones had been enveloped by natural causes in the tufaceous matrix now seen around them.

    Chapter 46

  4. Why does Lyell doubt forgers could fake M. Pichot's specimen?

    Lyell reports an expert anatomist's remark that assembling all thirty-eight bones of the hand and fingers, or the sixteen of the wrist, in true position without error, and without mixing right with left homologues, would far exceed the skill of the peasant or the dealer. Some frauds at Le Puy may have occurred given high prices for "human fossils," but Lyell treats this specimen's assembly as beyond such forgery.

    Chapter 46

Section 474 cards
  1. Why did some geologists doubt the genuineness of the fossil man of Denise?

    Some geologists were reluctant to accept the Denise human skeleton because, if genuine and coeval with the lava stream, it would imply humans were contemporary with an older fauna, that of Elephas meridionalis. That fauna is found in a separate tuff layer on the opposite slope of Denise, regarded by M. Robert as the product of a much older eruption from the more denuded Montagne de St. Anne.

    Chapter 47

  2. How does Lyell link the Elephas meridionalis fauna to an older volcanic epoch?

    At St. Prest near Chartres, the Eure valley cuts an older valley filled with 90 feet of fluviatile sand and gravel containing Elephas meridionalis and a rhinoceros distinct from R. tichorhinus. Lyell argues this fauna predates the mammoth gravels of the Seine and Somme, and was synchronous with an older epoch of volcanic action including the St. Anne cone; he says there is as yet no proof Man witnessed that middle phase.

    Chapter 47

  3. What did Lyell propose to explain the human pelvic bone found with Mastodon and Megalonyx at Natchez?

    Lyell suggested the human os innominatum might have come from the vegetable soil at the top of the cliff, while the extinct mammal bones were dislodged from a lower position, both falling into the same talus at the ravine's base. The bone's black colour could come from lying in dark peaty soil, as old Indian grave bones in the district were similarly stained. He noted the same idea had occurred to Colonel Wiley.

    Chapter 47

  4. What did Lyell observe about the Mammoth Ravine near Natchez and its formation?

    Lyell was assured by Colonel Wiley that the Mammoth Ravine, though 7 miles long and in places 60 feet deep, did not exist before 1812; Wiley had ploughed land now crossed by the watercourse. Lyell satisfied himself the ravine had recently enlarged and was still wasting. He attributed accelerated erosion partly to clearing of native forest and partly to the 1811-12 New Madrid earthquake, which fissured the region.

    Chapter 47

Section 484 cards
  1. Why did Lyell hesitate in 1846 to accept the fossil human bone as Pleistocene?

    Lyell says his reluctance arose partly from reflecting that the ancient loess of Natchez is anterior in time to the whole modern delta of the Mississippi. If the delta required many tens of thousands of years, and if Natchez man coexisted with the mastodon, humans would have peopled North America many tens of thousands of years before his time.

    Chapter 48

  2. On conchological data alone, how did Lyell compare the ages of the Picardy and Natchez alluvium?

    Lyell declares he does not consider the Natchez loam more ancient than the Somme alluvium. In both Europe and America the land and freshwater shells with extinct pachyderms are of living species, and he could detect no shell at Natchez as foreign to the Mississippi basin as Cyrena fluminalis is to modern European rivers. On shells alone, Abbeville might rank a shade older.

    Chapter 48

  3. What does Lyell argue confirming Natchez man coexisted with the mastodon would accomplish?

    Lyell argues it would not enhance the geological evidence for Man's antiquity, but would merely make the Mississippi delta available as a chronometer, measuring Pleistocene time less vaguely than any means yet available in Europe. He notes the 250-foot uplift at Natchez is exceeded by the Cagliari marine stratum containing pottery.

    Chapter 48

  4. Why does Lyell say a gap in human geological monuments occurs where glacial action was intense?

    Lyell explains that boulder clay or northern drift is usually destitute of organic remains, cutting short inquiry into the animate creation and man. Given the extreme scarcity of human bones and works of art in all strata, the chance of finding remains left by few wanderers over glacier-covered lands after thousands of years is infinitesimally small.

    Chapter 48

Section 494 cards
  1. What do the Crag shell percentages show about climate through the Pliocene?

    The tables show recent species falling from 85% in the Norwich Crag to 57% in the Red Crag and 51% in the Coralline Crag. Southern shells number 27 in the Coralline but vanish from the Norwich, while northern species rise from 2 to 8 to 12. Lyell reads this as good evidence of continual refrigeration of climate during the Pliocene in Britain.

    Chapter 49

  2. How does Lyell answer the objection that northern Crag shells came from deep water?

    He says the northern shells cannot be explained as deep-water inhabitants because species such as Tellina calcarea and Astarte borealis occur plentifully, sometimes with valves still joined by their ligament, alongside littoral shells like Mya arenaria and Littorina rudis. They were evidently not thrown up from deep water, so the arctic character reflects climate rather than depth.

    Chapter 49

  3. What do the Chillesford beds indicate about the timing of the glacial period?

    At Chillesford, near Woodbridge in Suffolk, the Norwich Crag shows marks of a much colder sea than now exists at that latitude. Of 23 shells, only Nucula Cobboldiae and Tellina obliqua are extinct, yet several betray an arctic character. Lyell concludes the glacial period commenced before the close of the Pliocene era.

    Chapter 49

  4. Who first inferred Pliocene refrigeration from the Crag shells, and when?

    Lyell credits the late Edward Forbes, who in 1846 inferred refrigeration of climate from the older to the newer Pliocene strata by studying the Crag shells, in the Memoirs of the Geological Survey. Lyell notes the conclusion is not announced for the first time in his own work. The shell tables were drawn up for Lyell by S.P. Woodward from Searles Wood's monograph.

    Chapter 49

Section 504 cards
  1. What evidence shows the marine shells at West Runton lived and died on the spot?

    Mr. King noted that at West Runton, northwest of Cromer, Mya truncata and Leda myalis are found with both valves united and erect in the loam, all with their posterior or siphuncular extremities uppermost. This attitude, Lyell says, is as good evidence to the conchologist that the mollusca lived and died there as the upright trees prove a forest once stood over the Chalk east of Cromer.

    Chapter 50

  2. What is the Forest Bed, and how far has it been traced?

    The Forest Bed (Number 3) rests directly on the Chalk south of Cromer, where the Norwich Crag thins out. It consists of erect tree stumps with roots attached, penetrating the old vegetable soil, and has been traced more than 40 miles from Cromer to near Kessingland. It is exposed between high and low water mark only when waves clear away sand and shingle.

    Chapter 50

  3. What do the lignite beds above the Forest Bed indicate about past conditions?

    The sands and clays with lignite (Number 3 prime), sometimes 10 feet thick, contain alternating fluviatile and marine strata. Lyell infers the old forest land sank so it was sometimes overflowed by a river and sometimes by an estuary, with probable oscillations of level. Marshes formed and peat accumulated, then salt water returned, so marine genera lived where Unio, Cyclas, and Paludina had flourished.

    Chapter 50

  4. How does the flora of the Forest Bed compare with its mammalian fauna?

    The plants and insects are of living species and familiar: Scotch and spruce fir cones, yew, water-lily, alder, oak, birch, and Donacia beetles. Yet the accompanying mammalia are, in Lyell's words, most extraordinary: three elephants, a rhinoceros, hippopotamus, a large extinct beaver, plus walrus, narwhal, and whale. He notes the Scotch fir is now confined to northern Britain and the spruce fir is not indigenous there.

    Chapter 50

Section 514 cards
  1. What evidence does Lyell cite that the till (Number 4) is glacial in character?

    Lyell says its glacial character is shown by the absence of stratification, the great size and angularity of included blocks of distant origin, and the polished and scratched surfaces of those hard enough to retain markings. Near Cromer, granite blocks 6 to 8 feet in diameter occur, along with syenite, porphyry, and trap, plus wrecked London Clay, Chalk, Oolite, and Lias.

    Chapter 51

  2. Where do Scandinavian erratics occur in the till, and what did Lyell conclude in 1834?

    Erratics of Scandinavian origin occur chiefly in the lower portions of the till. Lyell states he concluded in 1834 that they had really come from Norway and Sweden, after tracing a continuous stream of such blocks from those countries to Denmark, across the Elbe, through Westphalia, to the borders of Holland. He notes they reappear on the eastern coast between the Tweed and the Thames.

    Chapter 51

  3. How does Lyell explain contorted upper strata over undisturbed till?

    Lyell suggests ice-islands stranding could push pliant upper strata while lower beds stay unmoved, citing Dease and Simpson's polar observations. Alternatively, melting of ice-bergs or coast ice with interstratified deposits, ice-island capsizing, or Trimmer's suggestion of earthy layers sinking during liquefaction of intercalated ice could produce contortions while strata below and above remain horizontal.

    Chapter 51

  4. What does Lyell say about the apparent concentric arrangement around a nucleus (Figure 31)?

    Lyell calls the appearance delusive. It is produced by the intersection of beds bent into a convex shape; what seems the nucleus is in fact the innermost bed of the series, partially visible by removal of the protuberant portions of the outer layers. The entire mass shown is 20 feet in perpendicular height.

    Chapter 51

Section 524 cards
  1. What did Lyell originally conclude about the lignite beds and post-glacial deposits at Mundesley?

    When Lyell examined the coast in 1839, the section was less clearly exposed. Finding several fossils in the lignite beds (Number 3 prime) identical in species with those from the post-glacial deposits B and C, he supposed the whole to be contemporaneous and described them that way in his 1840 paper. Mr. Gunn first perceived the mistake and explained it to Lyell at Mundesley in autumn 1859.

    Chapter 52

  2. How were the Mundesley freshwater beds A–D interpreted, and what did they contain?

    They were thought to represent a silted-up river channel that remained for a time as a lake or mere, with the black peaty mass B accumulating slowly over river-bed gravel A. Beds A held shells (Anodon, Valvata, Cyclas, Succinea, Limnaea, Paludina), seeds of Ceratophyllum and Nuphar, fish scales and bones, and beetle elytra. The beds filled a valley cut through the older formations 3, 4, and 5.

    Chapter 52

  3. What did Agassiz and Yarrell disagree about regarding the Mundesley fish remains?

    Lyell showed Agassiz the scales and teeth of pike, perch, roach, and salmon from the formation. Agassiz thought they varied so much from their nearest living representatives that they might rank as distinct species. Mr. Yarrell doubted the propriety of so distinguishing them. The insects, like the shells and plants, were identical so far as known with living British species.

    Chapter 52

  4. What did Lyell argue about the antiquity of human relics relative to the glacial beds?

    Lyell argues the oldest memorials of our species yet discovered in Britain are post-glacial, later than the boulder clay (Number 4). He notes the Hoxne flint implements correspond in position to the Mundesley beds A–D, and that the gravel A looks like an old river-bed and is the most likely stratum for future flint tools. He adds that no flint tools had yet been observed there.

    Chapter 52

Section 534 cards
  1. What does Lyell say about finding signs of Man in forest bed Number 3?

    Lyell argues we need not despair of one day finding signs of Man's existence in forest bed Number 3 or the overlying strata 3 prime, since no uncongeniality of climate or incongruity in the animate creation bars our species. He says we must wait, as no investigations yet entitle us to wonder that bones or stone weapons of the Elephas meridionalis era have failed to appear.

    Chapter 53

  2. If human remains were found in those strata, how far back would they push Man's antiquity?

    Lyell states such a discovery would carry back the antiquity of Man to a distance of time probably more than twice as great as that separating our era from the most ancient tool-bearing gravels yet found in Picardy or elsewhere. Even then, he notes, the age of Man, though pre-glacial, would be so modern in the great geological calendar that it would scarcely date back to the commencement of the Pleistocene.

    Chapter 53

  3. How does Lyell explain the difference between unstratified till and stratified glacial deposits?

    Lyell explains that where a melting iceberg runs aground and is stationary with no current, angular and rounded stones mixed with sand and mud fall in an unstratified heap called till in Scotland. If a current intervenes at certain points or seasons, materials are sorted as they fall and arranged in layers by relative weight and size, producing passages from till to stratified clay, gravel, and sand.

    Chapter 53

  4. What does Lyell say about the direction erratic blocks travelled from Scandinavia?

    Lyell reports that while many blocks travelled south, others were carried northwards toward the Polar Sea and north-eastwards toward the White Sea, citing Boetlingk in 1840 and more recent inquirers. The blocks wandered toward all points of the compass from the mountains of Scandinavia as a centre, and rectilinear furrows on hard polished rock radiate outward from the highest land, corresponding to the erratics' course.

    Chapter 53

Section 544 cards
  1. What did Kjerulf argue about the elevation of glacial signs versus marine shells in Scandinavia?

    Kjerulf objected to Lyell's supposed excessive submersion of northern Europe. He noted glacial signs on Scandinavian mountains reach 6000 feet, while fossil marine shells of the same period never exceed 600 feet. He concluded the land may once have been higher but has not been much lower since the glacial period began, or shells would appear at greater elevations. Lyell concedes much glaciation was supramarine but refuses to limit depression to 600 feet.

    Chapter 54

  2. How did Kjerulf explain the direction of glacial furrows and striae in Norway and Sweden?

    Kjerulf contended the furrows neither match a general movement of floating ice from polar regions nor follow existing valley shapes, as independent glaciers in higher valleys would produce. Instead he argued for a universal ice covering over all Norway and Sweden, like Greenland's, annually fed by snow and pressing outward and downward to the coast, crossing lower ridges and ignoring minor depressions choked with ice.

    Chapter 54

  3. According to Dr. Rink, how does Greenland's inland ice move and discharge?

    Rink described an inland region buried under one continuous colossal ice mass always moving seaward, mostly toward Baffin's Bay. At fjord heads the ice rises abruptly to 2000 feet and higher inland, levelling minor ridges and valleys. Greatest discharge occurs at large fjords, where ice blocks several miles wide and 1000 to 1500 feet thick push into salt water, grinding and polishing the rocky bottom at depths over 1000 feet before breaking into icebergs.

    Chapter 54

  4. What does Lyell argue about flora and fauna near a glaciated region, using Greenland and Lapland?

    Lyell argues we must not imagine contemporaneous fauna and flora were everywhere poor and stunted wherever glaciation occurred. In Greenland's outskirts, below the 2000-foot snow line, hundreds of flowering plant species ripen seeds, with phanerogams found up to 4500 feet. Due east, about 1200 miles away, Lapland supports reindeer, bears, wolves, seals, walruses and whales. He suggests luxuriant life could exist a few hundred miles southward.

    Chapter 54

Section 554 cards
  1. What evidence does Lyell cite that Greenland once had a mild climate?

    Lyell cites Tertiary (Upper Miocene) fossil plants from Disco Island, latitude 70 degrees north, including Sequoia Langsdorfii, allied to the living Sequoia sempervirens of California. The Icelandic surturbrand also yielded over thirty-one well-preserved plants, fifteen identical with European Miocene species, including a tulip-tree, plane, walnut, and vine. Lyell argues this precludes glaciers existing there then.

    Chapter 55

  2. What sequence of glaciation does Lyell say Scandinavia passed through?

    Lyell argues Scandinavia went through successive phases: first separate glaciers, then a Greenlandic state of continental ice, then a second period of enormous separate glaciers filling valleys now wooded with fir and birch. Finally, under the Gulf Stream and changes in arctic land height, nearly all permanent ice between latitudes 60 and 70 north melted, so glaciers now reach the sea only north of 70 degrees.

    Chapter 55

  3. What did Lyell observe at Upsala suggesting erratics were transported recently?

    Lyell observed a ridge of stratified sand and gravel containing a marl layer of dwarf marine and fresh-water shells, raised over 100 feet above the Gulf of Bothnia. On top lay huge unrounded gneiss erratics 9 to 16 feet in diameter. He concluded these were transported during the Recent period, after the Baltic already had its peculiar brackish fauna.

    Chapter 55

  4. What did the Sodertelje section reveal about post-human land movement?

    At Sodertelje, south of Stockholm, a section exposed in 1819 showed a subsidence then re-elevation, each over 60 feet, since a rude hut was built on the ancient shore. The hut's wooden frame, hearthstones, and charcoal lay beneath marine strata over 60 feet thick with dwarf Mytilus edulis and other brackish shells. Wooden-pegged vessels were also embedded there.

    Chapter 55

Section 564 cards
  1. What did Robert Chambers conclude about the Highlands of Scandinavia and Scotland?

    After visiting Norway and Sweden and comparing glacial signs with the Grampians, Chambers concluded the Highlands of both regions had once been "moulded in ice." He argued the frozen mass's movement smoothed, polished, and scratched rocks and, over ages, deepened and widened valleys, producing much denudation usually ascribed only to water. He traced glaciation of the Scotch mountains to at least 3000 feet.

    Chapter 56

  2. How do glacial furrows in Scotland align with drainage, according to Jamieson?

    Jamieson describes glacial furrows in Aberdeenshire pointing south-east, in the Forth valley at Edinburgh from west to east, and higher at Stirling from north-west to south-east — as if ice followed the lines of present drainage. In Sutherland and Ross-shire furrows along the north coast point northwards, and in Argyleshire westwards, always matching the direction of principal glens and fjords.

    Chapter 56

  3. What evidence does Jamieson cite that ice moved from inland to the coast?

    Jamieson notes isolated hills and minor rock prominences are often polished and striated on the land side while rough and jagged on the seaward side, seen on both east and west coasts. He also mentions granite blocks that travelled from south to north in Aberdeenshire — impossible if erratics came from floating ice out of arctic regions while Scotland was submerged.

    Chapter 56

  4. What does Lyell consider the probable explanation of the stratified drift at Meal Uaine?

    Jamieson first inferred submergence to 1550 feet, but on revisiting the Tummel valley suggested, and Lyell thinks probable, that a glacier filling the valley dammed a mountain torrent, creating a deep pond where clay and sand were deposited. Charpentier described similar glacier-dammed receptacles and noted polished, striated stones falling from melting ice into such lakes.

    Chapter 56

Section 574 cards
  1. What evidence did Lyell cite for a much greater subsidence than 500-600 feet?

    Lyell concedes that glaciation above 2000 feet may be explained by land ice, but argues that erratics and stratified drift at greater heights require a larger subsidence. He cites Maclaren's mica-schist fragments on the Pentland Hills at 1100 feet, with the nearest source 50 miles away, and stratified gravels at all elevations there. He attributes the absence of marine shells above 525 feet partly to glaciers sweeping out marine strata after re-emergence.

    Chapter 57

  2. What did Lyell describe about the transverse moraine in the South Esk valley?

    Lyell described a terminal moraine of a retreating glacier crossing the South Esk a few miles above where it leaves the Grampians, about 6 miles below Kirktown of Clova. Its central part at Glenarm is 800 feet above sea level and about 150 feet high: lower part till with boulders 50 feet thick, resembling a Swiss moraine, topped by 50-100 feet of stratified sand, possibly rearranged by glacier-lake water. The Esk cut a passage about 400 yards wide through it.

    Chapter 57

  3. What continuous zone of boulder clay did Lyell trace in Perthshire and Forfarshire?

    Lyell traced a continuous zone of boulder clay forming ridges and mounds 50-70 feet high, with upper parts usually stratified, enclosing lakes, ponds and swamps with shell-marl and peat. With Grampian boulders and river-gravel, it runs 34 miles long and 3.5 miles wide from near Dunkeld by Coupar to south of Blairgowrie, through low Strathmore, then through the Sidlaw Hills' greatest depression from Forfar to Lunan Bay.

    Chapter 57

  4. How did Jamieson propose determining flow direction in extinct river channels?

    Jamieson proposed that the direction of former water flow can be found from the arrangement of oval and flattish pebbles in deserted channels: in a fast-flowing river such pebbles dip toward the current, the position of greatest resistance to the stream. Lyell says if this is admitted, the higher or mountainous country bore the same relation to the lower lands then as now.

    Chapter 57

Section 584 cards
  1. What did the Clyde and Forth Junction Railway excavation at Croftamie reveal about the reindeer antler's position?

    Workers cut through 12 feet of till with angular and rounded stones, then 6 feet of underlying clay, finding the reindeer antlers 18 feet from the surface and within a foot of the sandstone on which the till rested. Nearby and slightly deeper were marine shells including Cyprina islandica, Astarte elliptica, A. compressa, Fusus antiquus, Littorina littorea, and a Balanus, at 100 to 103 feet above sea level.

    Chapter 58

  2. Why does Lyell think the Scottish mammoth and reindeer finds matter for human antiquity?

    Lyell notes that tusks found without molar teeth make species identification uncertain, but if any specimen is correctly named as Elephas primigenius, then mammoth and reindeer in the Scotch boulder-clay matter because both are known to have been contemporary with Man. He argues this favours the idea that the close of the glacial period in the Grampians may have coincided with human existence in milder European regions like the Thames, Somme, and Seine basins.

    Chapter 58

  3. What are the dimensions and levels of the three Parallel Roads of Glen Roy?

    The lowest road is about 850 feet above sea level, the next about 212 feet higher, and the third 82 feet above the second. A fourth shelf occurs only in the contiguous valley of Glen Gluoy, 12 feet above the highest Glen Roy road, roughly 1156 feet above sea level. The roads are 10 to 60 feet broad and nearly horizontal, one continuous about 20 miles east-west and 12 miles north-south.

    Chapter 58

  4. What evidence supports the Parallel Roads being ancient beaches, and what did all theorists agree on?

    The terraces are stratified like alluvial or littoral deposits where torrents cut ravines, so they result from deposition, not denudation. Where an isolated hill like Mealderry rises above a shelf, a corresponding shelf passes around it, as if it were once an island. Each shelf also meets a col between glen heads. Despite differing theories from Macculloch, Lauder, Darwin, Agassiz, Milne, and Chambers, all agreed the shelves were ancient beaches of one or more sheets of water.

    Chapter 58

Section 594 cards
  1. What did Darwin propose formed the parallel roads of Glen Roy?

    Darwin argued the shelves were formed when the glens were still arms of the sea, so there were never any seaward barriers. He held that the land rose slowly and uniformly, as Sweden and Finland do now, but with pauses during which the sea stood stationary long enough to build up detrital matter and cut notches and cliffs in solid rock just above sea level.

    Chapter 59

  2. What difficulties did Lyell list against Darwin's marine theory?

    Lyell names four: the abrupt cessation of the roads at certain points; their unequal number in connected valleys, three in Glen Roy but one in Glen Spean; the precise horizontality of one shelf over many leagues, requiring no part of the land to rise even a few yards above another during a 1156-foot uplift; and each shelf coinciding in level with a col.

    Chapter 59

  3. What evidence did Jamieson find in 1861 supporting glacier-lakes?

    Jamieson found superficial scoring and polishing of rocks and boulder accumulations where glacial action should appear; shelves more sharply defined than Scottish raised beaches; small delta-like extensions of the lower Glen Roy shelf preserved as if settled in placid water untouched by tides; and alluvium on the cols consistent with water flowing east out of glacier-lakes.

    Chapter 59

  4. How did Lyell explain the higher shelves forming before the lower ones?

    Lyell reasoned that the higher roads formed first, when ice was most in excess. A glacier from Loch Treig crossed Glen Spean and rested on the opposite hill, preventing water from escaping over the Glen Glaster col, so the uppermost shelf formed in a shallow lake. As ice shrank, the second shelf formed at the col's level, and finally the lowest lake escaped over the Muckul pass.

    Chapter 59

Section 604 cards
  1. How did Dr. Hooker explain the parallel terraces in the Himalayan valleys?

    Dr. Hooker believed the Indian shelves originated on the borders of glacier-lakes. Their barriers were usually formed by ice and moraines of lateral or tributary glaciers crossing the main valley, though others he ascribes to the terminal moraine of the principal glacier, which had retreated during milder seasons, leaving an interval filled with water. He found such a glacier-lake near the head of the Yangma valley.

    Chapter 60

  2. Why does the level of a glacier-lake stay constant despite changes in the ice barrier?

    The author explains that the lake's stationary height is determined solely by the elevation of a col or parting ridge of rock, not by the ice barrier, provided the barrier is higher than the col. The dam may be repaired and vary in height by several hundreds of feet without affecting the lake level, since surplus water escapes over the col.

    Chapter 60

  3. What objection to the glacier-lake theory for Glen Roy does Lyell address?

    It was objected that the shelves must have taken a very long period to form, which seems incompatible with so precarious and fluctuating a barrier as ice. Lyell counters that permanency of lake level has no necessary connection with minor changes in the dam's height, because a col of rock, not the ice, fixes the water level.

    Chapter 60

  4. What did Mr. Jamieson suspect about the lowest shelf at Glen Roy after leveling in 1862?

    Mr. Jamieson, after several spirit-level measurements in 1862, suspected a rise in the lowest shelf of one foot in a mile from west to east, from the mouth of Glen Roy to a point six miles east in Glen Spean. Lyell says confirming this and checking whether the rise continues to the pass of Muckul would be most important.

    Chapter 60

Section 614 cards
  1. What three glacial periods did Ramsay describe for North Wales?

    Ramsay described three successive glacial periods: first, a time when the land stood much higher than now and ice was excessive; second, a period of submergence when the land was 2300 feet lower and only higher mountain tops rose as snow-covered islands; third, a period when a second, smaller set of glaciers ploughed out the marine boulder drift from the larger valleys.

    Chapter 61

  2. What did Trimmer and Forbes find on Moel Tryfan, and at what heights?

    Trimmer discovered marine shells in drift on Moel Tryfan in North Wales, elevated more than 1300 feet above sea level. He and Edward Forbes, corroborated by Ramsay and Prestwich, found about twelve species, including Fusus bamfius, F. antiquus, and Venus striatula, at heights between 1000 and 1400 feet, resting on rock previously exposed to glacial friction and striation.

    Chapter 61

  3. Why does Lyell think shells are rare in glacial drift?

    Lyell notes the general dearth of shells in glacial formations is a negative character of such deposits. He suggests porous strata permeated by rainwater may have destroyed organic remains, or that they were originally scarce because melting icebergs freshened and chilled seawater enough to drive away fish and kill mollusca. Moraines are barren from the start and stay barren if ice-bergs carry them.

    Chapter 61

  4. What did McClintock and Wallich's deep-sea discovery do to Forbes's depth limit?

    Edward Forbes had fixed the zero of animal life at 300 fathoms after dredgings in the Aegean. But McClintock and Wallich found starfish at more than a thousand fathoms (7560 feet) between Greenland and Iceland, with stomachs full of Globigerina, showing they had lived and fed there. Lyell says this rudely shook faith in an uninhabitable deep ocean.

    Chapter 61

Section 623 cards
  1. What shells in the Wexford drift suggest an older, possibly Pliocene age?

    Forbes reports that Sir H. James found, with the usual glacial shells, species characteristic of the Crag, including the reversed Fusus antiquus (F. contrarius) and the extinct Nucula Cobboldiae and Turritella incrassata. Lyell suggests part of this south Irish drift may belong to the close of the Pliocene, older than the Clyde shells, and may correspond to the uppermost Norwich Crag at Chillesford.

    Chapter 62

  2. Why does Lyell think the Irish drift is marine in origin?

    Lyell argues the scarcity of mammalian remains in the Irish drift favors a marine origin. Across the whole island he met only three recorded examples of the mammoth, including bones of Elephas primigenius, two bear species (Ursus arctos and Ursus spelaeus?), reindeer, and horse found in a cave near Dungarvan, and another near Belturbet in County Cavan.

    Chapter 62

  3. How did Trimmer's four sketch maps depict Britain's Pleistocene geography?

    Trimmer's first map restored a continental period, the first elephantine period or Cromer forest, uniting Ireland, England, and France. The second showed the great glacial submergence. The third showed partial re-elevation, reuniting Ireland with Scotland and north England while England stayed separate from France. The fourth returned to continental conditions, the second elephantine period, when man coexisted with the mammoth and the Thames was a tributary of the Rhine.

    Chapter 62

Section 634 cards
  1. What does Lyell's Figure 40 map represent?

    It shows the effect of a uniform subsidence of 100 fathoms (600 English feet) over the whole of the British Isles, reducing them to an archipelago of small islands except parts of Scotland, northern England, and Wales, where four sizable islands remain. Lyell stresses it does not depict any single past moment, since the district south of the Thames and Bristol Channel apparently stayed land throughout the glacial period.

    Chapter 63

  2. What would a 600-foot rise do to the British Isles, per Figure 41?

    A rise of the same 600 feet would unite all the British Isles — including the Hebrides, Orkneys, and Shetlands — with one another and with the Continent, and lay dry the sea now separating Great Britain from Sweden and Denmark. Lyell borrows this map from Sir Henry de la Beche's 'Theoretical Researches,' after making corrections. The gained land would form a nearly level terrace sloping outward, not hills and valleys.

    Chapter 63

  3. Why would a naturalist assume the British Isles were once joined?

    Lyell argues the identity of fauna and flora across these lands could only be explained by former union within the Pleistocene period; otherwise, like Madeira's archipelago since the Miocene, land-shell species would differ between Ireland and England and among the Hebrides. He adds that full fusion did not require continuous land at one moment, only connections allowing successive migration.

    Chapter 63

  4. What do the Selsea erratics indicate about southern England's glacial history?

    Erratic blocks at Pagham and Selsea, including a granite 27 feet in circumference, came not from the north but from Normandy, Brittany, or land now in the English Channel, probably drifted by coast ice. This supports southern England being dry land during great submergence. Below them, blue mud held Elephas antiquus skeletons, and lower sandy loam yielded 38 Recent marine shell species, some indicating warmer conditions before the cold.

    Chapter 63

Section 643 cards
  1. According to Lyell, during which period did the first appearance of Man in the British area occur?

    The author argues that the first appearance of Man in the British area took place during the second continental period, when he ranged freely from all parts of the Continent together with the mammoth and woolly rhinoceros, or with Elephas antiquus, Rhinoceros hemitoechus, and Hippopotamus major.

    Chapter 64

  2. How does Lyell calculate the total time for the grand oscillation of submergence and re-emergence?

    At 2.5 feet per century, Wales's 1400-foot submergence requires 56,000 years; adding Ramsay's 800 feet adds 32,000, totaling 88,000, with equal time for re-elevation. If land rose 600 feet above present level, that adds 48,000 more, making the whole oscillation about 224,000 years, assuming no stationary pauses.

    Chapter 64

  3. What mechanism does Lyell propose for the great movements of the earth's crust?

    Lyell states little progress has been made in divining the causes, but what is known of the interior suggests the gradual expansion or contraction of large portions of the solid crust may result from temperature fluctuations, probably connected to hundreds of active and thousands of extinct volcanoes. He notes granite and sandstone expand and contract annually, even in a Canadian winter and summer.

    Chapter 64

Section 653 cards
  1. According to Deville's experiments, how much contraction occurs when granite solidifies from a melted state?

    Deville's experiments showed that granite contracts by more than 10 percent in passing from a melted or plastic condition to a solid state. Lyell uses this to argue that a source of depression on a grand scale exists whenever granitic rocks originate in the earth's interior, and that such slow, gradual changes best explain revolutions of the habitable surface.

    Chapter 65

  2. What did Venetz, Charpentier, and Agassiz each contribute to the theory of former Alpine glacier extent?

    Venetz first announced in 1821 that Alpine glaciers once extended far beyond their present limits. Charpentier acknowledged and strengthened this with new observations, declaring in 1836 that glaciers had reached as far as the Jura, carrying moraines across the Swiss valley. Agassiz, after excursions with Charpentier and years of glacier study, published in 1840 a description of glaciers and the marks of former ice action.

    Chapter 65

  3. How does Lyell describe the transition from long-continued elevation to the opposite movement?

    Lyell presumes that after movement has gone on for a long time in one direction, whether elevation or depression, the change to the opposite movement would not take place suddenly. Instead it would be marked by a period of inaction, slight movement, or quiescence, such as prevails throughout large areas of dry land in the normal condition of the globe.

    Chapter 65

Section 663 cards
  1. What are terminal moraines, and what makes them liable to obliteration?

    Terminal moraines are prominent mounds of unstratified earth and stones left by a receding glacier, crossing a valley like ancient earthworks. They are the most liable to obliteration because violent floods or debacles, sometimes caused by the sudden bursting of glacier-dammed lakes, sweep away and level the transverse mounds and spread their materials in confused beds over the river-plain.

    Chapter 66

  2. How do glaciers polish, striate, and groove the rocks beneath them?

    Stones pushed along beneath a glacier sometimes adhere to the ice, which glides at a few inches to at most 2 or 3 feet per day. Sand acts like emery to polish the surface, pebbles like coarse gravers scratch and furrow it, and large stones scoop out grooves. Projecting rock eminences, called roches moutonnees, are smoothed into flattened domes where glaciers passed over them.

    Chapter 66

  3. What theory did Lyell and Darwin propose in 1841 for transporting the Jura erratics?

    Lyell and Darwin proposed that the erratics were transferred by floating ice when much of the Jura and the whole Swiss valley lay under the sea. If the Alps were then only half their present height, they would still resemble the Chilean Andes, whose glaciers send icebergs carrying granite blocks seaward; Chiloe, with its boulder deposit of Andean granite, offered a modern analogue.

    Chapter 66

Section 674 cards
  1. What theory did Murchison propose in 1849 for transporting erratics to the Jura?

    Murchison proposed that the granitic blocks were carried to the Jura by ice-floats at a time when the intermediate country was submerged. He thought it impossible that a glacier from one narrow valley could spread erratics over a region about 100 miles broad, as Charpentier's map laid down. The author notes this theory requires an oscillation of land level comparable to Charpentier's, only beginning with subsidence rather than elevation.

    Chapter 67

  2. What did Guyot argue about the arrangement of Alpine erratics on the Jura?

    Guyot argued the erratics are not scattered at random but arranged in a determinate order analogous to lateral, medial, and terminal moraines of great glaciers. The evidence rests on distinctive Alpine rocks foreign to both the Strath and the Jura, which consist only of Secondary and Tertiary limestones, sandstones, and clays. Maclaren presented Guyot's observations and argument to the British public in 1852.

    Chapter 67

  3. How does the distribution of blocks at Martigny support the glacier theory over floating ice?

    At Martigny (B), where the valley turns at right angles, blocks from the right side of the river (c d e) did not cross to the left side, as they should have if carried by floating ice. Instead they kept to the side they belonged to, consistent with once forming part of a right lateral moraine of a great extinct glacier. The author argues this harmonises with glaciers and is irreconcilable with floating ice.

    Chapter 67

  4. What did Charpentier argue against a sudden flood debacle from the Alps?

    Charpentier argued that a rush of muddy water would have mingled the blocks from the Rhone, Aar, Reuss, and Limmat basins confusedly together. Instead, each river's blocks remained in separate and distinct areas, as the glacial hypothesis predicts. The author says this argument, originally aimed at the debacle doctrine, can be revived against the floating-ice hypothesis.

    Chapter 67

Section 684 cards
  1. What evidence did Lyell cite against floating ice as the transport for Swiss erratics?

    Lyell argued that Morlot's map showed drift and erratics arranged by river-basin in a way irreconcilable with floating ice during submergence. He also noted that no marine shells or other fossils, only terrestrial remains like mammoth bones and coniferous wood, had been found in these drifts, though they are often many hundreds of feet thick.

    Chapter 68

  2. How did the Pontelyas granite blocks support the land-ice theory?

    Escher showed Lyell fragments of Pontelyas granite at Trogen, far from their source near Trons. The blocks stay on the left bank of the Rhine even where the valley bends sharply near Mayenfeld below Chur, and remain on the left side of Lake of Constance. Lyell says this is inexplicable if floating ice, not land-ice, is the transporting power.

    Chapter 68

  3. How did the extinct Alpine glaciers compare in size to modern ones?

    Lyell estimated the extinct glaciers were 50 to 150 miles long and 1000 to 3000 feet deep, versus modern lengths of 5, 10, or 20 miles and thicknesses of 200, 300, or at most 800 feet. He argued the ice-work, measured by distances of erratics, areas of drift, and polished or striated rock, was proportional to glacier volume.

    Chapter 68

  4. What did Lyell observe comparing modern and extinct moraines?

    At the Rhone's modern terminal moraine in 1859, Lyell counted several thousand pebbles before finding one polished or scratched, and in Zermatt and Viesch moraines one in several hundred. In contrast, the old Rhone moraine at Soleure had a marked proportion polished and scratched, with compact clay needing gunpowder in railway cuttings and a polished limestone surface with grooves matching Guyot's ice direction.

    Chapter 68

Section 694 cards
  1. What did Lyell observe about striated pebbles in the moraine at Mazze near Caluso?

    Lyell found that in a part of the moraine rich in limestone and serpentine, one-third of all stones showed glacial markings. Among serpentine alone, nineteen in twenty were polished and scratched, whereas in terminal moraines of modern glaciers where material travelled only 10 or 15 miles, scarce one in twenty serpentine pebbles showed polish or striation.

    Chapter 69

  2. What did M. de Mortillet propose about the origin of the great Alpine lake-basins?

    De Mortillet argued in 1859 that the great lakes existed before the glacial period but were first filled with alluvial matter and then re-excavated by ice, which scooped out loose alluvial strata up to 2000 feet thick and carried debris up inclined planes past the lake outlets. Lyell calls this hypothesis bold, given basins 500 to over 2000 feet deep.

    Chapter 69

  3. How does Lyell explain the contorted stratified beds exposed at Mazze near Caluso?

    Lyell offers two possible causes: an advancing glacier pushing a heap of stratified matter before it, as the Zermatt glacier has shoved blocks through house walls; or the melting of ice masses once interstratified with sand and gravel. He treats the contortion as proof of a close connection between ice-action and contorted stratification, as seen in Norfolk, Scotland, and North America.

    Chapter 69

  4. What evidence did Lyell cite for the former glacier that issued from the Ivrea defile?

    Lyell, with Gastaldi and Michelotti, traced a moraine descending from Mont Blanc and Monte Rosa through the Aosta valley, issuing from a narrow defile above Ivrea and spreading mud, gravel, boulders, and erratics for 15 miles. It reaches over 1500 feet high near the mountains, rests on metamorphic rocks and marine Pliocene strata, and resembles the drift of Perthshire and Forfarshire.

    Chapter 69

Section 704 cards
  1. What did Ramsay propose about the origin of Alpine lake-basins in 1859?

    Professor Ramsay suggested in 1859 that lake-basins were not pre-glacial but had been scooped out by ice during the glacial period, mostly in soft Miocene sandstone called "molasse." He reached this view after visiting Switzerland, without communication with M. de Mortillet. The theory let him dispense with filling pre-existing cavities with stratified alluvium, as de Mortillet had proposed.

    Chapter 70

  2. What is Lyell's first objection to glacial erosion on a large scale?

    Lyell concedes ice grinding over unequal rocks can make small depressions, as where quartzose mica-schist alternates with clay-slate or trap-dykes cut softer beds. But the larger a lake, the more surely it contains rocks of every hardness. A gradual deepening toward the center and shallowing toward the lower end, as in Swiss and Italian lakes 30 or 40 miles long, requires a power acting with considerable uniformity on masses of varying resistance.

    Chapter 70

  3. Why does Lyell say the Lake of Geneva's direction counts against glacial scooping?

    Lyell argues several great lakes do not lie in the direction ice would have taken. Had the Lake of Geneva been the work of ice, it would have been prolonged from the end of the upper Rhone valley toward the Jura, in the direction from F to G on his map, Figure 42, instead of running from F to I. The mismatch between ice flow and lake orientation is his second objection.

    Chapter 70

  4. What evidence at Utznach and Durnten shows the Lake of Zurich predates the glacial era?

    Lyell describes lignite-bearing deposits at Utznach and Durnten, each about 350 feet above the present lake level. At Utznach, clays over 100 feet thick rest unconformably on inclined Miocene molasse, are covered by stratified sand and gravel with small, unstriated pebbles, and topped by large erratic blocks showing a later glacier covered the old littoral deposit. Bones of Elephas antiquus indicate great age; Durnten yielded teeth of Elephas antiquus and Rhinoceros leptorhinus, plus shells of living species.

    Chapter 70

Section 714 cards
  1. What does Lyell propose as the origin of the great Alpine lake-basins?

    Lyell argues the lake-basins are due to unequal movements of upheaval and subsidence in Pleistocene times, after the valleys were already eroded. He notes the basins follow the main drainage lines but often cross the strata at high angles, so they are not synclinal troughs or fissures. He compares this to Sweden's uneven rate of land rise, and suggests subsidence faster in the upper country than near the mountains' edge could convert valley ends into lakes.

    Chapter 71

  2. How does Lyell say a glacier indirectly helps form and preserve lake basins?

    Lyell argues that without ice, sediment would fill an incipient cavity as fast as subsidence created it, and running water would cut a gorge through any barrier. A glacier instead carries mud, sand, and stones onward as moraines on top of the ice, past the new depression. When the glacier finally melts, the deep basin is revealed. Ice also prevents cavities from silting up and heaps moraine mounds that create ponds.

    Chapter 71

  3. What age does Lyell assign to the lignite beds near Zurich and other Swiss freshwater formations?

    Lyell states these lignite beds, including those at Utznach, Durnten, Wetzikon, Kaltbrunnen, Buchberg, and Morschweil, are all pre-glacial, overlaid by stratified gravel and then erratic blocks marking a later glacier. Yet they represent the beginning of the Pleistocene, not the older or newer Pliocene. He cites Ramsay that no strata of the age of the English Crag have been found in any Alpine valley.

    Chapter 71

  4. What did M. Moro find at Mercurago, and what does Lyell conclude from it?

    M. de Mortillet reports that at Mercurago, in peat filling one of the morainic lakes formed by the ancient Ticino glacier, M. Moro found piles of a lake-dwelling like those of Switzerland, along with various utensils and a canoe hollowed from a tree trunk. Lyell concludes that south of the Alps as well as north, a primitive people with similar habits flourished after the retreat of the great glaciers.

    Chapter 71

Section 724 cards
  1. What four successive phases of Alpine ice-action does Morlot recognize?

    Morlot identifies: first, glaciers at their greatest excess, with the Rhone glacier reaching the Jura and rising 2015 feet above Lake Neufchatel; second, a prolonged retreat accompanied by subsidence and stratified 'ancient alluvium'; third, a renewed advance, smaller than the first, filling Lake Geneva and building moraines; fourth, a second retreat to near present limits, with terraces of stratified gravels.

    Chapter 72

  2. What does the Dranse gorge section near Thonon reveal about glacial deposits?

    Morlot found three glacial formations in direct superposition: at the bottom, 12 feet of compact till or boulder-clay with striated Alpine limestone boulders; above it, 150 feet of stratified ancient alluvium of rounded pebbles in horizontal beds; and over that, a second unstratified boulder-clay with erratic blocks, forming the left lateral moraine of the Rhone's second advance.

    Chapter 72

  3. How does Morlot estimate the age of the Tiniere deltas?

    Morlot supposes the modern conical delta of the Tiniere, containing Roman, bronze, and stone age monuments at different depths, required 10,000 years to accumulate. A more ancient delta about ten times as large, at 150 feet above the lake, is therefore supposed to represent about ten times as many centuries, or 100,000 years, all referable to the fourth period after the last retreat.

    Chapter 72

  4. What evidence does Lyell cite for a colder climate in southern latitudes?

    Lyell cites northern shells such as Cyprina islandica and Panopoea norvegica in latest Tertiary formations of Sicily, pointing to a more severe former climate. He also notes Dr. Hooker's 1860 Syria journey, finding moraines of extinct glaciers beneath the cedars of Lebanon descending 4000 feet below the summit, though Lebanon at 10,200 feet now bears no perpetual snow.

    Chapter 72

Section 734 cards
  1. What is the origin of the fine mud forming the loess, according to Lyell?

    The author argues the loess's fine mud came largely from Alpine glaciers during the glacial period. Torrents issuing from icy caverns are densely charged with impalpable powder ground from rock and stones frozen into the ice. Swollen by melting ice, rivers carried this sediment far down the Rhine and Danube basins, accumulating it in inland valleys rather than dispersing it in the ocean.

    Chapter 73

  2. What fossils does the loess contain, and what do they indicate?

    The loess is generally devoid of fossils, but where abundant they are land-shells of living species, including Succinea oblonga, Pupa muscorum, and Helix hispida. These comprise much of the molluscous fauna still inhabiting the region. Shells requiring constant water, such as Limnaea and Planorbis, are extremely exceptional, occurring only at the bottom where the loess meets underlying river-gravel.

    Chapter 73

  3. What lies beneath the loess in the Rhine valley, and what does it show?

    The loess usually rests on ancient river-gravel, mostly pebbles and boulders of Alpine origin, showing rivers once carried coarse material hundreds of miles north from Switzerland. Later the same rivers deposited only fine mud, accumulating to 800 feet or more. Near the Black Forest, Vosges, and Odenwald, detritus from those local chains is also mixed in.

    Chapter 73

  4. How did early observers explain loess distribution, and what did Lyell conclude?

    Early observers imagined a vast lake filling the Rhine valley from Basle to Mayence, later moving the dam below Bonn when the Lahn valley's loess was raised as an objection. Lyell argues the loess boundary actually runs much farther north, near the 51st parallel through Cologne, Juliers, Louvain, and Courtrai to Cassel, possibly cut back later by marine denudation.

    Chapter 73

Section 744 cards
  1. What evidence does Lyell give against a lake origin for the loess?

    Lyell argues that even if the embedded fossil shells were lacustrine rather than terrestrial and amphibious, the vast height and width of the required barrier would rule out a lake. The loess occurs at elevations up to 1600 feet above the sea, covering the Kaiserstuhl volcanic mountain in the Rhine valley near Freiburg, showing the valley was a receptacle for fine mud later removed.

    Chapter 74

  2. How does Lyell explain interstratified loess and volcanic ejectamenta in the Lower Eifel?

    Lyell disagrees with geologists who thought the volcanoes erupted during loess deposition. He proposes the fluviatile mud gradually enveloped the cones of loose scoriae after they were completely formed. He supports this view from seeing the junction of granite and loess on steep slopes in the Bergstrasse, where loess layers abut against granite with a mixture of mica and unrounded quartz and felspar.

    Chapter 74

  3. What fossils characterize the loess in the Rhine valley and at Canstadt?

    In the Rhine valley loess, Elephas primigenius and Rhinoceros tichorhinus are cited as characteristic, and perfect skeletons of the marmot have been found at Aix-la-Chapelle. At Canstadt near Stuttgart, loess contains many fossil bones, especially Elephas primigenius and some Rhinoceros tichorhinus, determined by Dr. Falconer, and is covered by travertine with fossil plants, all Recent except two.

    Chapter 74

  4. Why does loess composition vary in small basins but appear uniform in large river basins?

    Lyell explains that in a limited basin where detritus comes chiefly from one formation, the prevailing rock imparts its colour and composition to the loam, as near Tubingen where loam is mottled red and green like the Keuper. In a great river basin with many tributaries, the loam is a mixture of almost every rock variety, giving an average result nearly the same everywhere, like the Saone and Rhone valleys.

    Chapter 74

Section 754 cards
  1. What two kinds of land movement does Lyell invoke to explain loess accumulation and denudation?

    The author argues that loess is accumulated during subsidence and removed during upheaval of the land. He holds that the same downward and upward movements of the great mountain-chain would produce analogous effects whether the great rivers flowed northwards or eastwards, so the theory can apply to both the Rhine and Danube basins.

    Chapter 75

  2. How does Lyell compare subsidence rates in mountains versus near the coast?

    Lyell supposes depression and re-elevation were considerably greater in the central region than in the lower countries nearer the sea. He suggests the Alps might sink at 5 feet per century while coastal areas sank only inches, and that coastal subsidence was never enough to let the sea invade the continent's interior through the main river valleys.

    Chapter 75

  3. What European example does Lyell cite for unequal vertical crustal movement in the Jurassic and Cretaceous?

    M. Hebert demonstrated, with M. Lory's observations, that during the Oolitic and Cretaceous periods the Alps area was rising and emerging while the Jura area about 100 miles north was slowly sinking and became submerged at the start of the Cretaceous. These oscillations occurred without perceptible derangement of the strata, which stayed horizontal.

    Chapter 75

  4. How does Lyell compare the Gangetic mud of Bengal to European loess?

    Lyell says the Himalayan mud of Bengal resembles loess in being generally devoid of stratification and shells, though it occasionally contains land shells and calcareous concretions called kunkur, comparable to lime nodules in Rhenish loess. Borings at Calcutta reached 300 to 400 feet through fine loam, with fluviatile or terrestrial remains, implying gradual subsidence kept pace with sediment.

    Chapter 75

Section 764 cards
  1. What human remains did Boue find in the loess at Lahr, and who confirmed them?

    In 1823 M. Ami Boue disinterred many bones of a human skeleton with his own hands from ancient undisturbed loess at Lahr, nearly opposite Strasburg on the right side of the Rhine valley. No skull was detected, but the tibia, fibula, and several other bones were well preserved and shown to Cuvier, who pronounced them human.

    Chapter 76

  2. Where and at what depth was the human jaw found near Maestricht, and what was it near?

    According to Professor Crahay, the jaw now at Leyden was found 19 feet from the surface where the loess joins the underlying gravel, in a stratum of sandy loam over gravel and under pebbly and sandy beds. The stratum was said to be intact and undisturbed, but the jaw was isolated, the nearest elephant tusk six yards away horizontally.

    Chapter 76

  3. What did Lyell conclude about the authenticity and significance of the Maestricht jaw?

    Lyell and van Binkhorst could not verify Crahay's statements but saw no reason to suspect the jaw belonged to a different geological period than the extinct elephant. If granted, it might have no higher antiquity than Schmerling's Belgian cavern remains, but occurrence in a Pleistocene alluvial deposit in open plains would be one of the first examples of such a phenomenon.

    Chapter 76

  4. What does Lyell say about the dark-stained human skull remains at Maestricht and their age?

    The Maestricht museum holds a human frontal and pelvic bone stained dark peaty, the frontal remarkable for lowness and prominent superciliary ridges resembling the Borreby skull. Crahay's memoir mentions a dark human skull with leaves, nuts, and freshwater shells in a black deposit at Hocht. Lyell says these were of an age long posterior to the loess containing elephant bones and the Leyden jaw.

    Chapter 76

Section 774 cards
  1. What evidence shows the Chalk's displacement postdates the drift?

    The author notes that drift beds are horizontal where the underlying Chalk is horizontal, but inclined, curved, or vertical where the Chalk is similarly deranged. Since the drift shares the Chalk's bending, the whole displacement of the Chalk must be posterior to the origin of the drift, not older than it.

    Chapter 77

  2. What are the four subdivisions of the drift above the Chalk?

    From lowest up: Number 2, stratified loam and sand about 5 feet thick with Cardium edule, Tellina solidula, and Turritella shells; Number 3, unstratified blue clay or till with pebbles and Scandinavian rock fragments, 20 feet; Number 4, yellow sandy clay, 40 feet, with striated granite blocks; Number 5, stratified sands and gravel with erratics, 40 to 100 feet.

    Chapter 77

  3. What did Puggaard conclude about the sequence of events at Moens Klint?

    Puggaard concluded the horizontal Chalk subsided gradually after denudation, so littoral-shell drift (Number 2) was deposited in shallow sea; boulder clays 3 and 4 fell in deeper water via floating ice from the north; irregular subsidences then bent and engulfed Chalk and drift, exceeding 400 feet; finally re-elevation and partial denudation occurred, like modern Sweden and Norway.

    Chapter 77

  4. Why do the large erratics suggest they postdate the convulsions?

    Puggaard observed that huge erratics, 20 feet or more in diameter, lie on the surface of Number 5 in some parts of the island, implying ice carried them in a sea deep enough to float large icebergs. But these big erratics never enter the fissures, as they would have done had they existed before the convulsions.

    Chapter 77

Section 784 cards
  1. Why does Lyell suspect some rock movements may be more recent than assumed?

    Lyell argues that because the stratified drift is only accidentally present, and much denudation has occurred, we might wrongly refer verticality, flexures, and faults to ancient eras such as Eocene or Miocene. He suggests that in regions lacking such means of dating, movements may be far more modern than usually supposed, possibly explaining anomalies in erratic blocks and glacial furrows.

    Chapter 78

  2. What did Bravais observe about raised sea-beaches at Altenfjord, Finmark?

    M. Bravais observed an ancient water-level marked by a sandy terrace and wave erosion, traceable for 30 miles south to north along a fjord. It rose gradually from 85 feet to 220 feet above the sea, about 4 feet per mile. This was a remarkable exception to the generally uniform uplift of Scandinavian sea-beaches containing Recent marine shells.

    Chapter 78

  3. What did the 1855 New Zealand earthquake reveal about uplift along a fault?

    At Muko-muka, northern Cook's Straits, land rose suddenly and permanently, reaching 9 feet vertically and declining to nothing about 23 miles north-west. Mr. Edward Roberts found the upheaval followed a fault running at least 90 miles south to north. East of the fault, Tertiary strata stayed stationary, shown by a line of Nullipores marking the old sea-level.

    Chapter 78

  4. Why does Lyell think most post-Tertiary movements were not extreme?

    Lyell argues that the principal movements in any period seem more uniform, altering chiefly height relative to the sea rather than visible topography or strata position. Otherwise we would not find conformable strata of all ages, including shallow-water primary fossiliferous beds, remaining horizontal through thousands of feet of subsidence, nor Carboniferous, Devonian, or Silurian strata still horizontal across vast areas of North America and Russia.

    Chapter 78

Section 794 cards
  1. What makes the Torquay mammoth tooth more modern than the Brixham cave fossils?

    Lyell reports a mammoth tooth in the Torquay museum, believed dredged from a partly submerged vegetable deposit whose elevated portion forms the floor of the valley where Tor Abbey stands. He argues this elephant must be more modern than the fossil mammoths of the Brixham cave gravel, because it lived when Devonshire's physical geography was almost identical with that of today.

    Chapter 79

  2. How does Lyell date the mastodon fossil found near Goat Island?

    Lyell argues the fluvial beds at Goat Island are post-glacial, and the Niagara ravine, 7 miles long between Queenstown and Goat Island, is posterior to those mastodon-bearing beds. Using the still-ongoing recession of the falls as a time measure, he reckons the individual's antiquity not by thousands but by tens of thousands of years, if his minimum erosion estimate is correct.

    Chapter 79

  3. What does Lyell say about reports of mastodon bones pierced by arrowheads?

    Lyell says the widely circulated stories of mastodon bones with surfaces pierced as if by arrowheads or marked by stone implements must in future be more carefully inquired into. He notes we can scarcely doubt the North American mastodon lived down to a period when the mammoth co-existed with Man in Europe, and refers readers to his views on the Natchez human bone.

    Chapter 79

  4. What glacial evidence in North America does Lyell cite near the chapter's end?

    Lyell notes marine shells of this era rarely traced above 500 feet, with 700 feet the known maximum, and erratic blocks travelling north to south, rarely deviating more than fifteen degrees east or west of the meridian, suggesting icebergs as the transport agent. He also cites independent dispersal centres like the White Mountains and, per Hitchcock, Massachusetts hills, and describes Berkshire erratic trains about ten degrees farther south than European equivalents.

    Chapter 79

Section 804 cards
  1. Why does Lyell reject glaciers as the transport agent for the Berkshire erratics?

    Lyell argues glaciers are ruled out because the blocks were not dispersed radially from a center but carried in one south-easterly direction across ridges A, B, and C and the intervening valleys. Had glaciers moved them from summit d, blocks would have radiated in all directions, yet none are found west of ridge A despite its steep western slope. He concludes the propelling power acted exclusively south-eastward.

    Chapter 80

  2. What evidence shows the erratics were worn before transport, not after?

    The block n in train 6 is 52 feet long, 40 wide, and 15 high, with a regularly rounded, smoothed top like the roches moutonnees, but its lower angles are sharp and unblunted. A smaller detached fragment nearby would fit its lower angular part exactly. Lyell infers the smoothing occurred at the parent rock, since no attrition could have happened after the block left it.

    Chapter 80

  3. How does Lyell explain the limited scatter and varying travel distances of the erratic trains?

    Lyell argues blocks passing through sounds between islands issued from new narrow starting points, and train width varies, with train 6 branching at p into train 5 and stragglers between trains. Distance depended on current strength, wind, block weight, and ice draught. Smaller fragments traveled farthest: they were more numerous, needed less ice, grounded less on shoals, and restarted more easily.

    Chapter 80

  4. What does the drift deposit at Berkshire resemble, and what surface features underlie it?

    The deposit consists of sand, mud, gravel, and stones, mostly unstratified, resembling European till or boulder clay, varying from 10 to 50 feet thick and deeper in valleys; the top is rarely stratified. Some embedded stones are polished, striated, and furrowed, and all are of north-western rock types. Exposed underlying rock shows polished, furrowed surfaces running north-west to south-east, matching the erratics' course.

    Chapter 80

Section 814 cards
  1. What evidence does Lyell cite for the transporting power of coast-ice?

    Lyell describes an angular sandstone block 8 feet in diameter carried several miles by ice to the Petitcodiac estuary in Nova Scotia by 1852. At South Joggins in 1850, larger blocks were moved by coast-ice, floated half a mile, and dropped in salt water beside a coal-loading pier, requiring blasting at low tide. He notes this occurred at latitude 46 degrees north, in a bay never invaded by icebergs.

    Chapter 81

  2. What determines the size of erratics buoyed up by a sheet of ice, according to Lyell?

    Lyell argues that a sheet of ice of moderate thickness, if it extends over a wide area, may suffice to buoy up the largest erratics falling on it. The size of these blocks depends not on the intensity of the cold but on how the rock is jointed and the consequent dimensions of blocks splitting off when falling from an undermined cliff.

    Chapter 81

  3. What did Mr. Hopkins estimate about the Gulf Stream's effect on Europe's temperature?

    Lyell reports that Mr. Hopkins, in an essay on former climate changes, calculated Europe's annual temperature would drop about six or seven degrees Fahrenheit if the Gulf Stream were diverted. Hopkins also supposed that submerging much of northern and central Europe, letting an arctic cold current sweep over it, would add three or four degrees of refrigeration.

    Chapter 81

  4. What difficulty does Lyell raise against the Gulf Stream hypothesis for glacial cold?

    Lyell argues that North American glacial cold extended about 10 degrees of latitude farther south than in Europe. If a warm current flowed north through the center of the American continent instead of the Atlantic, it would heat precisely the latitudes where ice-action monuments are greatest. He suggests the cold maxima on opposite sides of the Atlantic may not have been simultaneous, possibly separated by a thousand or more centuries.

    Chapter 81

Section 824 cards
  1. To what did Darwin and Hooker attribute plants common to temperate zones north and south of the equator?

    Darwin and Hooker referred them to migrations along north-to-south mountain chains during colder phases of the glacial epoch. Lyell notes this hypothesis lets us dispense with the doctrine that the same species ever originated independently in two distinct and distant areas, and it becomes more feasible if meridional belts of warmer and colder climate coexisted rather than simultaneous extreme cold in both hemispheres.

    Chapter 82

  2. How do Behring's Straits compare with the Straits of Dover, and what did Herschel say of them?

    Herschel observed the straits parting Asia and North America are only thirty miles broad where narrowest and twenty-five fathoms at greatest depth, yet important in nature's economy, letting circulating warmer water reach the polar basin, mitigating polar cold and probably preventing continual ice accretion. Lyell notes they agree singularly with the Straits of Dover, the depth differing by no more than 3 or 4 feet.

    Chapter 82

  3. What effect did Lyell attribute to the conversion of the Sahara from sea to land?

    Lyell suggests that while the Sahara was still submerged, no sirocco blowing for days carried hot blasts from a wide expanse of burning sand across the Mediterranean. South winds were comparatively cool, allowing Alpine snows to augment to an extent estimated only by the colossal dimensions of moraines of extinct glaciers. He offers this as a probable cause of vast temperature change in central Europe in comparatively modern times.

    Chapter 82

  4. What did Lyell conclude the monuments of the glacial period would help determine?

    Lyell states that when more thoroughly investigated, the monuments of the glacial period will do much toward expanding our views as to the antiquity of the fauna and flora now contemporary with Man. This will therefore enable us the better to determine the time at which Man began in the northern hemisphere to form part of the existing fauna. He declines to pursue these speculations further, citing the scope and limits of the volume.

    Chapter 82

Section 834 cards
  1. What three forest trees succeeded one another in Danish peat, and what did their periods tally with?

    The pine (Scotch fir), buried in the oldest peat, gave place to the oak, and the oak in turn yielded to the beech. Lyell states that the periods when these three trees predominated tally pretty nearly with the ages of stone, bronze, and iron in Denmark.

    Chapter 83

  2. Why are shells of periwinkle, mussel, and cockle dwarfed in the Baltic near the kitchen-middens?

    The same species still live on the coast of the inland sea adjoining the mounds, but are dwarfed and never half their natural size because the water is rendered too fresh by the influx of many rivers. In the olden time, like the oyster, they attained full dimensions.

    Chapter 83

  3. What did M. Morlot estimate about the oldest remains in the Tiniere delta?

    Morlot estimated the probable antiquity of three superimposed vegetable soils in the delta of the Tiniere, each containing human bones or works of art belonging successively to the Roman, bronze, and later stone periods. He assigned an antiquity of at least 7000 years to the oldest, though Lyell calls such computations tentative and needing confirmation.

    Chapter 83

  4. What does Lyell argue caused the extinction of many Pleistocene species, beyond the growing power of Man?

    The author argues that causes more general and powerful than human agency—alterations in climate, variations in the range of animals and plants, and geographical changes in height, depth, and extent of land and sea—likely produced the annihilation of many large mammalia over a vast series of years. He grants Man's growing power may have aided as a destroying cause.

    Chapter 83

Section 844 cards
  1. How does Lyell explain the migration of Germanic fauna and flora into the British Isles?

    Lyell argues there must have been free land communication between the Continent and the British Isles, and among the islands themselves, within the Pleistocene epoch. This connection accounts for Germanic fauna and flora migrating into every part of the area and for Scandinavian plants and animals retreating into the higher mountains. He adds that the English Channel may have been laid dry and resubmerged more than once.

    Chapter 84

  2. What does the vast time gap between the Somme's higher and lower gravels suggest to Lyell?

    Both gravels are rich in similar-shaped flint implements, though oval forms predominate in the newer gravels. Lyell concludes that the state of the arts remained stationary for almost indefinite periods. He allows, however, that different degrees of civilisation may have existed, suggesting the Aurignac hunters who buried their dead with funeral rites may have been less barbarous than the savages of St. Acheul.

    Chapter 84

  3. Why did early bronze implements copy the shapes of stone tools?

    Lyell argues the earlier instruments of bronze were modelled on the exact plan of the preceding age's stone tools, even though such shapes would never have been chosen had metals been known from the first. He cites this as evidence of the slowness of progress in savage life and the reluctance or incapacity of savage tribes to adopt new inventions, noting some East Asian peoples still used stone implements after neighbouring metal-using empires had flourished three thousand years.

    Chapter 84

  4. What does Lyell argue about the idea of a primaeval state of superior intelligence?

    Lyell argues that if the original stock of mankind had truly been endowed with superior intellectual powers and inspired knowledge, and possessed the same improvable nature as their posterity, they would have reached an immeasurably higher point of advancement. He attributes notions of degeneracy to conquest by less civilised but more warlike peoples, or to social and political revolutions in which knowledge was lost.

    Chapter 84

Section 854 cards
  1. According to Lyell, what did Lucretius say early humans fought with before forging arms?

    Lucretius describes early humans as a dumb and filthy herd who fought for acorns and lurking-places first with nails and fists, then with clubs, and at last with arms forged through experience. Only afterward did they invent names for things and words for thoughts, then desist from war, fortify cities, and enact laws.

    Chapter 85

  2. What Egyptian evidence did Lyell cite for the high antiquity of the Negro and Caucasian races?

    Lyell referred to pictures on the walls of ancient Egyptian temples in which, a thousand years or more before the Christian era, the Negro and Caucasian physiognomies were portrayed as faithfully and in as strong contrast as if taken yesterday. He used this to support the great antiquity and persistence of these races.

    Chapter 85

  3. What did Lyell conclude from the Negro's slight modification after two centuries in Virginia?

    Lyell noted the Negro had undergone only slight modification after being transported from the tropics and settled for more than two centuries in temperate Virginia. He concluded that if all races descended from a single pair, a vast series of antecedent ages must be allowed, during which external circumstances produced peculiarities increased over successive generations and fixed by hereditary transmission.

    Chapter 85

  4. What dilemma did Lyell raise for those who deny unity of origin of human races?

    Lyell argued that if one rejects a common origin for strongly marked varieties like Negro and European, despite traits handed down unaltered for hundreds of generations, one must explain why the transmutationist's claim that allied species share a common parentage should be resisted. He asked where one stops unless standing on independent creation of human races.

    Chapter 85

Section 864 cards
  1. How did Lamarck revise the Linnaean definition of species?

    Lamarck proposed adding time to the definition: a species consists of individuals resembling each other and reproducing their like, so long as surrounding conditions do not change enough to alter their habits, characters, and forms. He concluded existing animals and plants were not primordial creations but derived from pre-existing forms that varied gradually over ages under altered climate and animate world, some diverging enough to count as new species.

    Chapter 86

  2. What two flaws did Lyell identify in Lamarck's theory?

    Lyell argued, as he had in 1832, that Lamarck failed to adduce a single instance of the initiation of a new organ in any animal or plant. Second, variation, whether natural or assisted by breeders and horticulturists, had never produced two races so remote in physiological constitution as to be sterile when intermarried, or fertile only in producing sterile hybrids.

    Chapter 86

  3. How did Lamarck answer the Egyptian mummy objection?

    Cuvier and others cited embalmed animals and plants from Egyptian tombs, some 3000 years old, showing no modification in specific characters. Lamarck replied that the climate and soil of the Nile valley had not varied in that interval, so no change was expected. Had physical geography and conditions altered as geology shows elsewhere, he said, some of those animals and plants would have deviated enough to rank as new species.

    Chapter 86

  4. What did Lyell say about Lamarck's monads and progressive advance?

    Lamarck taught a slow, continuous progressive advance of organic life from simplest to most complex, from lowest instincts to reason, with humans evolved from the most highly organised inferior mammalia. To explain the persistence of low forms, he imagined monads, germs of living things, continually arising for each primary division. Lyell says this is essentially the old doctrine of equivocal or spontaneous generation, unsupported by modern experiment or observation, and no aid in speculating on the origin of vital phenomena.

    Chapter 86

Section 874 cards
  1. What did Lyell argue against in 1832 regarding species, while agreeing with Lamarck on what?

    Lyell argued against Lamarck's doctrine of gradual transmutation of one species into another, but agreed that changes now in progress in the organic world would, when fully understood, serve as a complete key to interpreting past vicissitudes of the living creation. He also opposed the then-popular doctrine of sudden destruction of vast multitudes of species and abrupt introduction of new batches of plants and animals.

    Chapter 87

  2. What causes of species extinction did Lyell enumerate, and which hypothesis did he oppose?

    Lyell listed the power of hostile species, diminution of food, mutations in climate, and conversion of land into sea and sea into land. He firmly opposed Brocchi's hypothesis of a decline in the vital energy of each species, maintaining that the last surviving representatives had reproductive powers as vigorous as their predecessors and could repeople the earth under favourable circumstances.

    Chapter 87

  3. Why did Lyell think the scarcity and dying out of species supported fixity of specific character?

    Lyell argued that species becoming scarce and dying out one after another showed a want of pliancy and capability of varying, which ensured their annihilation whenever adverse changes occurred. Time was not allowed for such transformation as might adapt them to new circumstances and convert them into what naturalists would call new species.

    Chapter 87

  4. How did Sedgwick explain organic progression, and did he accept transmutation?

    Sedgwick saw traces of organic progression in the absence of mammalia in older deposits, their rarity in newer Secondary groups, their abundance in upper Tertiary, and the recent appearance of Man. He held this marked gradual evolution of creative power toward higher types, but stated the elevation was not made by transmutation, but by creative additions, with Cephalopoda, then Fishes, Reptiles, Mammals, and Man successively leading.

    Chapter 87

Section 884 cards
  1. What did Bronn conclude after classifying over 24,000 fossil animals and plants?

    Bronn concluded that more highly organised types of animal and vegetable life were introduced over time, with modern species being on the whole more specialised. By specialised he meant having separate organs or body parts for different functions, which in earlier periods and in simpler beings were discharged in common by a single part or organ.

    Chapter 88

  2. How does Brongniart describe the geological succession of major plant groups?

    Brongniart does not claim an exact historical series, but notes cryptogamic forms, especially acrogens, predominate in primary formations like the Carboniferous; gymnosperms (conifers and cycads) abound from the Trias to the Wealden; and angiosperms, both monocotyledonous and dicotyledonous, only become abundant in the Tertiary. Angiospermous exogens, four-fifths of living plants, are wholly unrepresented in fossils from the Silurian to the Oolitic.

    Chapter 88

  3. Why did Lyell argue the Oolite marsupial was fatal to the theory of successive development?

    In 1832 Lyell pointed out that a single fossil marsupial in the Oolite was fatal to the theory of successive development as then propounded, because the popular creed held that the first warm-blooded quadrupeds were the Eocene mammals of Montmartre. The Stonesfield discovery, made in 1818, had been disputed for over a quarter of a century before Lyell used it against that dogma.

    Chapter 88

  4. What does Lyell say about the doctrine of progression after later mammal discoveries?

    Lyell argues the doctrine of progression is not gainsaid by later discoveries, since less advanced marsupials precede more perfect placental mammalia in order of appearance. He also warns that the frequent shifting back of old landmarks, each once thought to mark the first appearance of warm-blooded quadrupeds, should caution against treating the present limit of palaeontology as final.

    Chapter 88

Section 894 cards
  1. How does the fossil record of reptiles contradict a simple progressionist view?

    The author argues that the order of succession is reversed: the Iguanodon and higher Secondary reptiles long preceded the Eocene Palaeophis and living boa, while the crocodile is now the highest representative of its class. He calls this a retrograde movement in the vertebrata, perhaps explained by the later dominance of placental mammalia, which competed most directly with the class below them.

    Chapter 89

  2. When were the first Carboniferous reptiles discovered, and what barrier did this break?

    For thirty-four years it was a received axiom in palaeontology that reptiles had never existed before the Permian or Magnesian Limestone period. In 1844 this supposed barrier was thrown down when Carboniferous reptiles, terrestrial and aquatic, of several genera were brought to light. Discussions continue over possible Enaliosaur remains in Nova Scotia coal and reptilian bones near Elgin in Scotland.

    Chapter 89

  3. What did Hooker observe about early plants that opposes progression?

    Dr. Hooker observed that no parallel can be established between the order of appearance of plant forms and their complexity of structure. The earliest recognisable Cryptogams are not only the highest now existing but have more highly differentiated vegetative organs than later forms, and the dicotyledonous embryo and perfect exogenous wood preceded the monocotyledonous embryo and endogenous wood in date of appearance.

    Chapter 89

  4. Why are transmutation supporters often cautious about progression, while progressionists oppose transmutation?

    The author argues that no one can believe in transmutation without being profoundly convinced that all we know in palaeontology is as nothing compared with what remains to learn. Those who see the record as fragmentary are astounded at the confidence progressionists place in defective data. Progressionists who overrate the record's completeness read breaks as original chasms or catastrophes, not material connections.

    Chapter 89

Section 904 cards
  1. What two 1858 papers preceded Darwin's Origin of Species?

    Lyell states that no decided step was made until the 1858 publication of two papers, one by Mr. Darwin and another by Mr. Wallace, followed in 1859 by Darwin's book on the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. Wallace's essay, written at Ternate in February 1858, was sent to Darwin, and Hooker and Lyell urged its immediate printing alongside a chapter of Darwin's manuscript.

    Chapter 90

  2. What population principle do Darwin and Wallace apply to animals and plants?

    Both begin by applying to the animal and vegetable worlds the Malthusian doctrine of population: the tendency to increase in a geometrical ratio while food can only augment even locally in an arithmetical one. Since there is no room or subsistence for a large proportion born into the world, many must annually perish, producing a constant struggle for existence among individuals of each species.

    Chapter 90

  3. How does Darwin's giraffe explanation differ from Lamarck's?

    Lyell contrasts Lamarck, who imagined the giraffe stretched itself up to reach lofty boughs until continued effort and longing produced an elongated neck, with Darwin and Wallace, who simply suppose that in a season of scarcity a longer-necked variety, able to browse on foliage out of reach of most of the herd, survived and transmitted its cervical peculiarity to successors.

    Chapter 90

  4. Why do Darwin and Wallace prefer indefinite modifiability over fixed limits?

    Lyell says every naturalist admits a general tendency to vary, but the usual assumption that species cannot pass certain limits is taken for granted without proof. Darwin and Wallace argue the opposite hypothesis, that every species can vary indefinitely from its original type, is not a whit more arbitrary, and has the manifest claim of explaining many phenomena the ordinary theory cannot.

    Chapter 90

Section 913 cards
  1. Why does Lyell say Darwin's theory lets us dispense with a law of progression?

    The author argues that one of the theory's principal claims to acceptance is that it dispenses with progression as a necessary accompaniment of variation. It accounts equally for degradation toward simpler structure and removes the need for Lamarck's continual creation of monads, which Lamarck required to explain why simple beings still exist after ages of progressive power.

    Chapter 91

  2. What does Darwin argue true classification in zoology and botany actually is?

    Darwin argues, with no small success according to Lyell, that all true classification in zoology and botany is in fact genealogical. Community of descent is the hidden bond naturalists have unconsciously been seeking, while they often imagined they were looking for some unknown plan of creation.

    Chapter 91

  3. Why are rudimentary organs useful in classification, according to the theory?

    Rudimentary organs are remnants preserved by inheritance of organs the species once used, such as eyes of insects and reptiles in dark caverns or wings of flightless birds and beetles. Affinities of species are often more readily discerned by these imperfect structures than by others of much greater physiological importance to the individuals themselves.

    Chapter 91

Section 924 cards
  1. What did Darwin conclude from finding that large genera contain relatively more variable species?

    Darwin argued that varieties are incipient species. The existence of larger genera implies that the manufacturing of species has been active in the period immediately preceding our own, so we should find the same forces still in full activity, especially since the process by which new species are produced is believed to be slow.

    Chapter 92

  2. Why did Hooker initially doubt Darwin's generalization about large genera, and what changed his mind?

    Hooker was long disposed to doubt the result because he was acquainted with so many variable small genera. However, after examining Darwin's data, he was compelled to acquiesce in the generalization. Lyell notes that verifying such a conclusion requires investigating many thousands of species, and exceptions may easily be adduced in both kingdoms.

    Chapter 92

  3. According to Hooker, are species visionary or real, and how does he describe their constancy?

    Hooker contends species are neither visionary nor arbitrary creations of the naturalist, but realities, though they may not remain true for ever. Most are so far constant within the range of our experience, and their forms are faithfully handed down through thousands of generations, so they admit of being treated as if permanent and immutable.

    Chapter 92

  4. What does Hooker say about reversion in cultivated plants, using apples as an example?

    Hooker questions reversion in plants. He says species do not readily vary, but once they begin, new varieties tend to depart further from the old stock. Finer apples grown from seed degenerate into crabs, but they become crab states of the varieties they belong to, not a return to the original wild crab-apple.

    Chapter 92

Section 934 cards
  1. What does Hooker say about the average altitude range of Himalayan flowering plants?

    Hooker states that the average range in altitude of each species of flowering plant in the Himalayan Mountains, whether in the tropical, temperate, or Alpine region, is 4000 feet, equivalent to twelve degrees of isothermals of latitude. Individuals taken from the upper limits of a species' range prove hardier in England's climate than those from lower, warmer stations.

    Chapter 93

  2. How does Lyell describe the doctrine of 'independent creation' as a scientific position?

    Lyell says that no rival hypothesis has been proposed to replace transmutation, and that what we call 'independent creation,' or the direct intervention of the Supreme Cause, must simply be considered an avowal that the question lies beyond the domain of science. He presents this as a concession rather than a positive explanation.

    Chapter 93

  3. What does Steenstrup's discovery of alternate generation show, and what limit does Lyell draw from it?

    Alternate generation shows that a species may pass through stages so different that able zoologists referred them to distinct genera or even families, as when a Sertularia and a Medusa interchange. But Lyell stresses that the organism returns to its exact starting point after the cycle, so no new form or species is introduced into the world.

    Chapter 93

  4. How do Darwin and Hooker counter Lyell's expectation that new species resemble their predecessors generically?

    Lyell had expected the creative power to introduce new modifications of old types, such as marsupials in Australia or new sloths in South America. Darwin and Hooker reply that successful colonisers are rarely allied to the old indigenous species; more often members of distinct and foreign genera, orders, or classes spread fastest, as with placental quadrupeds in Australia and horses in the pampas.

    Chapter 93

Section 944 cards
  1. How many Rubus species do Bentham and Babington respectively recognize?

    The chapter states that for one set of Rubus forms, Mr. Bentham adopts the view that they constitute three species, while Mr. Babington adopts the view that they constitute thirty-seven, in their well-known treatises on British plants. The author uses this disagreement to illustrate how hard it is for botanists to agree on species counts.

    Chapter 94

  2. Which four brachiopod genera persisted from the Silurian to Recent periods?

    According to Davidson's monograph, the four genera Rhynchonella, Crania, Discina, and Lingula have been traced through the Silurian, Devonian, Carboniferous, Permian, Jurassic, Cretaceous, Tertiary, and Recent periods, and still retain in existing seas the identical shape and character they showed in the earliest formations.

    Chapter 94

  3. How did Davidson reduce the British Carboniferous brachiopod species count?

    After studying not less than 260 reputed species from the British Carboniferous rocks, Mr. Davidson reduced that number to 100, to which he added 20 species either entirely new or new to the British strata, giving 120. He also declared his conviction that when knowledge of these 120 is more complete, a further reduction of species will take place.

    Chapter 94

  4. Why does the author argue missing links may never be found?

    The author argues that if, as Mr. Darwin contends, competition in the battle of life is keenest between closely allied varieties and species, then many forms can never be of long duration or wide range, and must often pass away without leaving any fossil memorials. In this manner he accounts for many breaks in the series that no future researches will ever fill up.

    Chapter 94

Section 954 cards
  1. What fraction of Falunian (Upper Miocene) mollusca did Lyell announce in 1830 belonged to living species, and was it confirmed?

    In 1830 Lyell announced, on the authority of M. Deshayes, that about one-fifth of the mollusca of the Falunian or Upper Miocene strata of Europe belonged to living species. The conclusion was questioned by a few eminent conchologists, including Alcide d'Orbigny, but was later confirmed by most naturalists and by Hoernes's work on Vienna Basin fossil shells, where about one-third of Miocene forms agree specifically with living mollusca.

    Chapter 95

  2. How did Professor Heer classify the Miocene plants and insects relative to living species?

    Heer did not venture to identify the vast Miocene assemblage with living species by giving them the same specific names. Instead he presented lists of 'homologous forms' so similar to living ones that he supposed genealogical derivation. He hesitated over the manner of transformation, asking whether changes came from an influence exerted continually for ages or whether old types were suddenly struck with a new image.

    Chapter 95

  3. What conditions preserved the Oeningen Miocene plants and insects in such a small area?

    Lyell lists four combined causes: a river flowing into a lake; storms of wind that tore off leaves and sometimes boughs and floated them into the lake; mephitic gases rising from the lake that occasionally killed insects flying over its surface; and a constant supply of carbonate of lime from mineral springs, which precipitated and mixed with fine mud to form the fossiliferous marls. The beds are thinly laminated marls only 3 or 4 feet thick.

    Chapter 95

  4. What did Lyell observe about the red admiral butterfly in Alabama versus Britain?

    Lyell saw the common English butterfly Vanessa atalanta, the 'red admiral,' flying in Alabama woods in mid-winter and could detect no difference himself. But Mr. Doubleday observed that all American specimens Lyell took to the British Museum showed a slight peculiarity in colouring of a minute part of the anterior wing, first detected by Mr. T.F. Stephens, who found similar constant variations in other Lepidoptera on opposite sides of the Atlantic, still regarded as mere varieties.

    Chapter 95

Section 964 cards
  1. What did Falconer's monograph conclude about the boundary between Mastodon and Elephas?

    Falconer's monograph on proboscidians treated the Pliocene Mastodon borsoni and Elephas primigenius as the two extremes of one type, with twenty-six species enumerated between them. The intercalation of so many intermediate forms largely broke down the generic distinction between Mastodon and Elephas, since his subgenus Stegodon forms an intermediate group from which other species diverge by dental characters toward mastodons on one side and elephants on the other.

    Chapter 96

  2. Why did Falconer restrict the supposed ubiquity of Elephas primigenius?

    Falconer discovered that four species of elephant had been confounded under the title Elephas primigenius, which had made the mammoth seem ubiquitous in Pleistocene times across half the habitable globe. Once restricted, the mammoth still had geographical varieties: American teeth can mostly be distinguished from European ones, named E. americanus by Leidy, and another race existed before the Glacial period, as at Cromer and the Norfolk cliffs.

    Chapter 96

  3. How do Schlegel and Falconer disagree about the Sumatran and Indian elephants?

    Schlegel argues the living Sumatran elephant agrees with the Ceylon form but is a distinct species from that of Continental India, distinguishable by the number of dorsal vertebrae and ribs, tooth form, and other characters. Falconer considers these mere geographical varieties, since the characters are not constant: ribs vary from nineteen to twenty in Bengal E. indicus and from twenty to twenty-one in different varieties of E. africanus.

    Chapter 96

  4. What does the fossil horse record of the Americas suggest about future pedigree research?

    The author argues that future speculation on the pedigree of extinct quadrupeds from European drift or caverns must look to North and South America for information. Darwin first detected a fossil horse in South America, two more species followed there, and in Nebraska Hayden obtained a species indistinguishable from the domestic horse plus five other fossil Solipedes genera. In all, twelve equine species in seven genera are detected in US Tertiary and Post-Tertiary formations.

    Chapter 96

Section 974 cards
  1. What two competing explanations for the Miocene flora link between Europe and eastern America does the chapter present?

    Unger and Heer argue, on botanical grounds, for a former Atlantic continent during part of the Tertiary period. Oliver, following Asa Gray's theory, prefers migration via an overland route from America to eastern Asia between the fiftieth and sixtieth parallels, south of Behring Straits along the Aleutian islands, reaching Mongolia before the glacial epoch.

    Chapter 97

  2. Why does Lyell say osteologists disagree over whether certain cave remains belong to living species?

    Lyell attributes the disagreement to the poverty of palaeontological data: we rarely have even one perfect skeleton of an extinct species, still less skeletons of both sexes and different ages. We usually know nothing of geographical varieties or of the successive changes of form between the Upper Miocene and Pleistocene. He lists cases such as Talpa fossilis and Ursus spelaeus.

    Chapter 97

  3. What law does Lyell state about the longevity of species and the rate of organic change?

    Lyell states that the lower an organism's place in the graduated scale, or the simpler its structure, the more persistent it is in form and organisation. He first noted this in mollusca, where more lamellibranchs than gasteropods could be identified with living species. He says the rate of change has been greater where the grade of organisation is higher, whatever its cause.

    Chapter 97

  4. How does Lyell use the absence of mammals on remote islands in relation to transmutation?

    Lyell notes that small warm-blooded quadrupeds are absent from islands far from continents, however well fitted those islands are to support them. Darwin says this favours his views, since bats, the only exception, could fly there. Lyell finds it hard to reconcile the antiquity of Madeira and the Canaries with this absence, and stresses how slowly habits and organisation change.

    Chapter 97

Section 983 cards
  1. Why does Lyell say bats and seals are unlikely to diverge into new terrestrial forms on islands?

    Lyell argues bats and seals are aberrant, highly specialised types, so they should show fixity and little pliancy in organisation. They would have the smallest aptitude for deviating toward new structures or habits, such as changing from aquatic to terrestrial or from volant to non-volant modes of life.

    Chapter 98

  2. How does interbreeding with mainland arrivals affect island races, according to Lyell?

    Lyell argues the same powers of flight that brought the first bats would bring new arrivals from Africa. These would mix and cross with the island stock, checking the formation of new races or keeping them true to old types, as with birds of Madeira and Bermudas. This is reinforced if, as Darwin tried to prove, offspring of slightly varying races are more vigorous and prolific.

    Chapter 98

  3. Why does Lyell caution against inferring new bat species or genera arose on islands?

    Lyell says we know too little about species and genera of neighbouring continents to be confident that supposedly peculiar island forms do not exist elsewhere, such as in Africa. He adds that many Pleistocene mammalia became extinct by causes independent of Man, so mainland types may have died out while surviving on islands, making it rash to infer time for new creation there.

    Chapter 98

Section 994 cards
  1. What did the Hallstadt and St. Cassian beds reveal about the Upper Trias?

    Their true place on the Austrian Alps' flanks revealed, for the first time, the marine fauna of the Upper Trias, forcing palaeontologists to intercalate about 800 species of Mollusca and Radiata between the Lower Lias and Middle Trias faunas. Previously many geologists believed that period comparatively barren of organic types; in England, France, and northern Germany the known Upper Triassic strata were mostly fresh or brackish-water beds with terrestrial and amphibious reptile bones.

    Chapter 99

  2. What did the Solenhofen Archaeopteryx discovery overturn about birds in Secondary rocks?

    Until 1858 no well-determined bird skeleton was known below the Tertiary; then Barrett found Cretaceous bird bones, confirmed by Owen. The Archaeopteryx from the Upper Oolite lithographic limestone of Solenhofen gave a second pre-Eocene bird. The author concludes we may learn how rashly birds' existence in the Secondary rocks had been questioned on negative evidence alone, and how many new forms may yet appear in well-known strata.

    Chapter 99

  3. How does Owen interpret the Archaeopteryx tail, and how does it differ from living birds?

    The tail has twenty vertebrae, each supporting a pair of plumes, 11.5 inches long and obtusely truncated. In all living birds tail-feathers form a fan attached to a coccygean bone of fused vertebrae, though in embryos those vertebrae are distinct; the ostrich has eighteen foetal caudal vertebrae reduced to nine in adults. Owen therefore considers the Archaeopteryx tail as exemplifying persistence of what is now an embryonic character.

    Chapter 99

  4. What did Mr. John Evans identify on the Solenhofen slab after Owen's paper?

    Evans found a smooth protuberance on the otherwise even limestone surface that appears to be a cast of the brain or interior of the skull, with some cranial bone possibly still buried in the matrix. He noted its resemblance to a cast taken from a crow's cranium and still more to a jay's, observing that the median line separating the brain's two hemispheres is visible in the fossil.

    Chapter 99

Section 1004 cards
  1. How does Max Muller argue for a lost Aryan parent language?

    Muller compares Latin, Greek, Sanscrit, Zend, Lithuanian, old Sclavonic, Gothic, and Armenian, claiming they are eight varieties of one older type, none of which could be the source of the others. He reasons that, as the Romance dialects imply Latin, these eight tongues imply a more ancient Aryan language, whose speakers migrated to Northern Asia, Europe, and India south of the Himalaya.

    Chapter 100

  2. What objection does Crawfurd raise against the Aryan hypothesis?

    Crawfurd argues that the Hindoos, Persians, Turks, Scandinavians, and others said to have borrowed words and grammatical forms from an Aryan source each belong to a distinct race, and these races have kept their peculiar characters unaltered since the earliest dawn of history and tradition. If no appreciable change occurred in three or four thousand years, the Aryan migrations would need a far more remote date.

    Chapter 100

  3. How does Lyell answer Crawfurd's objection about unchanged races?

    Lyell argues Crawfurd himself admits a Sanscrit-allied people probably once inhabited north-west India and later poured conquering hordes over Western Asia and Eastern Europe. Such conquerors may have been few compared to the populations they subdued and could merge within centuries. Lyell notes the colour and features of Negro or European are entirely lost in the fourth generation without fresh infusion, so Aryan physical features could vanish while words and grammatical forms were retained.

    Chapter 100

  4. Why does Lyell say philologists have an advantage over naturalists defending transmutation?

    Lyell argues that cognate languages, traced back, would converge sooner in the past than existing human races, meaning races change much more slowly than languages. Under transmutation, forming a new species would take incomparably longer than forming a new race. No language seems to last a thousand years, while many species seem to have endured hundreds of thousands, so the philologist's case is easier.

    Chapter 100

Section 1014 cards
  1. What preliminary fact does Lyell say the philologist must first establish about modern European languages?

    The philologist would begin by proving that none of the languages of modern Europe were a thousand years old. An English scholar without special study of Anglo-Saxon cannot interpret documents from King Alfred's day, and German speakers could not converse with their ninth-century Teutonic ancestors. Even the Nibelungen Lied, only seven centuries old, cannot now be enjoyed except by the erudite.

    Chapter 101

  2. What evidence does Lyell cite from the treaty of A.D. 841 between Charles the Bald and Louis of Germany?

    Lyell cites a surviving thousand-year-old peace treaty dated A.D. 841 in which the German king swears an oath in the French tongue of that day, while the French king swears in the German of the same era. Neither oath would now convey a distinct meaning to any but the learned in the two countries, showing ceaseless linguistic change.

    Chapter 101

  3. How does Lyell explain the wide gaps between dead and living languages?

    Lyell argues it is no part of any people's plan to preserve memorials of their speech for posterity. Manuscripts and inscriptions serve present purposes, are occasional and imperfect from the first, and grow more fragmentary as some are intentionally destroyed and others decay. To reject the derivative theory because intermediate dialects are rarely traceable, he says, shows want of reflection on recording and obliterating processes.

    Chapter 101

  4. What question about variability does Lyell raise, and what examples show new words entering circulation?

    Lyell asks whether there are any limits to linguistic variability, noting that within one lifetime people notice slight changes in accent, pronunciation, or spelling and borrowed words. New technical terms are coined almost daily, new inventions need names, and some acquire metaphorical senses — "stereotyped," for instance, would have been meaningless to seventeenth-century men, as railway terms would to eighteenth-century men.

    Chapter 101

Section 1024 cards
  1. According to Lyell, what causes some languages or dialects to prevail over others?

    The author argues that language change follows fixed laws rather than mere chance: in a struggle for existence, terms and dialects with slight advantages in brevity or euphony may win, and selection is driven by fashion, aristocracy, popular writers, orators, preachers, and centralized governments organizing schools to promote uniformity and overcome provincial dialects.

    Chapter 102

  2. How does Lyell use the Icelandic and Pennsylvania German colonies to illustrate language divergence?

    The author argues isolation drives divergence: a Norwegian colony in ninth-century Iceland kept a modified old Gothic while Norwegians at home, through European commerce, developed a new speech and saw Icelandic as stationary. A German colony in Pennsylvania, cut off around 1792–1815, preserved an obsolete dialect, and by 1841 Lyell found newspapers mixing English and German terms.

    Chapter 102

  3. What examples does Lyell give of sacred or venerable languages failing to survive?

    The author argues even superstitious veneration cannot make a language permanent: Hebrew ceased to be a living language before the Christian era, and Sanscrit, the sacred language of the Hindoos, shared that fate despite reverence for the Vedas and once-popular Sanscrit poems. Greek-speaking Christians of Constantinople and the Morea likewise read liturgy in ancient Greek while speaking a different dialect.

    Chapter 102

  4. What does Lyell compare redundant or silent letters in spelling to?

    The author argues that if gradual transmutation applies to languages, each historical language had a closely allied prototype, with evidence of additions and borrowing. Silent or redundant letters, once meaningful in the parent speech, are compared by Mr. Darwin to rudimentary organs in living beings that were more fully developed and functional in a remote progenitor.

    Chapter 102

Section 1034 cards
  1. According to Lyell, how do languages become more perfect as civilization advances?

    The author argues that as civilization advances, more terms are needed for abstract ideas, and words once used vaguely acquire precise meanings. This subdivision of function makes language more complete, like higher organisms having specialized organs for seeing, breathing, and digesting that simpler organisms perform with one body part.

    Chapter 103

  2. What did William Humboldt say about man and speech?

    Lyell quotes Humboldt's profound saying: "Man is Man only by means of speech, but in order to invent speech he must be already Man." Lyell adds that other animals may utter sounds as articulate and varied as the Bushman's clicks, but voice alone can never enable brute intelligence to acquire language.

    Chapter 103

  3. What does Lyell say about deifying Variation or Natural Selection?

    The author argues that if we confound Variation or Natural Selection with creational laws, we deify secondary causes or immeasurably exaggerate their influence. Yet he expects scientists will generally accept that past changes in the organic world came about through the subordinate agency of such causes, and says greater mysteries remain inscrutable.

    Chapter 103

  4. Why does Lyell say it is futile to speculate on the number of original germs?

    Lyell argues that if early species were simple and varied, losing organs by disuse and acquiring new ones, they might soon differ as much as distinct primordial types. He compares this to isolated human communities quickly developing distinct languages, and notes the oldest fossiliferous strata may be the last of a long series of antecedent formations.

    Chapter 103

Section 1044 cards
  1. What does Lyell say a theory linking fossil absence to human remains claims?

    Lyell says such a theory connects the absence of all vertebrate relics in the oldest fossiliferous rocks with the presence of man's remains in the newest. It also explains the successive appearance of fish, reptile, bird, and mammal in intermediate strata. He calls this a grand generalisation embracing many positive and negative facts from around the globe over countless ages.

    Chapter 104

  2. What conclusion does Lyell say transmutation would force on human origins?

    Lyell argues that if transmutation is adopted, we cannot escape concluding that Man himself descended by an unbroken line from some inferior animal. He says avoiding this would mean abandoning many weightiest arguments for variation and natural selection as subordinate causes. He notes the gaps between allied mammalian genera are physically as wide as those separating Man from his nearest mammalian kin.

    Chapter 104

  3. How did Linnaeus classify Man in his system?

    Lyell reports that Linnaeus led the way by comparing Man and the apes just as he compared apes with carnivores, ruminants, and rodents. After modifying his scheme, Linnaeus ended by placing Man as one of many genera in his order Primates, which also included apes, lemurs, and bats. Modern naturalists keep Primates but exclude bats and usually rank Man as one of several families.

    Chapter 104

  4. Why does Isidore G. St. Hilaire reject the order Bimana?

    St. Hilaire calls Bimana an impracticable compromise between the human kingdom and the human family. He says it is too near the higher mammalia given Man's elevated faculties, yet too far if only organic affinities with apes are considered. He argues such half-truths satisfy no one, and that many modern zoologists rejected Bimana, ranking Man as a family within Primates.

    Chapter 104

Section 1054 cards
  1. Why does Huxley reject the term 'Quadrumana' for apes?

    Huxley argues the hind-limb of the Gorilla ends in a true foot, not a hand, since it shares the tarsal bone arrangement, short flexor, short extensor, and peronaeus longus with Man. The hand-like look is only skin deep. He therefore rejects 'Quadrumana' as a serious misconception and regards Man as one of the families of the Primates.

    Chapter 105

  2. What dental evidence does Huxley use to classify Man with Old World monkeys?

    Huxley notes the Gorilla and all Old World monkeys except lemurs have thirty-two teeth, the same number as Man, with a similar crown pattern, though non-human canines project like tusks. American apes have thirty-six teeth, differing more from Old World apes than those differ from Man. He argues this supports placing Man among the Primates.

    Chapter 105

  3. On what three cerebral characters did Owen base his 'Archencephala' sub-class?

    Owen proposed a distinct sub-class, Archencephala, for Man, based on cerebral features he claimed were exclusively human: cerebral hemispheres overlapping the olfactory lobes and cerebellum and extending beyond them, a hind-lobe with a posterior horn of the lateral ventricle and hippocampus minor, and maximum convolutions. He associated these with peculiar mental powers.

    Chapter 105

  4. How does the Orang's anatomy differ more from the Gorilla than the Gorilla's does from Man?

    Huxley contends the Orang's thumb is shorter and lacks a special long flexor muscle, differing more from the Gorilla than the Gorilla's thumb differs from Man's. The Orang's carpus has nine bones, while the Gorilla, Chimpanzee, and Man have eight. Lower apes like the spider-monkey and marmoset diverge even further from the human type.

    Chapter 105

Section 1064 cards
  1. What did Gratiolet criticize about the Dutch anatomists' chimpanzee brain figures?

    Gratiolet said the engravings faithfully showed the cerebral foldings but gave a false idea of the relative position of brain parts, because the specimen had shrunk and sunk by its own weight. He reprinted the incorrect figures (54 and 55) alongside correct views (56 and 57) as a warning to readers.

    Chapter 106

  2. What four characters did Gratiolet say man and apes share?

    Gratiolet listed a rudimentary olfactory lobe, a posterior lobe completely covering the cerebellum, a well-defined fissure of Sylvius, and a posterior horn in the lateral ventricle. He stated these characters are not met with together except in Man and the apes, despite the contrast in brain size.

    Chapter 106

  3. What did the Dutch anatomists conclude from dissecting the orang-outang in 1861?

    Their dissection bore out their 1849 conclusions that both human and simian brains possess the occipital lobe, hippocampus minor, and posterior cornu—features Owen had claimed were exclusively human. They also admitted Gratiolet's comments on their figures were just, and regretted Owen had overstated man-ape brain differences.

    Chapter 106

  4. Why does Lyell reject the Dutch anatomists' explanation for Owen's errors?

    They suggested Owen was led astray by zeal against Darwin's theory. Lyell notes Darwin's and Wallace's papers appeared in 1858 and the Origin in 1859, after Owen's 1857 classification, so the timing does not fit. He suggests the anatomists may have confused Owen's later prefatory allusions with earlier motives.

    Chapter 106

Section 1074 cards
  1. What did Marshall's 1861 dissection of a young chimpanzee show about the posterior lobe?

    Marshall dissected a young chimpanzee immediately after death and made photographic drawings showing that, in the fresh state, the posterior lobe of the cerebrum extends backward beyond the cerebellum even farther than in Gratiolet's figure. The projection was about one-ninth of the cerebrum's total length, versus an average of one-eleventh in the human brain. He also described how displacement and distortion occur when brains are preserved in spirits.

    Chapter 107

  2. According to Huxley's summary, how do lemurs differ from other primates in cerebellar and posterior lobe structure?

    Huxley stated that every lemur yet examined has its cerebellum partially visible from above, and its posterior lobe, with the contained posterior cornu and hippocampus minor, more or less rudimentary. Every marmoset, American monkey, Old World monkey, baboon, or man-like ape, by contrast, has its cerebellum entirely hidden and possesses a large posterior cornu with a well-developed hippocampus minor. In some, such as the Saimiri, the lobes extend proportionally farther behind the cerebellum than in Man.

    Chapter 107

  3. How did Owen's 1862 gorilla claim differ from his 1861 lecture and from Huxley?

    In an 1862 British Association paper, Owen stated that in the gorilla the cerebrum extends over the cerebellum but not beyond it. This corrected his own 1861 Royal Institution lecture, which had represented a considerable part of the gorilla's cerebellum as uncovered. It was also slightly at variance with Huxley, who maintained the cerebrum does project beyond. Owen further noted that in the Maimon Baboon the cerebrum extends backward beyond the cerebellum.

    Chapter 107

  4. Why does Lyell say the attempt to distinguish human from ape brains by new cerebral characters was abandoned?

    Lyell argues the attempt to distinguish Man's brain from the ape's on newly discovered cerebral characters showing differences in kind was virtually abandoned by its originator, Owen. If the subclass Archencephala is retained, it must rest on differences in degree, such as Man's vastly larger brain in absolute size and still greater relative size to body bulk. Huxley noted the smallest human cranium measured 63 cubic inches versus 34.5 for the largest gorilla, yet human racial variation is greater still.

    Chapter 107

Section 1084 cards
  1. Why does Lyell say brain volume cannot be dismissed as unrelated to mental power?

    Lyell argues we cannot conclude that mental differences have no connection to brain volume, since the highest and most civilised races exceed the lowest in average cranial capacity—the European brain being larger than the negro's and somewhat more convoluted and less symmetrical—and apes nearest Man in brain form and volume are more intelligent than Lemurs, Rodents, and Marsupials. Yet he notes the elephant and dog's great intelligence shows how far we are from understanding the real dependence of intellect on cerebral structure.

    Chapter 108

  2. What does Professor Rolleston suggest about differences of degree versus kind?

    Rolleston remarks that even if Man's brain and the ape's proved to differ entirely in quantity, there is no reason in nature why so many and such weighty differences in degree should not amount to a difference in kind. He notes that degree and kind are mutually exclusive terms in the language of the schools, but whether they are so in the laboratory of Nature we may well doubt. He also suggests the soul or higher faculties may play the first part in a progressive scheme.

    Chapter 108

  3. What two attributes does M. Quatrefages use to place Man in a separate kingdom?

    Quatrefages, in his work on the Unity of the Human Species, argues Man must form a kingdom by himself if his moral and intellectual endowments are given due weight in classification. He observes that anatomy shows near-absolute identity of structure with the mammalia, and that upright posture, mental faculties, speech, and love and hatred are shared with animals. The distinguishing characters, he says, are the moral faculty—the abstract notion of good and evil, right and wrong, virtue and vice—and the religious faculty, a belief in a world beyond and in higher beings.

    Chapter 108

  4. What does Archbishop Sumner add as the essential distinguishing character of Man?

    Lyell notes that Quatrefages omits a character Dr. Sumner, the late Archbishop of Canterbury, brought out in his Records of Creation: the power of progressive and improvable reason, which Sumner calls Man's peculiar and exclusive endowment. Sumner warns that comparison should not be drawn from upright form, which is not confined to mankind, nor from the vague term reason, which cannot always be accurately separated from instinct.

    Chapter 108

Section 1094 cards
  1. What test does the cited author propose for the alleged analogy between savage and brute?

    The author acknowledges it may be founded on fact that less difference exists between the highest brute and the lowest savage than between the savage and the most improved Man. But he argues the analogy only holds if the lowest savage is also no more capable of improvement than the Chimpanzee or Orang-outang. Animals, he says, are born what they are intended to remain; Man alone has improvable reason.

    Chapter 109

  2. Why does Lyell reject Agassiz's immortality argument as applied to animals?

    Agassiz held that every animal has an immaterial principle, and that most philosophical arguments for Man's immortality apply equally to its permanency in other living beings. Lyell, without impugning the doctrine itself, replies that only the weaker arguments carry over: identity persisting through bodily change. The weightiest arguments do not transfer, since no inferior animal can be imagined as undergoing moral trial or drawing comfort from faith in a hereafter.

    Chapter 109

  3. Why does Lyell think missing fossil links between apes and Man have not been found?

    Lyell argues that negative evidence is weak given the present state of science. The anthropomorphous apes live in tropical Africa and Borneo and Sumatra, regions whose Pliocene and Pleistocene mammalia are almost unknown. Brazil, the only equatorial region with explored ossiferous caverns, is not where an old-world type like Man should be sought. He expects the missing links in equatorial Africa and the East Indies, not in examined districts.

    Chapter 109

  4. What does Hallam mean by saying Man was made in the image of an ape?

    Hallam argues that the law of continuity binds Man's bodily structure to lower animal life through common conditions of nourishment, reproduction, and self-defence. He suggests this may explain the conflict between Man's intellectual and moral endowments and his animal appetites. Creation, he says, has necessary chasms and leaps between creatures. Standing on the frontier between animal and angelic natures, Man partakes of both.

    Chapter 109

Section 1104 cards
  1. How does Asa Gray describe the relationship between naturalist classifications and nature?

    Gray argues that nature secures her ends and makes distinctions manifest and real, but without important breaks or long leaps. Gradations between species and varieties occur, and genera and other groups are not absolutely limited, though systems represent them as such. He concludes that naturalists' classifications define abruptly where nature more or less blends, since our systems are nothing if not definite.

    Chapter 110

  2. What objection does a geologist reviewer raise about linking brute instinct to human mind?

    The reviewer, himself an accomplished geologist, declares that embracing continuous variation of all organic forms including Man as the last link requires a transition from brute instinct to the noble mind of Man. He asks where the missing links are and at what point Man acquired the spiritual part of his being and the awful attribute of immortality.

    Chapter 110

  3. How does Lyell counter the demand for an absolutely insensible passage to human reason?

    Lyell demurs from the assumption that variation and natural selection require an absolutely insensible passage from the highest animal intelligence to improvable human reason. He points to the birth of an individual of transcendent genius to ordinary parents as a phenomenon showing that progressive schemes may admit occasional strides, constituting breaks in an otherwise continuous series of psychical changes.

    Chapter 110

  4. What does Asa Gray say about natural selection and Natural Theology?

    Gray argues that the doctrine of Variation and Natural Selection does not weaken Natural Theology, since one may hold any popular view of how natural changes occur: forces communicated at the first without subsequent interference, occasional direct interposition of the Deity, or constant orderly action of an intelligent efficient Cause. Those who require direct creative action for individuals or species may retain that view compatibly with transmutation.

    Chapter 110

Section 1113 cards
  1. How does Lyell answer the charge that development theory is materialistic?

    The author argues that successive geological introduction of sensation, instinct, higher mammalian intelligence, and human reason shows an ever-increasing dominion of mind over matter, not materialism. He cites Asa Gray to argue that transmutation and perpetual adaptation leave the design argument as valid as ever, since working through an instrument presupposes more power, not less.

    Chapter 111

  2. What point does Lyell make using Newton and Leibnitz?

    The author invokes Dr. Gray's reminder that Newton and Leibnitz were both profoundly religious and philosophical, yet Newton produced the theory of gravitation while Leibnitz objected that it subverted natural religion. Lyell uses this to show that charges of irreligion against new scientific theories are not reliable, since the objection came from the religiously sincere side.

    Chapter 111

  3. How does the chapter's note classify strata above the Chalk?

    The note says the majority of British geologists use a slight modification of Lyell's 1833 classification: Neogene (Pleistocene, Pliocene, Miocene) and Palaeogene (Oligocene, Eocene). It differs chiefly by adding Oligocene for the upper part of Lyell's original Eocene. The note also argues against separating the Quaternary or Recent, since there is no definite break at the top of the Pliocene.

    Chapter 111

Section 1124 cards
  1. What Palaeolithic culture stages are listed, from latest to earliest?

    The recognised stages, from latest to earliest, are Azilian, Magdalenian, Solutrean, Aurignacian, Mousterian, Acheulean, Chellean, Strepyan, and Mesvinian. Below the Mesvinian lies the "nebulous region of eoliths," which are not yet definitely proved to be of human workmanship. The Neanderthal skull belongs to the Mousterian stage.

    Chapter 112

  2. Which human remains are the oldest known, and to what stage does the Neanderthal skull belong?

    The Neanderthal skull belongs to the Mousterian stage. The oldest known definitely human remain is the jaw from the Mauer sands near Heidelberg, which may be older than any of the recognised stages; some authorities assign it to the first interglacial period of Penck and Bruckner.

    Chapter 112

  3. What does the chapter say about the supposed pre-glacial remains at Ipswich?

    The chapter states that the supposed discovery of remains of pre-glacial man at Ipswich appears to be founded on errors of observation. According to the best authorities, the boulder-clay above the interment is merely a landslip or flow, not evidence of pre-glacial human antiquity.

    Chapter 112

  4. What evidence does the chapter cite for the great age of the Scottish peat-mosses?

    Lewis traced nine successive layers in Scottish peat-mosses, marked by different floras. The lowest layer and another at a higher level are distinctly arctic, while intermediate forest beds indicate milder periods when the tree limit in Scotland was higher than now. This shows the peat dates back at least to the later glacial stages and records a mild interglacial episode.

    Chapter 112

Section 1134 cards
  1. What did study of erratics reveal about ice streams during the glacial period?

    The chapter states that from a study of these erratics it has been found possible to draw important conclusions as to the direction and sequence of the ice streams which flowed over these regions during the different stages of the glacial period.

    Chapter 113

  2. What did Nansen observe on crossing Greenland, and where has bedrock been seen?

    On his first crossing of Greenland from east to west, Nansen attained a height of 9000 feet on a vast expanse of frozen snow, believed to rise even higher toward the north. The snow surface is perfectly clean and free from moraine-material, and no rock in situ has been seen in Greenland's interior more than 75 miles from the coast.

    Chapter 113

  3. What is the Coombe Rock, and how did Clement Reid explain its formation?

    Clement Reid describes the Coombe Rock as a mass of unstratified flints and Chalk debris filling the lower parts of the dry valleys (Coombes) of the South Downs, gradually passing into the brick-earth of the coastal plain. It is clearly a torrential accumulation, supposed to have formed while the Chalk was frozen, preventing water percolation and causing surface water to run off as strong streams during a period of heavy precipitation.

    Chapter 113

  4. How do Penck and Bruckner classify the Alpine glaciations and interglacial episodes?

    In Die Alpen im Eiszeitalter, Penck and Bruckner claim to have established four periods of ice advance, named the Gunz, Mindel, Riss, and Wurm glaciations, with corresponding interglacial genial episodes when the climate was possibly even somewhat warmer than now. During the maximum advance of the Riss period, the Rhone glacier's terminal moraine extended as far as Lyon and became continuous with the Rhine glacier's moraine.

    Chapter 113

Section 1144 cards
  1. Where were the centres of the Pleistocene ice-sheets in Europe and America?

    The ice-sheets radiated from independent centres, not from the extreme north of either continent and not from a general polar ice-cap. The European centre lay over the Baltic region or southern Scandinavia; the American centre was near Hudson's Bay. The American sheet reached about latitude 38 degrees north south of the Great Lakes, while the North European ice barely passed 50 degrees north in Central Europe.

    Chapter 114

  2. What is the main weakness of the Adhemar-Croll astronomical theory of the Ice Age?

    The theory is founded on changes in the ellipticity of the earth's orbit and is expounded by Sir Robert Ball. The text says its weak point, though mathematically unassailable, is that it proves too much: it postulates a constant succession of glacial periods throughout earth-history, for which there is no evidence. Meteorological hypotheses, such as Harmer's, are called the most promising field.

    Chapter 114

  3. Why does the footnote reject the argument about Conifers and dicotyledons?

    The footnote says the statement's meaning is unclear because Conifers are not dicotyledons: their seeds contain numerous cotyledons, up to twenty, and the plant belongs to a lower stage of development. The argument is therefore fallacious. In fact the groups appeared in the order evolution postulates: Gymnosperms, then Monocotyledons, then Dicotyledons, as Arber argued.

    Chapter 114

  4. What revision of Palaeolithic classification does the footnote on Pithecanthropus propose?

    It says the important line of division comes not between Palaeolithic and Neolithic as formerly thought, but in the middle of the Palaeolithic, between Mousterian and Aurignacian. Mousterian or Neanderthal man appears to have become extinct, possibly exterminated by migrating Aurignacian people, regarded as ancestors of modern man in Europe. Aurignacian to Azilian stages are closer to Neolithic.

    Chapter 114

Source and licence

Text used: Project Gutenberg eBook #6335 (Public domain in the United States). Generated from the full text; cards paraphrase the source.

Version: Public domain edition. Retrieved 2026-11-20. Cards reviewed 2026-11-20.

These cards paraphrase the text for study. They are not a substitute for reading the book, and they do not reproduce long passages.

Turn your own notes into cards

Upload a PDF, Word, or text file and get question-and-answer cards for closed-notes practice. Five cards are free, no signup.

Try 5 free cards