Book Cards

The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte Flashcards

Marx argues that people make history under inherited conditions and that revolutions replay past forms until circumstances allow genuine change, tracing France from February 1848 to Louis Bonaparte’s December 1851 coup. The deck covers his claims on historical repetition, class conflict, the June insurrection, and the phases of the revolution.

1 / 124

Chapter 1 · Question

What does Marx say Hegel forgot to add about historic facts and personages?

WakeCards · wakecards.com · Big ideas. Quick review.

Arrow keys move between cards. Space or Enter flips.

All questions and answers

Every card in the deck, in reading order. Click a chapter to expand. The reviewer above uses the same content.

Section 14 cards
  1. What does Marx say Hegel forgot to add about historic facts and personages?

    Marx credits Hegel with the claim that great historic facts and personages recur twice, then adds the missing clause: "Once as tragedy, and again as farce." He illustrates with Caussidiere for Danton, Louis Blanc for Robespierre, the Mountain of 1848-51 for that of 1793-05, and the Nephew for the Uncle.

    Chapter 1

  2. How does Marx describe the relationship between people and the conditions of their history-making?

    The author argues that man makes his own history, but not out of the whole cloth or under conditions of his own choosing; he makes it out of conditions he finds close at hand. The tradition of all past generations weighs like an alp upon the brain of the living, pressing on people even in revolutionary crises.

    Chapter 1

  3. What did the heroes of the old French revolution achieve in Roman costumes and phrases?

    Marx argues they achieved the task of their time: the emancipation and establishment of modern bourgeois society. One set destroyed the feudal groundwork and heads; Napoleon created conditions for free competition, exploitation of partitioned lands, and industrial production, and swept away feudal establishments beyond France to give the bourgeois system fitting European surroundings.

    Chapter 1

  4. Why did bourgeois society need heroism and terror to come into the world, according to Marx?

    The author argues that bourgeois society, though lacking in heroism, nevertheless needed heroism, self-sacrifice, terror, civil war, and bloody battlefields to bring it into the world. Its gladiators found in stern classic Roman traditions the ideals, forms, and self-deceptions needed to conceal the narrow bourgeois substance of their struggles and sustain great tragic passion.

    Chapter 1

Section 24 cards
  1. What does Marx say the reviving of the dead served in earlier revolutions?

    The author argues that reviving the dead in earlier revolutions served to glorify the new struggles rather than parody the old, to exaggerate the task to the imagination rather than recoil before solving it, and to rekindle the revolutionary spirit rather than trot out its ghost. In 1848-51, by contrast, only the ghost of the old revolution wandered about.

    Chapter 2

  2. How does Marx contrast bourgeois and proletarian revolutions?

    The author argues bourgeois revolutions rush rapidly from success to success, with stage effects outbidding one another, but are short-lived and reach their climax speedily before society relapses into a long nervous reaction. Proletarian revolutions, by contrast, criticize themselves constantly, interrupt their own course, return to what seemed accomplished to start anew, and recoil before the undefined magnitude of their own objects.

    Chapter 2

  3. What did the election of December 10th prove about the French?

    The author argues the French could not rid themselves of the Napoleonic memory so long as they were busy with a revolution, as the election of December 10th proved. They longed to escape the dangers of revolution back to the flesh pots of Egypt, and the 2d of December, 1851, was the answer—not merely a caricature of the old Napoleon but the old Napoleon himself, caricatured.

    Chapter 2

  4. What did the Democrats believe about May 2d, 1852, and how did Marx judge it?

    The author argues May 2d, 1852, had become a fixed idea and dogma among the Democrats, like the day Christ was to reappear for the Chiliasts. Weakness took refuge in the wonderful, believing the enemy overcome if hocus-pocused away in imagination. They packed their satchels and took laurels in advance, but the 2d of December struck them like a bolt from a clear sky.

    Chapter 2

Section 34 cards
  1. What three main periods does Marx identify in the French revolution from February 1848 to December 1851?

    Marx outlines three periods: first, the February period (February 24 to May 4, 1848), the prologue of the revolution; second, the period of constituting the republic, or the constitutive national assembly (May 4, 1848, to May 29, 1849); third, the period of the constitutional republic, or the legislative national assembly (May 29, 1849, to December 2, 1851).

    Chapter 3

  2. Why does Marx say the February days originally aimed at suffrage reform rather than a republic?

    Marx argues the February days originally contemplated only a reform of the suffrage laws, extending the politically privileged among the property-holding class and overthrowing the exclusive rule of the finance aristocracy. Only when real conflict came—the people on the barricades, the National Guard passive, the army unresisting, the kingdom fleeing—did the republic seem self-understood, and each party interpreted it in its own sense.

    Chapter 3

  3. What happened to the Paris proletariat after the June insurrection, according to Marx?

    The bourgeois republic won the June insurrection, described by Marx as the most colossal event in the history of European civil wars. Over 3,000 insurgents were massacred and 15,000 transported without trial. Marx argues the proletariat then stepped to the background, entering alliances with other fermenting classes and sharing their defeats, while its leaders fell to the courts and it turned to doctrinaire experiments like co-operative banking and labor exchange schemes.

    Chapter 3

  4. How does Marx characterize the February government and the mood of that period?

    Marx says the February government declared itself 'provisional,' and like the government, everything broached, attempted, or uttered pronounced itself provisional; nobody and nothing dared assume permanent existence. All elements that had prepared the revolution—dynastic opposition, republican bourgeoisie, democratic-republican small traders, social-democratic labor—found 'provisionally' their place in it. Marx describes a motley mixture of high-sounding phrases with doubt and helplessness.

    Chapter 3

Section 44 cards
  1. What did the June defeat reveal about the Bourgeois Republic in Europe?

    Marx argues the defeat of the June insurgents leveled the ground for the bourgeois republic but also showed that Europe faced issues beyond 'Republic or Monarchy.' It revealed that the Bourgeois Republic meant the unbridled despotism of one class over another. In older civilized nations with developed class distinctions, the republic is only the political revolutionary form of bourgeois society, not its conservative form as in the United States.

    Chapter 4

  2. How does Marx contrast the bourgeois republic in Europe with that in the United States?

    Marx argues that in the United States the republic is the conservative form of bourgeois society: classes exist but lack permanent character, are in constant flux, and modern production compensates for scarce population. In older European nations, with developed class distinctions and dissolved traditions, the republic can only be the political revolutionary form of bourgeois society, not its conservative form of existence.

    Chapter 4

  3. What was the 'Party of Order' and what slogan did it use against the June insurgents?

    All classes and parties joined hands in the June days as a 'Party of Order' against the proletariat, designated the 'Party of Anarchy,' of Socialism, of Communism. They claimed to have saved society against its enemies, giving out the slogans 'Property, Family, Religion, Order' as pass-words, crying to counter-revolutionary crusaders: 'In this sign thou wilt conquer!' Marx argues any party later taking the revolutionary field in its own class interest goes down before this same cry.

    Chapter 4

  4. Who were the 'pure republicans' of the National party and how did they come to power?

    The party of the 'National' was a coterie of bourgeois with republican ideas—writers, lawyers, officers, civil employees—purely republican, demanding a republican instead of monarchic form of bourgeois government and the bourgeoisie's lion's share. Marx argues it came to power not through a liberal bourgeois revolt against the throne as dreamed, but through a grape-shot-and-canistered mutiny of the proletariat against Capital—the most counter-revolutionary event, fruit from the Tree of Knowledge, not Life.

    Chapter 4

Section 53 cards
  1. How did the 1848 Constitution treat the freedoms of 1848?

    It proclaimed personal freedom, press, speech, association, assemblage, instruction and religion as absolute rights of the French citizen, but only insofar as they were not curtailed by the "equal rights of others," "public safety," or the laws. Future organic laws were to regulate these glosses, and Marx argues the "Friends of Order" later used them to restrict the freedoms in the bourgeoisie's interest.

    Chapter 5

  2. Why does Marx call the Constitution vulnerable at its head?

    Because the relation between President and Legislative Assembly is the one part framed absolutely and without contradiction. The Assembly can constitutionally remove the President, but the President can set aside the Assembly only by setting aside the Constitution itself. Marx argues the Assembly thereby challenges its own violent destruction, extending the division of powers to a contradictory extreme.

    Chapter 5

  3. What powers did the Constitution give the President?

    He appoints and removes ministers independently of the Assembly, controls all executive means and posts, commands the armed power, grants pardons, suspends the National Guards, and removes elected councilmen with the Council of State's consent. He also initiates foreign negotiations. His power expires on the second Sunday of May in the fourth year after election, with 600,000 francs set aside for him.

    Chapter 5

Section 64 cards
  1. How did the constitution's framers try to outwit fate, and with what result?

    The pure republicans sought to outwit fate through Section 111 of the Constitution, which required every motion to revise it to be discussed three successive times, a full month apart, needing at least a three-fourths majority and 500 members voting. Marx says this was only an impotent attempt to preserve as a parliamentary minority a power already daily slipping from their weak hands.

    Chapter 6

  2. What role does Marx assign to the state of siege of Paris?

    Marx calls the state of siege of Paris the midwife of the constitutional assembly during its republican pains of travail. He notes that when the constitution was later swept away by the bayonet, it should be remembered that the bayonet had also protected it in its mother's womb and planted it on earth, and that this bayonet was turned against the people.

    Chapter 6

  3. What constitutional requirement did Louis Bonaparte violate, according to Marx?

    Article 44 of the Constitution states that the President of the French Republic must never have lost his quality of French citizen. Marx notes that L. N. Bonaparte, the first President, had not only lost that quality and been an English special constable, but was even a naturalized Swiss citizen.

    Chapter 6

  4. How does Marx characterize the December 10, 1848 election of Louis Bonaparte?

    Marx says it was a reaction of the farmers' class, expected to pay the costs of the February revolution, against the other classes of the nation: a reaction of the country against the city. It was favored by soldiers, by the great bourgeoisie who saw Bonaparte as a bridge to the monarchy, and by proletarians and small traders who saw him as a scourge to Cavaignac.

    Chapter 6

Section 74 cards
  1. What did Bonaparte's ministry decide at its first session regarding the Roman expedition?

    At its first session, the ministry decided to carry out the expedition to Rome behind the back of the National Assembly and to wring the funds for it from the Assembly under false pretences. Marx presents this as the start of a swindle on the National Assembly combined with a secret conspiracy with absolute foreign powers against the revolutionary Roman republic.

    Chapter 7

  2. What did the party of Order demand of the constitutive assembly on January 6, 1849?

    Through Representative Rateau, the party of Order proposed that the assembly abandon the organic laws and instead order its own dissolution. Royalist members and the Barrot ministry argued its dissolution was necessary to restore public credit, consolidate order, and end the provisional state. Marx notes Bonaparte later repeated these same slogans against the royalists themselves on December 21, 1851.

    Chapter 7

  3. What happened on January 29, 1849, and how does Marx characterize it?

    On January 29, 1849, the constitutional assembly was to decide on its own dissolution; its building was occupied by the military, and Changarnier held a great military review while royalists threatened force. Marx asks whether this was anything but the coup d'état of December 2, 1851, executed by the royalists with Napoleon's aid against the republican assembly.

    Chapter 7

  4. How did Bonaparte respond to the Assembly's May 8, 1849 censure of the ministry?

    When the National Assembly censured the ministry over Oudinot's occupation of Civita-Vecchia and ordered the Roman expedition returned to its alleged purpose, Bonaparte published that same evening in the Moniteur a letter congratulating Oudinot on his heroic feats. Marx says Bonaparte thereby posed as the generous protector of the Army against the quill-pushing parliamentarians, while the royalists merely smiled and took him for their dupe.

    Chapter 7

Section 83 cards
  1. How does Marx contrast the course of the 1789 revolution with that of 1848?

    The author argues the first French revolution moved along an upward line: Constitutionalists, then Girondins, then Jacobins, each resting on its more advanced element until shoved aside by more daring allies. In 1848 the reverse occurs: the proletarian party is betrayed by the democratic party, which leans on bourgeois republicans, who lean on the party of Order, which leans on armed power—a downward line.

    Chapter 8

  2. What was the Barrot-Falloux Ministry and what advantages did the party of Order hold in 1849?

    Bonaparte installed the Barrot-Falloux Ministry on December 20, 1849, the day of his 'Ascension'; it was a ministry of the party of Order, the Legitimist and Orleanist coalition. Marx notes the party of Order held the Government, the Army, and the legislative body—total state power—morally strengthened by general elections and by counter-revolutionary victory across Europe.

    Chapter 8

  3. What contradictions does Marx say define the Constitutional Republic's period?

    The author argues the period from May 29, 1849 to December 2, 1851 is a jumble of contradictions: constitutionalists conspiring against the Constitution, revolutionists who are constitutional, royalists upholding the republic they hate, an Executive strong in its weakness, and a republic that is the combined infamy of two monarchies with an imperial label.

    Chapter 8

Section 94 cards
  1. What did Marx say actually kept the Legitimists and Orleanists apart?

    Marx argues that what divided the two royalist factions was not their professed principles but their material conditions of life: two different forms of property. The Legitimists represented large landed property, the Orleanists high finance, industry and commerce—Capital. Their rivalry was the old antagonism of City and Country, Capital and Landed property, though each faction attached itself to its royal House through tradition, prejudice and illusion.

    Chapter 9

  2. According to Marx, why did the party of Order attack the republic it depended on?

    Marx argues the party of Order sensed that the parliamentary republic completed the bourgeoisie's authority while undermining its social foundation. Without a crown as intermediary or mask, the republic forces the ruling class to confront the subjugated classes directly. Feeling weak, they recoiled from the full demands of their own class rule and retreated to less complete, less dangerous forms of it.

    Chapter 9

  3. How did the coalized royalists act differently in public and behind the scenes?

    Marx writes that behind the scenes the Legitimists and Orleanists resumed their old liveries and tourneys, intriguing in the press, at Ems and Clarmont. On the public stage, as a great parliamentary party, they treated their royal Houses with mere courtesies and adjourned the monarchy's restoration 'in infinitum.' Their real business was conducted as the Party of Order under a social, not political, title—the bourgeois class against other classes.

    Chapter 9

  4. What did Marx say the democrats wrongly believed about the legislative National Assembly period?

    Marx says the democrats viewed the period as simply a struggle between republicans and royalists, summed up in the catch-word 'Reaction'—a night in which all cats are grey. To them the party of Order seemed a tangle of royalist factions conspiring against the Republic, while the Mountain defended the 'eternal rights of man.' Marx argues this superficial appearance veils the class struggle and vanishes on closer inspection.

    Chapter 9

Section 104 cards
  1. What was the Social Democratic party, per Marx's chapter?

    A coalition formed against the allied bourgeoisie between small traders and workingmen. The small traders felt ill rewarded after June 1848 and saw their interests endangered, so they drew closer to the workingmen. Their parliamentary representatives, the Mountain, allied with Socialist leaders; reconciliation banquets were held in February 1849, a common program drafted, and fusion candidates set up.

    Chapter 10

  2. How does Marx define the peculiar character of Social Democracy?

    The author argues that Social Democracy demands democratic-republican institutions as the means, not to remove the two extremes—Capital and Wage-slavery—but to weaken their antagonism and transform them into a harmonious whole. The substance is transforming society on democratic lines, but within the boundaries of the small traders' class.

    Chapter 10

  3. What bait did the party of Order use to trap the Mountain?

    The bombardment of Rome by French troops. It violated Article V, which forbade using French forces against other nations' liberties, and Article IV, which forbade the Executive declaring war without the Assembly's consent; the constitutive assembly had censured the expedition on May 8. Ledru-Rollin moved to impeach Bonaparte and his ministers on June 11, 1849.

    Chapter 10

  4. What happened to the Mountain after June 13, 1849?

    Part fled abroad, another part was assigned to the High Court of Bourges, and a parliamentary regulation placed the rest under the President of the National Assembly's supervision. Paris was again put under a state of siege and the democratic portion of the National Guards disbanded. Thus the Mountain's parliamentary influence was broken, along with the small traders' power in Paris.

    Chapter 10

Section 114 cards
  1. Why did the Mountain believe the Army would revolt in its favor?

    The Mountain believed the Army would revolt because a part of it had voted for the democrats. Marx argues this was self-deception: from the troops' standpoint the occasion meant only that revolutionary soldiers should side with Rome's soldiers against French soldiers. The memory of June 1848 also kept the proletariat hostile to the National Guard and secret-society leaders mistrustful of democratic leaders.

    Chapter 11

  2. How does Marx characterize the democrat's view of class and the 'people'?

    Marx argues the democrat represents the middle class, a Transition Class where two other classes' interests are mutually dulled, yet imagines himself above all class contrast. Democrats grant a privileged class opposes them but claim they and the rest of the nation constitute the 'PEOPLE,' representing 'people's rights' and 'people's interests.' Thus they need not examine different classes' interests or seriously weigh their own means.

    Chapter 11

  3. What did the party of Order establish on June 13 regarding the Constitution?

    On June 13 the party of Order not only broke up the Mountain but established the subordination of the Constitution to majority decisions of the National Assembly. Marx says this made the bourgeois rule in parliamentary form without a monarchical check of executive veto or liability to dissolution. Yet by excluding its most popular part and surrendering deputies to the public prosecutor, the bourgeoisie struck parliament itself with incurable weakness.

    Chapter 11

  4. How did the June 13 defeat benefit Bonaparte personally?

    The Mountain had wanted to place Bonaparte under charges, so their defeat was a direct victory and personal triumph of Bonaparte over his democratic enemies. The party of Order fought for the victory; Bonaparte only pocketed it. On June 14 a proclamation presented him as stepping forward against his will, complaining of calumnies and identifying the cause of order with his own person. Having restored the High Priest to the Vatican, he hoped as King David to occupy the Tuileries.

    Chapter 11

Section 123 cards
  1. What did the June 13 riot amount to, and how did the party of Order portray it?

    The riot of June 13 was only a peaceful street procession, so no laurels were won. The party of Order nonetheless converted this bloodless battle into a second Austerlitz, with tribune and press praising the army as the power of order against the popular multitude and calling Changarnier the "bulwark of society"—a mystification he finally believed himself.

    Chapter 12

  2. How did the National Guard's role change from 1830 through December 2, 1851?

    In 1830 the National Guard decided the downfall of the restoration. In June 1848 it joined the regular troops against the proletariat. On June 13, 1849, the bourgeoisie had the small traders' National Guard broken up; on December 2, 1851, the bourgeoisie's own National Guard vanished, and Bonaparte signed the decree for its disbandment.

    Chapter 12

  3. How did Bonaparte use and then dismiss the Barrot-Falloux Ministry?

    Bonaparte needed the Barrot Ministry, composed of Legitimists and Orleanists, to dissolve the republican constituent assembly, effect the Roman expedition, and break up the democratic party, while hiding behind the mask of "homme de paille." On November 1 he surprised the Assembly with a message dismissing it, declaring his own name independent of the parliament of the party of Order.

    Chapter 12

Section 134 cards
  1. What did the party of Order lose when Bonaparte dismissed the Barrot-Falloux Ministry?

    Marx states that with the dismissal of the Barrot-Falloux Ministry—the first and last parliamentary ministry Bonaparte created—the party of Order lost the handle to Executive power, an indispensable post for maintaining the parliamentary régime, never to regain it. Marx argues this loss left the National Assembly without real influence unless it simplified administration and reduced the office-holding army.

    Chapter 13

  2. Why does Marx say the French bourgeoisie's material interest required a large governmental machine?

    Marx argues the bourgeoisie's material interest was bound to maintaining a large, ramified governmental machine: it provided for its superfluous membership and supplied, as government salaries, what it could not pocket as profit, interest, rent and fees. Meanwhile its political interests compelled it to increase repressive power and war against public opinion, so it destroyed the conditions for parliamentary power, its own included.

    Chapter 13

  3. What did Bonaparte's appointment of Fould and Carlier signify, according to Marx?

    Marx notes the d'Hautpoul Ministry contained only one man of parliamentary reputation, the Jew Fould, a notorious member of high finance, who took the finance portfolio. Marx points to Paris stock quotations showing French stocks rising and falling with Bonapartist shares from November 1, 1849. Simultaneously Bonaparte took possession of the Police by appointing Carlier as Prefect of Police.

    Chapter 13

  4. What two laws summed up the party of Order's legislative activity, and how does Marx characterize them?

    Marx says the legislative activity was summed up in two laws: the law reestablishing the duty on wine, and the education laws to suppress infidelity. He notes that while wine drinking was made difficult for Frenchmen, the 'water of pure life' was poured out more bounteously. Orleanists entrusted supervision of French intellect to the Jesuits, joining the means of oppression of the July monarchy and the Restoration.

    Chapter 13

Section 144 cards
  1. Why does Marx say the bourgeoisie turned against its own liberal rights?

    The author argues the bourgeoisie perceives that every weapon it forged against feudalism now turns against itself, and that its citizens' rights and progressive organs menace its class rule. It therefore brands these as "socialistic," correctly scenting socialism's threat. Marx adds that the bourgeoisie fails to see that its own parliamentary régime must also fall under this same ban.

    Chapter 14

  2. Why does the parliamentary régime, by its own logic, invite the masses to decide?

    Marx argues the parliamentary régime lives on discussion, converts every interest into a general thought, and leaves everything to majority decision. Orators' conflict spawns press and club debate; representatives appeal to popular opinion, justifying petitions. So if those above fiddle, those below will dance. The bourgeoisie, to preserve social power, must break its own political power.

    Chapter 14

  3. What did the March 1850 supplementary elections reveal, and how did Bonaparte react?

    Paris elected only Social-Democratic candidates, uniting its largest vote on Deflotte, a June 1848 insurgent; the Army in Paris voted for him against Bonaparte's minister Lahitte, and the provinces mostly backed the Mountain. Bonaparte again vanished behind the party of Order, apologizing and offering any ministry the majority wanted. The party of Order failed to seize the proffered power.

    Chapter 14

  4. How did Bonaparte try to win popular favor against the National Assembly?

    Marx says Bonaparte's ministry pushed laws in the party of Order's spirit or exaggerated their severity, while Bonaparte himself offered childishly silly propositions to contrast with the Assembly and hint at hidden plans. Examples include a daily extra pay of four sous to under-officers and a "word of honor" loan bank for working-men. Marx calls this presents and loans, speculating on the dullness of the masses.

    Chapter 14

Section 154 cards
  1. How did the democrats squander their March 1850 election victory?

    Instead of pressing their hustings victory in parliament while popular enthusiasm and army temper were favorable, the democrats forced a new campaign in March and April. Marx argues they let revolutionary vigor exhaust itself in constitutional successes, petty intrigues, and hollow declamation, giving the bourgeoisie time to prepare. He says they turned the 10th of March into an April Fool.

    Chapter 15

  2. What did the election law of May 31, 1850 abolish and require?

    Introduced by Mr. Faucher on May 8, the law abolished universal suffrage and imposed three years' residence in the election district as a condition for voting. For the working-man, proof of this residence depended on the testimony of his employer. Marx calls it the bourgeoisie's coup d'état, striking at least three million voters off the rolls.

    Chapter 15

  3. How did the May 31 law affect the presidential election minimum?

    The constitution required at least two million votes for a valid presidential election, out of ten million registered voters — about one-fifth. The law cut the rolls to seven million while keeping the two-million minimum, raising the threshold from a fifth to nearly a third. Marx says this was designed to shift the presidential election from the people to the National Assembly.

    Chapter 15

  4. How did Bonaparte exploit the May 31 situation to raise his salary?

    The constitution fixed his salary at 600,000 francs, doubled earlier via Odilon Barrot. After May 31, Bonaparte had ministers move a civil list of three million, threatening to denounce the Assembly's maiming of popular sovereignty to the people unless it bought his silence. The Assembly refused the annual civil list but granted 2,160,000 francs once, which Marx calls a double weakness.

    Chapter 15

Section 164 cards
  1. What was the Society of December 10, and whom did it organize?

    Marx describes it as a secret Bonapartist organization founded in 1849 under the pretext of a benevolent association. It organized the slum-proletariat of Paris into secret sections led by Bonapartist agents, with a Bonapartist general at the head. Its membership included vagabonds, dismissed soldiers, discharged convicts, sharpers, gamblers, porters, beggars—the dissolute mass the French call "la Bohéme."

    Chapter 16

  2. Why did Bonaparte dissolve the Society of December 10, and was it real?

    After Police Commissioner Yon reported to the Permanent Committee that a Decembrist section had plotted to murder General Changarnier and Dupin, a parliamentary inquest seemed inevitable. Just before the National Assembly reconvened, Bonaparte circumspectly dissolved the Society—on paper only. Marx notes that as late as the end of 1851, Police Prefect Carlier vainly sought its real dissolution in an exhaustive memorial.

    Chapter 16

  3. How did Bonaparte try to convert the public Army into a Decembrist force?

    Marx says Bonaparte treated officers and under-officers at the Elysée to cigars, champagne, cold poultry and garlic-sausage, then repeated the manoeuvre with the rank and file at the October 3 review of St. Maur and again on a larger scale at the October 10 Satory parade. Marx presents this as Bonaparte's first attempt, funded by money wrung from the National Assembly.

    Chapter 16

  4. How did Changarnier and Neumeyer figure in the October 1850 army conflict?

    At both reviews Changarnier commanded as Commander-in-chief of the Army of Paris. At Satory part of the cavalry cried "Vive Napoléon!" while Changarnier ensured the infantry under his friend Neumeyer kept icy silence. Bonaparte's Minister of War then deposed Neumeyer under the pretext of a provincial command; Neumeyer declined and resigned. Changarnier published an order on November 2 forbidding political cries under arms.

    Chapter 16

Section 174 cards
  1. What did Bonaparte's November 12 message to the National Assembly notably omit?

    The message was prolix in enumerating recently enacted laws but passed over in affected silence the most important of all, the election law. It also stated that under the express provisions of the Constitution the President alone disposes over the Army, and closed with professions of devotion to peace and the people's will. The party of Order was annoyed by the omission of the election law and by the passage on the army.

    Chapter 17

  2. Why did the party of Order not answer Bonaparte's 'peace' message with 'war'?

    The party of Order feared a double thing: re-conjuring the revolutionary disturbance of the peace, and appearing before the bourgeoisie as itself the disturber of the peace. Since it had been apostrophizing the revolution with 'France demands, above all things, peace' since February, Bonaparte turned the same language against it. So it let its rival gather the fruits and avoided every decisive conflict.

    Chapter 17

  3. How did the National Assembly respond to Mauguin's imprisonment for debt?

    A judgment for debt was secured against Mauguin, a Representative, and the Minister of Justice Rouher declared an order of arrest should be made out. Mauguin was cast into the debtors' prison. The Assembly bristled, ordered his immediate release, and had him forcibly taken out of Clichy by its own greffier. It then declared imprisonment of a Representative for debt permissible with its previous consent, wiping out the last semblance of members' inviolability.

    Chapter 17

  4. What happened in the dispute over the Assembly's own police force and Commissioner Yon?

    After Allais's testimony about a plot to murder Dupin and Changarnier, the questors proposed a parliament-paid police force independent of the Police Prefects. Baroche protested; a compromise made the Assembly's Police Commissioner paid from its private budget but appointed and dismissed by questors only with the Interior Minister's prior agreement. Allais was prosecuted and his testimony ridiculed. Baroche then demanded Yon's dismissal; the committee voted to keep him, but the Assembly, frightened after the Mauguin affair, dismissed Yon anyway.

    Chapter 17

Section 184 cards
  1. What did the National Assembly do when Bonaparte's Goldbar Lottery was exposed by Duprat?

    The Assembly went over to the order of the day rather than prosecute. Marx argues this happened partly because Girardin's motion to declare itself 'satisfied' reminded the party of Order of its own systematic corruption, and because the bourgeois statesman supplements practical meanness with theoretical pompousness, believing he can fight only in a higher, more exalted manner.

    Chapter 18

  2. What was the Goldbar Lottery scheme, and who profited from it?

    A lottery of seven million tickets at a franc each, ostensibly to ship Parisian vagabonds to California, though French law forbade lotteries except benevolent raffles. Marx says the real vagabonds were Bonaparte and his insolvent associates, who pocketed part of the surplus, manufactured false tickets, and sold fifteen to twenty lots of Number 10 alone.

    Chapter 18

  3. Why did the Assembly's vote of confidence in Changarnier weaken it?

    Marx argues the Assembly resigned its own powers and decreed its own impotence by committing itself to a general's private protection. Changarnier falsely denied the order existed and promised to answer the Assembly's calls, but he held his power only as a fief from Bonaparte. Marx says Changarnier wrongly believed himself a 'Third Power' beside the government.

    Chapter 18

  4. How does Marx characterize the party of Order's conduct toward the Executive power?

    Marx argues it evaded combat under severe provocations, then fought only small quarrels about jurisdiction, chicaneries, and boundary disputes, turning stale questions of form into substance. It dared not accept a collision involving principle, fearing the nation would move. Its later valor appeared stale, the tempest a tea-pot storm, the collision a scandal.

    Chapter 18

Section 194 cards
  1. What did the party of Order do instead of electing Changarnier President of the National Assembly?

    Rather than elect Changarnier President of the National Assembly and requisition troops, the party's leaders went to the Elysée on the evening of January 6 to persuade Bonaparte to drop the removal. Marx argues this step recognized Bonaparte as master of the situation, and on January 12 Bonaparte appointed a new Ministry and cashiered Changarnier.

    Chapter 19

  2. How did the January 18 vote of lack of confidence split, and what did it reveal?

    The vote passed 415 ayes to 286 nays, carried by a coalition of Legitimists and Orleanists with pure republicans and the Mountain. Marx says it revealed that in its conflict with Bonaparte the party of Order had lost not only the Ministry and the Army but also its independent parliamentary majority, as a troop of Representatives deserted its camp.

    Chapter 19

  3. Why did the party of Order frame its January 18 motion without naming Changarnier?

    The party of Order had to frame its motion that way to secure republican votes, because Changarnier's dismissal was the one ministerial act the republicans approved. The party could not condemn the other ministerial acts, since it had itself dictated them. The motion thus passed as a vote of lack of confidence without Changarnier's name being mentioned.

    Chapter 19

  4. What did Thiers and Berryer admit about their royalist plans, according to Marx?

    Marx says Thiers and Berryer, the Orleanist and the Legitimist, were compelled to proclaim themselves openly as republicans, admitting their heart favored royalty but their head the republic, and that the parliamentary republic was the only possible form for bourgeois rule. They thus branded the restoration plans they still pursued behind parliament's back as a senseless intrigue.

    Chapter 19

Section 204 cards
  1. How did the party of Order respond to Bonaparte's dismissal of Changarnier?

    The party of Order passed a January 18 vote of lack of confidence against the Ministers rather than Bonaparte himself. Marx argues they could not deny the President's constitutional right to remove a General, and only protested his unparliamentary use of it. He attributes their confusion to "Parliamentary Idiocy," which fetters its victims to an imaginary world and robs them of understanding of the outside world.

    Chapter 20

  2. What kind of ministry did Bonaparte appoint on January 20, and to what effect?

    Bonaparte appointed a so-called transition Ministry whose members belonged to no parliamentary party—wholly unknown and insignificant individuals, a Ministry of mere clerks and secretaries. Marx argues this concentrated the whole executive power more securely in Bonaparte's own person, giving him freer elbow-room, while the party of Order could wear itself out playing with puppets. The Executive no longer considered it worthwhile to be seriously represented in the Assembly.

    Chapter 20

  3. How did the party of Order avenge itself, and what did the vote reveal?

    The party of Order, allied with the Mountain, rejected Bonaparte's Presidential endowment of 1,800,000 francs. The majority was only 102 votes, meaning 27 more votes had fallen off since January 18; Marx reads this as evidence the party's dissolution was progressing. The party also refused to consider a motion by 189 Mountain members for a general amnesty to political criminals.

    Chapter 20

  4. What did Persigny tell Changarnier, and how did the party of Order react?

    Persigny invited Changarnier to join Bonaparte's camp, assuring him the National Assembly's influence was wholly annihilated and that a proclamation was ready for a contemplated but postponed coup d'état. Changarnier relayed this death notice to the party's leaders, but Marx says they could not believe a bed-bug bite could kill, seeing the duel with the "Society of December 10" as merely a duel with a bed-bug.

    Chapter 20

Section 214 cards
  1. What did the Bonapartists chiefly want from constitutional revision?

    The Bonapartists were above all concerned with abolishing Article 45, which forbade Bonaparte's re-election and the prolongation of his term. Their interest in revision was therefore simple and direct, unlike the tangled position of the party of Order.

    Chapter 21

  2. Why did the republicans believe they could block any revision?

    The republicans rejected all revision as a conspiracy against the republic. Since they held more than one-fourth of the votes in the National Assembly, and the Constitution required a three-fourths majority to revise and call a revisory convention, they needed only to count their own votes to be certain of victory.

    Chapter 21

  3. Why did the party of Order resist recalling the Bourbons?

    The author argues the parliamentary republic was the indispensable condition for the common reign of the two bourgeois factions, Legitimists and Orleanists. As royalists they relapsed into their old antagonism over the overlordship of landed property versus money. Hence their resistance to the recall of the Bourbons, despite Orleanist motions to repeal the banishment decree.

    Chapter 21

  4. What dilemma did voting on revision pose for the party of Order?

    Voting against revision left Bonaparte only violence, risking revolutionary anarchy by May 2, 1852. Voting constitutionally for revision meant voting in vain and going under before the republican veto. Voting unconstitutionally for a simple majority meant surrendering to the Executive, making Bonaparte master of the Constitution, the revision and the party itself.

    Chapter 21

Section 224 cards
  1. Why did the party of Order attempt a fusion of the Orleanist and Legitimist dynasties?

    The party of Order's diplomats believed a fusion of the two royalist houses could allay the rivalry between the two bourgeois factions, which the question of constitutional revision had revived. Marx argues the true fusion of the restoration and July monarchy was already the parliamentary republic, where Orleanist and Legitimist colors dissolved. The fusionists sought a monarchy that could incarnate the unity of interests their separate kingships personified.

    Chapter 22

  2. What did Marx argue the proposed Orleans-Legitimist fusion actually amounted to for the house of Orleans?

    Marx argues fusion amounted to nothing but the resignation of the house of Orleans—its Legitimist resignation, a repentant return from the Protestant State Church to the Catholic. If Henry V. recognized the Count of Paris as successor, Orleans gained no claim that Henry's childlessness had not already secured it, but lost all claims conquered by the July revolution, bartering away its historic prerogative, its family-tree.

    Chapter 22

  3. What did the failure of the royalist fusion do to the party of Order?

    The essay of royalist fusion not only miscarried; it broke up the party of Order's parliamentary fusion, the republican form they had adopted in common, and decomposed the party into its original components. The breach between Venice and Claremont widened, and each of the two large factions fell into new fragments, as old political shades revived their own groups and antagonisms.

    Chapter 22

  4. What motion did the revision-seeking section of the party of Order unite with Bonapartist Representatives to propose?

    That portion of the party of Order eager for revision but divided on its extent—Legitimists under Berryer, Falloux and Laroche Jacquelein, plus tired-out Orleanists under Molé, Broglie, Montalembert and Odillon Barrot—united with Bonapartist Representatives on an indefinite, loosely drawn motion: that, to restore the nation the full exercise of her sovereignty, the Constitution be revised.

    Chapter 22

Section 234 cards
  1. Why did the revision of the Constitution fail on July 19?

    The revision was rejected because it failed to obtain the three-fourths majority the Constitution required. The vote was 446 in favor and 278 against. Tocqueville, speaking for the commission, argued the National Assembly had no right to abolish the republic, that power belonging only to a Constitutional Convention. The resolute Orleanists Thiers and Changarnier voted with the republicans and the Mountain.

    Chapter 23

  2. How did Marx interpret Bonaparte's seizure of power relative to parliament and the Constitution?

    Marx argues Bonaparte acted in the sense of parliament when he tore up the Constitution, since revision meant continuing presidential power, and in the sense of the Constitution when he chased away parliament, since the Constitution pronounced against the parliament. The parliament had declared itself for Bonaparte while the Constitution declared against it, leaving each side's logic pointing toward his victory.

    Chapter 23

  3. What did the party of Order do during the crisis, and how does Marx judge it?

    The party of Order adjourned from August 10 to November 4, stepping off the stage for three months while Bonaparte strengthened his position. Marx argues it proved it knew neither how to rule nor how to obey, neither how to maintain the Constitution nor throw it overboard, neither how to co-operate with the President nor break with him. It looked to the calendar and the course of events for a solution.

    Chapter 23

  4. Why did the aristocracy of finance and industrial bourgeoisie support Bonaparte over parliament?

    Marx argues the finance aristocracy, tied to public credit and government securities, saw the President as guardian of order on every Stock Exchange and condemned parliamentary strife as a disturbance of order. The industrial bourgeoisie likewise reprimanded its representatives for coalition with the Mountain. Marx contends this bourgeois party was not worth the intrigues wasted on it, since it treated its own class interests as a disturbance of private business.

    Chapter 23

Section 244 cards
  1. Why did the commercial bourgeoisie's attitude toward parliamentary strife shift in 1851?

    When business was brisk at the start of 1851, the commercial bourgeoisie attacked parliamentary strife for upsetting business. When business turned dull from the end of February 1851, they blamed the same parliamentary strifes as the cause of the standstill and clamored for quiet so business could revive. The author presents this as no contradiction, since they wanted the provisional status ended by being indefinitely continued.

    Chapter 24

  2. What did the bourgeoisie mean by demanding preservation of the 'status quo'?

    The author argues that by ending the provisional status the bourgeoisie understood its continuance — the indefinite postponement of any final decision. The status quo could be preserved only by prolonging Bonaparte's term or by his constitutional withdrawal and the election of Cavaignac. Part of the bourgeoisie preferred the latter and advised their representatives to stay silent, hoping an ostrich Parliament would keep Bonaparte from acting.

    Chapter 24

  3. How did the bourgeoisie treat its own press during its conflict with Bonaparte?

    The bourgeoisie showed its wrath at its literary representatives more unequivocally than at its parliamentary ones. Bourgeois juries inflicted excessive fines and shameless prison sentences for every attack by the bourgeois press on Bonaparte's usurping aspirations and every attempt to defend the bourgeoisie's political rights against the executive. The author says this amazed not only France but all Europe.

    Chapter 24

  4. What does the author say about the bourgeoisie blaming the proletariat after the coup?

    The author argues the bourgeoisie, which had rebelled against even the parliamentary and literary contest for its own class supremacy and betrayed its leaders, now blames the proletariat for not rising in its defense. He cites the Economist, which called Bonaparte 'Guardian of Order' four days before the coup and afterward cried treason by the proletariat against the middle and upper ranks. The author says the stupid mass was the bourgeoisie itself.

    Chapter 24

Section 254 cards
  1. What did the French bourgeoisie blame for the 1851 business stagnation?

    The French bourgeoisie attributed the stagnation to purely political causes: the strife between Parliament and the Executive, uncertainty over a provisional form of government, and fears about May 2, 1852. Marx does not deny these depressed some branches of industry in Paris and the Departments, but argues the effect was only local and trifling, since business improved in mid-October just as the political situation worsened.

    Chapter 25

  2. What did Marx identify as the real causes of the 1851 crisis?

    Marx points to overproduction and overspeculation in 1849–1850, worsened by the prospect of the Industrial Exposition, the failed cotton crops of 1850–51, oscillations of the cotton market, a below-average French raw silk crop, and woolen manufacture outpacing wool production. He calls the seeming crisis a regular halt in the industrial cycle before the General Commercial Crisis, not a product of French politics.

    Chapter 25

  3. How did the crisis differ between France and England in 1851?

    Marx states that in France the crisis was industrial and in England commercial: French factories stood still while English ones kept working under less favorable circumstances than in 1849–50. In France exports suffered most, in England imports. Commercial failures broke out in England while French industry stopped, partly from English competition and partly because French luxury industry is hit by any stoppage of trade.

    Chapter 25

  4. What did the Liverpool firm's 1851 report blame for the disappointing year?

    A large Liverpool firm's yearly trade report for 1851 said few years had more disappointed expectations, calling it one of the most discouraging in a quarter century despite scanty stocks, abundant capital, cheap provisions, a rich autumn, continental peace and no home disturbances. It blamed excessive trade in imports and exports, warning that unless merchants rein in activity, only a panic every three years can keep them going.

    Chapter 25

Section 264 cards
  1. What did Bonaparte announce to his Ministers on October 10?

    On October 10, Bonaparte announced to his Ministers his decision to restore universal suffrage. By the 16th they had handed in their resignations, and by the 26th Paris learned of the formation of the Thorigny Ministry. Simultaneously, Carlier was replaced as Prefect of Police by Maupas, and Magnan concentrated the most reliable regiments in the capital.

    Chapter 26

  2. How did the National Assembly repeal the law of May 31, 1850?

    On the day it re-opened, the Assembly received Bonaparte's message demanding restoration of universal suffrage and repeal of the law of May 31, 1850. It rejected the Ministers' motion of urgency but repealed the law itself on November 13 by a vote of 355 against 348. Marx says it thus tore up its own mandate and became a usurpatory parliament of a class.

    Chapter 26

  3. What was the Quæstors' Bill and what did its rejection reveal?

    The Quæstors' Bill would have given the Assembly the right to immediate requisitions for troops, building a parliamentary army. By debating this instead of acting, the Assembly admitted doubts about its power; by rejecting the bill (minority of 108), it publicly confessed its impotence. Marx says it thereby recognized the Army as the decisive power in the State.

    Chapter 26

  4. What does Marx say caused the success of the coup?

    Marx argues the coup succeeded neither because of Bonaparte's reticence nor an unforeseen surprise of the National Assembly. Bonaparte constantly betrayed and blabbed the coup idea, and Parisians refused to believe it when it appeared. It succeeded despite his indiscretion and with its anticipation—a necessary, unavoidable result of the preceding development.

    Chapter 26

Section 274 cards
  1. How did the industrial bourgeoisie react to Bonaparte's coup, and how were they repaid?

    The industrial bourgeoisie applauded the coup d'état of December 2, the destruction of parliament, and Bonaparte's dictatorship. Marx notes that the loudest applauder, Mr. Sallandrouze, had his house most damaged by bombs when the cannon roared on December 4, answering the applause of November 25.

    Chapter 27

  2. How does Marx contrast Bonaparte's seizure of power with Cromwell's and Napoleon's?

    Marx says Cromwell dissolved the Long Parliament alone, pulling out his watch and driving members out with humorous invectives; Napoleon went into the legislative body and read its death sentence, though tremulously. The second Bonaparte, holding a very different executive power, modeled himself not on universal history but on the annals of the Society of December 10 and criminal jurisprudence.

    Chapter 27

  3. What did the rump-parliament at the Tenth Arrondissement do, and what became of it?

    Amid cries of 'Long live the Republic!' the rump-parliament, mainly Legitimists and Orleanists, resolved to depose Bonaparte. It harangued the crowd in vain, was dragged under escort of African sharpshooters to the Orsay barracks, then bundled into convicts' wagons and sent to the prisons of Mazas, Ham and Vincennes. Marx says this ended the party of Order, the Legislative Assembly and the February revolution.

    Chapter 27

  4. What pattern does Marx identify in the bourgeoisie's successive demands and their consequences?

    Marx argues the bourgeoisie rebelled against proletarian rule and brought the slum-proletariat to power; it feared 'red anarchy' and had its leading citizens shot down; it apotheosized the sabre, destroyed the revolutionary press, imposed the state of siege, and suppressed movements by force — each measure later turned against it. Bonaparte now shouts to the bourgeoisie the same command it gave the revolution: 'Fuge, Tace, Quiesce!'

    Chapter 27

Section 283 cards
  1. What did Guizot say about December 2, and how does Marx read it?

    Guizot characterized the 2d of December as "the complete and definitive triumph of Socialism." Marx argues that although the downfall of the parliamentary republic carries the germ of the proletarian revolution's triumph, its immediate and tangible result was Bonaparte's triumph over parliament—the Executive over the Legislative, force without phrases over the force of phrases.

    Chapter 28

  2. How does Marx describe the origin and growth of the Executive power?

    Marx describes it as a tremendous bureaucratic and military organization—an army of office-holders half a million strong plus a military force of another million—a parasitic body coiling like a snake around French society. It originated with the absolute monarchy and declining feudalism; the first French revolution developed centralization, Napoleon completed the machinery, and each overturn perfected rather than broke it.

    Chapter 28

  3. What does Marx mean by the revolution's "preliminary programme"?

    Marx argues the revolution works methodically through purgatory, fulfilling its programme in two halves. Down to December 2, 1851, it had ripened the Legislature's power to maturity in order to overthrow it; now it ripens the Executive power to its purest expression, isolates it, and concentrates all revolutionary forces of destruction against it. When this second part is done, Europe will exclaim, "Well hast thou grubbed, old mole!"

    Chapter 28

Section 294 cards
  1. Which economic class does Marx say Bonaparte represents?

    Marx argues Bonaparte represents the allotment farmer, the most numerous class in France. Just as the Bourbons represent large landed property and the Orleans represent money, the Bonapartes are the dynasty of the small farmer. Marx claims the Bonaparte who swept away the bourgeois parliament, not the one who submitted to it, is the elect of this farmer class.

    Chapter 29

  2. Why does Marx say the allotment farmers do not constitute a class?

    Marx argues that although millions of families live under conditions separating their interests and culture from other classes, their production isolates them. Only local connections exist, with no unity of interest, national connections, or political organization. Therefore they cannot assert class interests in their own name and must be represented by someone who also appears as their master.

    Chapter 29

  3. What distinction does Marx draw between the two kinds of French farmers?

    Marx argues the Bonaparte dynasty represents the conservative farmer who wants to confirm the small allotment and be saved by the ghost of the Empire, not the revolutionary farmer pressing beyond his economic conditions. He says it represents the farmer's superstition, bias, and past rather than his judgment, future, and intelligence.

    Chapter 29

  4. How does Marx describe the effect of the Napoleonic form of landownership over time?

    Marx argues that after the first revolution converted serf farmers into freeholders, Napoleon fixed the conditions for exploiting the soil. But the very partition of the soil that once enabled emancipation and enrichment developed over the century into a law of enslavement and pauperism, producing deteriorating agriculture and an encumbered agriculturist.

    Chapter 29

Section 304 cards
  1. What did the allotment system do for the bourgeoisie against the old aristocracy?

    The chapter states that the small allotments' boundary-posts constituted the natural buttress of the bourgeoisie against every stroke of the old overlords, and that the farmer class was a ubiquitous protest against the landed aristocracy. The roots the system cast into French soil deprived feudalism of all nutriment, supplementing urban free competition and incipient large production under Napoleon.

    Chapter 30

  2. What replaced the feudal lord and feudal duties, according to the chapter?

    The chapter argues that in the course of the nineteenth century the City Usurer stepped into the shoes of the Feudal Lord, the Mortgage substituted the feudal duties formerly yielded by the soil, and bourgeois capital took the place of the aristocracy of landed property. The former allotments now serve only as a pretext letting the capitalist class draw profit, interest and rent, leaving the farmer to knock out his own wages.

    Chapter 30

  3. Why does the allotment system lend itself to a powerful bureaucracy?

    The chapter argues the allotment system produces an even level of conditions and persons across the country, allowing even influence from a high central point; it annihilates aristocratic gradations between the masses and the Government, calls for direct governmental intervention, and produces an unemployed excess population that snatches after public office, provoking the creation of further offices. Heavy taxes sustain this apparatus.

    Chapter 30

  4. How does the chapter contrast the farmer's army under Napoleon with the army now?

    The chapter states the Army was the farmer's point of honor: farmers turned masters, defending new property abroad, with the uniform as State costume and war as poetry. Now, the author argues, the foe is sheriffs and tax collectors, the allotment lies in the mortgage register, and the Army is the swamp-blossom of the slum-proletariat, made of remplaçants, its heroism performed in raids against farmers.

    Chapter 30

Section 314 cards
  1. Why did the French bourgeoisie feel compelled to elect Bonaparte, according to Marx?

    The author argues the bourgeoisie had no choice but to elect Bonaparte, comparing their plight to Cardinal d'Ailly's retort at the Council of Constance: only the devil himself could save the Catholic Church. So the French bourgeoisie cried that only the chief of the "Society of December 10" could save bourgeois society — only theft could save property, only perjury religion, only disorder order.

    Chapter 31

  2. How does Bonaparte's contradictory mission explain the contradictions of his government?

    The author argues Bonaparte feels himself representative of the middle class, yet breaks its political power daily while protecting its material interests; representative of the farmers and people; and above all chief of the "Society of December 10." This contradictory mission explains his government's confused groping — now winning, now humiliating each class — until all classes array against him, a comic contrast with his imperious, Napoleonic style of decrees.

    Chapter 31

  3. What does Marx say about Bonaparte's attempt to be benefactor of all classes?

    The author argues Bonaparte would like to appear as patriarchal benefactor of all classes, but he can give to none without taking from others. Like the Duke of Guise, who converted his estates into bonds upon himself, Bonaparte would convert all property and labor of France into a personal bond upon himself — stealing all of France to present it back to France, with percentages dropping to the "Society of December 10."

    Chapter 31

  4. What does Marx claim about the "idées Napoléoniennes" and the small-holding farmers?

    The author argues the "idées Napoléoniennes" are the ideas of the undeveloped, youthfully fresh allotment, now an absurdity for the allotment that survives — hallucinations of its death struggle, words turned to hollow phrases, spirits to spooks. Yet this parody of the Empire was requisite to free the mass of the French nation from the weight of tradition and to sharpen the contrast between Government and Society.

    Chapter 31

Section 324 cards
  1. What does Marx say Bonaparte does to the bourgeois social system?

    Marx argues that Bonaparte, harassed by contradictory demands and forced to stage constant small surprises to keep public attention on himself as Napoleon's substitute, throws the whole bourgeois social system into disorder. He broaches what seemed unbroachable by the 1848 revolution, makes one group patient under the revolution and another anxious for it, and produces anarchy in the name of order.

    Chapter 32

  2. How does Bonaparte treat the government machinery, according to Marx?

    Marx argues Bonaparte rubs the veneer of sanctity off the whole machinery of government, profaning it and making it at once nauseating and laughable. He does this while producing anarchy in the name of order. Marx also says Bonaparte rehearses in Paris the cult of the sacred coat of Trier alongside the cult of the Napoleonic Imperial mantle.

    Chapter 32

  3. What does Marx say will happen when the Imperial Mantle falls on Louis Bonaparte?

    Marx writes that when the Imperial Mantle finally falls upon the shoulders of Louis Bonaparte, the iron statue of Napoleon will drop down from the top of the Vendôme column. An endnote states this prophecy was literally fulfilled a few years later: after Bonaparte's coronation as Emperor, the military statue of the first Napoleon atop the column was taken down and replaced with one in imperial robes.

    Chapter 32

  4. What two cults does Marx say Bonaparte rehearses in Paris?

    Marx says Bonaparte rehearses in Paris the cult of the sacred coat of Trier together with the cult of the Napoleonic Imperial mantle. This pairing illustrates his point that Bonaparte, as Napoleon's substitute, keeps the public's eyes riveted on himself through constant surprises while throwing the bourgeois social system into disorder.

    Chapter 32

Source and licence

Text used: Project Gutenberg eBook #1346 (Public domain in the United States). Generated from the full text; cards paraphrase the source.

Version: Public domain edition. Retrieved 2026-11-19. Cards reviewed 2026-11-19.

These cards paraphrase the text for study. They are not a substitute for reading the book, and they do not reproduce long passages.

Turn your own notes into cards

Upload a PDF, Word, or text file and get question-and-answer cards for closed-notes practice. Five cards are free, no signup.

Try 5 free cards