Book Cards

The Eureka Stockade Flashcards

Raffaello Carboni’s The Eureka Stockade is a first-hand account of the 1854 Ballarat miners’ rebellion, written by a participant who insists on his own testimony’s value. The deck covers Carboni’s prefatory remarks on language, truth, and audience, plus his claims about the Local Court and the Powell inquest.

1 / 381

Chapter 1 · Question

Who taught Carboni English, and what does he admit about his command of it?

WakeCards · wakecards.com · Big ideas. Quick review.

Arrow keys move between cards. Space or Enter flips.

All questions and answers

Every card in the deck, in reading order. Click a chapter to expand. The reviewer above uses the same content.

Introduction4 cards
  1. Who taught Carboni English, and what does he admit about his command of it?

    Carboni says he was taught English by the Very Reverend W. Vincent Eyre, Vice Rector of the English College, Rome. He states it cost him immense pains to bring his English up to the mark, but that he could never master the language to perfection, so foreign idioms occasionally appear, probably to the annoyance of his readers.

    Chapter 1

  2. What does Carboni say determines whether his book succeeds or fails?

    In his "Nota Bene," Carboni says that in person he solicits no subscription and in writing asks no favour from his reader. He declares that a book must stand or fall by the truth contained in it, making truth the sole basis on which he expects his work to be judged.

    Chapter 1

  3. What does Carboni announce about an Italian edition of his book?

    Carboni states that of course a proper edition, in Italian, will be published in Turin. This remark follows his admission that he could never master English to perfection and that foreign idioms may annoy his readers, implying the Italian edition will present the work properly in his own language.

    Chapter 1

  4. How does Carboni date and locate the writing of this introduction?

    He signs from the Prince Albert Hotel, Bakery Hill, Ballaarat, and dates it the Anniversary of the Burning of Bentley's Eureka Hotel, 1855. The dating by that anniversary ties the introduction to the Eureka Hotel burning rather than a plain calendar date.

    Chapter 1

Chapter I.4 cards
  1. What three reasons does Carboni give for publishing his work?

    Carboni lists three reasons: first, an honourable ambition to have his name remembered among the illustrious of Rome and to vindicate his character after being tried for high treason in a British Supreme Court; second, moral courage to show the truth of his text because he believes in the resurrection of life; third, to drag the names of fallen comrades, including the bearer of the Southern Cross, from oblivion.

    Chapter 2

  2. How does Carboni describe his role as a witness to the events?

    Carboni uses the image of two boys see-sawing on a plank balanced on its centre: when the world is up with one, it is down with the other, but the centre stays stationary. He says he was in the centre, an actor and therefore an eye-witness. He saw the events, knew the persons face to face, and heard the words with his own ears.

    Chapter 2

  3. What does Carboni say about the truth in his Latin epigraph?

    In the epigraph and its translation, Carboni writes that the lie, like a whirlwind, clears itself a royal road through the whole earth, and the fool says in his heart there is no God. Truth, however slow, step by step like a little child, someday finds a footpath to light, and then the righteous flourish like a palm tree.

    Chapter 2

  4. Who does Carboni intend as his reader, and how does he describe the book's contents?

    Carboni wants a lover of truth, warning that anyone buying the book to lull himself to sleep should spend his money on grog instead, and anyone reading it to smoke a pipe will need plenty of tobacco. He says facts from the stubborn-things store are retailed here, with observation and induction stamped with sincerity, and he will not acknowledge a mistake unless the contrary be proved.

    Chapter 2

I.3 cards
  1. What did the eight of nine Local Court members do on 30 September 1855?

    Having already settled 201 disputes involving roughly half a million sterling, eight of the nine members of the first Local Court at Ballaarat called on fellow miners to a public meeting at Bakery-hill to ask whether they had done their duty and still held the diggers' confidence. Carboni notes no miner raised a finger against them.

    Chapter 3

  2. What does Carboni say the Belgravian letter was used as on Ballaarat?

    Carboni satirizes the practice of making a Belgravian billet-doux, a letter of aristocratic introduction, the sine qua non recommendation for gold-lace (official position) on Ballaarat at the time. He frames it as a letter introducing a well-connected but frivolous young candidate, mocking rule by patronage rather than merit.

    Chapter 3

  3. What does Carboni claim about the Local Court members' standing among miners?

    Carboni argues the members were practical men of the miners' own class, elected from among themselves to arbitrate disputes and represent them at the Local Court. He presents their bold call for a confidence meeting, with no miner opposing them, as the key to understanding the Local Courts' history on the gold-fields.

    Chapter 3

I. Document.4 cards
  1. What verdict did the jury return for Henry Powell's death?

    The jury found that Powell, a gold-digger, died from sabre cuts and gunshot wounds wilfully and feloniously inflicted by Arthur Purcell Akehurst, Clerk of the Peace at the Ballaarat bench, and other persons unknown. They returned a verdict of Wilful Murder against Akehurst and others unknown, and condemned Captain Evans for not swearing the deceased's statement after Dr. Wills warned of his immediate danger.

    Chapter 4

  2. According to Powell's deposition, what did the trooper do after ordering him to stand?

    Powell says the foremost trooper, a fair-complexioned, reddish-haired young man he knew as the Clerk of the Peace, told him to stand in the Queen's name and called him his prisoner. Powell replied 'Very good, Sir.' He then says the young man struck him on the head with a sheathed crooked knife about three and a half feet long; he fell, and they fired at him and rode over him several times.

    Chapter 4

  3. What did the jury condemn about Captain Evans's conduct?

    The jury condemned Captain Evans for not swearing the deceased at the time of taking his statement, after Dr. Wills had cautioned him that Powell was in immediate danger. The jury also expressed extreme horror at the mounted police firing at and cutting down unarmed and innocent persons of both sexes, at a distance from the scene of disturbance, on December 3rd, 1854.

    Chapter 4

  4. How does Carboni use the Akehurst encounter to express his view of the colony?

    Carboni notes that after his own trial, travelling to Ballaarat, he met the identical Akehurst in Geelong, cracking nuts and speaking to young ladies. He then writes 'I DESPAIR OF THIS COLONY,' and asks that Her Majesty cause inquiry into the character of those who branded the Ballaarat miners as disloyal to their Queen. The author argues the colony's justice is deeply compromised.

    Chapter 4

Chapter II.4 cards
  1. What licence fee and term did Carboni's party obtain at the Camp?

    Carboni states that he and his party went to the Camp to get their gold licence, and for one pound ten shillings sterling a head they were duly licensed for one month to dig, search for, and remove gold. He notes they wanted to drink a glass of porter to their future success, but there was no Bath Hotel at the time.

    Chapter 5

  2. What did Carboni find on his first lesson in 'fossiking' at Golden Point?

    Carboni describes jumping into an abandoned hole about three feet in diameter and five to eight feet deep, where a mate gave him his first lesson in 'fossiking.' In less than five minutes he found a little pouch of gold. He compares the sensation to a first declaration of love and exclaims 'Great works,' noting he had earned in minutes double what interpreting in London paid.

    Chapter 5

  3. How does Carboni contrast his earnings in Victoria with his work in London?

    Carboni says that in old Europe he had to take off his hat half a dozen times and walk from east to west before earning one pound as a sworn interpreter and translator of languages in London. At Golden Point he earned double that amount in a few minutes, without crouching or crawling to Jew or Christian, which he presents as a striking contrast.

    Chapter 5

  4. What did Carboni find after leaving Golden Point to ascend Canadian Gully?

    Carboni says the gold fever got the best of his usual judgment: he dreamt of a hole choked with gold sunk with his pick on virgin ground. He started the hill on the right-hand side, ascending Canadian Gully, and, 'safe as the Bank of England,' pounced on gold—seventeen and a half ounces at a depth of ten feet.

    Chapter 5

II.4 cards
  1. What tax does this chapter demand be totally abolished?

    The chapter's heading calls for the total abolition of the diggers' and storekeeper's licence tax. This is the central demand around which the Bakery reformers are organized. The author frames the movement's whole program as compressible onto a 'copper,' and the licence tax sits at the top of that program as the grievance to be removed.

    Chapter 6

  2. What does the author say is the way to make John Bull stir?

    The author asserts, in a parenthetical aside, that pricking John Bull at his pounds, shillings and pence is the dodge to make him stir. The author argues that financial self-interest, not abstract principle, is what moves him to action. The line is followed by three cheers for Humffray, linking the sentiment to the reform leader.

    Chapter 6

  3. What admission terms does the notice set out?

    The notice specifies a 2s. 6d. gentleman's ticket, with no admission for ladies at present. It urges that the course of action be carried out unswervingly until the oppressors' heel is removed, and warns against letting the thing drop for want of co-operation and support. It closes with the Latin tag 'Durum sed levius fit Patientia.'

    Chapter 6

  4. What does the notice tell readers to stop singing, and why?

    It tells them to leave off singing 'Britons never, never shall be slaves' until they stop fondling the chains that prove the song a lie, a mockery, a delusion and a snare. It also warns against letting the word 'British' become a bye-word, and invokes 'God helps him who helps himself (to the 2s. 6d.).'

    Chapter 6

II. Document.4 cards
  1. According to Hasleham's sworn statement, how was he wounded on the morning of the 3rd?

    Hasleham states that after the fighting had ended and the forces were preparing to return with prisoners, he was standing about 300 yards from a detachment of mounted police. Three troopers approached; the leading one hailed him as a friend, asked if he wished to join his force, then levelled a holster pistol and shot him at about four paces. Hasleham notes he was unarmed and in weak health.

    Chapter 7

  2. Where was Hasleham's tent relative to the stockade, and what separated them?

    Hasleham's tent was pitched on rising ground about 500 yards south of the stockade. Both the tent and the stockade sat on eminences, separated by a large gully running east and west whose breadth comprised nearly the whole of that distance. He and his three mates were roused from sleep by musketry, with many balls whistling over the tents.

    Chapter 7

  3. What does Hasleham claim about his loyalty before the affray, and what does he say about the scene when shot?

    Hasleham asserts that as a newspaper correspondent at Ballaarat he had shown, on all proper occasions, a strong instinctive leaning to the side of law, authority, and loyalty. He states he was shot when the affray was over, the forces and prisoners were about to return to camp, the scene of action was invisible from where he stood, and no other bloodshed had taken place.

    Chapter 7

  4. How does Carboni respond to Hasleham's statement in the chapter's closing note?

    Carboni dismisses the trooper with a curse and congratulates 'poor Frank, of the good town of Bedford,' sarcastically noting that 'this madness on the part of the diggers' procured Hasleham 400 pounds sterling from Toorak. He says Hasleham can spare him the trouble of encroaching further into the statement, closing with 'Great works!' — the author's ironic editorial voice, not neutral reportage.

    Chapter 7

II.4 cards
  1. According to the opening verse, what determines whether we dwell in heaven or in hell?

    The chapter's opening verse states that on earth we live within our thoughts, which are the slaves of our conceptions in each varied mood. The spirit feeds on the waves of our imaginings and laughs or raves as if drunk. The verse concludes that we exist and dwell in heaven or in hell as the mind may dispose.

    Chapter 8

  2. What does the chapter's THEME line say about death?

    The chapter's THEME line declares: "Death which we dread so much, is but a name." It presents death as a mere name rather than something to be feared, standing as a short thematic statement separate from the sonnet that follows it in the chapter.

    Chapter 8

  3. In the sonnet, what does the poet say those who never wept cannot know?

    The sonnet asks whether any mortal eye never wept, noting tears begin in childhood and the man is swept out of the earth with tears. It says he who never ate bread in tears, passed a bitter night, or wept as an exile at the sight of Babylon's waters does not know the might of Heaven's word.

    Chapter 8

  4. Where does the sonnet say we learn to know Him who keeps the world?

    The sonnet closes by saying that whether we bless or grumble here below, we learn to know Him who has ever kept the world in His hand in dark affliction's school. The chapter also notes parenthetically that the author's original is in Italian.

    Chapter 8

Chapter III.3 cards
  1. Why did the trooper with a carbine and fixed bayonet approach the narrator at work?

    The narrator was digging when his dog Bonaparte would not stay controlled. A six-foot fellow in a blue shirt and thick boots, armed with a carbine and fixed bayonet, demanded "Your licence, mate." After the old "all right" was exchanged, the man left. The narrator learned such men were called "traps" and "troopers," and he was unable to work any more that day.

    Chapter 9

  2. What did the narrator reflect after the licence hunt, and what did his mates tell him?

    He reflected sadly that he had come 16,000 miles in vain to escape the law of the sword. His sorrow was not eased when mates and neighbours told him Australia was a penal settlement, naming inveterate murderers, audacious burglars and bloodthirsty bushrangers as a ruling trio of Vandemonians. He felt tamed and less angry at the following search for licences.

    Chapter 9

  3. What gold discovery at Canadian Gully is described, and what effect did it have on diggers?

    At the latter end of the month, one hundred and seventy-seven pounds troy of gold, in two superb masses, was found at a depth of sixty feet on the hill opposite where the narrator worked. Talk spread "Vulcanish" through the land. Diggers blinded by gold fever, who had deserted Ballaarat for Mount Alexander and Bendigo, returned like ravens, and by the end of February 1853 Canadian Gully was in full glory.

    Chapter 9

III. Document more important, by far.4 cards
  1. What happened to Mr. Hassall, owner of the London Hotel, on 28th November?

    When troops arrived near the site of the stockade, the officer in command called at the London Hotel to ask the way to the Camp. Mr. Hassall came out to point out the way and received a ball in his leg, which laid him up for a while and caused him great loss of money, directly and indirectly.

    Chapter 10

  2. What did the board conclude about Hassall's claim for compensation?

    The board appointed to investigate such claims reported that, from the evidence, it appeared impossible Mr. Hassall could have received his wound from the military, and saw nothing to justify recommending compensation. The Colonial Secretary wrote that the Governor could not entertain the petition, as he had no power to award compensation except on the board's recommendation.

    Chapter 10

  3. What limit did the Colonial Secretary cite on the Governor's power to award compensation?

    J. Moore, A.C.S., wrote that the Governor could not entertain the petition because he had not power to award compensation except on the recommendation of the board. Since the board declined to recommend any compensation for Hassall, the petition could not proceed, regardless of the miners' memorial on his behalf.

    Chapter 10

  4. How does Carboni close this chapter, and what does it signal?

    Carboni ends with the exclamation 'Great works' this time at Toorak, eh! oh! dear,' a sarcastic comment on the official response. He then writes 'So far so good, for the present; because spy Goodenough wants me in the next chapter,' signaling that the informer Goodenough will figure in the following chapter.

    Chapter 10

Chapter IV.4 cards
  1. How often did licence searches occur, and did that frequency change?

    Searches for licences, called "the traps are out to-day," happened once a month. Carboni says the strong population on the gold-field had perhaps rendered it necessary twice a month, and he recalls they came out three times only in October. The practice was annoying but not exasperating, because John Bull was born for law, order, and safe money-making, though he hates being bullied with the bayonet.

    Chapter 11

  2. What did the November 1853 Bakery-hill meeting and petition ask for?

    A public meeting was announced on Bakery-hill in November 1853, with four hundred diggers present. Carboni dates here the Victorian system of memorialising: the diggers of Ballaarat sympathised with those of Bendigo in their common grievances and prayed the governor to reduce the gold licence to thirty shillings a month. There was also much talk about diggers not being represented in the Legislative Council and against the squatters.

    Chapter 11

  3. What did Doctor Carr tell Carboni privately, and how did Carboni respond?

    Doctor Carr honoured Carboni with the private information, "Nous allons bientot avoir la Republique Australienne! Signore." Carboni replied, "Quelle farce!" He judged the man before him capable of destroying sugarsticks, and gave him credit as the founder of a republic for babies to suck their thumbs. Earlier, Carr had asked who paid for the good stuff in the empty bottles around the Camp.

    Chapter 11

  4. Why did Carboni say the licence fee became a nuisance, and who joined the complaints?

    Carboni says the thirty shillings a month for the gold licence became a nuisance. John Bull's grumbling was honest but joined by the cant of the drunkard, that is the lazy, which make the incapables, and the Vandemonians pulled up with wonted audacity. Carboni adds that he understood little of the representation and squatter matters at the time, as the shoe had not pinched his toe yet.

    Chapter 11

Chapter V.4 cards
  1. What licence fee did Carboni pay at Magpie Gully, and why was no licence search made?

    Carboni took out his licence at the reasonable rate of two pounds for three months, calling it his contribution for the support of gold-lace. No search for licence took place because the diggers of Bendigo, by sheer moral force in the shape of some ten thousand in a mob, had inspired the red-tape authorities with better sense.

    Chapter 12

  2. What happened to Carboni's washing stuff and hole at Bryant's Ranges?

    Carboni shaped his hole like a bathing tub, dropped on gold, and paid two pounds to cart one load down the Loddon, getting twenty-eight pennyweights from it. Returning the third day to cart the other two loads, he found the washing stuff gone, the hole gone, and the gully itself gone — the whole face of it had been clean shaved.

    Chapter 12

  3. How does Carboni describe the Bendigo diggers' reputation and Governor Latrobe's treatment in the press?

    Carboni says he had no fault to find with Governor Joseph Latrobe, and believes the diggers cared about nothing else from him. Yet a clap of 'The Thunder' from Printing House-square called the diggers 'vagabonds' and put Latrobe down as 'an incapable' for keeping friends with them — all, Carboni says ironically, for the honour of British rule.

    Chapter 12

  4. What did Carboni conclude about the Messiah and shepherds after his time on the Loddon?

    After losing his whole flock one night and finding his sheep again (only shaken by wild dogs), and after encountering the Tarrang tribe in corrobory, Carboni was satisfied that the Messiah the Jews are looking for will not be born in this bullock-drivers' land, and that the angels won't announce the happy event to the shepherds.

    Chapter 12

Chapter VI.4 cards
  1. What does Carboni say about the national groups working different areas at Ballaarat?

    Carboni reports that English, German, and Scotch diggers generally worked the Gravel Pits, while the Irish had their stronghold on the Eureka. The Americans, he says, fraternised with all the wide-awake, quoting 'ubi caro ibi vultures.' He also notes the Eureka gold dust was finer, purer, and brighter, and that truants who had rushed to Bryant's Ranges returned to Ballaarat.

    Chapter 13

  2. What practice does Carboni describe as beginning as a profession at this time?

    Carboni describes 'shepherding,' or keeping claims in reserve, as beginning as a profession—the digger turning squatter. He connects this development to the reign of a gracious gold commissioner, which leads him to speak again of the gold licence. The practice marks a shift from working a claim to holding ground in reserve.

    Chapter 13

  3. What does Carboni's pig-and-cap comparison satirize?

    Carboni tells the reader to take a young pig, stand it on its hind legs, put on a gold-laced cap, and whitewash its snout—producing 'the ass in the form of a pig.' He means a 'man' who has the brains of both brutes. The satire targets the gold commissioner, whom he introduces this way before returning to the licence question.

    Chapter 13

  4. What does Carboni foresee about the hill near his tent, and what does he recall of his mate?

    Writing on the Feast of the Assumption, 1855, Carboni recalls choosing an unknown hill for his rest on Easter 1854 and asks who could have told him it would soon be called Massacre Hill. He adds that by next Christmas his mate would lie in a forgotten grave and he himself would be in gaol with the rope round his neck.

    Chapter 13

Chapter VII.3 cards
  1. How did fights over claims typically get 'settled' according to the chapter?

    A broken nose with a pair of black eyes, and when manageable a good smash in the teeth or ribs—both if possible—was supposed to improve the transaction so much that the tooth dropping or rib cracking meant it was 'settled.' Carboni says this origin gave rise to the special title 'rowdy mob,' or Tipperary, in reference to the Irish.

    Chapter 14

  2. What was 'shepherding' and how did the 'spare ground' institution work?

    Shepherding was squatting by one man on ground allotted by law to four men. Primitive shepherds found it cheap and profitable to have each claim visibly separated by some twenty-feet wall, mutually agreed among themselves to call it 'spare ground.' Carboni says this had grown into an institution, keeping the shepherds safe from the gutter below.

    Chapter 14

  3. What did Carboni observe about 'jumping' and its connection to drink?

    Carboni says 'Young Ireland' at Eureka headquarters was accused of monopolising the concern. If Paddy wanted a 'tip' (gin on the sly), Scotty, having gulped his 'toddy' (auld whisky), would sink six inches more in Paddy's hole—called 'jumping.' Thus broken noses grew in proportion to tips and toddy drunk on the sly.

    Chapter 14

Chapter VIII.2 cards
  1. According to Carboni, what caused much of the miners' hatred of red-tape?

    The author argues that much of the mining community's odium against red-tape arose from the accursed practice of jumping—seizing others' claims. He offers the Eureka gutter dispute as one fact from the 'stubborn-things' store, where a party of Yankees jumped the Britishers' second hole, dismantled the windlass, and Commissioner Rede was fetched to settle it.

    Chapter 15

  2. How does Carboni describe the commissioners' experience of jumping disputes?

    For the commissioners, jumping was by no means an agreeable job. They were fetched to the spot, a mob would soon collect round the disputed claim, and for 'fair play' it required the wisdom of Solomon, because the parties concerned set the same price on their dispute as the two harlots on the living child.

    Chapter 15

Chapter IX.3 cards
  1. What did Carboni claim about producing his licence during a single hunt?

    Carboni asserts as a matter of fact that he was often compelled to produce his licence twice during each and the same licence hunt. He describes being stopped at his water-hole cradle, again up the hill at his hole, and a third time while crossing the holes loaded with washing stuff, each time by a different trooper or trap.

    Chapter 16

  2. What complaint does Carboni raise about the treatment of diggers?

    Carboni asks whether diggers are dogs or savages to be hunted on the diggings, commanded to come out of their holes, and summoned from their tents by hounds of the executive. He asks whether the digger's garb marks inferiority, and cites 'In the sweat of thy brow thou shalt eat bread,' calling it an infamy now-a-days.

    Chapter 16

  3. What image opens the chapter, and what does it signal?

    The chapter opens with the shout of 'Joe,' which Carboni says no one can understand unless present at Ballaarat then. On a horrible day plagued by hot winds, the shout is carried by a hurricane blast toward Eureka, described as a wolf's howl for shepherds, a bull-dog's yell for fossikers, and a scarecrow for miners who scrambled down and left mates at the windlass.

    Chapter 16

IX.4 cards
  1. What covenant did Carboni make at the gum-tree before the Local Court?

    Carboni vowed to the Lord God of Israel that if he regained his former health and good spirits, he would speak out the truth. He further pledged that during his six months sitting in the Court he would give right to whom right was due and smother the knaves, irrespective of nationality, religion, or colour. He states he kept his word.

    Chapter 17

  2. What did Carboni do with his position as arbitrator, and when?

    Carboni resigned into the hands of his fellow-diggers the trust reposed in him as one of their arbitrators. He declared that after Christmas, 1855, he would not sit in the Local Court. He stated he came in with clean hands and goes out with clean hands, calling that the testimony of his conscience, and looking for no other reward.

    Chapter 17

  3. Where did Carboni stop on his first visit to the Court, and why is it significant?

    Carboni stopped under the gum-tree before the Local Court Building, at the identical spot where he, Father P. Smyth, and George Black had delivered to the Camp authorities their message of peace on the night of Thursday, November 30th, 1854, by moonlight, to prevent bloodshed. He notes they were then not successful.

    Chapter 17

  4. How does Carboni describe the outcome of his own conduct in office?

    Carboni claims he kept his word and that his bond is now at an end. He resigns the trust as arbitrator, saying he came in with clean hands and goes out with clean hands, which he calls the testimony of his conscience. He explicitly states he looks for no other reward. The passage is signed Carboni Raffaello, dated Dec. 1st, 1855.

    Chapter 17

Chapter X.4 cards
  1. How did troopers and traps hunt unlicensed diggers on the goldfields?

    The author describes a regular hunt: troopers were sent out like bloodhounds to beat the bush, while traps crept among the holes and sneaked into sly-grog tents. A trooper who caught a 'vagabond' would confine him round a big gum-tree by threat of his sword, and prisoners were taken to a depot down the gully. The commissioner then took bail of one, two, or five pounds from diggers who could pay, jailing the penniless.

    Chapter 18

  2. What happened to diggers who could not pay bail after being caught without a licence?

    According to the author, the commissioner would collect one, two, or five pounds in bail from any digger who could afford it or had friends to help. Those who were penniless and friendless were ordered to the lock-up in the camp. The author claims to be a living eye-witness and challenges contradiction on this account of the licence-hunt.

    Chapter 18

  3. How does the Ballaarat Times report describe the fining of unlicensed diggers?

    The reprinted report says five men were fined the 'mitigated trifle' of 5 pounds for being without licences. It mocks the contrast between the rough, bearded digger faltering an apology about an expired licence, no money, and a borrowed bag of flour for his wife and children, and the finely dressed gentleman on the bench. The magistrate replies that the law makes no distinctions and fines 5 pounds.

    Chapter 18

  4. Why does the reporter say he never runs out of news at the police court?

    The reporter explains that digger-hunting is a standing case at the police office, so he is sure of not being dead beat for news at any time. He jokes that long practice has made him so precocious he can tell the number of diggers fined every morning without going to the court at all. The author quotes this document from his subsequently gaol-bird mate, then reporter of the Ballaarat Times.

    Chapter 18

Chapter XI.4 cards
  1. What two questions does Carboni say will be put to him about the gold licence?

    Carboni anticipates two questions: first, whether camp officials issued licences to diggers at their place of work when required, without forcing them to stop work and renew at the camp; second, whether licence searches occurred only one day each month, and why diggers did not therefore make that day a half-holiday on the old ground.

    Chapter 19

  2. What grievance does the letter from 'Fellah Digger' describe about the licence office?

    The letter, published in the Ballaarat Times of October 14, 1854, complains that the miner who goes to camp to take out a licence gets miserable accommodation: he must stand in rain or sun, kept behind a wooden rail a couple of yards from the tent, as if the official feared contamination. Many mistook the licence-office for the commissioner's water-closet, prompting a placard over the door.

    Chapter 19

  3. How does Carboni describe Sir Charles Hotham's arrival and welcome in June 1854?

    Carboni records that on Thursday, 22 June 1854, Sir Charles Hotham landed as Lieutenant-Governor, the Queen's representative, and received a welcome described as never heartier in the history of public ovations. Melbourne proclaimed 'Victoria welcomes Victoria's choice.' Carboni notes that within six short months, five thousand Melbourne citizens greeted this same ruler with loud and prolonged indignation.

    Chapter 19

  4. What does Carboni's diary entry of 26 August 1854 record about Hotham's visit to the diggings?

    Carboni's diary records that Hotham suddenly inspected a shaft behind the Ballaarat Dining Rooms at about five p.m.; miners were respectful and did not 'joe' him, and laid slabs to ease his progress. Big Larry carried Lady Hotham across a crab-hole and kept the crowd back with a switch. Hotham was cheered three-times-three and proclaimed the 'Diggers' Charley,' then gave a short speech thanking the miners and promising not to neglect their interests.

    Chapter 19

Chapter XII.3 cards
  1. How did the frequency of licence searches change by late 1854?

    Up to mid-September 1854, licence searches happened about once a month, at most twice, though perhaps weekly on the Gravel Pits due to proximity to the Camp. Afterwards, licence-hunting became the order of the day: twice a week on every line, and in October and November, when weather allowed, the Camp rode out every alternate day.

    Chapter 20

  2. What did Carboni identify as the two causes of digger discontent?

    Carboni states the objectionable mode of collecting the tax was not the sole cause; the tax itself, two pounds for three months, was also objected to. He argues the practical miner who worked hard for months and bottomed a shicer could not afford to pay, and found it atrocious to be confined in the Camp lock-up for having no luck.

    Chapter 20

  3. What rhetorical question does Carboni raise about the licence money?

    Carboni puts a question 'of the old Roman stamp,' Cui bono? — that is, where did the licence money go to? He calls it a nut that will be positively cracked by-and-bye, implying the destination of the funds was a matter he intended to expose later rather than answer in this chapter.

    Chapter 20

Chapter XIII.4 cards
  1. Why did the diggers not interfere when the troopers cut down and carted off the sly-grog tent?

    Carboni gives two reasons: the store had already annoyed the diggers often enough during the long winter nights, and the plunderers were such Vandemonian-looking traps and troopers that the diggers were not encouraged to say much, because it would have been of no use. They only cried "Shame! shame!" sulkily.

    Chapter 21

  2. What effect did the dawn raid on the sly-grog tent have on the diggers' mood?

    As soon as the sun was up and all hands were going to work, the occurrence increased the discontent already brewing and it rose to excitement. Carboni says this exasperated state, vented in shouting "Joe," did not prepare the Eureka boys to submit patiently to a licence-hunt later that day.

    Chapter 21

  3. What does Carboni argue about attempts to stop sly-grog selling on the diggings?

    The author argues it is impossible to prevent the sale of spirits on the diggings, and that no laws, fines, or punishment imposed on dealers or consumers can stop sly-grog selling. A miner working in wet and cold during winter must and will have his nobbler occasionally, and Carboni thinks it very necessary to preserve his health.

    Chapter 21

  4. What story of the injured man does Carboni relate as an act of "silver and gold lace humanity"?

    A man is found insensible from loss of blood after falling on a broken bottle and cutting an artery in his head, and is taken to the Camp hospital. After some hours, because he raves from loss of blood, he is carried into the common lock-up and left about ten hours on the floor unattended. Only after repeated representations was he returned to hospital, where he died two hours later.

    Chapter 21

Chapter XIV.4 cards
  1. Why did the friends of Scobie call the October 17 meeting?

    The friends of the deceased believed both the coroner's inquest and the police court trial of Bentley and others were unfairly conducted. The inquest found Scobie died from injuries by persons unknown, and Bentley, his wife, and another party were charged but acquitted. The friends agreed to meet at the murder site to devise measures to discover the guilty and bring them to justice.

    Chapter 22

  2. What happened to Scobie and Martin at the Eureka Hotel?

    Two old friends, Scobie and Martin, reunited in Ballaarat and drank for 'Auld lang Syne.' They called at the Eureka Hotel for a finishing glass but were refused admittance, properly, for drunkenness. About fifty yards away they heard a noise, retraced their steps, and were met by unknown persons who struck them, leaving one insensible and the other lifeless.

    Chapter 22

  3. How does Carboni characterize Thomas Kennedy?

    Carboni describes Kennedy as the 'lion of the day,' with a thick, bold, bald head. He says Kennedy's merit lies in chartist slang, making him clever at spinning yarns never to the purpose, full of long phrases and cant. Carboni argues Kennedy took up the diggers' cause less from heroism than to hammer on the death of his countryman Scobie for 'auld lang syne.'

    Chapter 22

  4. What did the October 17 meeting resolve?

    The meeting resolved unanimously that, being dissatisfied with how the magistrates and coroner handled James Scobie's death, it would use every lawful means to bring the case before other, more competent authorities. It also resolved to collect subscriptions offering a reward for conviction of the murderers and to defray all other expenses connected with prosecuting the case.

    Chapter 22

Chapter XV.4 cards
  1. What did the crowd do to the Eureka Hotel after the police displayed their force?

    The crowd threw stones, bottles and sticks to smash every window, then entered and tossed out furniture, clothing and bedding, ripped off weatherboards, and set fires. The police extinguished an early blaze and tried to form a cordon, but the hotel burned to the ground. The author attributes the riot partly to the injudicious display of police strength.

    Chapter 23

  2. How did Commissioner Rede's attempt to address the crowd end?

    Rede arrived and tried to pacify the people by speechifying, mounting the sill of a broken window to gesture for a hearing. An egg thrown from behind a tent opposite narrowly missed his face and broke on the wall. He became excited and ordered troopers to arrest the thrower, but no trooper relished the task.

    Chapter 23

  3. What role does the author assign to the gale in the hotel's destruction?

    The author says a gale of wind blowing at that exact time, announcing the hurricane that soon followed, was the principal helper in devouring the building, because it blew in the direction most favourable to spreading the fire. He also notes the British habit of making fun of a fire, which he had observed in London.

    Chapter 23

  4. What did the crowd shout and do as the 40th regiment arrived?

    The crowd shouted that the 40th were coming and told each other to wait and let them see the sight. When the soldiers formed line with swords drawn, the crowd cheered and said there was no use waiting longer; the bowling alley and hotel were then fired, and the crowd cheered as the building burned.

    Chapter 23

Chapter XVI.4 cards
  1. How did Carboni describe the Geelong Advertiser's Ballaarat correspondent's outlook?

    Carboni says he did not know the correspondent personally and can only guess his frame of mind. He imagines the man believed every person must earn bread by the sweat of his brow, that trade is life wherever Britons go, and that the lazy drunkard cannot barter. The correspondent's practical advice, in Carboni's reconstruction, was to go to the loaves and fishes yourself rather than wait for them to jump into your mouth.

    Chapter 24

  2. How did Carboni characterize the Argus and its Ballaarat reporter's attitude toward the diggers?

    Carboni says the Argus persisted in its own conceit and misrepresented, perverted, and slandered the diggers' cause, so it lost influence. He guesses its reporter held that the land belongs to the Queen and Crown, disdained teaching the golden-lace to shoot, and wanted money made in the colony while keeping the vulgar mob at bay. In sum, Carboni claims the Argus wanted to screw as much as possible out of the diggers.

    Chapter 24

  3. What did Carboni identify as the characteristic vice of his times, and what did he say caused it?

    Carboni urges a future southern Tacitus to bewail the perfidious mendacity of the times, whose characteristic is slander. He says slander proceeds from devil grog, and that the pair together generate the prosperity of the wicked. He offers as a sample a public meeting held on Bakery-hill on Saturday, September 29th, 1854, where Local Court members took the sense of miners on admitting the legal profession to plead in that court.

    Chapter 24

  4. Why did Carboni turn to the free British press, and how did he rate the Melbourne papers?

    Carboni says his peace of mind was destroyed, so he had recourse to the free British press to learn what was said in Melbourne. He notes the Morning Herald was in good demand, but the Geelong Advertiser had the sway on the goldfields, helped by a rattling Ballaarat correspondent who hastened the movement. The Argus, by contrast, misrepresented the diggers and went fast to leeward.

    Chapter 24

Chapter XVII.4 cards
  1. How does the author contrast the aftermath of a storm with that of a fire?

    The author argues a storm is life: rain conquers the gale, the rainbow recalls God's covenant with Noah, and nature returns refreshed to her work. Fire, by contrast, devours everything and leaves only embers and ashes as evidence of what was once kingly or beggarly. He concludes the calamity of fire is death.

    Chapter 25

  2. What does the author mean by the claim that death is life?

    The author argues ashes lie lifeless until a storm forces them back into the living order of nature, which can then ingraft them and make them prosper with the grain of mustard seed. From this he concludes that death is life, presented as the order of Providence.

    Chapter 25

  3. What image closes the chapter and what does it point to?

    The chapter ends by directing the reader to watch the handful of ashes of what was once Bentley's Eureka Hotel. The fire imagery is thus applied to the destroyed hotel, tying the meditation on fire, ashes, and death-is-life to a specific site from the Eureka story.

    Chapter 25

  4. According to the chapter, what does the rainbow signify after the storm?

    The author says the victorious rainbow reminds man of the covenant of God with Noah, not far from this southern land. The sun then restores confidence that all is right again as before, and nature, refreshed and bolder, returns to her work. He uses this to support the claim that the storm is life.

    Chapter 25

Chapter XVIII.4 cards
  1. Who formed the triumvirate of the committee defending the three men arrested after the Eureka Hotel burning?

    The committee for the defence of the three men charged with riot met at the Star Hotel and collected subscriptions from tents across Ballaarat. Carboni contributed and then learned that Vern, Kennedy, and Humffray were the triumvirate of that committee. The three men had been taken into custody in the dead of night after the hotel burning and committed for trial in Melbourne.

    Chapter 26

  2. What reward did the Government offer for the Bank of Victoria robbers, and how did it compare to the Scobie reward?

    Placards offered 500 pounds for the apprehension and conviction of the robbers of the Bank of Victoria, increased by Government to 1,600 pounds. At the same time, placards offered 500 pounds for the discovery, apprehension, and conviction of the murderer of James Scobie, found dead near the late Eureka Hotel. The bank reward was thus more than triple the Scobie figure.

    Chapter 26

  3. How was the Bank of Victoria robbery on Monday, October 16th carried out?

    In broad mid-day in the Ballaarat township, four men in the garb of diggers, wearing sou'-wester hats with crepe over their faces, entered the Bank of Victoria. They succeeded in carrying off property in notes and gold to the amount of about 15,000 pounds. Carboni adds that he could not then have known he would soon be messmate to those unknown robbers in the same gaol.

    Chapter 26

  4. What did Carboni believe the diggers seriously contemplated after the Eureka Hotel burning?

    Carboni states that in the dead of the night after the burning of the Eureka Hotel, three men were taken into custody, charged with riot, and committed for trial in Melbourne. He thinks the diggers at this time seriously contemplated burning down the Camp, and thus getting rid in a blaze of all their grievances. This is the author's own assessment of digger sentiment.

    Chapter 26

Chapter XIX.3 cards
  1. What happened to Johannes M'Gregorius, the priest's servant, during the licence hunt?

    A trooper ordered him out of a tent, and when M'Gregorius explained he was the priest's servant and a disabled man unable to walk the diggings, the trooper struck and knocked him down, dragged him about, and tore his shirt, injuring him enough that diggers cried "shame! shame!" Commissioner Johnson told the crowd not to interrupt the trooper's 'dooty.'

    Chapter 27

  2. How did the priest respond to his servant's arrest, and what was the outcome in court?

    The priest came to the spot and handed Commissioner Johnson a five-pound note as bail for his servant's appearance at the police-office the next day. In the morning M'Gregorius was charged with being on the gold-fields without a licence and fined five pounds, despite trying to defend himself.

    Chapter 27

  3. What was the final outcome of the case, and how does the narrator summarize it?

    The case ended, in the narrator's words, in the Ballaarat tune then in vogue: "Fined 5 pounds; take him away." So despite the witness testimony that the trooper struck the disabled foreigner, M'Gregorius was fined five pounds and removed.

    Chapter 27

Chapter XX.4 cards
  1. What did Thomas Kennedy propose at the Catholic chapel meeting on Bakery-hill?

    Kennedy proposed that the meeting condemn Commissioner Johnson's conduct toward Rev. Mr. Smyth as calculated to awaken the highest indignation in his flock, and call on the government to inquire into Johnson's character and remove him at once from Ballaarat. The motion was carried unanimously.

    Chapter 28

  2. How does Carboni describe Father Patricius Smyth's background and education?

    Carboni describes Smyth as a native of Mayo, about thirty-five, of the unadulterated Irish caste, with half-curled hair, an anxious forehead, and keen fiery eyes. He is a Latin and Celtic scholar, educated at Maynooth, and his moderate proficiency in modern languages is excused on that account.

    Chapter 28

  3. What does Carboni say about the style and character of Father Smyth's preaching?

    Carboni says Smyth's preaching is not remarkable for eloquence but does not lull to sleep; there is no cant and little argument, because his short sentences are the decided opinion of his mind and warm expression of his heart, anxious for his flock's salvation. His character was never impeached, as his conduct exemplifies the strength of his faith.

    Chapter 28

  4. How did Father Smyth respond to the meeting, and what followed his address?

    Father Smyth addressed the meeting with coolness and forbearance, yet commended the constitutional manner in which his congregation sought redress from the government for the insult offered them through his person in the trooper Lord's abuse of his servant. He was warmly cheered, and then he and his friends adjourned to the parsonage for refreshments.

    Chapter 28

Chapter XXI.4 cards
  1. What five political reforms did the Reform League contemplate, according to the chapter?

    The chapter lists five: a full and fair representation; manhood suffrage, which the author notes now costs one pound thanks to the Eureka boys; no property qualification for Legislative Council members; payment of members; and short duration of Parliament. The author presents these as items imported from old England and mocks them rather than endorsing them.

    Chapter 29

  2. How does the author describe John Basson Humffray's appearance and manner?

    The author calls him a gentleman of good old family, about thirty-five, well proportioned but inclining to John Bull's build. He describes a fine forehead, spell-working eyes, a Grecian nose, and elastic lips that make him a model English speaker. His tenor voice is undulating and clear, never obstreperous, but his cool John Bull smile betrays that his heart does not always go with his head.

    Chapter 29

  3. What does the author say about Humffray's friends and enemies?

    The author says Humffray has many enemies, yet not one has ever dared substantiate a charge against his character. He has as many friends, but not one friend, because his policy is to stay friendly with redcoats and gold-lace at the same time as with blueshirts and sou'-westers. The author insists he means nothing dishonourable by this.

    Chapter 29

  4. How does the peg diagram illustrate what Humffray's foes say of him?

    The diagram places Camp, Eureka, red-tape doodledom, and blue-shirts at four corners with Work at the center. The author says foes claim Humffray sinks at Eureka with the red cap, sips Toorak small-beer at red-tape, then tramps to Camp to toast Doctor Kenworthy, yet later shakes hands at Eureka and helps rock the cradle. Bottoming his shaft at Work is a different thing.

    Chapter 29

Chapter XXIII.3 cards
  1. What did the Ballarat Times claim the Reform League was the germ of?

    The Ballarat Times, in its November 18, 1854 article, declared the Reform League was nothing less than the germ of Australian independence. It said fate had stamped the movement with an indelible signature and that no power on earth could restrain the people's strides for freedom. The paper also predicted the League would eventually resolve itself into an Australian Congress.

    Chapter 30

  2. How does Carboni undercut the Times's lofty praise of the League?

    Carboni inserts sarcastic parenthetical asides throughout the quoted article, such as 'indeed!' and 'Great works,' and adds bracketed jibes. He suggests the paper's hopes and prayers come 'in the shape of a goodly pile of half-crowns,' and that the trio Vern, Kennedy, and Humffray will shirk the League's mighty task. The author thus mocks the paper's grand rhetoric as self-interested.

    Chapter 30

  3. What mock electoral roles does Carboni assign to Humffray, Kennedy, and Vern?

    Carboni closes the chapter with a satirical 'vote': Humffray should be Auctioneer, Kennedy should be Bellman, and Vern should be Runner of the 'Starring league.' This follows his earlier bracketed remark that the League's grand task is 'but not the trio, Vern, Kennedy, Humffray.' The author argues, through ridicule, that these three leaders will not carry out the League's proclaimed mission.

    Chapter 30

Chapter XXIV.4 cards
  1. What verdict and sentences did the Bentley trial produce for James Scobie's death?

    The Supreme Court in Melbourne found Bentley, his wife, Hanse and Farrel guilty of manslaughter, not murder. The judge called their conduct wanton and reckless and sentenced each to three years' imprisonment with hard labour on the roads. Mrs. Bentley went scot-free. The chapter presents this outcome as an outrage that inflamed the miners.

    Chapter 31

  2. What rider did the jury add to the Eureka Hotel arson verdict?

    After finding Fletcher, M'Intyre and Westerby guilty of burning the Eureka Hotel, with a recommendation to mercy, the jury foreman appended a rider: the jury felt they would probably never have had that painful duty if those entrusted with the government offices at Ballaarat had done theirs properly. The rider thus blamed official misconduct, not only the prisoners.

    Chapter 31

  3. How did the arson sentences compare with the Bentley sentences?

    The arson convicts received far lighter terms: M'Intyre three months without labour, Fletcher four months, and Westerby six months' confinement. The chapter sets this against the three years' hard labour given in the Bentley manslaughter case, and its sarcastic 'Great works!' implies the contrast showed the Executive was strong enough to punish law-breakers selectively.

    Chapter 31

  4. How did the Ballaarat Times report affect the miners?

    When the Ballaarat Times appeared on Saturday, November 25, 1854, carrying the full report of the Bentley trial, work stopped at every hole. The miners left the deep diggings and mobbed together around anyone reading the report aloud. The chapter thus presents the published verdict as the immediate spark of collective agitation.

    Chapter 31

Chapter XXV.4 cards
  1. Why does Carboni say he was anxious about W. H. Archer?

    Carboni had received no answer to his letters of 17 and 22 October. While at Creswick's Creek he learned Father Smyth held a letter for him, and on returning to Ballaarat the following Monday he received Archer's letter of 20 October through Messrs. Muir Brothers. He says he is heartily glad to learn Archer is well.

    Chapter 32

  2. What meeting did Carboni attend on Bakery-hill and in what role?

    Carboni attended a 'monster meeting' on Bakery-hill, held, he writes, for the old purpose of 'the redress of grievances' rather than thanksgiving or celebration of a first harvest. He states he was the delegate of upwards of one thousand foreigners, or 'aliens,' as he sarcastically calls them per the Legislative Council's wording.

    Chapter 32

  3. How did soldiers of the Twelfth Regiment arriving on 28 November come under attack?

    About eight o'clock on Tuesday 28 November the Twelfth Regiment arrived from Melbourne, riding in carts drawn by three horses each, crossing the line at the Eureka's going-ahead end. Carboni says the soldiers were pelted with mud, stones, old stumps and broken bottles. A party of Gravel-pits men stopped a cart, pulled soldiers out, and robbed them of ammunition and bayonets.

    Chapter 32

  4. How did the camp respond to the officer who abused them that night?

    A detachment returned and its officer, whom Carboni calls a bully and a regular incapable, drew his sword and swore at the campers, calling them scoundrels. Carboni says he was soon put to rights because everyone present offered to search for the missing soldiers. One was found in a deserted tent, another in a hole down the Warrenheip Gully.

    Chapter 32

Chapter XXVI.4 cards
  1. What was the Report read to the Monster Meeting about?

    The Report of the Deputation appointed by the League to wait upon his Excellency, relative to the release of the three prisoners, M'Intyre, Fletcher, and Yorkie, was listened to with great anxiety. The meeting was held on Bakery-hill, Wednesday, November 29th, and by two o'clock about ten thousand men were present, the greatest gathering the letter's author claims to have witnessed in the Colony.

    Chapter 33

  2. How does the narrator describe George Black's reception and appearance?

    George Black was the man of the day and was received by the people with three hearty cheers. From his outward appearance one would take him for a Christian parson, not a prebendary or a bishop. His English is elegant, and being conscious of his education and gentle birth, he never prostitutes his tongue to colonial phraseology.

    Chapter 33

  3. Why did Black's Diggers' Advocate fail, according to the narrator?

    The narrator says the paper, though conducted with ability, failed because Black thought gold-diggers interested themselves with true religion as laid down in Saint James' Catholic Epistle. He made a greater mistake in not considering that men, though digging for gold, do still pretend to some religious denomination or other.

    Chapter 33

  4. What does the narrator suggest Black's character and principles are?

    The narrator presents Black as educated, sober, and gentlemanly, with settled principles rooted in a good conscience rather than mere convention. He is enthusiastic for the virtuous, yet his benevolent heart keeps him from proceeding to extremities with the vicious, and he is afflicted at the number and audacity of rogues and vagabonds, especially in the Colony.

    Chapter 33

Chapter XXVII.4 cards
  1. Why did the Governor reportedly object to the Deputation's claim?

    Mr. Black reported that the Governor received the Deputation courteously and personally had no objection to granting the public prayer. The great objection was what was termed want of courtesy in wording: the Committee sent to demand, not petition, the release of the state prisoners, and the word "demand" was said to operate more against the Deputation than the object of its mission.

    Chapter 34

  2. What did Humffray report that calmed the assembly?

    J. B. Humffray, received by the Governor as a private digger, explained plainly that Sir Charles was with the people and determined to end their grievances. He said the Governor had appointed a Commission of Inquiry of popular men well known to the diggers and had made up his mind to act accordingly. The feverish excitement was subdued and three cheers were given for the New Chum Governor.

    Chapter 34

  3. Why was the proposal to adopt a memorial form rejected?

    After hearing the Governor's reasons, it was proposed to adopt the form of a memorial and petition the Governor. This was furiously scouted on the ground that it did not comport with the dignity of the League first to demand and afterwards to pray. The letter also notes an evident split among the three Delegates.

    Chapter 34

  4. What three points does Carboni assert when interrupting the letter?

    Carboni asserts: first, that Peter Lalor and he had never addressed any meetings before this monster one; second, that intending to return to Rome the following Christmas per his brother's desire, he had attended to his work and taken no part in the agitation, and to his knowledge neither had Lalor; third, that he was never present at the Star Hotel and personally knows nothing of the boisterous Committee held there.

    Chapter 34

Chapter XXVIII.3 cards
  1. What resolution did Peter Lalor propose at the meeting?

    Lalor proposed that a meeting of the members of the Reform League be called at the Adelphi Theatre the following Sunday at 2 o'clock to elect a Central Committee, and that each forty members have the power to elect one member for the Central Committee. Carboni, an old acquaintance of Lalor, supported the resolution.

    Chapter 35

  2. How did Carboni become delegate and later interpreter to Lalor?

    Carboni says his tent on the Eureka was a Babel that Wednesday morning, as foreigners from all quarters of the globe and the diggings came to ask him what the excitement on Ballaarat was about. He translated the news from the Ballaarat Times and the Geelong Advertiser's correspondent for them, and thus, and thus alone, became honourably their delegate and subsequently interpreter to Lalor, the Commander-in-Chief.

    Chapter 35

  3. Who does Carboni name as a living witness to his account?

    Carboni names 'Le Pere Duprat', a well-known old hand and respected French miner on Ballaarat, who was with him within the Eureka Stockade. Carboni had interpreted Duprat's proposed plan for the defence to Lalor. Carboni offers Duprat as a living witness to his account, and expresses the hope that Lalor, though mutilated, may in time find at Toorak a little more credit for his testimony than did the spy Goodenough.

    Chapter 35

Chapter XXIX.4 cards
  1. Why does Carboni say the diggers are now compelled to demand rather than petition?

    Carboni recounts that the diggers wrote petitions, signed memorials, and made remonstrances by the dozens, but all failed ('no go'). Because these peaceful appeals produced nothing, he argues they are compelled to demand and must prepare for the consequences. He frames the conflict as the old style of oppressors and oppressed, a sad reflection for any educated and honest man.

    Chapter 36

  2. What does Carboni say about the distance from Austrian rule and why he emigrated?

    Carboni says he came from old Europe, 16,000 miles across two oceans, thinking that a respectable distance from the hated Austrian rule. Citing the Roman proverb 'Chi sta bene non si muove,' he asks why they left if they had a bird in hand, calling themselves silly fools to cross two oceans and chase two jackasses in the Australian bush.

    Chapter 36

  3. What was Carboni's dream, and how does it contrast with the actual meeting?

    Carboni dreamed they had gathered to thank their Father in heaven for a plentiful harvest, with their own food for the year, each holding a tumbler of Victorian wine and calling on him for a song; his harp was tuned and he struck up 'Oh, let us be happy together.' But, he says, not so: they must meet as in old Europe for redress of grievances.

    Chapter 36

  4. Whom does Carboni blame for the grievances, and what does he call on diggers to salute?

    Carboni says the grievances are inflicted not by crowned heads but by blockheads, aristocratical incapables who never did a day's work in their life. He says he hates the oppressor whatever coat he wears, and he calls on all fellow-diggers, irrespective of nationality, religion, and colour, to salute the Southern Cross as the refuge of all the oppressed from all countries on earth.

    Chapter 36

Chapter XXX.4 cards
  1. What did the Reform League meeting resolve about the licence-fee?

    The meeting declared the licence-fee an imposition and an unjustifiable tax on free labour, and pledged to take immediate steps to abolish it by burning all their licences at once. It further resolved that if anyone were arrested for having no licence, the united people would under all circumstances defend and protect them.

    Chapter 37

  2. What deadline did the meeting set for Reform League membership?

    The meeting resolved it would not feel bound to protect any man after the 15th of December who had not become a member of the Reform League by that day. Protection was thus conditional on joining the League before the deadline.

    Chapter 37

  3. How did Rev. Mr. Downing's amendment fare, and why?

    Rev. Mr. Downing proposed an amendment that the licences should not be burned. He was heard with patience and respect, but a sullen excitement pervaded the assemblage while he spoke. Even his most devoted followers thought his sentiments did not accord with the spirit of the times, and the amendment fell to the ground.

    Chapter 37

  4. What 'peculiar colonial habit' does Carboni note at the meeting?

    Carboni notes that a sly-grog seller stood on the platform and plied all the folks there with the black-bottle. The day was very hot and the sun almost burning. Carboni presents this as a peculiar colonial habit worth remembering alongside the meeting's proceedings.

    Chapter 37

Chapter XXXI.4 cards
  1. What escalating pledge did chairman Timothy Hayes ask the miners to make?

    Hayes asked whether a thousand, then two thousand, then four thousand men would volunteer to liberate a League member jailed for lacking a licence, and finally whether they were ready to die. The crowd answered yes each time. He warned that the spirit is willing but the flesh is weak, urging them to prove their sincerity before he put the resolution.

    Chapter 38

  2. What did the miners do with their gold-licences at the 29 November meeting?

    Many burned their licences, a gesture the author treats as virtually pledging themselves to the adopted resolution, which he calls the business of the day. The meeting also saw a volley of revolvers and other pistols fired. Carboni says roughly fifteen thousand people attended and dispersed with remarkable order and regularity.

    Chapter 38

  3. How does Carboni describe the enthusiasm of the Ballaarat miners?

    The author argues no one who was absent from that monster meeting, or who never saw a Chartist meeting in Copenhagen-fields, London, can form an idea of the miners' enthusiasm on 29 November. He records deafening clamour, pistol volleys, licence burning, and an orderly retirement of some fifteen thousand people.

    Chapter 38

  4. What did Hayes quote after the crowd's clamour encouraged him?

    Carboni says the clamour put Hayes in such good spirits that he launched into verse, reciting lines about the field, doom sealed, conquering or being slaves, and the sun seeing the country free or setting upon their graves. Carboni calls these 'great works,' a remark that reads as tongue-in-cheek.

    Chapter 38

Chapter XXXII.4 cards
  1. What was the purpose of the Ballaarat meeting described in the letter?

    The meeting's whole purpose was to form and fully organise a Reform League to carry out the clearance of all the diggers' grievances, modelled on the old style of the Corn Law League in Great Britain. The Southern Cross was first unfolded on Ballaarat that day, gathering round itself all the oppressed of the world. A further meeting was set at the Adelphi to organise the people and appoint a responsible executive committee.

    Chapter 39

  2. Why does the author call the gold-licence an 'abomination' rather than an ordinary tax?

    The author concedes the licence-fee as a tax is perhaps a cause of growling like any other tax in Great Britain or elsewhere. But on the gold-fields it has become an 'abomination' because of the Camp's insolence when diggers obtain it, the annoyance and bore of showing it when asked by a trap's 'pup' at work, and the imbecility and arrogance of so many commissioners and troopers uselessly employed for the purpose.

    Chapter 39

  3. What does the author say about John Bull and the passport system?

    The author argues John Bull is rather of a doggish nature and will growl to himself if left alone picking his bone, but the passport system is a bone he will not pick, no ways and under no shape whatever. The author claims to know this by experience. The point is offered privately to Mr. Archer to convey to the Lieutenant Governor.

    Chapter 39

  4. What requests does the letter make regarding the Camp and the three prisoners?

    A memorial to his Excellency for the release of the three prisoners under sentence for burning the Eureka Hotel is, through Humffray, in course of signature; the diggers earnestly desire mercy, though it may appear an act of justice considering how rightly they guessed the Bentley affair. The author also says the whole Camp pack, except magistrate Hackett, is detested and had better be changed at once.

    Chapter 39

Chapter XXXIII.4 cards
  1. What did Carboni assert about the Eureka hands on Thursday, November 30th?

    Carboni asserts, as an eye-witness, that most of the hands on the Eureka came to their work and worked as usual on Thursday morning, November 30th, at sunrise. While taking a break, they discussed the previous day's monster meeting, spinning a yarn in the usual colonial style. The general impression was that once Melbourne knew the diggers' real feelings, the licence-hunt would stop.

    Chapter 40

  2. What was Carboni doing around ten o'clock that Thursday?

    Around ten o'clock, his hour for a working-man's breakfast, Carboni retired to his tent from the mid-day heat and set about finishing his letter to Mr. Archer, which he was anxious to forward immediately to Melbourne. He then copies the letter word for word, noting it was penned in great haste and excitement.

    Chapter 40

  3. What interrupted Carboni before he could post his letter?

    Just as he prepared to post the letter, Carboni reports being worried by the usual Irish cry to run to Gravel-pits: the traps were out for licences and playing hell with the diggers. He writes that if that were the case, he would not give half-a-crown for the whole fixtures at the Camp, and says he must go see what's up.

    Chapter 40

  4. What mystery does Carboni raise about his letter to Archer?

    Carboni says the letter is now in the hands of James Macpherson Grant, M.L.C., solicitor, Collins-street, where it will remain till Christmas for inspection before being returned to its owner. He states it was not produced at his State Trial, and that this was, and still is, a mystery to him.

    Chapter 40

Chapter XXXIV.4 cards
  1. What role did Lalor give Carboni during the march to Eureka?

    Lalor appointed Carboni his aide-de-camp, or more precisely his interpreter, because Lalor knew only a little French and was no scholar in modern languages. Lalor asked Carboni to tell foreign diggers who lacked firearms to attach a five- or six-inch piece of steel to a pole. Carboni says he is now proud to be Lalor's historian.

    Chapter 41

  2. Who carried the Southern Cross and led the diggers' march to Eureka?

    Captain Ross of Toronto was the standard-bearer. He hauled down the Southern Cross from the flag-staff and headed the march as the diggers fell in two abreast and moved toward the Eureka. Carboni marched in the ranks with John Manning, both carrying pikes, after Patrick Curtain took Carboni's sword to lead the pikemen.

    Chapter 41

  3. How large did Carboni estimate the armed digger force, and what arms did they have?

    Carboni asserts as an eye-witness that they numbered within one thousand in the ranks, armed with all sorts of weapons, down to the pick and shovel. He also recalls that when the Southern Cross reached the road to Eureka, the file crossing the gully stretched back to the hill where the Catholic church stands.

    Chapter 41

  4. Why did the diggers march to Eureka instead of fighting at Bakery-hill?

    The redcoats, traps and troopers had retired to the Ballaarat Camp and wanted a spell, so the authorities were too cunning to be drawn out. Lalor ordered the men to defend themselves among the holes at Eureka in case a hunt was attempted there. The diggers resolved to end the licence-hunting and the shooting of mates in the Gravel-pits.

    Chapter 41

Chapter XXXV.4 cards
  1. Who called the captains and chief persons together, and at whose request?

    Peter Lalor called in all the captains of division then present, along with the chief persons who had taken part in the movement, at the request of the diggers' leaders. The meeting took place in a room about twelve feet square in Diamond's store, where Carboni took precautions to prevent any spy from creeping in among them.

    Chapter 42

  2. What was Edward Thonen's background and character according to Carboni?

    Thonen was a native of Elbertfeld, Prussia, about thirty years old, five feet high, thin but robust, and used no razor. Carboni describes him as shrewd yet honest, benevolent but scorning the knave, of deep thought though prompt in action, and says he possessed the head belonging to men whose word is their bond. He was also unmatched at chess on the goldfields.

    Chapter 42

  3. What does Carboni say about John Manning's character and habits?

    Carboni describes Manning as an Irishman to the back-bone, above forty, bald, with an intelligent forehead but marked by care from dreaming too much of virtue and believing knaves are not the majority. He was self-educated but lacked judgment to discipline his fermenting brain, and had acquired the colonial habit of drinking, hence his greying hair. Carboni says he remained an Irishman, not John-Bullised.

    Chapter 42

  4. Which division did Patrick Curtain help lead, and what was its fate?

    Curtain was captain, and subsequently lieutenant, of the pikemen division when they chose Hanrahan as their captain. That division was among the first to take up arms on Thursday, November 30th, after the licence-hunt, formed on Bakery-hill and received Lalor with acclamation. It was the strongest division in the Eureka stockade, stood truest to the Southern Cross, and suffered the greatest loss on the morning of the massacre.

    Chapter 42

Chapter XXXVI.4 cards
  1. Why did Lalor say he ended up in a position of responsibility?

    Lalor explains that the diggers, outraged by the Camp officials' licence-hunt at bayonet point that morning, saw it as an insult to their manhood and a challenge to the previous day's monster meeting. They rushed for arms and crowded Bakery-hill, but with no leader, confusion followed. Lalor mounted the stump, called on them to fall in by fire-arm divisions and choose their own captains, and the call was obeyed with unanimous acclamation.

    Chapter 43

  2. What did Lalor say about his military qualifications and his pledge?

    Lalor made no pretensions to military knowledge and did not presume to assume chief command more than any well-meaning man. He said he expected someone better known to come forward and direct the movement. Still, if appointed commander-in-chief he would not shrink, and pledged that once he gave his hand to the diggers he would neither defile it with treachery nor render it contemptible by cowardice.

    Chapter 43

  3. Why did Carboni decline nomination as commander, and whom did he think should lead?

    Manning nominated Raffaello Carboni, pointing to his scars as evidence of pluck against Austrian rule. Carboni declined because he had over-tasked his physical strength during the past winter and lacked the vigour essential to such an emergency. He also held that confidence is the bond between soldier and officer, and that however much a foreigner may be respected on the gold-fields, the right man should be taken from among Britons.

    Chapter 43

  4. How was Lalor appointed, and what did the first council-of-war agree?

    Thonen seconded the motion, the first 'unnamed' showed approval, and Lalor was appointed by a majority of eleven to one. Lalor thanked the council and assured members he was determined to prepare the diggers to resist force by force. It was perfectly understood and openly declared in this first council-of-war that they meant to organise for defence and had taken up arms for no other purpose.

    Chapter 43

Chapter XXXVII.3 cards
  1. What did Lalor require of those who would not take the oath?

    Lalor ordered all persons who did not intend to take the oath to leave the meeting at once. He warned that any man who, after the solemn oath, did not stand by the standard was a coward in heart. Divisions under arms then fell in around the flagstaff, and about five hundred armed diggers advanced in sober earnestness, their captains saluting Lalor.

    Chapter 44

  2. What was the exact oath sworn by the diggers?

    Kneeling bareheaded with his right hand pointing to the standard, Lalor swore: "WE SWEAR BY THE SOUTHERN CROSS TO STAND TRULY BY EACH OTHER, AND FIGHT TO DEFEND OUR RIGHTS AND LIBERTIES." About five hundred right hands stretched toward the flag, and a well-rounded universal "Amen" was the determined reply. The author compares the scene to the Crusaders in Palestine.

    Chapter 44

  3. How does the author describe the Southern Cross flag?

    The flag is silk with a blue ground and a large silver cross similar to the one in the southern firmament. It bears no device or arms, and the author calls it exceedingly chaste and natural. He judges it more beautiful than any flag in old Europe, and describes the five hundred diggers of all languages and colours as sturdy, self-overworking gold-diggers.

    Chapter 44

Chapter XXXVIII.4 cards
  1. Who was nicknamed 'Judas Iscariot' among the diggers, and how did Carboni describe him?

    Carboni calls 'Goodenough' the 'Judas Iscariot' among the diggers, appearing in the garb of a fossiker and seemingly under the influence of drink. He shouted drunkenly about standing up and fighting for rights and liberties and burning down the camp like the late Eureka Hotel. Carboni, wishing to shame him on a solemn occasion, lost his temper and kicked him.

    Chapter 45

  2. What consequence did Carboni suffer after kicking Goodenough?

    Carboni says he gave Goodenough a kick with a most respectable boot, and that it served him right when both his new watertight boots were robbed from his shins by Goodenough's satellites on the subsequent Sunday at the Ballaarat Camp. The theft is presented as retaliation for the kick.

    Chapter 45

  3. What did Carboni do after the Thursday's sun set, following the day's drill?

    After the drill was gone through with eagerness, and after the scene with Goodenough, Carboni notes that the Thursday's sun was setting and they returned to the Eureka. He states that he had to attend the 'Council for the Defence.'

    Chapter 45

  4. How does Carboni frame his account of the Goodenough incident for the reader?

    Carboni insists he tells no joke and is not in humour to spin a yarn, presenting the incident as a serious matter on a solemn occasion. He wished to shame Goodenough for his villainy, and describes his own loss of temper and the kick plainly, then notes the later theft of his boots.

    Chapter 45

Chapter XXXIX.3 cards
  1. How did Carboni describe the composition of the Eureka camp divisions by Saturday afternoon?

    Carboni states that the camp was enclosed by slabs thrown down at random, and diggers with firearms kept arriving to form new divisions, with pikemen growing stronger. He solemnly declares that up to four o'clock Saturday there was not one single division distinguished by nationality or religion, though the men were of all nations and colours.

    Chapter 46

  2. How was Lalor's position as Commander-in-chief established?

    Vern's gall was fermenting, but once Peter Lalor was proclaimed Commander-in-chief, the appointment was ratified by a hurrah from the diggers. Carboni notes the armed men numbered about five hundred by six o'clock.

    Chapter 46

  3. What did the diggers demand of Carboni when he was called to the stump?

    There was a decided intention to do 'something' with the strong arm at once, so Carboni was called on the stump. He asked the diggers to give time for deliberation and pledged his word to inform them of the result. The crowd shouted 'Go a-head! Great works!'

    Chapter 46

Chapter XL.4 cards
  1. What two demands did the deputation from the armed diggers carry to the Camp?

    The deputation was to demand the immediate release of the diggers dragged to the lock-up during the morning licence hunt, and to demand from Commissioner Rede a pledge not to come out licence-hunting any more. Black proposed the motion and Manning seconded it. The chapter notes this demanding tone reflected the diggers' temper at the time.

    Chapter 47

  2. Who was chosen for the deputation, and who accompanied them?

    Father Smyth proposed Mr. George Black, and Lalor proposed Signor Raffaello Carboni; both were agreed to unanimously. The deputation was accompanied by Father Smyth, who had an easy pass and went ahead alone to head-quarters to speak first for the safety of the others. The council stayed sitting until the deputation returned.

    Chapter 47

  3. How many diggers had gathered, and what did they want from their leaders?

    By this time the diggers from all parts had swelled to eight hundred. The chapter states they were not clamorous; they wanted to know what was determined on by the leaders. The council met in the dark, with Carboni taking the light into the council room, and both Father Smyth and Black looked serious and anxious about the responsibility of their position.

    Chapter 47

  4. What did Carboni reflect on while passing the noisy circus and drunken shouting?

    On approaching the main road, the noisy band of Row's Circus and the colonial cursing and shouting of inveterate grog-bibbers prompted Carboni to meditate on the scripture 'Unde bella et pugna inter vos?' from James, chapter iv. The night was starry and rather cold, with the moon shining in all its southern splendour.

    Chapter 47

Chapter XLI.4 cards
  1. Who was the Resident Commissioner the deputation met, and what did Carboni think of him?

    The deputation met Mr. Rede, the Resident Commissioner. Carboni describes him as a benevolent gentleman who had offered help with brickmaking, yet says he was feared by the few, respected by many, and detested by all because official iniquities were visited on his gold-lace cap. Carboni calls him a marionette whose words and movements were directed from Toorak, and says he was neither the right man nor in the right place for Sir Charles Hotham.

    Chapter 48

  2. What did Carboni suspect the correspondence between Rede and Toorak would reveal?

    Carboni writes that he would willingly turn burglar to get hold of the whole correspondence between Rede and Toorak. He feels satisfied that in it he would unravel the mystery of the Eureka massacre. This reflects his belief that Rede was not acting independently but was directed by telegraphic wires from Toorak, making the Commissioner's office a channel for decisions made elsewhere.

    Chapter 48

  3. How does Carboni describe Charles Henry Hackett, the police magistrate?

    Carboni says Hackett inspired confidence. His amiable countenance commands respect, not fear. His eyes prejudice you against him at first, but when turned on you benevolently they mean no harm. Within splendid blond whiskers are a genteel nose and mouth and a semi-serious forehead, expressing a good sound heart that loves truth even from devils. Hackett sat at Rede's left.

    Chapter 48

  4. Why did Rede decline to take the deputation to his residence?

    Rede asked the deputation's names and cautioned them that their message would be reported at head-quarters. Having a gang of vile spies at his bidding, perhaps forced upon him, he now suspected the deputation might be spies themselves. He told them plainly he thought it not prudent to take them to his residence, since the camp was prepared against a supposed attack from the diggers.

    Chapter 48

Chapter XLII.4 cards
  1. What did Mr. Rede say when Mr. Black first presented the diggers' demands?

    Rede objected to the word "demand," saying he was responsible only to the government and must obey it. He denied the prisoners were taken for lacking licences, claiming they were charged with rioting and would go before a magistrate, so it was out of his power to interfere with the course of justice.

    Chapter 49

  2. What did Carboni offer Mr. Rede, and who interrupted him?

    Carboni said the diggers' immediate aim was to resist further licence-hunting, spoke for the foreign diggers, and objected to Austrian rule under the British flag. He offered a pledge to halt licence-hunting until the Commissioner consulted the Governor. Father Smyth imperatively interrupted: "Give no pledge: sir, you have no power to do so."

    Chapter 49

  3. What did Mr. Rede claim was the real purpose behind the diggers' agitation?

    Rede dismissed the idea that the agitation aimed only at abolishing the licence, doubting the diggers would stop paying two pounds for three months. He argued the licence was merely a cloak to cover a democratic revolution. Black acknowledged the fee and its bayonet collection were not the only grievances, citing representation and unlocking the lands.

    Chapter 49

  4. What did Mr. Hackett help arrange regarding the prisoners and future licence searches?

    After consultation, bail was accepted for two of the prisoners, with Father Smyth to bring sureties the next morning. Hackett also assented that Rede could promise to consider the diggers' excited feelings and use his best judgment on further licence searches the next day. Rede agreed but insisted, "I give no pledge."

    Chapter 49

Chapter XLIII.4 cards
  1. What did Mr. Black do upon returning to the Eureka camp?

    Mr. Black calmed the excited men waiting on the main road as kindly as circumstances admitted, then returned to the camp at the Eureka and rendered an account of the mission with the candour that characterises him as a gentleman. Carboni wished to correct him on one point only.

    Chapter 50

  2. What was Carboni's one correction to Mr. Black's account?

    Carboni's impression was that the Camp, choked with red-coats, would quash Mr. Rede's 'good judgment' and get the better of his sense, if he had any, and that Rede would come out licence-hunting on an improved style. He framed this as his own impression, not established fact.

    Chapter 50

  3. When did Peter Lalor adjourn the meeting to?

    Peter Lalor adjourned the meeting to five o'clock in the morning. This followed the return of Mr. Black and Carboni to the Eureka camp, where the men were anxiously waiting to learn the success of the mission and Mr. Black calmed their excitement.

    Chapter 50

  4. What does the chapter's Italian proverb passage suggest about the mission's outcome?

    The passage opens with proverbs: the fox changes its coat but not its skin; the serpent changes skin but not venom; the dog does not bark with a full belly; the wolf dresses in sheep's clothing among the lambs. It calls this 'ancient history, but without glory,' framing the mission's result as unchanged nature rather than reform.

    Chapter 50

Chapter XLIV.4 cards
  1. What did Peter Lalor order regarding the stockade's construction, and who was in charge?

    Peter Lalor gave the order to build the stockade, and Vern had charge of it, wielding his tremendous sword. All available slabs and timber were thrown higgledy-piggledy around the camp. Lalor then directed the position each division should take around the holes, putting everyone on the 'qui vive.'

    Chapter 51

  2. Did the Council of the Eureka Stockade order a stop to work on the gold-field?

    No. Carboni asserts as a matter of fact that the Council of the Eureka Stockade never gave or hinted at any order to stop the usual work on the gold-field. He notes that not one digger had turned to work, though certain Cornishmen were not allowed to indulge in encroaching.

    Chapter 51

  3. What did Lalor request regarding arms, and what did he not counsel?

    Lalor spoke of the want of arms and ammunition and requested that everyone endeavour to procure as much of both as possible. Carboni states Lalor did certainly not counsel or even hint that stores should be pressed for it.

    Chapter 51

  4. How does Carboni describe the German blacksmith working in the stockade?

    A German blacksmith within the stockade was blazing, hammering and pointing pikes as fast as his thick strong arms allowed. He praised his past valour in the wars of Mexico and swore his pikes would fix red-toads and blue pissants. He was making money fast, and his coarse workmanship would hardly stick an opossum.

    Chapter 51

Chapter XLVIX.4 cards
  1. Why did Humffray introduce Doctor Kenworthy to the diggers at Eureka?

    Humffray, unseen since the previous Wednesday, sent a handwritten letter addressed 'To the Commander-in-Chief of the armed diggers, Eureka,' introducing Doctor Kenworthy as surgeon. He did so because he feared a collision between the diggers and the military would soon take place. Kenworthy had a Yankee face under a bell-top French hat and spoke with Carboni about Mazzini and Captain Forbes.

    Chapter 52

  2. What does Carboni say about the day of judgment and the Eureka massacre?

    Carboni states he is a Catholic who believes in the life everlasting. He says that on the day of judgment it will go milder with the Emperor Nicholas than with whoever prompted and counted on the Eureka massacre on Sunday morning, December 3rd, 1854, calling it a disgrace to the Christian name.

    Chapter 52

  3. How does Carboni describe his exchange with Kenworthy at the barricade?

    Carboni, sword in hand and on watch, spoke with Kenworthy about Mazzini and Captain Forbes, a brave American officer who fought in the 1848 struggle at Rome. Pointing with a smile to the barricade, Carboni told Kenworthy the diggers had thrown it up for defence against licence-hunting. He notes a living witness, a countryman in a red shirt covered with picks and shovels.

    Chapter 52

  4. What did Vern shout when a band of men approached the stockade?

    Vern, whose silly vanity would not let him accept not being elected Commander-in-Chief, suddenly cried out in his bombastic style, 'Here they are coming, boys: now I will lead you to death or victory!' A band of men was in fact tramping at full speed towards the stockade.

    Chapter 52

Chapter XLV.4 cards
  1. Why did the Creswick diggers march to Ballaarat, and what did they find?

    Carboni says two demagogues stumped at Creswick, urging diggers to help their Ballaarat brothers and promising plenty of arms, ammunition, forage, provisions, work, honour and glory. The roughly three to four hundred who arrived were grog-worn and ragged, proved a great nuisance, and most soon guessed they had been humbugged and returned to their old quarters.

    Chapter 53

  2. How were the newly arrived Creswick diggers fed and sheltered at the stockade?

    Carboni records that something had to be done, so Thonen acted as purveyor. The Eureka butcher on the hill supplied plenty of meat, and plenty of bread was obtained from neighbouring stores and paid for. A large fire was lit in the middle of the stockade, some men were made as comfortable as circumstances allowed, others were quartered at friends' tents, and the greater part soon returned to their old quarters.

    Chapter 53

  3. Why did the stockade lack arms and ammunition, according to Carboni?

    Carboni says arms and ammunition were the want: men were enough and ready to fight, but blue and red coats cannot be driven off with fists alone. Lalor gave the subject his attention but would not yet consent to press stores for it, and Vern kept expecting his German Rifle Brigade. Carboni argues the diggers had taken up arms only in self-defence and had never planned any preparation.

    Chapter 53

  4. What happened when the Council heard soldiers were marching from Melbourne?

    In the evening the Council was told that a reinforcement of soldiers from Melbourne was on the road. Captains Ross and Nealson hastened with their divisions across the bush to intercept the expected troops and seize their arms and ammunition. Carboni states that all proved in vain. He also notes that a certain committee kept up its hallucinated talk at the Star Hotel, though he never went there.

    Chapter 53

Chapter XLVI.3 cards
  1. What did Vern do to the stockade on Saturday morning?

    Vern enlarged the stockade across the Melbourne road and down the Warrenheip Gully. The night before had been very cold, and the men kept watch for fear of being surprised, with the cry "The military are coming" raised every hour.

    Chapter 54

  2. Why does Carboni doubt the stockade could be defended?

    Carboni argues that no man in his right senses would credit Vern with military tactics, since an acre of open hilltop fenced in by a few slabs placed at random could not be defended by a handful of men, mostly without military knowledge, against disciplined soldiers backed by traps and troopers.

    Chapter 54

  3. How did the diggers' view of the stockade change despite its weakness?

    Carboni says that despite the stockade's obvious vulnerability, the diggers were so infatuated that they now considered it stronger because it looked more higgledy-piggledy. He presents this as self-deception rather than sound reasoning.

    Chapter 54

Chapter XLVII.4 cards
  1. What warning did Father Smyth give the armed men in the stockade?

    Father Smyth told those under arms who belonged to his congregation that the government camp was under arms with seven or eight hundred men, and that reinforcements from Melbourne would soon reach Ballaarat. He warned them against useless bloodshed, reminded them they were Christians, and urged them to attend Mass the following Sunday morning.

    Chapter 55

  2. How did Lalor respond to Father Smyth's request to address the men?

    Father Smyth came inside the stockade during Carboni's watch and obtained permission from Lalor to speak to those under arms who belonged to his congregation. Vern consented, and Manning announced it to the men. Carboni notes the advice was kindly received, though he asks whether it failed because it was sown on barren ground.

    Chapter 55

  3. What did the Colonial Secretary's letter to Father Smyth say about the government's position?

    J. Moore, A.C.S., thanked Father Smyth for his efforts to allay the disturbances. He stated that unless the government enforced the laws, disorder and licentiousness must prevail, and that a commission had been issued to inquire into the condition of the digging population. Until its report, the laws the Governor found in force must be obeyed.

    Chapter 55

  4. What does Carboni suggest about the fate of Father Smyth's advice?

    Carboni writes that Father Smyth's advice was kindly received, then asks whether it failed to thrive because it was sown on barren ground. He introduces the Colonial Secretary's letter as a document that may in time help bring the truth to light, framing it as evidence rather than mere correspondence. The author thus questions whether the men were willing to heed the warning.

    Chapter 55

Chapter XLVIII.4 cards
  1. What did Carboni claim about the Eureka stockade between one and two o'clock on Saturday, December 2nd, 1854?

    Carboni asserts as a matter of fact, and as a living eye-witness, that the stockade was comparatively deserted at that time. About one hundred remained: those with a long distance to their tents, those deterred by the hot day, or those with no tent or friend on Ballaarat. He notes he observed this from his own tent while frying steak, with Manning peeling an onion.

    Chapter 56

  2. Why did the diggers decide licence-hunting was over for the day?

    Towards twelve o'clock the diggers decided licence-hunting was over for that day, because no digger could recollect a licence search ever taking place on a Saturday afternoon. Their talk then turned to the coming reform league meeting at two o'clock on Sunday at the Adelphi, as announced at the monster meeting on Wednesday.

    Chapter 56

  3. What general impression did the diggers hold about 'Charley' and the commissioners?

    The impression was almost general that 'Charley' would soon dismiss the hated brood of the commissioners, after which things would be 'all right.' This expectation circulated among the diggers that Saturday morning, alongside the plan to attend the reform league meeting on Sunday. Carboni reports it as the prevailing mood rather than as a confirmed outcome.

    Chapter 56

  4. How does Carboni support the reliability of his account of the deserted stockade?

    Carboni says he transcribes the account from the identical note he had taken down in his diary at the identical hour, written from his tent, the second from the stockade on the hill west. On that basis he claims he can afford to challenge contradiction. The chapter's epigraph muses that things ardently wished for either never come or come too late.

    Chapter 56

Chapter L4 cards
  1. What was the name of the brigade that appeared at the stockade, and how was it armed?

    Carboni records the arrival of the 'Independent Californian Rangers' Revolver Brigade,' numbering about a couple of hundred men who looked Californian enough. They were armed with a large-size Colt's revolver, and many also carried a Mexican knife at the hip. Carboni copied the long four-horned name from a pencil note he made that same Saturday because it was too difficult to remember.

    Chapter 57

  2. How does Carboni describe James M'Gill's appearance and character?

    Carboni calls M'Gill a breed from the other side of the Pacific, thought to have been educated in a military academy, with the manners of a young gentleman. He is rather short, wide awake, with 'What's up?' as his motto. Carboni reads violence in the white of his eyes, colouring of his cheeks, and paleness of his lips, yet says M'Gill is not wicked in heart, though perhaps lacking settled principles.

    Chapter 57

  3. What does Carboni argue about duelling and an honest man's moral courage?

    Carboni argues that while a man lives there is hope for fair play and for hearing his evidence; moral courage to assert truth shuts out the physical strength used to shampoo a lie. He concludes that an honest, upright man of education and a Christian leaves 'duelering' to fools. He also notes M'Gill's honour was impeached by Vern, who never came up to the scratch.

    Chapter 57

  4. What bitterness does Carboni express toward M'Gill after the stockade?

    Carboni says he was not vexed to hear M'Gill at liberty and happy while he himself was in gaol, since he could not wish his misery on anyone. But M'Gill's boast at Ballaarat that his friend Dr. Kenworthy had procured him a 'written free pardon' smothered Carboni with bitterness. He also suggests M'Gill helped others draw chestnuts out of the Eureka Stockade for some old Fox.

    Chapter 57

Chapter LI.4 cards
  1. What did Thomas Allen say about the stockade drill at Eureka?

    Allen testified that he heard the word to 'fall in' for drill and saw military evolutions performed, but not exactly in a military manner—more like an 'awkward squad.' He had been at the battle of Waterloo and knew what military evolutions were. He saw one squad with pikes and another with rifles, and heard commands such as 'Shoulder poles,' 'Order poles,' 'Ground arms,' and 'Stand at ease.'

    Chapter 58

  2. How did Allen respond when asked to join the stockade men?

    After nightfall, one of the men threw down a pike and told 'Old Waterloo' he must join them. Allen refused, calling it 'such a d----d ugly one.' When another came, he asked what bounty was offered, saying 50 pounds was little enough for an old Waterloo man. Because he would not join, he was taken into custody and guarded by three men with pikes at his door.

    Chapter 58

  3. What did M'Gill say the night order actually was?

    M'Gill assured Carboni, looking him in the eyes, that the order Allen heard was for appointing officers for watch at the stockade, for 'out-posts' to keep a sharp look-out, and for a march to intercept reinforcements—in short, an order for military discipline, necessary under the prevailing excitement. M'Gill said it was drawn up by his command and written by Alfred, brother of George Black.

    Chapter 58

  4. What did M'Gill say about the supposed Declaration of Independence?

    M'Gill stated that the supposed 'Declaration of Independence,' modeled on the American one, is a gratuitous falsehood, which must have originated from someone well-disposed toward or well-affected to Toorak small-beer. He directed Carboni to challenge the production of the document, original or copy, with satisfactory evidence of its being genuine, and Carboni expressed the hope that H. R. Nicholls would take notice.

    Chapter 58

Chapter LII.4 cards
  1. Why was Carboni refused entry to the council room?

    The council room was guarded by Californian faces who were perfect strangers to him; the pass-word had been changed, so he was refused admittance. He had returned anxious to communicate with Lalor after seeing some two hundred red-coats under arms at the foot of Black hill.

    Chapter 59

  2. What did Captain Ross bring into the stockade in triumph?

    Captain Ross entered the stockade in triumph with some old fire-arms and a splendid horse, having been sticking up some three or four tents called the Eureka government camp. Carboni mocks the fuss, noting Commissioner Amos was so frightened he got his large eyes squinting after his mare.

    Chapter 59

  3. How did Carboni respond to the order to press two horses?

    Young Black, who had taken down names at Lalor's stump and had never been within the stockade, came from the committee-room and ordered Carboni to pick men and press two horses. Carboni gave him a violent look and refused to 'do the bushranger yet'; fresh hands unknown to him carried out the order with revolvers, and Carboni felt disgusted at the violence.

    Chapter 59

  4. What does Carboni argue about the reign of terror under the British flag?

    The author argues the reign of terror will not strike root among Britons because Austrian rule does not thrive under the British flag, and calls it a crab-hole that brave Lalor alone can properly log up. He also notes sly-grog sellers profited, and Lalor personally ordered a brandy-selling devil-send out of the stockade.

    Chapter 59

Chapter LIII.4 cards
  1. How does Carboni describe the typical 'Vandemonian' in this chapter?

    Carboni describes the 'Vandemonian' as a sulky ruffian of low, vulgar manners and hard talk, with a bull-dog head and vulture eyes, sun-burnt and grog-worn. He claims their aristocracy rests on three marks: standing oceans of grog, 'shouting' for all hands, and boasting of black-eye giving and nose-smashing. He calls them naturally cowards who rely on grog for 'pluck,' and says they rarely reach grey hairs.

    Chapter 60

  2. What role does Carboni assign to Vandemonians in the colony's moral state?

    The author argues that through such men Satan planted his standard to rule the southern land before Christ could show his Cross. He claims that before Ballaarat could point at a barn and call it a church, Satan already had three palaces there, the first a match for any in the world, making its landlord as wealthy and proud as a merchant-prince of London.

    Chapter 60

  3. What does Carboni say about the danger of approaching these men?

    Carboni states it is dangerous to approach them because they know how to pick up a quarrel to gratify their appetite for fighting. He adds that they cannot be avoided in the colony since they are too numerous, and that he saw hundreds of them during his four months in gaol. He compares their hearts to those of vultures, being of the same trade.

    Chapter 60

  4. How does Carboni explain the physical decline of these men?

    The author argues that although their frame may be robust by nature, it wears out through hard drink and goes the way of all flesh, rarely with grey hairs. He ties this to their reliance on grog as 'pluck': the more they swallow, the more they count on success, so their strength is consumed by the very drink they trust.

    Chapter 60

Chapter LIV.4 cards
  1. How does Wiesenhavern respond when the armed gang demands nobblers round?

    Wiesenhavern agrees to give each man one nobbler and no more, then sets two decanters of brandy and tumblers on the bar for them to help themselves. When they demand another round and one tries to enter the bar, he fetches pistols while his partner Johan Brandt brings a double-barrelled gun, and they cow the gang into leaving.

    Chapter 61

  2. What conditions does Wiesenhavern set before serving the armed men?

    Wiesenhavern tells the men each will have one nobbler and no more, after which they must go their way, and asks if they agree. They accept. When they later call for the bottles to be refilled for another round, Wiesenhavern refuses and instead uses the promise of special Champagne Cognac to keep them calm until he returns with his pistols.

    Chapter 61

  3. What does Carboni report about gangs plundering stores in the committee's name?

    Carboni relates with sorrow that several similar armed bands were scouring the gold-fields in the name of the Eureka stockade committee, pressing for fire-arms and ammunition and plundering respectable stores. One gang of four ransacked D. O'Conner's store at Golden Point, taking hams, coffee, and a cash-box worth about twenty pounds.

    Chapter 61

  4. Does Carboni claim the committee ordered these plundering raids?

    No. Carboni states these are facts but explicitly does not assert that such were the orders of the committee formed after four o'clock that Saturday at the Eureka stockade. He adds that he had no part in the committee and knows nothing of it personally, carefully separating the reported raids from any claim of official authorization.

    Chapter 61

Chapter LV.4 cards
  1. Why did Carboni enter the stockade near midnight?

    Carboni ran up to the stockade to remonstrate with Peter Lalor about what he calls suicidal proceedings. He had too much respect for Lalor to believe he had any hand in, or had sanctioned, such plans. Carboni entered using the password and found things comparatively quiet, with most men asleep or warming themselves around the big fire.

    Chapter 62

  2. Where were the Californian Rangers and Nealson's division that night?

    M'Gill and two-thirds of the Independent Californian Rangers' Rifle Brigade were out 'starring' to intercept reinforcements reported on the road from Melbourne, in line with the vocation named in their title. Nealson and his division were off for the same purpose. Carboni asks whether their lot would be that of Lot's wife.

    Chapter 62

  3. Why could Carboni not speak with Lalor that night?

    Carboni asked Thonen to see Lalor, but was told that Peter, from sheer exhaustion, must rest for an hour or two and was asleep. Carboni himself had not closed an eye since Thursday and felt severely the want of sleep. He wished Thonen good night, and Thonen told the outposts, chiefly Californians, to let him pass to his tent.

    Chapter 62

  4. What did Carboni do after leaving the stockade?

    Thonen gave word to the outposts, chiefly Californians, to let Carboni pass to his tent. Carboni threw himself on his stretcher, with everything quiet around, and soon fell asleep. He reflects that he does not remember his frame of mind, probably thinking enough for the day and that the morrow would have its own troubles.

    Chapter 62

Chapter LVI.4 cards
  1. How did the battle at the Eureka Stockade begin on Sunday, December 3rd?

    Carboni awoke at full dawn to a discharge of musketry, a bugle round, the command 'forward,' and further musketry kept up by some 300 red-coats advancing on the gully west of the stockade for a couple of minutes. Shots whizzed by his tent, and he rushed to his chimney facing the stockade, where the forces within could not muster above 150 diggers.

    Chapter 63

  2. Who occupied the rifle-pits in the lower stockade, and how did they fight?

    The shepherds' holes in the lower part of the stockade had been turned into rifle-pits, occupied by Californians of the I.C. Rangers' Brigade, some twenty or thirty who had kept watch at the out-posts overnight. Carboni notes a brave American officer commanding the rifle-pit men fought like a tiger, was shot in his thigh at the onset, yet kept hopping and stuck by Captain Ross.

    Chapter 63

  3. What happened to Lalor, Ross, and Thonen during the assault?

    Peter Lalor stood on top of the first logged-up hole inside the stockade, gesturing for men to retire among the holes, and was shot down in his left shoulder at that moment—Carboni calls it a chance shot. Ross was shot in the groin, and another shot struck Thonen exactly in the mouth, felling him on the spot.

    Chapter 63

  4. How did the military take the stockade, and what happened to the Southern Cross?

    The command 'Charge!' was heard and the red-coats rushed with fixed bayonets to storm the stockade. A few cuts, kicks and pulling down finished it quickly; they thrust bayonets into the bodies of the dead and wounded, a wild hurrah burst out, and the Southern Cross was torn down amid laughter, as if it were a prize from a May-pole. Armed diggers fled or surrendered and were marched off in chains.

    Chapter 63

Chapter LVIII.3 cards
  1. What did the troopers do to the tents inside the stockade after entering?

    The troopers dismounted, took firebrands from the large fire in the middle of the stockade, and deliberately set ablaze all the tents around. Carboni says he saw one tall trooper strike a bundle of matches and set fire to the corner end north of Diamond's store, where the council for the defence had met. The wounded were burned to death, and those who had surrendered and taken refuge in tents were kicked and made prisoners.

    Chapter 64

  2. How did Carboni regain his freedom after being taken prisoner?

    Sub-inspector Carter pointed a pistol and ordered Carboni to join a batch of prisoners, and he obeyed. In the gully he expostulated with Captain Thomas, who asked whether he had been made a prisoner within the stockade. Carboni answered no. Thomas, noting his frankness and grief, gave him a gentle stroke with his sword and released him, saying if he were an honest digger he was not wanted. Mr. Gordon was released the same way as a living witness.

    Chapter 64

  3. What happened to Carboni as he crossed the gully back to his tent?

    A trooper riding on the road to Ballaarat deliberately aimed at him and fired a Minie rifle pistol with tolerable precision. The shot whizzed past and struck the brim of Carboni's cabbage-tree hat, blowing it off his head. Mrs. Davis, who was outside her tent close by, is cited by Carboni as a living witness to the incident.

    Chapter 64

Chapter LIX.4 cards
  1. What did Carboni find when he reached the stockade after the battle?

    Carboni describes a horrible sight: old acquaintances crippled by shots, gore protruding from bayonet wounds, and clothes and flesh burning. Thonen's mouth was choked with bullets, Teddy More lay with both thighs shot and asked for water, and Peter Lalor was concealed under a heap of slabs, in agony, with a stream of blood forcing its way downhill.

    Chapter 65

  2. How does Carboni contrast the clergy's conduct at the stockade?

    Carboni notes that Father Smyth, a Catholic priest, was performing his sacred duty to the dying despite troopers who threatened his life and forced him to desist. By contrast, he states that none of the Protestant ministers was there to help the digger in his hour of need, and he tells Protestants to spare him their sabbath cant in future.

    Chapter 65

  3. What does Carboni say about John Bull and human life?

    Carboni argues that John Bull will bend his neck to any burden for palaver and war to protect universal shop-keeping and the sacred rights of property, but that human life is to him as it was to Napoleon: fodder for the cannon, or tools to make money. A dead man needs no further care, and humankind breeds fast enough.

    Chapter 65

  4. What did Mr. Binney tell Carboni inside the stockade, and who corroborates it?

    Binney took Carboni warmly by the hand and said he was glad to see him alive, because everyone thought a dead digger among the heap was 'poor Great Works.' Carboni, distracted, answered 'Thank God, I am alive' and went to his duty. Carboni cites Binney, now of Binney and Gillot, storekeepers on the Ballaarat township, as a living witness.

    Chapter 65

Chapter LX.4 cards
  1. What does the Geelong Advertiser correspondent report counting at the barricade?

    The correspondent writes that he counted fifteen dead at the barricade, and describes one stout-chested man of about forty with a pike beside him bearing fifteen wounds, including three contusions to the head, strokes across the brow, and a bayonet wound in the throat. He notes some bodies might have been removed, and that the sight left him loathing the remembrance.

    Chapter 66

  2. What did the little terrier do after its master was killed?

    The correspondent describes a little terrier sitting on the breast of the dead man with the pike, howling continuously. When removed, it always returned to the same spot, and when the master's body was thrown into the cart with the other corpses, the dog jumped in after him and lay on his dead master's breast, howling again.

    Chapter 66

  3. How does the correspondent describe the relative numbers at Eureka?

    He states that there were only about one hundred and seventy diggers opposed to nearly six hundred military, and that all whom he spoke to were of one opinion: that it was a cowardly massacre. He adds that the feeling among many is not intimidation but a cry for vengeance and an opportunity to meet the soldiers with equal numbers.

    Chapter 66

  4. What happened to Mr. Haslam, and how was he freed?

    The correspondent reports that Haslam was roused by a volley of bullets fired through his tent, rushed out, and was shot down by a trooper and handcuffed. He lay bleeding from a chest wound for two hours until friends sent for a blacksmith, who forced off the handcuffs with a hammer and cold chisel. A surgeon was later probing for the ball.

    Chapter 66

Chapter LXIII.4 cards
  1. Who arrests Carboni at the London Hotel, and on what pretext?

    Spy Goodenough, a trooper, bursts into the London Hotel between eight and nine o'clock, points a cocked pistol at Carboni, and says "I want you." When Carboni protests that he is helping Dr. Carr bandage a wounded American digger, Goodenough refuses to listen, threatens to shoot him "like a rat," and drags him out to join a dozen other prisoners marched to the Camp.

    Chapter 67

  2. What does Carboni note about the wounds of the American digger he was bandaging?

    Carboni records that the American digger had at least half-a-dozen shots on his body, all in front, which he treats as evident proof the man had stood his ground like a man rather than being hit while fleeing. Carboni adds that he would gladly write the man's name if he could recall it, praising him as a brave fellow.

    Chapter 67

  3. What mysteries does Carboni say surround Dr. Carr's conduct?

    Carboni says Dr. Carr never spoke a word in his behalf despite two years' acquaintance, was the first to enter the stockade after the military action though he had never been on the Eureka during the agitation, was appointed to attend wounded diggers brought to the Camp, and was absent from Carboni's trial. Carboni calls these circumstances a mystery to him still.

    Chapter 67

  4. How were the prisoners moved to the Camp, and how did the diggers respond?

    Carboni was dragged out and hobbled to about a dozen other prisoners, and the group was marched to the Camp. He notes the main road was clear, and that diggers crawled among the holes at the simple bidding of any trooper riding beside the prisoners — suggesting little resistance or defiance along the route.

    Chapter 67

Chapter LXIV.4 cards
  1. What did Inspector Foster take charge of when Carboni was stripped at the Camp?

    Carboni pulled out a small bag containing Eureka gold-dust and his licence, and Mr. Foster took care of the bag. Just as Carboni's name was copied from the licence, a fresh batch of prisoners arrived and Foster was called outside the room where Carboni was stripping.

    Chapter 68

  2. Why was Carboni thrown naked and senseless into the lock-up?

    A trooper pretended to recognize him as one of the 'spouts' at the monster meeting. Carboni wanted to keep his waistcoat because of money and papers in the breast pocket, and when he attempted to remonstrate his clothes were torn to rags, he was kicked, knocked down, and thrown naked and senseless into the lock-up.

    Chapter 68

  3. What conditions in the prison did Carboni describe, and what relief came?

    The prison was crammed to suffocation, with prisoners taking turns to stand or lie down. Fleas, lice, horse-stealers and low thieves introduced themselves; vermin, heat, stench and horror made life intolerable, and by midnight Sunday Carboni was delirious. About two o'clock Monday morning Commissioner Rede had the Eureka prisoners moved to the Camp store-house, a spacious, well-ventilated, clean room.

    Chapter 68

  4. How did Commissioner Rede respond to Carboni's appeal in French?

    Carboni addressed Rede in French to call attention to his misery. Rede answered kindly, saying he would not fail to speak to Doctor Carr and, if what Carboni said proved true, he would interest himself on Carboni's behalf. Carboni replied that he was very good. The author notes Rede showed no air of exultation and seemed to feel for their situation.

    Chapter 68

Chapter LXV.3 cards
  1. Who was the literary prisoner brought into the camp, and what was he arrested for?

    Henry Seekamp, the Editor of 'The Times' newspaper, was arrested for sedition and arrived among the prisoners on Monday morning. Carboni describes him as a short, thick man of quick movements and sardonic countenance, with a German-moulded head and moustachios. Camp officials and their men rushed in to gaze at him, supposing his paper had stirred up the trouble at Ballaarat.

    Chapter 69

  2. How does Carboni describe Seekamp's temper and his attitude toward flunkeys and fools?

    Carboni says Seekamp has a temper he must work to control, hates humbug and 'yabber-yabber,' and holds a decided contempt for 'incapables.' His motto is Nelson's: you must do your duty. He becomes your enemy if you are or play the flunky, calling you a 'thing.' Carboni notes his energy never abated though Victorian red-tape tried to dry his inkstand and smother his lamp in gaol.

    Chapter 69

  3. What did Carboni do with Seekamp, and what presentiment did he have afterward?

    Carboni felt for Seekamp and joined him in conversation in French. He states as a matter of fact that there and then he had the presentiment that all the spies pointed him out there, and only there and then, as Seekamp's accomplice. This suggests his speaking French with the literary prisoner drew suspicion onto him.

    Chapter 69

Chapter LXVI.4 cards
  1. What did the December 1854 Buninyong proclamation declare, and from when?

    It declared martial law in the district of Buninyong, to be administered from noon on Wednesday, 6 December 1854, against anyone committing rebellion, treason, treasonable or seditious practices, or other outrage or misdemeanor within the listed limits. It was issued by Lieutenant-Governor Sir Charles Hotham with the advice of the Executive Council, and published in the Victoria Government Gazette Extraordinary.

    Chapter 70

  2. What limits did the proclamation set for martial law?

    The proclamation applied within boundaries defined by place names: arrowee, Lal Lal, Moorabool, Ran Rip, and Yarrowee. The text as given is garbled and incomplete, so the exact perimeter cannot be fully reconstructed from this chapter alone. The limits mattered because martial law applied only to persons within them after the stated hour.

    Chapter 70

  3. What power did the proclamation give officers commanding Her Majesty's forces?

    It ordered and authorized all officers commanding Her Majesty's forces to employ them with the utmost vigour and decision for immediate suppression of the rebellion, and to proceed against and punish every person acting, aiding, or in any manner assisting in the rebellion according to martial law, as to them should seem expedient.

    Chapter 70

  4. What limit did the proclamation place on death sentences?

    It especially declared that no sentence of death should be carried into execution against any such person without the Lieutenant-Governor's express consent. Carboni appends the sarcastic aside 'Great works!' after this clause, which the author uses to undercut the proclamation's tone rather than to praise it.

    Chapter 70

Chapter LXVII.3 cards
  1. What rumor frightened the prisoners in the Camp?

    The prisoners were frightened by the report that a gang of red-coats were sinking a large pit in the Camp. Carboni joked grimly that being buried alive without flogging was not half so merciful as Haynau's rule in Austria. His Irish mate replied sorrowfully, asking where in history the British Lion was ever merciful to a fallen foe.

    Chapter 71

  2. How does Carboni contrast his youthful view of human nature with his present view?

    Carboni recalls happy days in his youth when he thought with Rousseau that the heart of man is from nature good. He calls it a sad fatality that now compelled him to feel the truth from the prophet Isaiah, that the heart of man is desperately wicked. The change reflects his experience of the December 1854 events.

    Chapter 71

  3. What did Carboni refuse to comment on regarding the evidence against him?

    Carboni says he was thunderstruck at the savage eagerness with which spies and red-coats sprang out to point him out. He notes a British soldier swore and confessed his cowardice of running from before Carboni's pike, which Carboni says he never had on the stockade where the fellow could not have seen him. Carboni refuses to prostitute his intelligence commenting on evidence from bloodthirsty mercenary spies.

    Chapter 71

Chapter LXVIII.4 cards
  1. Who were the only witnesses Carboni acknowledges had seen him before his arrest?

    Carboni states that, apart from the spies Goodenough and Peters, none of the witnesses against him had ever seen his face before. He insists he had never seen them prior to being under arrest at the Camp, and that several gave contradictory accounts of chasing, shooting at, or capturing him.

    Chapter 72

  2. What did Carboni tell the magistrate about the witnesses' evidence?

    Carboni pointed out to the sitting magistrate the absurdity of the witnesses' evidence and noted that Sub-inspector Carter and Dr. Carr could prove the contradiction. He also says he repeatedly told each witness during prison 'recognition' that they must be mistaking him for another man, since he was not inside the stockade that Sunday morning.

    Chapter 72

  3. How does Carboni characterize the Camp officials and their use of witnesses?

    Carboni denounces the 'red-tape' officials at Ballaarat as a brood of Satan who squandered diggers' earnings and competed in vomiting like sick dogs. He argues their sheer number was wrongly treated as proof of truthfulness, citing the Mosaical rule that two witnesses suffice to condemn, though most had never seen him before.

    Chapter 72

  4. What happened when Carboni was brought before Mr. Sturt?

    Mr. Sturt, whom Carboni describes as plump and odious-faced, took the magisterial chair and committed Carboni and the 'nigger-rebel' to whom he was hobbled to stand trial for high treason. Carboni notes his bitterness at being committed despite his protests about the contradictory evidence.

    Chapter 72

Chapter LXIX.4 cards
  1. What news from Melbourne reached the prisoners on December 7th?

    The report reached the prisoners that the Melbourne people had held a Monster Meeting of their own, equal to the Ballaarat meeting of November 29th, and that Mr. Foster, called the 'Jesuit,' had been dismissed from office. Carboni notes this came despite the bayonets and blunderbusses.

    Chapter 73

  2. What happened to the 160 prisoners, and how many were held back?

    Between Wednesday and Thursday, all 160 prisoners were liberated, with the necessary exception of thirteen, who were reserved to confirm the title of the book. Carboni frames the Ballaarat tragedy as over and the scene shifting to what he calls the farce of the State Trials in Melbourne.

    Chapter 73

  3. What does Carboni say about young Fergusson and spy Peters?

    Carboni says Fergusson, an American suffering from consumption, was among them and with them at four o'clock on Saturday, at the same time spy Peters was within the stockade. Yet no spy, trap, or trooper appeared against Fergusson; Doctor Kenworthy, his countryman, managed to get him off.

    Chapter 73

  4. Why does Carboni keep Fergusson's blue blankets?

    Carboni says he intends to keep the blue blankets Fergusson left to him in prison for his comfort, in his remembrance. He calls Fergusson a brave, kind-hearted, republican-minded young American, and says he respects him too much to disclose their private conversation.

    Chapter 73

Chapter LXX.4 cards
  1. What did the Melbourne deputation of five hundred men offer the Lieutenant-Governor?

    A deputation of five hundred bankers, merchants, and other Melbourne residents presented an address placing themselves, their services, and their influence unreservedly at the Lieutenant-Governor's disposal, for maintaining order and upholding the paramount authority of existing law. The Governor received them with marked attention and replied with a speech that Carboni then annotates.

    Chapter 74

  2. According to the Governor's answer, what was the real cause of the Ballaarat outbreak?

    The Governor states it was not a particular law or complaint, and not exactly the licence fee, though that was made the 'nom de guerre' and 'cheval de bataille.' He argues the masses were urged on by designing men with ulterior views hoping to profit by anarchy, and by active, intriguing foreigners seeking disorder. Carboni's bracketed notes dispute this account.

    Chapter 74

  3. How does Carboni plan to distribute five hundred copies of his work?

    Carboni leaves five hundred copies with Messrs. Muir, Brothers and Co., merchants of Flinders-lane, Melbourne, at ten shillings each. The firm serves gratuitously, so he authorises them to keep half-a-crown from each ten shillings and, in the spirit of Matthew chapter six, share it: one shilling to the Benevolent Asylum, one to the Melbourne Hospital, and sixpence to the Miners' Hospital, Ballaarat.

    Chapter 74

  4. What does Carboni mean by invoking 'Audi Alteram Partem' and 'Fair Play'?

    Carboni opens by transcribing the Governor's side from The Argus of 15 December 1854, so readers may judge both accounts — 'hear the other side.' Through bracketed French asides he contests the Governor's claims, and closes hoping to understand 'Fair-play' better than Toorak, contrasting official treatment of the Ballarat prisoners with his own professed fairness.

    Chapter 74

Chapter LXXI.4 cards
  1. What does Carboni say about his personal acquaintance with the twelve state prisoners?

    Carboni states that, except for Hayes and Manning, of the remaining ten, seven were perfect strangers to him and three he had only met at work on the gold-fields. He declines to say anything further about them. This means he could personally vouch for only two of the twelve prisoners.

    Chapter 75

  2. How does Carboni describe Michael Tuhey and the outcome of his defence?

    Carboni calls Tuhey the stoutest heart among them: a young, healthy, good-hearted Irishman who hated John Bull's ways, was misled by George Black countenancing two demagogues at Creswick-creek, and came to Ballaarat with double-barrelled guns. Tuhey never regretted it. His brother paid about forty pounds to a solicitor for his defence, but at trial the lawyer was not there.

    Chapter 75

  3. What does Carboni recount about Thomas Dignam's conduct and trial?

    Carboni describes Dignam as a serious, short, tight-built Sydney native, honest and opposed to rogues. He braved mob fury on the Eureka on Tuesday, November 28th, saving at risk of his own life a soldier of the 12th regiment. He took up arms in Thursday's licence-hunt, drilled at the stockade, fought on Sunday morning, and paid over thirty pounds to his solicitor, yet at trial no charge was brought and the prosecution was dropped.

    Chapter 75

  4. How were the prisoners treated in gaol, according to Carboni?

    Carboni says they remained in chokey at Ballaarat under Sergeant Harris, who showed affection for Joseph and had Hayes clear a tub full of urine and solids once; Hayes refused to repeat it and fell into disgrace. Carboni reports Hayes's body was bloated with lice from the lock-up, Manning suffered worst, and he himself was plagued by the vermin throughout the four months in gaol.

    Chapter 75

Chapter LXXII.4 cards
  1. What scene does Carboni record on Sunday afternoon in this chapter?

    Carboni records the farewell visit of Mrs. Hayes and her six children to Timothy Hayes, one of twelve prisoners, before his journey to Melbourne. She brings clean clothing and provisions to make the trip comfortable, holds her baby at her breast, and keeps her eyes on her husband. The children surround their father, and the eldest, twelve years old, kisses his hand while weeping.

    Chapter 76

  2. How does Timothy Hayes behave during the farewell, and how do the other prisoners react?

    Hayes forces himself to appear as cheerful as his honourable heart and proud mind allow: he presses his little daughter who wants to climb his shoulder and blesses the younger of his sons. The other prisoners respond differently—some gaze stationary 'in a fix,' some pace the prison cursing, and the rest, cast down and desponding, do violence to themselves to dam their flooded eyes. Carboni counts himself among the broken-hearted.

    Chapter 76

  3. What does Carboni urge the weeping eldest son to do, and what Psalm does he cite?

    Carboni tells the boy his sorrows have begun soon enough for his sensible heart, and urges him to strengthen it with Christian courage by time, lest grief smother it before his hair turns grey. He reminds him there is a God and tells him to learn by heart the Psalm 'Beatus vir qui timet Dominum,' especially the last verse ending 'Desiderium peccatorum peribit.'

    Chapter 76

  4. What does Carboni say about his own mind and powers of observation at the end?

    Carboni says that had he cultivated painting in his younger years, he could produce a tableau to match his countryman Raffaelle. He claims an all-wise Providence endowed him with a cast of mind that, when his 'electric fluid' is called into action on such solemn occasions, is actually a daguerreotype—capturing the scene exactly. He notes his head still has the red hair of his youth.

    Chapter 76

Chapter LXXIII.3 cards
  1. What did Captain Thomas tell the prisoners would happen if they moved during transit?

    Captain Thomas read an 'Order of the day' stating the prisoners were under his charge for transit to Melbourne, and that if any stirred a finger or moved a lip—especially across the diggings—the transgressor would be shot on the spot. Carboni calls the arrangement Austrian-like and unworthy of a British officer, and shouts 'God save the Queen!' in response.

    Chapter 77

  2. How did Inspector Foster respond to Carboni's shout?

    Inspector Foster sprang at Carboni with his hopping leg, tightened the darbies on him, and placed him and the mulatto-rebel at the front of the cart. Foster ordered them shot down if either attempted to turn their heads. Carboni notes this treatment made his hatred for figures like Haynau and Jellachich decline.

    Chapter 77

  3. What did Carboni see while being taken through the Eureka?

    Though it was clear daylight, Carboni saw only one digger on the whole main road. Passing through the Eureka, he glimpsed his snug little tent, where he had spent many happy hours and which was sacred to him on Sundays. It lay deserted and uncared for, and he says his eyes filled with tears—at forty, a man does not cry for little.

    Chapter 77

Chapter LXXIV4 cards
  1. How were the thirteen prisoners transported and guarded on the road to Ballan?

    The thirteen healthy, able-bodied men were chained together on three carts. A dozen dragoons rode on horseback as sharp-shooters in all directions ahead of the carts, while a score of troopers with swords unsheathed and carbines cocked kept so close that one was thrown from his horse by a gum-tree and disabled but not killed.

    Chapter 78

  2. What contrast does the narrator draw between nature and the prisoners' condition at Ballan?

    The narrator describes a fine spring morning, a superb landscape, blue flowers in splendid grass, and chattering parrots and crows all joy and happiness. At the foot of this picture, however, lie thirteen chained prisoners on the bare ground, while guards and others eat and drink before them.

    Chapter 78

  3. What treatment did the chained prisoners receive at Ballan compared with the guards?

    The dragoons and troopers had biscuit, cheese, and ale served to them, though paid for by themselves, before the prisoners' teeth. The state prisoners, chained and lying on the bare ground, had no breakfast and had some trouble obtaining even a drop of cold water from the red-coats watching them.

    Chapter 78

  4. What does the narrator say is the purpose of recounting this lesson to the reader?

    The narrator asks the good reader to enter within his mind and says the lesson, if read, learned, and inwardly digested, will be of good use for the future, because the troubles of the colony have begun. He frames the scene as instruction rather than mere travel narrative.

    Chapter 78

Chapter LXXV.4 cards
  1. What did the Ballaarat delegates say about the diggers taking up arms?

    The delegates told the Governor they repudiated physical force for constitutional redress, but argued the diggers' arming, though reprehensible, deserved judgment on special grounds: they had special provocation. The diggers did not take up arms against British rule, but against the mis-rule of officials paid to administer the law properly, defending themselves against bayonets, bullets, and swords in an unconstitutional attack.

    Chapter 79

  2. What did the delegates argue about the Governor's claim that diggers forestalled inquiry?

    The delegates reversed the charge: the fault lay with the government for prostituting the military as tax collectors under vain officials. They argued it was Commissioner Rede and Co. who forestalled the inquiry by trying to crush the '500 scoundrels' he complained of, and that the digger-hunt of 30 November and the slaughter of 3 December were acts of petty official revenge.

    Chapter 79

  3. How did the delegates use the Governor's own 'equal justice' principle against him?

    The delegates noted the Governor laid down 'equal justice to all' as government's duty. They argued that if American citizens received clemency, equal justice demanded amnesty for all irrespective of nationality, and that making exceptions violated his own principle. They did not blame him for freeing the Americans, but complained he showed no same liberality to others.

    Chapter 79

  4. What did the delegates say about the bloodshed as grounds for amnesty?

    The delegates argued that even if the government had been right in everything — which facts do not warrant — the slaughter of some fifty people was blood enough to expiate far greater crimes than the diggers had committed, without seeking the lives of thirteen more victims. They said the government would act wisely in not pursuing so suicidal a course.

    Chapter 79

Chapter LXXVI.4 cards
  1. What did Captain Thomas send the prisoners at Bacchus Marsh, and why does Carboni thank him?

    Captain Thomas sent the prisoners a gallon of porter and plenty of damper, and Carboni writes of this kindness with thanks. Carboni notes that Thomas must have acknowledged the prisoners had behaved as men, and remarks that Thomas had no occasion to shoot any of them. The lockup at Bacchus Marsh was dark but far cleaner than the lousy one at Ballaarat.

    Chapter 80

  2. What happened when the prisoners reached the Melbourne gaol at eight o'clock at night?

    After a long day smothered in dust and burning with thirst, the prisoners arrived before the Melbourne gaol at eight o'clock at night. A man in the garb of a digger gave them a welcome glass of ale and introduced them to the governor, giving a good account of them. Hearing they had eaten nothing since mid-day, the governor allowed them bread and cheese.

    Chapter 80

  3. What indignity began the prisoners' prison life, and what did their cell contain?

    The prisoners were commanded to strip to the bare shirt, which Carboni calls the usual ignominy to begin a prison life with. They were then shown their cell, which contained a board to lie down on and a blanket, and the heavy door was bolted on them. Within the darkness of the cell they gave vent to their grief, each in his own way.

    Chapter 80

  4. What does Carboni say about sleep and where his mind wandered in the cell?

    Carboni observes that sleep is not a friend to prisoners. Lying in the darkness of the cell, he says his mind naturally wandered back to the old spot on the Eureka. The chapter closes on this reflection rather than on any further action, framing the prisoners' grief and memory of the Eureka as the emotional end of the day.

    Chapter 80

Chapter LXXVII.4 cards
  1. Who compiled the report of the killed and wounded at Eureka, and what did he ask of the public?

    Peter Lalor, signing as Commander-in-Chief, compiled the lists of killed and wounded at the Eureka Massacre of 3 December 1854. He states the numbers are well known but there is a want of names, and asks that friends or acquaintances forward particulars to 'The Times' office, Ballaarat, so they may be used in a more lengthened narrative.

    Chapter 81

  2. How does Lalor's report divide the wounded, and who appears in the recovered group?

    Lalor splits the wounded into two categories: 'Wounded and since dead' (including Lieutenant Ross of Canada and Thaddeus Moore of County Clare) and 'Wounded and since recovered.' Peter Lalor himself heads the recovered list, followed by Patrick Hanafin, Michael Hanly, the Callanans, Frank Symmons, James Warner, Luke Sheehan, Michael Morrison and Dennis Dynan.

    Chapter 81

  3. What details are given for the killed at Eureka, and which entries lack names?

    The killed list gives names and origins: John Hynes and John Diamond of County Clare, Patrick Gittins of Kilkenny, Samuel Green of England, John Robertson of Scotland, Edward Thonen the lemonade man from Prussia, John Hafele of Wurtemberg, and others. Entries 13 and 14 are names unknown, one usually known on Eureka as 'Happy Jack.'

    Chapter 81

  4. What mystery does Carboni raise at the end of the chapter?

    After reproducing Lalor's signed report, Carboni states that what has become of George Black 'was, and is still, a MYSTERY to me.' He explains he lost sight of Black since Black left for Creswick-creek on 1 December 1854, two days before the massacre.

    Chapter 81

Chapter LXXVIII.4 cards
  1. What did Carboni receive for breakfast and tea in gaol?

    Carboni states that both his breakfast and his tea consisted of a dish of 'hominy' (Indian meal), which was sometimes 'fattened with grubs.' He describes this as his regular fare during his four months in the gaol, and says his health was ruined for ever by the experience.

    Chapter 82

  2. What did Carboni identify as the cause of his dysentery?

    Carboni attributes his dysentery to the prison food: a morsel of dry bullock's flesh, sometimes 'high-flavoured,' and a bit of bread 'eternally sour.' His dinner also included a soup of scalding water with a few grains of rice and a couple of black potatoes.

    Chapter 82

  3. Why did Carboni find Sundays the most trying day in gaol?

    On Sundays Carboni was let out with the Catholics to hear mass, but the priest was always in a hurry, twice failed to come, once said half the mass without an assistant, and never visited the prisoners. After mass he was allowed half an hour in the yard among criminals, then shut in his cell until Monday.

    Chapter 82

  4. How does Carboni describe the priest's conduct toward the prisoners?

    Carboni says the priest was always in a hurry, twice did not come at all, once said half the mass without an assistant, and never let him hear two words together out of his short sermon. He adds that the priest never once came to see the prisoners, though Carboni felt the want of Christian consolation.

    Chapter 82

Chapter LXXIX.4 cards
  1. What did Carboni say happened to the prisoners during the turnkeys' search?

    Carboni records that the prisoners were one afternoon surprised by the whole gang of turnkeys, ordered to strip, and subjected to an ignominious search in which even their very private parts were discovered and touched. He marks this item first 'for shame' and cites 'Veritatem dico, non mentior' to affirm he tells the truth.

    Chapter 83

  2. How did tobacco reach Manning and the prisoners in their cell?

    Manning badly wanted a chew of tobacco. Carboni and Tuhey would strike up favourite pieces from Italian opera, and the charm succeeded: a gentle tap at the cell door was the signal to receive a stick of tobacco from a crack below. Then, Carboni says, they were all jolly, decreeing that even in hell there must be some good devils.

    Chapter 83

  3. How does Carboni describe Governor Wintle's treatment of the state prisoners?

    Carboni says Mr. Wintle, the governor, inclined to the John Bull in corporation, preserved a good, kind heart even in a Melbourne gaol crammed monthly with confirmed criminals. Without relaxing discipline, he used no cruelty toward the state prisoners, spoke kindly, regretted their position, wished them well, and had regard for Carboni on account of his bad health—which Carboni says he will always remember.

    Chapter 83

  4. What did Carboni expect from the indictment, and what did solicitors tell the prisoners?

    Carboni devoured the indictment expecting some count charging them with riot, and its absence was a welcome disappointment that made him consider himself safe. Solicitors instead warned it would go hard with anyone found guilty, saying the government meant to make an example with some fifteen years in the hulks, having learned from Lynn of Ballaarat that no defence funds were collected—and thus won some 200 pounds from frightened prisoners with ready cash.

    Chapter 83

Chapter LXXX.4 cards
  1. What physical conditions do the Ballaarat state prisoners describe in their letter to the Sheriff?

    They describe being led at seven in the morning into a small yard about thirty yards long and eight wide, with no seats or benches, so they must stand, walk, or sit on cold earth that also serves as their table, leaving food saturated with sand, dust, and filth. They are locked in about three in the afternoon, four or five together, in a cell three feet by twelve, barred from free air for sixteen hours out of twenty-four.

    Chapter 84

  2. What restrictions on writing, reading, and tobacco do the prisoners complain of?

    The prisoners state they are debarred the use of writing materials except for pressing necessity, are never permitted to see a newspaper, and are strictly prohibited the use of tobacco and snuff. They argue that writing could fill the dreary vacuum of prison life and that moderate use of snuff and tobacco would cheer it and soothe the mental irritation consequent upon seclusion.

    Chapter 84

  3. What does the letter say about the Sunday confinement and the searching process?

    The prisoners say Sunday, a day of relaxation to all men in Christendom, is to them one of gloom, being locked in a dreary cell from three o'clock Saturday evening until seven on Monday morning, except about an hour and a half on Sunday—forty consecutive hours in a narrow dungeon. They also protest being stripped naked, a dozen men together, during 'searching,' which they call revolting and an outrage upon common decency.

    Chapter 84

  4. What remedy do the prisoners request, and on what principle do they base it?

    They submit that since the state looks only at present to their being well secured, they ought to be treated with every liberality consistent with safe custody, and that unnecessary harshness or arrogant display of power is wanton cruelty. They express belief that the government does not wish such treatment and that the Sheriff would alter it if made acquainted with it, noting their trial appears postponed sine die.

    Chapter 84

Chapter LXXXI.4 cards
  1. Who was the first gentleman to volunteer as friend to the state prisoners?

    James MacPherson Grant, a solicitor, was the first gentleman to grasp the hand of the state prisoners and volunteer as their friend, together with Hayes. Carboni describes Grant as a middle-sized Scotchman, an active man of business and shrewd lawyer, whose benevolent countenance showed his heart was for anyone in trouble, and who told Carboni he need not fear and would soon be out.

    Chapter 85

  2. How does Carboni describe the Melbourne people's attitude toward the state prisoners?

    Carboni says the brave people of Melbourne remembered the state prisoners, who had been forgotten by the Ballaarat diggers. The diggers, once the storm was over, considered themselves luckily cunning to have got off safe and could afford to 'joe' again, since the red-streak near Golden-point had restored the good old spirits of the good old times.

    Chapter 85

  3. What does Carboni's verse say happens to someone who devotes himself to the public cause?

    The verse asks the people if they are 'there' to die, and they answer with thundering applause and 'Yes, yes hurrah.' But the speaker soon finds out the lie: cast in a gaol, he is at best thought a fool, his foe grows red hot, and his friend too cool. Carboni presents this as the reward of public devotion.

    Chapter 85

  4. How many times did Hayes and Carboni return broken-hearted to gaol, and whom did they curse?

    Carboni writes that Timothy Hayes and he returned broken-hearted to their gaol for the FIFTH time, and asks whether they did not curse the lawyers. He also says he now smothers his bitterness for the sake of Grant and the barrister Mr. Aspinall, passing over all he suffered on account of so many postponements.

    Chapter 85

Chapter LXXXIII.3 cards
  1. What does the author say happens to a fatalist who succeeds versus one who fails?

    The author argues that belief in fate can embolden a man to knock down friend or foe to carry out his conceit. If successful, he becomes a Caesar; if unsuccessful, the reward is ignominy and a violent grave. The author frames this as the outcome of the fatalist's worry, not as a recommendation.

    Chapter 86

  2. What Latin phrases does the chapter use, and what do they mean?

    The chapter opens with 'Initium Sapientie Est Timor Domini,' meaning the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. It also quotes 'sic sinuerunt Fata,' rendered as 'so the Fates willed it,' used to describe the fatalist's attitude. Both phrases frame the chapter's reflection on fate and self-knowledge.

    Chapter 86

  3. What does the author say about belief in fate outside a gaol?

    The author argues that certain circumstances are so inexplicable, overwhelming, and clashing with common sense that even an honest man may at moments believe in fate. He says this holds true as people rove through living hosts and changing scenes, moved by passions or accident, but it does not hold true in a gaol.

    Chapter 86

Chapter LXXXIV.4 cards
  1. Who were the counsel and attorney defending Carboni at his Melbourne trial?

    James MacPherson Grant was Carboni's attorney for the defence, and Richard Davis Ireland was his barrister counsel. Butler Cole Aspinall, previously unknown to Carboni, volunteered to assist Ireland. Carboni notes another lawyer had promised to attend but was absent. He praises Ireland's forceful eloquence and describes Aspinall as a gentleman and scholar.

    Chapter 87

  2. What did Justice Barry tell the jury about Carboni's motive for emigrating?

    Barry said the jury had been told the prisoner came sixteen thousand miles to escape Austrian tyranny for liberty, and that this was true in the truest sense. Barry added that the liberty Carboni enjoyed imposed on him a local respect for Her Majesty and her laws, and that he had the privilege of trial by jury deciding solely on the facts.

    Chapter 87

  3. How does Carboni describe Judge Barry's manner and temper?

    Carboni calls Barry a man of the old-gentleman John Bull stamp, with nothing in his face resembling the notorious Jefferies. He says Barry can manage his temper even amid the vexations of law, and always addressed Carboni with kindness. Carboni does note Barry's summing-up carried a parson's solemnity and some self-congratulation.

    Chapter 87

  4. What does Carboni say about the composition of the jury sworn for his trial?

    Carboni lists twelve jurors sworn after the usual challenging, including farmers, joiners, butchers, carpenters, a painter, gardeners, a grocer and a baker, from places such as Gore-street, Brighton-road, Kew, Hawthorne and Heidelberg. He says the first glance at the foreman made him serene, sure the right man was in the right place.

    Chapter 87

Chapter LXXXV.4 cards
  1. What did George Webster swear Carboni did at the Bakery-hill meeting?

    Webster testified that at the 29 November meeting, with Mr. Hayes as chairman, the prisoner was on the platform and gave a speech saying he had come 16,000 miles to escape tyranny and that the diggers should put down the tyrants, pointing to the Camp. Webster also claimed the prisoner tore up his licence and threw it toward the fire, urging others to do the same.

    Chapter 88

  2. How did Webster's testimony change at the later Beattie and Tuhey trial?

    At the next state trial of James Beattie and Michael Tuhey, Webster was cross-examined by Mr. Ireland and stated that Carboni Raffaello was at the 29 November meeting. When a gold licence was handed to him, he confirmed it was in the name of Carboni Raffaello and that its date covered the period when licences were burned, causing a sensation in court.

    Chapter 88

  3. What does Carboni assert about burning his licence at the meeting?

    Carboni states he was present in person as a free man and asserts he did not burn any paper or anything at all at the monster meeting, challenging contradiction from any bona fide miner present. He says he paid two pounds for his licence on 15 October 1854 to Commissioner Amos and still has it in his possession, reproducing the licence document.

    Chapter 88

  4. What conditions appear on the reproduced gold licence?

    The licence, No. 134, dated 17 October 1854, was issued to Carboni Raffaello for two pounds, valid three months ending 16 January, signed by Commissioner G. A. Amos. It was not transferable, had to be carried and produced on demand, barred mining destructive of roads, required observance of Sundays, and allowed each licensed miner a claim of twelve foot square.

    Chapter 88

Chapter LXXXVI.4 cards
  1. What did the deputation offer Commissioner Rede on November 30th, and how did he respond?

    The deputation, including the prisoner, said that if Rede assured them he would not again go out with police and military to collect licences, they could undertake that no disturbance would occur. Rede replied that because threats had been made that bloodshed would be on the authorities' heads if he refused, he could make no such engagement then and had no power to refrain from collecting the licence fee.

    Chapter 89

  2. What did Rede say the licence issue really was, according to Hackett's testimony?

    Hackett recalled Commissioner Rede saying the word 'licences' was merely a cloak used by the diggers and that the movement was in reality a democratic one. The prisoner assured Rede that among the foreigners he had conversed with there was no democratic feeling, but merely a spirit of resistance to the licence fee.

    Chapter 89

  3. What did Private James Gore testify about the prisoner at the stockade?

    Gore, a private in the 40th, testified he was in the attack on the Eureka stockade and that the prisoner and two other men followed him when he entered, compelling him to go out; the prisoner was armed with a pike. On cross-examination Gore said it was daylight but not broad daylight, he had fired his musket but not used his bayonet, he ran because three men opposed him, and no other soldier or policeman was near.

    Chapter 89

  4. How did Sergeant Hagartey's cross-examination qualify his testimony?

    Hagartey, a sergeant in the 40th, testified he was beside Captain Wise when Wise was shot from the stockade, saw the prisoner at the stockade, was in the guard that took him to the Camp, and saw him a prisoner there about five o'clock. On cross-examination by Mr. Ireland, he said he did not know that the prisoner did not escape on the way from the stockade to the lock-up.

    Chapter 89

Chapter LXXXVII.3 cards
  1. What does Carboni swear about the eight men before his arrest?

    Carboni, identifying himself as a Catholic from an old Roman family whose honour was never questioned, asserts before God and man that before being arrested at the Camp he had never seen the faces of the eight men he names: Gore, Synnot, Donnelly, Concritt, Dogherty, Badcock, Hagartey, and Tully.

    Chapter 90

  2. Whom does Carboni challenge to contradict his assertions?

    Carboni challenges contradiction from any bona fide digger who was present at the stockade during the massacre on the morning of December 3rd, 1854. He limits the challenge to genuine diggers who witnessed that morning, rather than opening it to anyone at all.

    Chapter 90

  3. What does Carboni hope the Australian press will do?

    As a man of education and therefore a member of the Republic of Letters, Carboni expresses the hope that the press throughout the whole of Australia will open their columns to any bona fide contradiction to his solemn assertions. He adds that he cannot possibly say anything more on such a sad subject.

    Chapter 90

Chapter LXXXVIII.4 cards
  1. What did Mr. Ireland argue about the law of high treason?

    The author reports that defence counsel Mr. Ireland spent much time on the law of high treason, arguing its absurdity and that its interpretation had long vexed even lawyers. He then turned to more tangible points, contending the law's gruesome penalties were absurd, and called on the jury to end the prisoner's continued incarceration by their verdict.

    Chapter 91

  2. How does Carboni mock the quartering penalty's gate display?

    Carboni reasons that where there are no bricks there are no walls, and walls are needed to enclose gates, so Ballaarat has no gates. He jokes that his quarters therefore cannot be hung on Ballaarat's gates, concluding Toorak must possess a craft beyond traitors' understanding. The author presents this as his own humorous schoolboy-style argument.

    Chapter 91

  3. What did Mr. Aspinall's speech for the prisoner accomplish, per the author?

    The author says Mr. Aspinall's speech was spirited, cutting and withering, but could only cover the falsehood and not bring the truth to light. Therefore Carboni decides not to record it, saying it cannot serve the purpose of his book, and points instead to four documents and his important observation on them in the following chapter.

    Chapter 91

  4. What did the author think of the jury's reaction to Ireland's address?

    Carboni says the jury at first appeared frightened by Mr. Ireland's powerful thundering, but that His Honour seemed to assent to the counsel's line of argument. After Ireland's lengthy but able address, the author thought the jury now appeared ready to let the high traitor go his way in bodily integrity.

    Chapter 91

Chapter LXXXIX.4 cards
  1. Why was Raffaello's trial postponed, and who did the judge say was responsible for the witnesses?

    The trial was postponed because of the absence of witnesses for the defence, including Dr. Alfred Carr, Mr. Gordon of Gordon and M'Callum, and others. When Raffaello asked the Chief Justice to protect him by ensuring his witnesses were served with subpoenas, His Honour replied that he was not responsible; the prisoner's attorney was the party to speak to, and it was the attorney's business to get the witnesses.

    Chapter 92

  2. What did the letter signed J.B. in The Age describe Raffaello doing at Eureka?

    J.B. wrote that on the morning of 3 December at Ballaarat he met Raffaello on the Redhill searching for Dr. Carr's hospital. They returned to the Eureka, Raffaello bringing Dr. Carr's surgical instruments. Inside the stockade they saw many lying almost dead from gun-shot and bayonet wounds. J.B. left fearing arrest, but Raffaello stayed rendering mercy to the dying, risking the constant explosions of firearms.

    Chapter 92

  3. How did The Age's tone toward the state prisoners change between January and March 1855?

    Carboni notes that The Age ran an able leading article headed 'The State Trials' (see January 15) concluding, 'If they be found guilty, then Heaven help the poor State Prisoners.' After his acquittal, the same paper of March 26, 1855, printed a satirical Bill mocking the prosecution as a farce titled 'State Prosecutions; or, the Plotters Outwitted,' casting Stawell as Tartuffe.

    Chapter 92

  4. What does Carboni say remains a mystery, and how does he describe his imprisonment?

    Carboni says it was and still is a MYSTERY to him why Dr. A. Carr, Sub-inspector Carter, Messrs. Gordon and Binney were not present as witnesses at his trial. He adds that he leaves it to the reader to guess whether, after four long months in gaol which ruined his health for ever, he laughed or cursed on reading the satirical bill.

    Chapter 92

Chapter XC.4 cards
  1. What defence line did Mr. Aspinall take at Carboni's trial?

    Mr. Aspinall, like Mr. Michie in John Manning's trial, conceded the riot but mocked the treason charge. He argued that however rashly the diggers took up arms and however disorderly the stockade's management, they were justified in resisting unconstitutional force with force. The jury seemed willing to release Carboni with an admonition to sin no more.

    Chapter 93

  2. How long did the jury deliberate before returning its verdict?

    The jury retired at nine o'clock and was back in the jury-box after twenty minutes past nine, so the deliberation lasted roughly twenty minutes. Carboni read their countenances as a sign that 'the People' were victorious. The foreman then answered the clerk's question with a firm 'NOT GUILTY!'

    Chapter 93

  3. What did Carboni compare waiting in the felon's dock to?

    Carboni described waiting in the felon's dock while the jury consulted as a sensation peculiar in kind, framing it as 'To be or not to be.' He called it the most important monosyllable in the language: pronounced it means life, omitted it means death, an awkward position especially for an innocent man. He first turned his thoughts to God, then to friends in Rome and London.

    Chapter 93

  4. How did the crowd outside learn of the not-guilty verdict?

    After the foreman said 'NOT GUILTY!' with a firm voice, Carboni wrote that his chains sprang asunder. People inside the court telegraphed the good news to the crowd outside, and 'Hurrah!' rent the air in the old British style. Carboni also invoked 'Magna opera Domini' with the aside 'God save the People.'

    Chapter 93

Chapter XCI.4 cards
  1. What does Carboni do immediately upon leaving the Supreme Court as a free man?

    Carboni says the people nearly smothered him with demonstrations of joy; he asks for silence, stretches his right hand toward heaven, and prays earnestly as a Christian. He notes the prayer was written in pencil on paper while he was in the lower cell, No. 33.

    Chapter 94

  2. What sins does Carboni's prayer acknowledge on behalf of the people?

    The prayer to the Lord God of Israel acknowledges transgressions since coming to their adopted land: intemperance, greediness, and the pampering of many bad passions, which provoked God against them. It asks that if God's justice must chastise them, His mercy save Victoria from the curse of the spy system.

    Chapter 94

  3. What specific curse does Carboni ask God to spare Victoria from?

    Carboni prays that if God's justice is called upon to chastise the people, His mercy should save the land of Victoria from the curse of the 'spy system.' The prayer frames the spy system, not merely personal sin, as the calamity to be averted from the colony.

    Chapter 94

  4. Who responds 'Amen' to Carboni's prayer, according to the chapter?

    Timothy Hayes answered 'Amen,' and so did all the people present. Carboni adds that his good reader will answer 'Amen' as well, extending the prayer's affirmation beyond the crowd at the Supreme Court portal to the audience of his account.

    Chapter 94

Chapter XCIV.3 cards
  1. Why does Carboni say he waited a full year before publishing his story?

    Carboni offers what he calls "one excuse, and 'it is an excuse'": his cast of mind was terribly shaken during four long months suffering in gaol, worsened by the company he was kept in, which he calls his misery. He also cites the excitement of his trial, his acquittal by a British jury, and the people's acclamations of joy.

    Chapter 95

  2. To whom is the explanation by Don Antonio Carboni addressed?

    The explanation is to be submitted to Her Most Gracious Majesty Queen Victoria in London, and to His Holiness Pius IX, Pontifex Maximus, in Rome. It is written by Carboni's brother, Don Antonio Carboni, D.D., Head-master of the Grammar School at Coriano, Romagna, and opens with the motto "Homo Sum, Nil Humani a me Alienum Puto."

    Chapter 95

  3. What does Carboni claim his credit now consists in?

    Carboni says his credit consists now in having the moral courage to assert the truth among living witnesses. He frames his account as corroborating, not boastingly, the impression that he was the brave fellow before whose pike a British soldier ran away, and notes he was not sorry the Toorak spiders lent him the wings of a hero.

    Chapter 95

Chapter XCVI.2 cards
  1. What physical state does Carboni describe in himself at this point?

    Carboni writes that his right hand shakes like a reed in a storm and his eyes swell from a flood of tears. He says he can control the bitterness of his heart and say 'So far shalt thou go,' but he cannot control its ebb and flow, which is just now at springtide.

    Chapter 96

  2. What Latin heading opens the chapter, and what does Carboni say follows it?

    The chapter opens with 'Est Modus In Rebus: Sunt Certi Denique Fines, Quos Ultrae, Citraque Nequit Consistere Rectum.' Carboni then asks whether he has anything more to say and answers yes, that a string of the realities of the things of this world follows.

    Chapter 96

Chapter XCVII.3 cards
  1. What did Carboni claim he lost when arrested at the Camp?

    Carboni states he was arrested by seven troopers, handcuffed, and dragged to the Camp, where he was kicked and thrown into the lock-up by half-drunken troopers and soldiers. He says his money, clothes, and new watertight boots could not be found, and that Gaoler Nixon had bolted. He declares his loss amounted to 30 pounds, though he could not state its full extent with certainty.

    Chapter 97

  2. What did Carboni find when he returned to his tent on the Eureka?

    Carboni says he tramped back to Ballaarat in bad health and worse spirits and found his tent on the Eureka robbed of everything worth a sixpence: cradle, two tubs, digging tools, cooking utensils, blankets, gold specimens and dust, and his belt with money in it. From his account-book he states he had 49 pounds in cash on his person and in the tent on the morning of his arrest.

    Chapter 97

  3. What does Carboni say about the sympathy he received from Ballaarat leaders?

    Carboni says he told half-a-dozen times over to most of the 'well-disposed and independent' yabber-yabber leaders on Ballaarat how he was robbed at the Camp and how everything was stolen from his tent, noting the thieves were neither Vandemonians nor Chinese. He met grand sympathy in 'words,' which he calls superlatively impotent even to move for restitution of his watertight boots.

    Chapter 97

Chapter XCVIII.4 cards
  1. What reason did the Colonial Secretary give for refusing Carboni compensation?

    The Colonial Secretary, J. Moore, wrote that the government is bound by fixed rules and never grants money in compensation except when the clearest evidence of loss is given. He stated that a personal statement, no matter by whom given, is never accepted as sufficient testimony, though the government did not doubt the veracity of Carboni's statement.

    Chapter 98

  2. What does the letter say about the government's view of Carboni's honesty?

    The letter explicitly states that the government by no means doubts the veracity of Carboni's statement. Despite accepting his honesty, the government claims a duty to the public that requires the clearest evidence of loss before any compensation is paid, and personal testimony alone is never deemed sufficient.

    Chapter 98

  3. How does the 'Cheer-up' poem respond to Moore's refusal?

    The poem dismisses Moore's letter as too costly a store, tells him to hang the word 'Compensation,' and calls instead for 'RESTITUTION.' It mocks the notion that restitution is an old institution or popish innovation, and its chorus cheers the great works at Toorak while warning to keep clear of the wool-pack.

    Chapter 98

  4. What is the 'Waterloobolter Chimes' section of the chapter?

    It is a short nonsense-verse passage following the magpie's cheer, built from syllables like 'Sip sop stir-up' and 'do si la sol fa me re do,' mixing musical scales with phrases about Toorak small beer and washing down chops and snacks. It reads as a satirical jingle rather than a statement of fact.

    Chapter 98

Chapter XCIX.4 cards
  1. What did Inspector Foster say happened to Carboni's cap, shirt, and boots?

    Foster replied that the cap, shirt, and boots Carboni wore when brought to the Camp were put among the surplus clothing taken from other prisoners, and he was not aware how they were disposed of afterwards. He noted the shirt was wool over a cotton one, which Carboni retained during confinement.

    Chapter 99

  2. What discrepancy does Carboni point out in Foster's letter date?

    Foster's letter is dated Nov. 2, 1854, yet refers to Carboni's arrest at the Camp as occurring in December, 1855. Carboni inserts a bracketed correction, noting it was in 1854. He also observes that his money is not mentioned in Foster's reply at all.

    Chapter 99

  3. What does Carboni say about who robbed him?

    Carboni concedes that Foster himself was not the one who robbed him, yet still complains that his money is never mentioned in the official reply. He treats the omission as clever evasion rather than an answer to his complaint about being deprived of property during arrest.

    Chapter 99

  4. What does Carboni argue in his postscript about British versus Italian treatment?

    The author argues that had a British man been robbed in Italy even half as wantonly, the British press would have denounced Popish gendarmes and the Roman Inquisition. He contends that a friendless Italian robbed under arrest on British ground by British troopers draws no such outcry, implying a double standard.

    Chapter 99

C. Raffaello, member of the Local Court. He hoped,4 cards
  1. What three matters did Carboni Raffaello bring before the meeting?

    He stated the first concerned the meeting and himself, the second concerned himself, and the third concerned those present. The first was whether he had done his duty as member of the Local Court to their satisfaction, which drew yes and cheers. The second covered his personal position toward the lawyers, and the third asked whether those present were fairly represented by them.

    Chapter 100

  2. Why did Carboni oppose admitting lawyers into the Local Court?

    He argued that admitting lawyers would give rise to endless feuds where valuable interests were concerned, and that much time would be lost in useless litigation. He also said he had no wish, through any personal obligation, to see lawyers in the Local Court, and considered it advantageous to the miners that they should not be admitted.

    Chapter 100

  3. How did The Argus reporter's account differ from Carboni's own report?

    Carboni asserts his report is correct as far as it goes, with some five hundred diggers present. He quotes the Argus reporter, who called him a foreigner and his speech sedition, and who framed the snuff remark ambiguously, leaving unclear whether Raffaello or Dunne was meant. Carboni calls this braying by asses and a perversion by anonymous scribblers.

    Chapter 100

  4. How did Carboni characterize The Age and the Ballaarat Times?

    He says The Age was then just budding and was considered on the diggings the organ of the new chum Governor, but it soon mustered Roman courage for the diggers and jumped the claims of The Herald and The Argus, remaining the diggers' paper. The Ballaarat Times was all the go across the diggings, and its reporter and editor would soon appear in propria persona.

    Chapter 100

Chapter C.4 cards
  1. What does Carboni ask the Melbourne editors to do in this final chapter?

    Carboni asks the editors of The Age, The Argus, and The Herald to pull together and drag out of the Toorak small-beer jug the correspondence concerning his case. He lists nine parties to that correspondence, including Sir Charles Hotham, W. C. Haines, W. Foster Stawell, Mr. Sturt, W. H. Archer, Captain M'Mahon, Police-Inspector H. Foster, one unnamed person, and himself as Signor Carboni Raffaello, M.L.C. of Ballaarat.

    Chapter 101

  2. What specific grievances does Carboni raise against the Melbourne press?

    Carboni complains that The Argus appends 'a foreigner' to his name and should extend him the old motto 'fair-play.' He notes The Age is foremost in the digger's cause regardless of language or colour, and that The Herald erected him as a 'MONUMENT OF GRATITUDE.' He appeals to the editors on the score of his being an old Collaborateur of the European Press.

    Chapter 101

  3. Why does Carboni say there are scores of cases like his?

    Carboni states that scores of cases similar to his exist and are more important by far, because widows and orphans are concerned in them. He thus frames his own grievance as less weighty than others. He adds the Latin phrase 'Sunt tempora nostra!' and urges Master Punch to join the chorus and give a lift to Great-works.

    Chapter 101

  4. What does Carboni say about fear and his promise to the reader?

    Carboni insists it is not fear that makes him shake at chapters XCII and XCIII. He tells the good reader that to the last line of the book his quill shall stick to his word as given in the first chapter. Hence, for the present, this is the last chapter. He bids farewell and says to put by the pipe carefully, as they may want it again.

    Chapter 101

Source and licence

Text used: Project Gutenberg eBook #3546 (Public domain in the United States). Generated from the full text; cards paraphrase the source.

Version: Public domain edition. Retrieved 2026-11-20. Cards reviewed 2026-11-20.

These cards paraphrase the text for study. They are not a substitute for reading the book, and they do not reproduce long passages.

Turn your own notes into cards

Upload a PDF, Word, or text file and get question-and-answer cards for closed-notes practice. Five cards are free, no signup.

Try 5 free cards